Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63832 (KAR)
IRAPPA v. RAMESH AND ANR
MFA/201923/2017 · 2025-09-19
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63832 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63832 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "!#
$%!!&!& !!##
'&( )
!" #
$%"
&
" % %
'
"
!"
" %
"" ()"")
!" #
$" )*
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!"!+"! %&
% ) )
,-$& ) % % %
) %
-!""!,
" -! %
"
%
%
)
"-,!!!!. % / "!!!!. % /
"
% )
) %
%
% 0 "%%
%
12345564723 82769 :; <742=4>? 366@2>A 6>14><6=6>? B8 <B=56>34?2B> 4C4D969 2> EF9A=6>? 4>9 4C4D9 94?69 -!""!,5433692> B" -! :;?16D2><25476>2BD 2G27F9A64>9 2E4;45FD4"
" D268 84<?3 76492>A ?B 8276 <742= 56?2?2B> 4D6 43 F>96D*
14?B>'"!"!?16<742=4>?4>94>B?16D.D66914D C6D6?D4G672>AB>=B?BD<;<76:64D2>A B". . '8DB= 4>>B772?B4;4C494A22774A6"?4:BF?"!!5"="C16>?16; C6D6 >64D ?16 74>9 B8 B>6
4>A4554 434??2 B> 4?12147. 2>94C4D9 DB49 4 E665 :64D2>A B". .,! <4=6 4>9
- 3 -
943169?B?16="3D63F7??16;3F3?42>6936G6D62>EFD2634>9 ?4@6 ?D64?=6>? 2> ?16 1B352?47" 16 <742=4>? 143 82769 <742= 56?2?2B>"16?D2:F>4714343363369<B=56>34?2B>4>9543369 EF9A=6>? 4>9 4C4D9" B? 34?238269 C2?1 ?16 <B=56>34?2B> 4C4D969 :; ?16 D2:F>47 ?16 <742=4>? 143 82769 ?123 5D636>? 455647"
-" %64D9764D>69<BF>3678BD?164556774>?4>9764D>69 <BF>3678BDD635B>96>? B">3FD4><6B=54>;"
'" 64D>69 <BF>367 8BD ?16 4556774>? CBF79 <B>?6>9 ?14??164<<296>?143?4@6>574<62>?16;64D!4>98BD?16 3429 ;64D ?16 >B?2B>47 2><B=6 23 3"!!!. 43 56D <14D? 5D654D69:;?166A476DG2<63F?1BD2?;8BD9235B347B8<4363 2>B@.49474?14>9?16D2:F>471436DD692>?4@2>A?162><B=6 4? 3",!!." %6 8FD?16D 3F:=2?3 ?14? "" B<?BD C1B ?D64?69 ?16 <742=4>? 143 233F69 9234:272?; <6D?282<4?6 H"- 965B369?14??164556774>?<742=4>?14356D=4>6>?9234:272?;
4? '!/" 16 D2:F>47 143 6DD69 2> ?4@2>A 9234:272?; 4? /" 16<742=4>?C4349=2??692>?161B352?478BD!94;34>9?16 D2:F>47 143 >B? 4C4D969 7B33 B8 2><B=6 9FD2>A ?16 7429 F5 56D2B9"
B>3296D2>A ?16 8D4<?FD6 B> 7BC6D 72=: ?16 <B=56>34?2B>4C4D969:;?16D2:F>478BD7B33B84=6>2?26323
- 4 -
B>7BC6D3296"%68FD?16D3F:=2?3?14?2=574>?34D682H694>9 B<?BD1433?4?69?14?16143?BF>96DAB3FDA6D;8BDD6=BG47 B82=574>?34>98BDD6=BG47B82=574>?3C277D6IF2D66H56>363" 2?1?123165D4;3?B477BC?16455647"
" 64D>69<BF>3678BDD635B>96>? B"CBF79<B>?6>9 ?14? ?16 D2:F>47 143 D2A1?7; ?4@6> 9234:272?; 4>9 D2A1?7; 4C4D969<B=56>34?2B>2>47716493"16D64D6>BADBF>938BD 6>14><6=6>? B8 <B=56>34?2B>" 2?1 ?1636 16 5D4;3 ?B 923=233?16455647"
" %4G2>A 164D9 764D>69 <BF>3673 ?123 BFD? 143 56DF3692=5FA>69EF9A=6>?4>9?D247BFD?D6<BD93"
