- 1 - !" #"$"" "% & '&()* +&)) , !" # $ $ % " %&" ' % ( ) !" # * %&'*! #%' * "% $ " $ ) * " $ $* ( " ( Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ** ' +"$ !+"$ # ,- .-/01023 4-505023-. 6-037 5,- 899:1-; 03 2235,-<0=-2<5,-=-8.3-;;;=0/0= $:;7- 83; $* 809,:. !<2. 1,2.5 >.08= 2:.5# 01 0?4:73037 5,- @:;7?-35 2< 923/095023 83; 2.;-. 2< 1-35-39-;85-;923/095037,0?<2.5,-2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-. -95023 % 2< 5,- -725086=- 315.:?-351 95 !<2. 1,2.5 > 95A# 83; 1-35-39037 52 48B <03- 2< 1) !:4--1 0C 8D,1 3=B# E05, ;-<8:=51-35-39-E,09,E81923<0.?-;03.0?038=44-8= 2)235,-<0=-2<5,-=-8.3-;.039048= 015.09583; -110231 $:;7- 809,:. !,-.-038<5-. .-<-..-; 52 81 >*0.15 44-==85- 2:.5A# /0;- @:;7?-35 ;85-; 6B ;01?0110375,-844-8=83;923<0.?0375,-@:;7?-354811-; 6B5,-.08=2:.5 - 3 - *8951 2< 5,- 981- 03 6.0-< 8.- 5,85 5,- .-1423;-35 ,-.-03 81 92?4=803835 ,81 <0=-; 5,- 4.0/85- 92?4=803503287803155,-899:1-;8==-7037 92??0110232<5,-2<<-39-4:301,86=-:3;-.-95023%2< 5,-955015,-9235-350232<5,-92?4=8038356-<2.- 5,-.08=2:.55,855,-899:1-;01,01<8?0=B<.0-3;83;,- 8/80=-; ,83; =283 2< 1 <.2? 5,- 92?4=803835 ;:.0374.0=-4.2?01-;52.-48B5,-18?-E05,03 5E2 ?235,1 2E8.;1 .-48B?-35 2< =283 8?2:35 5,- 899:1-;011:-;5,-9,-F:-814-.C;85-;)) <2. 1 ',-3 5,- 180; 9,-F:- E81 4.-1-35-; <2. -3981,?-35 5,- 18?- E81 ;01,232.-; 81 5,-.- E81 031:<<090-35 <:3; 03 5,- 8992:35 2< 5,- 899:1-; ,- =-78= 32509- 81 4-. C E81 011:-; 03<2.?037 5,- 899:1-; .-78.;037;01,232.2<5,-9,-F:-83;98==037:423,0?52 .-48B5,-9,-F:-8?2:35315-8;2<.-48B0375,-9,-F:- 8?2:35 ,- 011:-; .-4=B 32509- 81 4-. C) 58D037 :35-386=- ;-<-39- 83; 5,-.-6B 92??055-; 5,- 2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-. -95023 % 2< 95 ,-.-<2.- 5,- - 4 - 92?4=803835.-F:-15-;5,-.08=2:.55258D-92730G839- 2<5,-2<<-39-83;520305085-=-78=895023 % ,- .08= 2:.5 522D 92730G839- 2< 5,- 2<<-39- 83; 1:??23-; 5,- 899:1-; 6B .-7015-.037 5,- 981- 03 2,-899:1-;844-8.-;6-<2.-5,-.08= 2:.583;4=-8;-;3257:0=5B83;9=80?-;526-5.0-;,- 92?4=803835 -C8?03-; ,0?1-=< 81 ' 83; 725 ?8.D-; C152)031:442.52<,019235-35023,-899:1-;,81 ;-30-;8==5,-039.0?0385037?85-.08=18/80=86=-23.-92.; -C8?03-;,0?1-=<81 '83;725?8.D-;C1 52 % 031:442.52<,01;-<-39-,-.08=2:.58<5-.58D0370352 92310;-.85023 8== 5,-1- ?85-.08=1 23 .-92.; 98?- 52 5,- 9239=:1023 5,85 5,- 92?4=803835 01 1:99-11<:= 03 4.2/037 5,-7:0=52<5,-899:1-;6-B23;.-812386=-;2:656:55,- 899:1-; ,81 325 .-6:55-; 5,- =-78= 4.-1:?45023 83; 5,-.-<2.- 01 =086=- <2. 923/095023 992.;037=B 5,- 0?4:73-; @:;7?-35 2< 923/095023 83; 2.;-. 2< 1-35-39- 98?-526-4811-; - 5 - "-037877.0-/-;6B5,-18?-5,-899:1-;,81 4.-<-..-;.0?038=44-8=2),-*0.1544-==85- 2:.523.-844.