- 1 - !"# $ %& '%(!!!% % )%!* ! " # $% & &' (!!( " # && ) % & ' ( & ' & && && ! ' *& & & & !+ &' Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & & '& & '& & +!(+!,+!+ & (! '& & - +!!+ & & ./ & ' & 0 0 &1 & & #0&1 & &% 23$ 45636378 3$ 93:5; <= >??@$5; 7 $55A38B 97C D@>$238B796254C7?55;38B$458;38B38C3E57 !+ 79 ><>:5$2F>C> 7:3?5 6>6378 3$6 3G>=>4@C> 97C 625 79958?5$4@83$2><:5@8;5C5?6378$+!(+!,+!>8;+ 79 8;3>858>:7;5 (! 25 9>?6$ 38 <C359 >C5 62>6 625 456363785C 3$ >CC>=5; >$ ??@$5; 7 >8; F>$ $5CH38B >$ 585C>: >8>B5C #45C>6378$% 73:5C 5?6378 >6 $ >8;23 >2>A>C3 >AA>C5 >CA2>85 3=>E36 C3$28>8>B>C #% 4@C$@>86 67 >8 >447386E586 :5665C ;>65; - 3 - ! + 8 625 =5>C ! @8;5C677A >8 5I4>8$378 4C7G5?6 >8; 9:7>65; 658;5C$ 97C 625 $>3; 4@C47$58I5?@63H57EE36655E55638B?2>3C5;<=625 C5$3;586F>$25:;78!!! F25C538625456363785C 38 625 87CE>: ?7@C$5 79 23$ 7993?3>: ;@635$ 4:>?5; 625 >B58;>C5:>638B67625745838B>8;5H>:@>63787965?283?>: <3;$ @<$5D@586:= 78 ! !! > E55638B 79 625 7>C; 79 3C5?67C$ >8>B38B 3C5?67C >8; 585C>: >8>B5C F>$ ?78H585; 38 F23?2 625 7>C; C5$7:H5; 67 3$$@5 > 9C5$2 5665C 79 86586 38 9>H7@C 79 $ @B>C 8B3855C$ C3H>65 3E365; 25 $>3; ;5?3$378 3$ 5H3;58?5; <= 625C5$7:@6378 >6 885I@C5J :627@B2 >8>BC55E586 2>;5>C:35C<5585I5?@65;F362 $ 78 !! 6257>C;7F38B67?7$65$?>:>6378>8;C5H3$5;7995C$9C7E 6257C3B38>:658;5C5C$677A>?78$?37@$;5?3$37867?>8?5: 6255>C:35C>F>C;>8;3$$@5>9C5$25665C79 86586;>65; !! !! ?@:E38>638B 38 > $@44:= >BC55E586 ;>65; (!!! 25 456363785C/$ C7:5 F>$ :3E365; 67 $3B838B 625$>3;$@44:=>BC55E586E5C5:=>$625$5?78;F3685$$ - 4 - F3627@6 <538B > $3B8>67C= 38 23$ 7993?3>: ?>4>?36= 7C > 4>C63?34>8638625;5?3$378E>A38B4C7?5$$ 25456363785C C5$3B85; 9C7E >8; F>$ C5:35H5; 9C7E $5CH3?5 78 !!! 6 3$ ?78658;5; 62>6 >965C 85>C:= 97@C =5>C$ 5$478;586 7 2>$ :7;B5; 625 4C5$586 ?7E4:>386 >::5B38B 9C>@; >8; 3CC5B@:>C3635$ 38 625 658;5C 4C7?5$$ 627@B2 625 ;3$4@65 3$ 5$$5863>::= ?7EE5C?3>: 38 8>6@C5 5>C85;?7@8$5:97C625456363785C$@<E36$62>6625C53$87 $45?393?7H5C6>?6>66C3<@65;67625456363785CF27853625C 2>;>@627C36=67>44C7H5E7;39=7C>F>C;625658;5C87C 4>C63?34>65;38625;5?3$378$6>A585I?:@$3H5:=>66257>C; :5H5: 6 3$ 62@$ @CB5; 62>6 ?78638@>6378 79 4C7?55;38B$ >B>38$6625456363785C3$F27::=@8F>CC>865; &>H38B 25>C; 625 :5>C85; ?7@8$5: 97C 625 456363785C>8;625:5>C85;&3B27@C67H5C8E586:5>;5C 97C 625 6>65623$ 7@C6 2>$?>C59@::=5H>:@>65; 625C3H>: ?786586378$ >8; E563?@:7@$:= 45C@$5; 625 ?7E4:>386 625 ?2>CB5$2556 E>65C3>:$ 4:>?5; 78 C5?7C; >8; 625 ;7?