Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63837 (KAR)

GURUNATH S/O SANGAPPA KADLE v. SANJIVE REDDY S/O VITHAL REDDY SHERIKAR AND ANR

MFA/200220/2023 · 2025-11-19

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #$% %% &"' ( ! " # $ % #% &' # () # %&# * # ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ' ) + &$ #' ' )+"$'# ' # '' # # & #' %# & # # # # '# , ) & ( & # ' # %#& # -# % $ " -# % $ ./0 122314 /0 5/436 78 9.3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 =:63> 3;9/?:)+"$?5#?9?>3./;430;9 ,;.1443:@/:@9.3 A=6@<3:91:61B1>661936 210036/:#? 78 9.3 664 /09>/;9 1:6 300/?:0 ?=>9 1:6 664 #/61> 0/99/:@19=<:1716 9?<?6/589.301/6 A=6@<3:91:69?3:.1:;39.3;?<23:019/?: - 3 - 31>69.31>@=<3:90?59.3431>:36;?=:0345?> 9.3 1223441:9 1:6 431>:36 ;?=:034 5?> >302?:63:9 ? ?9/;39?>302?:63:9? /06/023:036B/9. + .3/:A=>36;41/<1:91@36831>0 B.?<39B/9. 1: 1;;/63:9 ?: , 5/436 ;41/< 239/9/?: ;41/</:@ ;?<23:019/?: ?5 0 735?>3 9.3 9>/7=:14 =9 9.3 9>/7=:14 ;?:0/63>/:@ 9.3 3:9/>3 3C/63:;3 ?: >3;?>6 @>1:936 ;?<23:019/?: ?5 0 , ) B/9. /:93>309 19 9.3>193?5(D2 1 5>?<6193?5239/9/?:9/44>314/019/?: @@>/3C36 78 9.3 01/6 ?>63> 9./0 122314 /0 2>353>>36 /:B./;./9/0;?:93:9369.199.36?;9?>10030036 +D6/017/4/989?9.343594?B3>4/<71:6D9?9.3>/@.9 4?B3>4/<7 =99.39>/7=:14.1091E3:?:48D 3B10 31>:/:@ 0 2 1 =9 9.3 9>/7=:14 .10 91E3: 0 , 23><?:9.1:69.31<?=:9@>1:936=:63>9.3 ?9.3> .3160 1>3 140? <31@3> .3>35?>3 >3F=30936 5?> 3:.1:;3<3:9?5;?<23:019/?: - 4 - 0 23> G 1:6 140? 10 23> 9.3 6/0;.1>@3 0=<<1>8 /9 B10 ?703>C36 9.19 9.3 239/9/?:3> 0=091/:36 ! " # $ % ! & ' ( ! ()**( $449.3/:A=>/30 1>3@>/3C?=0/::19=>3 &100300369.36/017/4/98=:63> G 6/017/4/98;3>9/5/;193 023>6/0;.1>@3;1>6.3B10 16</9936 ?: , 1:6 6/0;.1>@36 ?: , 1:69.=0.?02/914/H365?>)6180 9/05=>9.3>0919369.19 6=39?9.317?C3/:A=>/30 .3;1::?96?./061/481;9/C/9/30 ( .3 6?;9?> 10030036 9.3 6/017/4/98 10D 9? 9.3 >/@.9 4?B3> 4/<7 1:6 +D 9? 9.3 4359 4?B3> 4/<7 &.?43 7?686/017/4/98/0:?910030036 =99.39>/7=:14.1091E3: 9.36/017/4/9810D B/9.?