-90850232<5,-?85-.08=123.-92.;<2:3; 5,855,-92?4=803835011:99-11<:=034.2/0375,-7:0=52< 5,- 899:1-; 6-B23; .-812386=- ;2:65 83; 8992.;037=B ;01?011-; 5,- 844-8= 6B 923<0.?037 5,- @:;7?-35 2< 923/09502383;2.;-.2<1-35-39-"-037877.0-/-;6B5,- 18?-5,-899:1-;016-<2.-5,012:.5 -8.; .0 8,835-1, 850= =-8.3-; 92:31-= <2. 5,-.-/010234-505023-.83;.0,0/8383; 8558381,-550 =-8.3-;92:31-=<2.5,-.-1423;-35-.:1-;5,-?85-.08=1 23.-92.; ) 3 /0-E 2< 5,- .0/8= 9235-350231 :.7-; 6B 5,- =-8.3-;92:31-=<2.625,5,-48.50-15,-420355,85E2:=; 8.01-<2.?B92310;-.8502301 - 6 - & B 831E-. 52 5,- 862/- 42035 01 03 5,- +<2.5,-<2==2E037 1 1585-; 862/- 05 01 5,- 9235-35023 2< 5,- 92?4=803835 5,85 5,- 899:1-; ,8; 8/80=-; 5,- =283 2< 1 ;:.037 4.0= 2E8.;1 .-48B?-35 2< 5,-18?-5,-9,-F:-814-.CE81011:-;,-5-32. 2<9.211-C8?03850232<'83;5,--/0;-39-=-8;6B5,- 899:1-; 81 ' ;019=21- 5,85 ,- ,81 58D-3 8 ;-<-39- 5,85 ,- ,8; 62..2E-; =283 2< 1 <.2? 5,- 92?4=803835 ;:.037 83; ,8; 011:-; 5,- 6=83D 9,-F:-C811-9:.05B-,8;.-480;5,-=2838?2:35 E,09,E8158D-36B5,-92?4=8038356:55,-6=83D9,-F:- 011:-;811-9:.05BE81?01:1-;6B5,-92?4=803835 ',-3 5,- 899:1-; 8;?051 011:839- 2< 5,- 9,-F:-E05,,01107385:.-15,-4.-1:?45023:3;-.-95023 83;%2<95E2:=;8.01-,-6:.;-31,0<5123 5,-899:1-;52.-6:55,-=-78=4.-1:?45023<2.E,09,,-01 .-F:0.-; 52 4.2686=0G- ,01 ;-<-39- /-3 5,2:7, 5,- - 7 - 899:1-; 9.211-C8?03-; ' 83; 15-44-; 0352 5,- E053-11 62C 81 ' 83; 725 ?8.D-; C1 52 % ,01 ;-<-39-013254.26868=0G-;3;-.1:9,90.9:?15839-1,- 01=086=-<2.923/095023 ,8/-723-5,.2:7,5,-0?4:73-;@:;7?-352< 923/09502383;2.;-.2<1-35-39-4811-;6B5,-.08=2:.5 E,09, E81 923<0.?-; 6B 5,- *0.15 44-==85- 2:.5 "25, 5,- 2:.51 ,8/- 58D-3 0352 92310;-.85023 8== 5,-1- ?85-.08=123.-92.;83;.07,5=B923/095-;5,-899:1-;;2 325<03;83B.-812352035-.<-.-E05,5,-18?- 5 5,01 1587- =-8.3-; 92:31-= <2. 5,- .-1423;-351:6?055-;5,855,-899:1-;E81923/095-;83; ,-,8;:3;-.58D-35248B5,-<03-8?2:356-<2.-5,-*0.15 44-==85-2:.52E-/-.,-,8;325480;5,-18?-/-3 6-<2.- 5,01 2:.5 5,- 923;050238= 2.;-. 2< 1:14-31023 2< 1-35-39- E81 265803-; 1:6@-95 52 ;-42105 2< H 2< 5,- <03- 8?2:35 2E-/-. 5,- 18?- ,81 325 6--3 92?4=0-; E05,50==;85-83;,-39-4.8B1<2.48110371:0586=-2.;-.1 - 8 - -8.3-; 92:31-= <2. 5,- .-/01023 4-505023-. 1:6?051 5,85 5,- 844-==835899:1-; E0== ?8D- 8..837-?-3515248B5,-<03-8?2:35E05,035E2?235,1 % 3/0-E2<5,-862/-831E-.5,-862/-42035 035,-> 83;4.29--;5248115,-<2==2E037 0# .0?038=.-/010234-50502301 00# 231-F:-35=B5,-.-/010234-505023-.899:1-;01 ;0.-95-; 52 ;-42105 5,- <03- 8?2:35 6-<2.- 5,- .08=2:.5E05,035E2?235,1<.2?52;8B -7015.B 01 ;0.-95-; 52 1-3; 689D 5,- .08= 2:.5 .-92.;1 8=237 E05, 5,- 924B 2< 5,01 @:;7?-35 <2. 03<2.?8502383;3--;<:=895023 -* &"") $ 0152=2 I