," 164<<296>?143?4@6>574<6B>'"!"!4>9B> ?14? 94?6 ?16 <742=4>? C43 4A69 ! ;64D3" 16 94?6 B8 4<<296>?4A6B8<742=4>?4>9724:272?;B82>3FD4><6B=54>;4D6 >B?2>9235F?6"16 B?2B>47><B=682H698BD?16;64D!23 3"!!!. 43 56D <14DA6 5D654D69 :; ?16 6A47 6DG2<63 F?1BD2?; 8BD 9235B347 B8 <4363 2> B@. 49474?1 4>9 ?16 D2:F>471436DD692>?4@2>A2><B=6B83",!!."16B<?BD
""-C1B143?D64?69?16<742=4>?1433?4?69?14?9234:272?; 234?'!/4>9<B>3296D2>A?1634=69234:272?;143?B:6?4@6>
- 5 -
4?/434A42>3?/?4@6>:;?16D2:F>47">G26CB8?16 4:BG67B33B88F?FD62><B=62343F>96D*
3"!!!.HHH/J3"+!!!. " 16 D2:F>47 143 D2A1?7; 4C4D969 3"-!!!!. ?BC4D93 542> 4>9 3F886D2>A 3"+!+'. ?BC4D93 =692<47 6H56>363" 16 <742=4>? C43 49=2??69 2> ?16 1B352?47 8BD ?6> 94;3"16D68BD616236>?2?7694??6>94>?<B>G6;4><64>98BB9 4>9>BFD231=6>?2>3F=B83"!!!!.434A42>3?3"-!!!!. 4C4D969:;?16D2:F>47"16D2:F>47143>B?4C4D9697B33B8 2><B=6 9FD2>A 7429 F5 56D2B9 4>9 ?16D68BD6 ?16 4556774>? <742=4>? 23 6>?2?769 7B33 B8 2><B=6 8BD 7429 F5 56D2B9 B8 !- =B>?13 2"6" 3"!!!. H - J3"'!!!." B>3296D2>A ?16 8D4<?FD6 B> 7BC6D 72=: ?16 <742=4>? 23 6>?2?769 ?B 7B33 B8 4=6>2?263 2> 3F= B8 3"-!!!!. 43 4A42>3? 3"!!!.
43 4C4D969 :; ?16 D2:F>47" 16 9B<?BD 143 3?4?69 2=574>?3 4D6 82H694>98BDD6=BG47B8?1634=616143?BF>96DAB3FDA6D;
4>9 8BD ?14? 16 D6IF2D6 6H56>363" 2?1BF? <B>3296D2>A ?16 34=6?16D2:F>47143>B?4C4D9698F?FD6=692<476H56>363" 16D68BD6?16<742=4>?236>?2?769?B8F?FD6=692<476H56>3632> 3F=B83"-!!!!."16D2:F>471434C4D9692>?6D63?4??16
- 6 -
D4?6 B8 +/ "" C12<1 23 B> 12A16D 3296" 16D68BD6 ?16 4556774>?<742=4>?236>?2?769?B2>?6D63??16D4?6B8 /""
+" >G26CB8?164:BG6?16<742=4>?236>?2?769?B?47 <B=56>34?2B>43F>96D* !* +,-. /0+1.,231 ,4,5-+-67 283.952
B33B88F?FD62><B=6 3"+!!. BC4D93542>4>93F886D2>A 3"-!!!!. - 692<476H56>363 3"+!+'. ' B33B82><B=69FD2>A7429F556D2B9 3"'!!!. ??6>94>? B>G6;4><6 )BB9 4>9 >BFD231=6>?<14DA63 3"!!!!. B33B84=6>2?263 3"-!!!!. , )F?FD6 692<476H56>363 3"-!!!!. 2,* .:::;
!" 16 <742=4>? 23 6>?2?76 ?B ?B?47 <B=56>34?2B> B8 3"',''. 43 4A42>3? 3"-,!-'. 4C4D969 :; ?16 D2:F>47C2?12>?6D63?4??16D4?6B8 /56D4>>F="
" >G26CB8?164:BG6?168B77BC2>A
2& 1645564723
22& 16 <742=4>? 23 6>?2?76 ?B ?B?47 <B=56>34?2B> B8 3"',''. 43
- 7 -
4A42>3?3"-,!-'.4C4D969:;?16 D2:F>47 C2?1 2>?6D63? 4? ?16 D4?6 B8 / 56D 4>>F= 8DB= ?16 94?6 B8 56?2?2B>?277D6472K4?2B>* 222& 635B>96>? B".>3FD4><6<B=54>; 31477 965B32? ?16 3429 4C4D9 4=BF>? C2?1 2>?6D63? 4? ?16 D4?6 / "" C2?12> 4 56D2B9 B8 62A1? C66@3 8DB= ?123 94; 84272>A C12<1 2? 23 724:76 ?B 54; 2>?6D63? 4? ?16 D4?6 B8 +/ 56D 4>>F=* 2G& 16 BD96D B8 965B32? 4>9 D676436 543369 :; ?16 ?D2:F>47 D6=42> F>47?6D69"
!-; '!&!&( %
23? B"7 B"'