Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63862 (KAR)
THE BRANCH MANAGER v. BASVARAJA AND ANR
MFA/201123/2023 · 2025-07-18
Ravi V Hosmani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63862 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63862 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#"
$# %% &&
'%( )
! "
# $
! %
$ & '( ')! ! &' *
'
+
&$, ' $ ')
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!-(&.( &' *
-
"
#
$ /
%
+-#%
$ )
& $ ) $
*
$ )
'
' 0 $
#
1233456756 89:6;45< 25: 2=2>: :2<4:
?2@@4: AB >75C7?23 7@<>7C< 25: 4@@7D5@ $9:64 25:
27C19>#ED>@1D><0>7A95230%75 5D&<17@2??423 7@E734:
>7 258952<1 2332BB2 14<<B 342>54: CD95@43 2??42>756 ED> >7 :2B D5695<7F2> 342>54: CD95@43 @9A;7<<4:2??423=2@AB
5@9>4>C12334567562=2>:D5372A737<B 2@ =433 2@ D5G925<9;
< =2@ @9A;7<<4: 2@?4>C327;25< D5
- 3 -
(.=14514=2@>7:756;D<D>CBC345D!-(&++ E>D; 2562?9> <D=2>:@ 12F<75262> :>7H4> DE 9<D 5D! -(&.(:>DH47<752>2@125:54637645<;2554>25::2@14:
26275@< C327;25<I@ ;D<D>CBC34 C29@756 2CC7:45<
5 2CC7:45< C327;25< @9@<2754: @4H4>23 6>74HD9@ 7589>74@ 4@?7<4 <2F756 <>42<;45<14@9@<2754:?4>;2545<?1B@7C23:7@2A737<B25:3D@@ DE 42>5756 C2?2C7<B 14>4ED>4 14 E734: C327; ?4<7<7D5 95:4> 4C<7D5((DE D<D>417C34C<26275@<D=54>25:75@9>4>DE 9<D>7CF@12=
- 5 2??42>25C4 D=54>&75@9>4> D??D@4: C327;
?4<7<7D5 D5 233 6>D95:@ 75C39:756 :45723 DE DCC9>>45C4 DE 2CC7:45< :94 <D >2@1 25: 54637645< :>7H756 DE 9<D >7CF@12= C327;?4<7<7D5A47564JC4@@7H425:75@9>4>23346756H7D32<7D5DE <4>;@ 25: CD5:7<7D5@ DE ?D37CB DE 75@9>25C4 52;43B 75@9>4:
H417C34 =2@ A4756 9@4: =7<1D9< E7<54@@ C4><7E7C2<4 25: :>7H45 =7<1D9<1D3:756H237:25:4EE4C<7H437C45C4
2@4: D5 ?342:756@ <>7A9523 E>2;4: 7@@94@ 25: >4CD>:4: 4H7:45C4 327;25< 4J2;754: 17;@43E 25:
>>7:12> 4::B 2@ )@ 25: J17A7<@ <D #2% =4>4 6D< ;2>F4: 4@?D5:45<@ 4J2;754: DEE7C723 DE 75@9>4>/
- 4 -
DEE7C723 DE 25: D=54> DE H417C34 2@ )@ <D - 25: 6D< ;2>F4:J17A7<@<D
5CD5@7:4>2<7D5>7A9523143:2CC7:45<=2@:94<D >2@125:54637645<:>7H756DE75@9>4:H417C34AB7<@:>7H4>25: C327;25<12:@9@<2754:?4>;2545<?1B@7C23:7@2A737<B342:756<D 3D@@ DE 42>5756 C2?2C7<B 25: 45<7<34: ED> CD;?45@2<7D5 E>D; 5@9>4>2@ED33D=@' 3D 42:@ ;D95< % 275K9EE4>756 @L %
4:7C23 2<<45:25<I @ 25: 5D9>7@1;45< 4J?45@4@ @L -% D@@ DE 75CD;4 :9>756327:9??4>7D: #@-J- D5<1@% @-.+L % D@@DEE9<9>475CD;4 @-+(L %
4:7C234J?45@4@ @--((L (% >25@?D><2<7D5 4J?45@4@ @L
*+, -.! /
01232 -. /
66>74H4: AB E75:756@ 75@DE2> 2@ 372A737<B 2@ =433 2@ G925<9;75@9>4>7@752??423
( < =2@ E7>@<3B @9A;7<<4: 2CC7:45< DCC9>>4: D5 (.
