Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63851 (KAR)

NAGARAJ S/O RAMESH GANI v. PUNDALIK S/O RAMAPPA WALIKAR AND ANR

MFA/200832/2023 · 2025-11-13

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"# $%& && ' () * ! "# # !$ % & % ' # % !() ! ! ** ! % ! !#% !#! %# ! " !! ! % !* + $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! * * "$ * ! ! ! & ! # * ! ! & * ! * ! ! ! ' , ! ! ! & ! ! # & ! * ! * * ! !& ! -# ! % !./0122314/05/436789.3:41/;1<91=1/<099.3 >?6=;3<9 1<6 1@1A6 61936 ' 21003678 9.3 66/9/B<14 3</BA /C/4 ?6=3 1<6 B;;/00/B<3A 5BA ;24B8330 B;23<019/B< :9 />1812?A1 D5BA 0.BA9 EB;;/00/B<3AFG/<B, !.3/<>?A36:41/;1<91=36831A0@BAH/<=10 6A/C3A /< 9.3 1?9B A/:H0.1@ 731A/<= A3=/09A19/B< B% ?<63A A302B<63<9 B ;39 @/9. 1< 1::/63<9 B< ' @.3< .3 @10 B< ./0 6?98 10 23A 9.3 - 3 - /<09A?:9/B<0 B5 A302B<63<9 B 1<6 0?091/<36 =A/3CB?0 /<>?A/3035/4361:41/;239/9/B<735BA39.3B;;/00/B<3A 033H/<= :B;23<019/B< B5 0 B< 1::B?<9 B5 /<>?A/30 0?091/<36 78 ./; 6?A/<= 9.3 :B?A03 B5 ./0 3;24B8;3<9 !.3 B;;/00/B<3A 1593A :B<0/63A/<= 9.3 3<9/A33C/63<:3B<A3:BA66/0;/00369.3:41/;239/9/B<B< 9.3=AB?<69.199.3:41/;1<951/4369B309174/0.3;24B833 1<6 3;24B83A A3419/B<0./2 739@33< ./;0345 1<6 A302B<63<9 B ==A/3C36 78 9.3 01/6 1@1A6 9.3 239/9/B<3A:41/;1<9.102A353AA369./0122314 31A6 1A=?;3<90 B5 7B9. 9.3 21A9/30 1<6 23A?0369.3;193A/141C1/41743B<A3:BA6 ' 31A<36:B?<034 5BA 9.31223441<9:41/;1<9 .10 :B<93<6369.199.31223441<9@10@BAH/<=106A/C3A/<9.3 1?9B A/:H0.1@ B% ?<63A A302B<63<9 B 1<6.3@1031A</<=023A;B<9.1<60 61/48 71991 9 /0 5?A9.3A :B<93<636 9.19 A302B<63<9 BB@<3A /< ./0 @A/993< 09193;3<9 .10 16;/9936 9.3 A3419/B<0./2 B5 3;24B83A 1<6 3;24B833 739@33< ./;0345 - 4 - 1<6 9.3 :41/;1<9 1<6 B::?AA3<:3 B5 1::/63<9 6?A/<= 9.3 :B?A03 B5 3;24B8;3<9 7?9 9.3 B;;/00/B<3A 3AA36 /< 6/0;/00/<=9.3239/9/B< 9.3 431A<36 :B?<034 5BA A302B<63<9 B I <0?A1<:3 B;21<8 0?22BA90 9.3 /;2?=<36 >?6=;3<9 1<6 1@1A6 210036 78 9.3 B;;/00/B<3A 9 /0 :B<93<6369.199.3A3/0:431A16;/00/B<78&":41/;1<9$ 9.19A302B<63<9BB@<3AB59.3C3./:43.10<B9.1<636 BC3A9.31?9B9B./;1<6.36/6<B9033A302B<63<9B 9/4461931<6B<31<=?.1<636BC3A9.31?9B9B./;@.B /0 <B9 9.3 B@<3A B5 9.3 C3./:43 1<6 9.?0 9.3 <0?A1<:3 B;21<8A3J?309365BA6/0;/0014B59.3122314 < 9./0 122314 9.3 5B44B@/<= 0?7091<9/14 J?309/B<0B541@@B?461A/035BA:B<0/63A19/B< - 5 - ! ! ! " # $ K 23A?014 B5 @A/993< 09193;3<9 5/436 78 A302B<63<9 B 735BA3 9.3 B;;/00/B<3A A3C3140 9.19 A302B<63<9B /09.3 B@<3A B5 1?9B 1<6 19 9.3 9/;3B5 1::/63<9:41/;1<9@10@BAH/<=106A/C3A/<9.301/61?9B < C/3@ B5 0?:. 