=91:8710/0 ?:0/63>/:@9.3 :19=>3 ?5 /:A=>/30 9./0 ?=>9 5/:60 /9 >310?:1743 9? 91E3 - 5 - +>6 ?5 +D / 3 19 9.3 >193 ?5 ) ((D >?=:636 ?55 9? D ) .3 239/9/?:3> .10 :?9 5/436 1:8 /:;?<3 2>??5 9? 9.39>/7=:141:6.3<39B/9.1:1;;/63:9?: , 0 23> 9.3 @=/634/:30 ?5 9.3 1>:191E1 9193 3@14 3>C/;30 =9.?>/98 ./0 :19/?:14 /:;?<3 /0 9? 73 91E3: 10 0 + 0 .3 /0 1@36 831>0 <=49/24/3> 9? 73 91E3: 10 3:;3 9.3 4?00 ?5 5=9=>3 31>:/:@ ;121;/98 ;?<309?0 + GGGDI)*+ , 3B10.?02/914/0365?>)61801023>6/0;.1>@30=<<1>8 .39>/7=:14.16@>1:936) ,9?B1>60<36/;14 3G23:030 10 23> G ?:0/63>/:@ ./0 ?;;=219/?: :19=>3 ?5 /:A=>/30 23>/?6 ?5 .?02/914/H19/?: 1:6 ?9.3> 51;9?>0 9./0;?=>95/:60/9>310?:17439?@>1:91:1<?=:9 ),5?>21/:1:60=553>/:@ ) ,5?>4?00 ?5 1<3:/9/30 ) 5?> 9>1:02?>919/?: 3G9>1 :?=>/0.<3:91:61993:61:9;.1>@301:6.3</@.9:?9.1C3 1993:636 1:8 ?9.3> B?>E 5?> 1 23>/?6 ?5 <?:9.0 - 6 - .3>35?>3 ),"+ G$ /0 @>1:936 9?B1>60 4?00?531>:/:@6=>/:@41/6=223>/?6 .=0 /: 144 ;?<2?:3:90 1B1>63678 9./0 ;?=>9 1>310734?B , 3:;3 9.31223441:9;41/<1:9/03:9/94365?>9?914 ;?<23:019/?:?5) + ,14?:@B/9./:93>309199.3 >193 ?5 (D 2 1 /:09316 ?5 0 , ) 10 @>1:936 78 9.39>/7=:14 1>9/;=41>0 <?=:9 /:0 ?00 ?5 5=9=>3 31>:/:@ ;121;/98 , ) #36/;143G23:030 + ,,) 1/:1:60=553>/:@ ?00?51<3:/9/30 >1:02?>919/?: 3G9>1 :?=>/0.<3:9 1:6 1993:61:9;.1>@30 + ?00?5/:;?<36=>/:@41/6 =223>/?6 + -./ + - 7 - :9.3>30=49 9.35?44?B/:@?>63>/0210036 / 22314/0/:21>9 // .3 A=6@<3:9 1:6 1B1>6 210036 210036/:#? 78 9.3664 /09>/;91:6 300/?:0?=>91:6 #/61> 0/99/:@19=<:1716 /0 <?6/5/36 /// .3 ;41/<1:9 /0 3:9/9436 9? 1 0=< ?5 ) + , 14?:@ B/9. /:93>309 19 9.3 >193 ?5 (D 2 1 5>?< 9.3 6193 ?5 239/9/?: 9/44 9.3 6193 ?5 >314/H19/?: /:09316 ?50 , )@>1:936789.39>/7=:14 /C 302?:63:9 ? :0=>1:;3 ;?<21:8 14>3168 632?0/936 9.3 1<?=:9 1B1>636 78 9.3 9>/7=:14 1:6 .3:;3 /90 6/>3;936 9? 632?0/9 9.3 >3<1/:/:@ 1<?=:9 ?5 0 ( 14?:@ B/9. /:93>309 19 9.3 - 8 - >193?5(D2 1 B/9./:?:3<?:9.5>?<9.3 6193?59./0?>63> C : 0=;. 632?0/9 ;41/<1:9 /0 23></9936 9? B/9.6>1B 9.3 3:9/>3 1<?=:9 14?:@ B/9. /:93>3091;;>=36?:9.301<3 )0, &%' $ /09? 4?