J?4>;7< =2@ DA<2754: ED> :9>2<7D5
- 5 -
CD;;45C756E>D;.<D.14>4ED>42@D5 :2<4DE2CC7:45<H417C34:7:5D<12H4?4>;7<5@27:6>D95: E75:756DE<>7A9523D5372A737<B=2@>4G97>4:<DA4;D:7E74:
+ 5G925<9;7<=2@@9A;7<<4:2@?4>J=D95:
C4><7E7C2<4 C327;25< @9@<2754: E>2C<9>4 DE >761< :7@<23 E4;9> E>2C<9>4DE?2<433225:E>2C<9>4DE>761<9352)DC<D>=1D 12: 7@@94: :7@2A737<B C4><7E7C2<4 2< J 2@@4@@4: 37;A :7@2A737<B DE -M D=4H4> <>7A9523 2@@4@@4: E95C<7D523 :7@2A737<B 2< M =17C1 =2@ 6>D@@3B 4JC4@@7H4 14>4ED>4 G925<9; DE CD;?45@2<7D5 95:4> E9<9>4 3D@@ DE 75CD;4 =2@ >4G97>4: <D A4 >4:9C4: 5 2ADH4 6>D95:@ 14 @D961< ED> 233D=7562??423
5 D<14> 125: >7 2@2H2>28 2<1 342>54: CD95@43 ED> >4@?D5:45<C327;25< @9A;7<<4: <12< J :7@2A737<B C4><7E7C2<4 7@@94: AB ) 75:7C2<4: <12< <14>4 =2@ @1D><45756DE>761<37;ADEC327;25<ABC;@>4@<>7C<7D5DE E34J7D5 DE F544 AB <D :46>44 25: 4G9759@ DE >761< 25F34 25:<14>4ED>41412:@9@<2754:=1D34AD:B:7@2A737<B2<-M <=2@E9><14>@9A;7<<4:CD5<45<7D5DE75@9>4><12<2@@4@@;45<
- 6 -
DE:7@2A737<B=2@<D37;A=2@5D<CD>>4C<25:D??D@4:2??423D5 G925<9;
. >7 2A9
4<269::2 342>54: CD95@43 ED> >4@?D5:45<D=54> @9A;7<<4: <1D961 J =2@ 7@@94: ED> ?4>7D:@9A@4G945<<D2CC7:45<4H45ED>42>374>?4>7D:H417C34 =2@7@@94=7<1?4>;7<=17C1=2@H237:9?<D-. <=2@ @9A;7<<4: H7D32<7D5 233464: =2@ 5D< E95:2;45<23 H7D32<7D5 43B756 9?D5 :4C7@7D5@ DE 7H7@7D5 45C1 DE <17@ D9>< 75
!"#$ %% #&"# ' 25: %( ) ( ) *
+
"#"#""!"#$ %% #,#&"#""' 7< =2@ @9A;7<<4: H7D32<7D5 DE ?4>;7< CD5:7<7D5 =2@ D?754: <D 75H7<4 D53B E754 25: =D93: 5D< @9EE7C4 <D 2HD7: 372A737<B5@27:6>D95:@14@D961<:7@;7@@23DE2??423
5 >4?3B 342>54: CD95@43 ED> 2??43325<75@9>4> @9A;7<<4: <12< 4C<7D5 #% DE C< =D93: ;25:2<4 <12< 2??37C2<7D5ED>>454=2312@<DA4E734::2B@?>7D><D:2<4DE 4J?7>B:;7<<4:3B7575@<25<C2@42??37C2<7D5=2@5D<E734:75
- 7 -
<7;425:>454=23=2@2E<4>:2<4DE2CC7:45<14>4ED>4D5:2<4 DE2CC7:45<<14>4=2@5D?4>;7<
42>: 342>54: CD95@43 25: ?4>9@4: 7;?9654:
89:6;45< 25: 2=2>: 25: C4><7E74: CD?B DE J+ :7@2A737<B C4><7E7C2<4;2:42H2732A34AB342>54:CD95@43ED>C327;25<
>D; 2ADH4 ?D75<@ <12< =D93: 2>7@4 ED> CD5@7:4>2<7D52>4'
! "
#$ ! ! ## #%&$ '
"$ ! # ! $# !&#'
&$(&! !)$$ &&*
+
! ,$ ! !&&)- ! #$ &$#$$!!#*. 34&51*1 - 14>47@CD5C9>>45C4DE342>54:CD95@432AD9<E2C< <12<2@D5:2<4DE2CC7:45<75@9>4:H417C34:7:5D<12H4H237:
?4>;7<
5@DE2> 2@ G94@<7D5 =14<14> @2;4 =D93: @9EE7C4 ED> 75@9>4> <D 2HD7: 372A737<B 7H7@7D5 45C1 :4C7@7D5@ C7<4: AB 342>54:CD95@43ED>>4@?D5:45<5DD=54>12H4C342>3B143:75
- 8 -
5462<7H4 D33D=756 @27: >2<7D ?D75< 5D 7@ 25@=4>4: 75 2EE7>;2<7H4
34&51*1
J=D95: C4><7E7C2<4 25: J:7@2A737<B C4><7E7C2<4 =D93: 75:7C2<4 <12< C327;25< 12: @9@<2754: E>2C<9>4 DE >761< :7@<23 E4;9> E>2C<9>4 DE ?2<4332 25: E>2C<9>4 DE >761< 9352 )1734 2@@4@@756 ?1B@7C23 :7@2A737<B ) 12@ 5D<4: @1D><45756DE>761<346ABC;@25<2367C627<>4@<>7C<7D5DE E34J7D5 ;DH4;45< DE >761< F544 E>D; :46>44@ 25: 23@D >4@<>7C<7D5 DE >761< 25F34 ;DH4;45< D CD5C39:4 =1D34 AD:B :7@2A737<BDEM
327;25<7@@<2<4:<DA4(B42>@DE26425::D756 ?>7H2<4=D>F75!