16;/00/B< 78 A302B<63<9 B /< ./0 @A/993<09193;3<9/9/0:431A9.3:41/;1<9.10309174/0.36 3;24B83A 1<6 3;24B833 A3419/B<0./2 739@33< A302B<63<9 B 1<6 ./;0345 1<6 9.19 9.3 1::/63<9 /0 6?A/<= 9.3 :B?A03B5./03;24B8;3<9#?99.3B;;/00/B<3A51/4369B 122A3:/193 9.3 51:902AB23A48 !.3A35BA3 9./0 B?A9 /0B5 9.3 C/3@ 9.19 /;2?=<36 >?6=;3<9 1<6 1@1A6 210036 78 9.3B;;/00/B<3A/09B7303910/63 3=1A6/<= :B;23<019/B< 9./0 B?A9 .10 =B<3 9.AB?=. 9.3 ;193A/14 1C1/41743 B< A3:BA6 ?3 9B 1::/63<914 /<>?A/30 1223441<9 .10 0?091/<36 =A/3CB?0 - 6 - /<>?A/30 9/0091936789.3:41/;1<99.19.3@1016;/9936 9B/09A/:9B02/914/>1812?A11<69.3A31593A9B%?<61A=/ B02/914 />1812?A1 @.3A3/< .3 9BBH 9A319;3<9 10 /<219/3<9 1<6 023<9 0 5BA ./0 9A319;3<9 < 0?22BA9 B5 ./0 :103 .3 .10 2AB6?:36 &B?<6 3A9/5/:193 /0:.1A=3 ?;;1A8 B02/914 #/440 /017/4/98 3A9/5/:193 1<6LA18A32BA901<6140B3M1;/<369.3B:9BA10& @.B /00?36 M I /017/4/98 3A9/5/:193 100300/<= N 6/017/4/98!.3A35BA39./0B?A95/<60/9A310B<17439B91H3 A6B5N'N9B;3399.33<60B5>?09/:3 , 6;/9936486193B51::/63<9/0'1<6 :41/;1<9 @10 1=36 831A0 19 9.3 9/;3 B5 1::/63<9 !.B?=.:41/;1<9091930 9.19.3 @10 31A</<=0 23A;B<9.1<6023A61810#1991#?91023A9.3 <B9/5/:19/B< ./0 /<:B;3 /0 9B 73 91H3< 10 0 23A ;B<9. 1<6 0/<:3 /9 /0 :103 B5 /<>?A8 N B5 0 0'23A;B<9./09B7391H3<5BA9.32?A2B03 B5 6393A;/<19/B< B5 :B;23<019/B< 0 9.3 :41/;1<9 @10 1=36831A0199.39/;3B51::/63<99.3A343C1<951:9BA/0 - 7 - K ::BA6/<=48 9.3 :41/;1<9 /0 3<9/9436 :B;23<019/B<10?<63A 0'MKM'NO0' *?A9.3A 9.3 :41/;1<9 /0 3<9/9436 9B 0KK 9B@1A60;36/:143M23<0301023A9.3;36/:147/440!.?0 9.3 9B914 :B;23<019/B< :B;30 9B 0' 14B<= @/9. /<93A309 19 N 23A 1<<?; 5AB; 9.3 6193 B5 1::/63<9 9/44 A314/P19/B< <9.3A30?499.35B44B@/<=BA63A/0210036 "/$ 22314/0 "//$ !.3 :41/;1<9 /0 3<9/9436 5BA 9.3 3<.1<:36 :B;23<019/B< B5 0' @/9. /<93A309 19 N 23A 1<<?; 5AB; 9.3 6193 B5 1::/63<99/44A314/P19/B< "///$ 302B<63<9 B I <0?A1<:3 B;21<8 /0 6/A3:936 9B 632B0/9 9.3 15BA301/6 - 8 - :B;23<019/B<1;B?<914B<=@/9./<93A309@/9./< B<3;B<9.5AB;9.36193B59./0>?6=;3<9 "/C$ < 0?:. 632B0/9 9.3 :41/;1<9 /0 23A;/99369B@/9.6A1@9.33<9/A31;B?<914B<= @/9./<93A3091::A?36B</9 06 (&) % # /09B4BK !