@E586$C5:35;@478<=625456363785C - 5 - + ?>C59@:5I>E38>637879625?7E4:>386;3$?:7$5$ 62>687$45?393?;59383657C?78?C565>::5B>63783$:5H5::5; >B>38$6 625 456363785C >66C3<@638B >8= >?63H5 C7:5 38 625 >::5B5;E3$>44C74C3>637838;@?5E586;3$2785$6386586378 7C;3H5C$378799@8;$$C3B26:=473865;7@6<=625:5>C85; ?7@8$5: 97C 625 456363785C 625 E>65C3>: 78 C5?7C; @8E3$6>A><:= 38;3?>65$ 62>6 625 456363785C <538B 625 585C>: >8>B5C #45C>6378$% 79 625 73:5C 5?6378 F>$ 45C97CE38B C7@6385 >;E383$6C>63H5 >8; ?:5C3?>: ;@635$ &3$ 38H7:H5E5863$?789385;78:=674:>?38B625>B58;><597C5 625 I5?@63H5 7EE36655 >8; :>65C $3B838B 625 $@44:= >BC55E586;>65; (!!!E5C5:=>$>$5?78;F3685$$ >8; 876 >$ >8 >@627C3$5; $3B8>67C= 7C > ;5?3$378E>A38B >@627C36=796257745C>63H57?356= 25 $27C6 <@6 $@<$6>863>: D@5$6378 62>6 625C597C5>C3$5$97C?78$3;5C>63783$F25625C>45C$78F27 $3B8$ > ;7?@E586 E5C5:= >$ > F3685$$ F3627@6 <538B > 4>C6= 67 625 6C>8$>?6378 7C F3627@6 >8= C7:5 38 36$ 85B763>6378 >44C7H>: $>8?6378 7C 5I5?@6378 ?>8 <5 - 6 - 9>$6585; F362 ?C3E38>: :3><3:36= ><$586 >8= E>65C3>: 67 $27F 23$ 4>C63?34>6378 ><56E586 7C ?78$43C>?= 38 625 @8;5C:=38B 6C>8$>?6378 25 C5?7C;$ 4:>?5; <597C5 623$ 7@C6 ;7 876 ;3$?:7$5 5H58 > C5E765 $@BB5$6378 62>6 625 456363785CF>$38H7:H5;387C4C3H=67625;5?3$378E>A38B 4C7?5$$ C5:>638B 67 9:7>638B 658;5C$ 5H>:@>638B <3;$ >44C7H38B ?786C>?67C$ ?>8?5::38B 625 5>C:35C 7C 3$$@38B6259C5$25665C79 8658638>8@>C=!! ( 25 >::5B>6378$ 38 625 ?7E4:>386 5$$5863>::= $65E9C7E625;5?3$378796257>C;793C5?67C$67?2>8B5 625 ?786C>?67C C5H3$5 625 658;5C H>:@5 >8; ?>8?5: 625 5>C:35C>F>C;7F38B67?7$65$?>:>6378$>8;C5H3$5;7995C$ 25$5>C54@C5:=?7EE5C?3>:>8;>;E383$6C>63H5;5?3$378$ 6>A58>6625:5H5:796257>C; 25456363785C3$876$27F8 67 2>H5 <558 586C@$65; F362 >8= 938>8?3>: 47F5C$ ;3$?C56378>C= >@627C36= 7C $@45CH3$7C= ?786C7: 7H5C 625 658;5C4C7?5$$H58625$@<$5D@586;5H5:74E586$F23?2 97CE 625 <>$3$ 79 625 >::5B>6378$ 7??@CC5; >965C 625 456363785C 2>; 658;5C5; 23$ C5$3B8>6378 >8; F>$ C5:35H5; - 7 - 9C7E $5CH3?5 78 !!! 23$ 9>?6 $@993?3586:= 5$6><:3$25$62>6625456363785C2>;?5>$5;67<5>$$7?3>65; F3626257?356=<=62563E5625>::5B5;3CC5B@:>C3635$>C5 $6>65;672>H5$@C9>?5; 8 625 ><$58?5 79 >::5B>6378$ 7C E>65C3>: ;5E78$6C>638B 586C@$6E586 79 4C745C6= ;3$2785$6 386586378 7C <C5>?2 79 6C@$6 625 5$$5863>: 38BC5;3586$ 79 5?6378$+!(>8;+!,79 >C5F27::=><$5863E3:>C:= 97C >8 79958?5 @8;5C 5?6378 +!79 625 4C7$5?@6378 E@$6 4C3E> 9>?35 5$6><:3$2 ;3$2785$6 386586378 >6 625 38?546378 79 625 6C>8$>?6378 25 C5?7C;$ 9>:: $3B8393?