- 1 - !"!# $%"& % ' '()* ')) *+ % , ' '()* ')) * + !! " # $%& ' !! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ( $ () ' $% #&% *+ !! " # $ ', %'(& ' !( ' ((- * (((! ' ' % $ $ ' ./01 ' (( ' '' -(-(- !!)' - ' ' ,* + ) $% *+ !! ( ' - 3 - $% *+ !! - )) ' $% *+ !! $ ) ' % *+ !! ! % - ' % * !( # & ) % -- ' % * " # $%& ' !! ' - 4 - ( $ () ' $% #&% *+ !! " # $ ', %'(& ' !( ' ((- * (((! ' ' % $ $ ' ' (( ' '' -(-(- ! !) ' - ' ' (2 ' 3 $% # 3 $% & 4506 07 5895: 517; ;450846 <./8=4; >.0 1?4 @41717.840= 07 $5A5650 ?5?5B/6678 ;450846 7C? ./01 .D408A481 ;45640 >.0 1?4 >70=1 04=@.864811514 - 5 - 586 07 585A581?05:5 786.; ;450846 <./8=4; >.0 1?4 =4<.8604=@.86481<.A@;57858178B.1?1?4@41717.8= ( 41717.840 78 0; .(-)((! 85A4;: 07:565=?787 . 50/17 7= 5<</=46 . 78 .(((! ?5= =./C?1 >.0 E/5=?78C .> 1?4 =576 @0.<44678C= .8 1?4 C0./86 1?51 =?4 7= =1058C40 1. 1?4 >5A7;: - .5;=.780; .(((!7804=@4<1.> @41717.840 .= ! 586 )5<</=46 .=! ) 586 2 ?5D4 =./C?1 >.0 E/5=?78C .> 1?4 @48678C @0.<44678C= 78 .(((! <.8148678C 1?51 1?4: 504 A500746 =7=140= .> 5<</=46 .58604=7678C=4@50514;: '5<1= 78 B074> F?7<? 504 /1A.=1 84<4==50: >.0 67=@.=5;.>1?4@04=481@41717.8=5045=/8640 <.A@;5781 <5A4 1. B4 ;.6C46 B: 1?4 =4<.86 04=@.86481 A1 /=585 5C578=1 1?4 $57=?44; 4104 586 .1?40= 1 7= 5;;4C46 1?51 @41717.840 07:5650=?787 7= - 6 - ?5D78C7;;7<7104;517.8=?7@F71?=576$57=?44;#5<</=46 .& F?.7=1?4?/=B586.>1?4=4<.8604=@.86481 ( 1 7= 5;=. 5;;4C46 1?51 @50481= .> >70=1 5<</=46 5048.A.04586?7=/8<;4586.1?4004;517D4=?5D4B448 04=@.8=7B;4 >.0 1?4 B7<G4078C 78 1?4 A5107A.875; 174 04=/;178C 78 A4815; 586 @?:=7<5; ?505==A481 B478C 7A@501461.=4<.8604=@.86481B:5;;1?45<</=46@40=.8= 5=5<</=46 .7=?5D78C5?5@@:;7>4F71?07:5650=?787 F?.7=5<</=46 . ! >14004<47@1.>1?4<.A@;5781.;7<404C7=14046 1?4 <5=4 B4>.04 1?4 .A48H= .;7<4 1517.8 7650 04C7=140467807A4 ..>((.82)((>.01?4 .>>48<4=@/87=?5B;4/86404<17.8=-(--(! !) 0456 F71? 4<17.8 .> 8675 485; .64 586 4<17.8=-586.>.F0:0.?7B717.8<1) ) ?4 .;7<4 5>140 1?.0./C? 78D4=17C517.8 >7;46 <?50C4=?4415C578=11?4@41717.840=#5<</=46 .=(1.& 586 5<</=46 . ?4 075; 5C7=10514 1..G <.C87I58<4 - 7 - 586 04C7=14046 1?4 <5=4 F?7<? 7= 8.F @48678C 78 .(((! 2 478C5CC074D46B:1?4=5A407:5650=?787586 5<</=46 .=(1.2504B4>.041?7=./01586?5D4=./C?1 >.0E/5=?78C.>1?4@48678C@0.<44678C= 07 5895: 517; ;450846 <./8=4; >.0 1?4 @41717.840= <.81486= 1?51 D40: 04C7=10517.8 586 <.8178/517.8 .> 1?4 <07A785; <5=4 5C578=1 1?4 @41717.840= ?5=04=/;146785B/=4.>@0.<4==.>;5F5=1?4:5048.F5: 04=@.8=7B;4 >.0 1?4 5;;4C46 7;;10451A481 >.0 =4<.86 04=@.86481 ;450846 7C? ./01 .D408A481 ;45640=/@@.01=1?4<.8178/517.8.>1?4<07A785;<5=4 5D78C?45061?450C/A481=.8B.1?=764=1?7= ./01@40/=461?4A514075;.804<.06A417</;./=;: 8=/<?@40/=5;.>1?4A514075;.804<.06717= <0:=15; <;450 1?51 07:5650=?7875<</=46 . B478C 1?4 - 8 - =1058C401.1?4>5A7;:<588.1B4?4;604=@.8=7B;4>.01?4 .>>48<4/86404<17.8.>86758485;.64 ( 1 1?4 A.=1 7> 1?4 =4<.86 04=@.86481 ?5= =./C?1 58: 04;74> 5C578=1 5<</=46 . 71 7= >.0 ?40 1. 78717514 5@@0.@07514 @0.<44678C= >.0 ?5D78C 7;;7<71 04;517.8=?7@F71?1?45<</=46 . - '/01?405<</=46 .=!1.2F?.504@41717.840 .=1.)780; .(((!B478CA500746=7=140= 504;7D78C=4@50514;:5866768.1=?504<.AA.80..> '.;;.F78C1?467<1/A.>1?4 .8HB;4@4J./01 78 1?4 <5=4 .> !"#04@.014678$%&58615G78C 8.14 .> 1?4 >5<1 1?51 1?4 5;;4C517.8= 5C578=1 1?4A 504 C48405; 586 .A87B/= 5;;4C517.8= 1?7= ./01 7= .> 1?4 <.8=764046 .@787.8 1?51 @0.<44678C F71? 5 <07A785; <5=4 5C578=11?4AF./;604=/;178A7=<50075C4.>9/=17<4 - 9 - ! 07 5895: 517; 5;=.@;5<46 .8 04<.06 5 A4A. =44G78C67=A7==5;.>1?4@41717.85=8.1@04==465=5C578=1 @41717.840 .=1.- ) 48<41?4>.;;.F78C 7& ?4 <07A785; @41717.8 .(-)((! 7= 5;;.F46 77& ?4 <07A785; @41717.8 .(((! 7= 5;;.F4678@501 777& 48678C @0.<44678C= 78 .(((! .81?4>7;4.>1?4078<7@5;7D7;$/6C4586 $ './01 7650507=78C./1.>07A4 .(( 04C7=14046 B: .A48 .;7<4 1517.8 7650 7= ?404B: E/5=?46 5= 5C578=15<</=46 .=1.)586 7D& : @;5<78C 1?4 A4A. .8 04<.06 @41717.8 5C578=1 5<</=46 . 1. - F?. 504 5<</=46 .=( 1. 7= ?404B: 67=A7==46 F71?;7B401:5=@05:46>.0 - 10 - D& 1 7= A564 <;450 1?7= ./01 ?5= 8.1 4J@04==46 58: .@787.8 1?4 A4071= .> 1?4 A51140 -* '&) " 7=1 .; .!