25:<D4@<2A37@1@2;414?>D:9C4:=264 @37?2<J.4@<>7C<7D5DE;DH4DEF544C255D<A4@<2<4:5D< <D C29@4 25B :7@2A737<B 2< 233 < @2;4 <7;4 =14<14> @D;4 :46>44DE>4@<>7C<7D5DE;DH4;45<=D93:45<2733D@@DE42>5756 C2?2C7<B2<M2@2@@4@@4:AB<>7A9523=D93:>4G97>4:<DA4 4J2;754:
5 3761< DE J. <1D961 C327;25< CD5<759756 75 4;?3DB;45< 2E<4> 2CC7:45< 2>4 5D< E933B 4@<2A37@14: CD5@7:4>756@;2334J<45<DE>4@<>7C<7D53D@@DE42>5756C2?2C7<B
- 9 -
2@@4@@4:AB <>7A9523 2< M 2??42>@ <DA4 D5 17614> @7:4
< =D93: A4 2??>D?>72<4 <D CD5@7:4> 7< 2< M D5@4G945<3B CD;?45@2<7D5 <D=2>:@ 3D@@ DE E9<9>4 75CD;4 =D93: A4 2@ ED33D=@' #@-JJ%JML@---.&
( 19@ <14>4 7@ >4:9C<7D5 75 CD;?45@2<7D5 <D=2>:@ 3D@@ DE E9<9>4 75CD;4 AB @--(& #@(+( @---.% D;?45@2<7D5 2=2>:4: 95:4> D<14> 142:@ 2>4 5D<A4452@@2734:AB47<14>DE?2><74@ 3D 42:@ ;D95< % 275K9EE4>756 @L %
4:7C23 2<<45:25<I @ 25: 5D9>7@1;45< 4J?45@4@ @L -% D@@ DE 75CD;4 :9>756 327:9??4>7D: @-.+L % D@@DEE9<9>475CD;4 @---.L %
4:7C234J?45@4@ @--((L (% >25@?D><2<7D5 4J?45@4@ @L
*+, -! ! /
01232 -! ! + 5H74=DE>4:9C<7D575CD;?45@2<7D5?D75<5D7@ 25@=4>4:?2><3B752EE7>;2<7H4 D5@4G945<3BED33D=756'
- 10 -
7 ??4237@ ))-. /
77 $9:6;45<25:2=2>::2<4:?2@@4:
AB >75C7?23 7@<>7C< 25: 4@@7D5@ $9:64 25:
27C19> 75
5D& 7@ ! 777 327;25< 7@ 143: 45<7<34: ED> >4:9C4:
CD;?45@2<7D5 DE @& 2@ 26275@< & 2=2>:4: AB >7A9523 =7<1 75<4>4@<2<>2<4DE(M?4>2559;E>D;:2<4DE C327;?4<7<7D5<733>4237N2<7D5
7H ;D95< 75 :4?D@7< A4 <>25@;7<<4: <D <>7A9523 ED>:7@A9>@23
H 5@9>4>7@372A34<D?2BA2325C47E25B25:7@ :7>4C<4: <D :4?D@7< @2;4 =7<1 75<4>4@< A4ED>4 >7A9523=7<175ED9>=44F@
H7 5C2@4DE25B4JC4@@@2;4@1233A4>4E95:4: <D2??43325<75@9>4>
26 '%% ( #
7@<D'3D'