>86:= $27C6 79 623$ C5D@3C5E586 7 E>65C3>: $@BB5$6$ 62>6 625 456363785C 2>; >8= 9C>@;@:586 386586 7C 62>6 25 38;@?5; >8=785674>C6F362E785=7C4C745C6=3A5F3$55?6378 + 79 #E3$?2359% 3$ F27::= 38>44:3?><:5 67 625 456363785C >$ 625C5 3$ 87 >::5B>6378 79 ;5$6C@?6378 >:65C>63787CFC78B9@::7$$?>@$5;<=23E 25 &78/<:5 @4C5E5 7@C6 38 > ?>658> 79 G@;BE586$ 38?:@;38B - 8 - 2>$5E42>63?>::=25:;62>64@C5:=?7EE5C?3>:?786C>?6@>: 7C <@$385$$ ;3$4@65$ ?>8876 <5 6C>8$97CE5; 3867 ?C3E38>: 4C7$5?@6378 E5C5:= <5?>@$5 785 4>C6= >::5B5$ 938>8?3>: :7$$ '258 625 ;3$4@65 3$ 4C5;7E38>86:= ?3H3: 38 8>6@C5 ?C3E38>: 4C7?55;38B$ 7@B26 876 67 <5 45CE3665; 4>C63?@:>C:=F25885?5$$>C=38BC5;3586$7962579958?5$>C5 ?78$43?@7@$:=><$5867@C6$2>H5?78$3$6586:=;54C5?>65; >665E46$673E4>C6>?C3E38>:?7:7@C67?3H3:;3$4@65$>$> E5>8$795I5C638B4C5$$@C5784>C635$ , 25 ?7E4:>38>86 2>$ ?27$58 67 38$636@65 625 4C5$586 ?C3E38>: 4C7?55;38B$ >965C > :>4$5 79 85>C:= 97@C =5>C$9C7E625456363785C/$C5$3B8>6378F3627@65I4:>3838B 625;5:>=7C4C7;@?38B>8=38?C3E38>638BE>65C3>:>B>38$6 23E 25 ><$58?5 79 >8= >::5B>6378 62>6 625 456363785C ;5C3H5; 45?@83>C= <585936 ?7::@;5; F362 ?786C>?67C$ E>834@:>65;;7?@E586$7C>?65;F362;3$2785$6386586378 C53897C?5$ 625 ?78?:@$378 62>6 625 4C7?55;38B$ >C5 1#!+% !(,! - 9 - 38$636@65;78:=67C745385H5C=45C$78C5E765:=?7885?65; F362 625 4C7G5?6 F23?2 >E7@86$ 67 > ?:>$$3? 5I>E4:5 79 ><@$579625?C3E38>:4C7?5$$ ! 25 &78/<:5 @4C5E5 7@C6 2>$ ?>65B7C3?>::= :>3; ;7F8 ?3C?@E$6>8?5$ 38 F23?2 4C7?55;38B$ E>= <5 D@>$25;@8;5C6253825C586G@C3$;3?637879623$7@C6$@?2 >$ F258 625 >::5B>6378$ ;7 876 ?78$636@65 >8= 79958?5 F258 @8?786C7H5C65; E>65C3>: ;75$ 876 ;3$?:7$5 625 38H7:H5E586 79 625 >??@$5; >8; F258 625 4C7?55;38B$ >445>C67<538363>65;E>:3?37@$:=7CF362@:65C37CE763H5$ 254C5$586?>$5$D@>C5:=9>::$F36238625$5?>65B7C35$>$ 87 4C3E> 9>?35 E>65C3>: 5I3$6$ >B>38$6 625 456363785C >8; 625 ?78638@>6378 79 4C7?55;38B$ F7@:; C5$@:6 38 $5C37@$ E3$?>CC3>B579G@$63?5 25C597C5 38 7C;5C 67 $5?@C5 625 58;$ 79 G@$63?5 623$ 7@C6 3$ 45C$@>;5; 67 38H7A5 36$ 3825C586 G@C3$;3?6378 @8;5C 5?6378 + 79 C 87F ?7CC5$478;38B 67 5?6378 79 625 2>C>63=> >B>C3A - 10 - @C>A$2>>8236>!674C5H586625E3$@$579?C3E38>: :>F 7C62597C5B738BC5>$78$623$7@C64>$$5$625 97::7F38B0 3'C36456363783$! 33 C7?55;38B 458;38B 38 C3E5 7 !+ 79 ><>:5$2F>C> 7:3?5 6>6378 3$6 3G>=>4@C> 97C 625 79958?5$4@83$2><:5@8;5C5?6378$+!(+!,+!>8;+ 79 8;3>8 58>: 7;5 (! >C5 D@>$25; 38 $7 9>C >$ 625 456363785C25C5383$?78?5C85; !+, )!!% %* ( 3$670:70, 0