- 1 - !" #!$!! ! %& %'() &%(( * !"!" # # $" !"!" # # % !! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & % % !! ' # ( !"!" # $ &' !"!" # # % % ) ( - 3 - &' % % ) *% + , # ' ) # ) * % + % , % &( %+,'( + #, % ) % % % $$"& +,+, ""' % # - 4 - - +% - , ./0/121234/567/2485/60349/413613(24 5:26; 3 $$"& 34 1./ <2:/ 3< 1./ %524;20=: 2>2: ?98/=49 249.=4?5@<356.351A52=:3?51BC<2:/9 ?49/5 /;1234 3< 1./ %531/;1234 3< #3D/4 <53D 3D/612; 23:/4;/ ;1 ""' @<35 6.351 A ;1BC =5/ 6//E24813F?=6.1./;52D24=:053;//924824212=1/9=8=2461 1./D./5/60349/41./5/24261./0/121234/5241./6=29 053;//92486 /=59D1421= /99G:/=54/9;3?46/:<35 1./ 0/121234/56 =49 52 =.=41/6. %=12: :/=54/9 ;3?46/: <351./5/60349/41%/5?6/91./D=1/52=:6345/;359 ./ 0=512/6 =5/ ./5/24=<1/5 5/</55/9 13 =6 0/5 1./255=4E2487/<35/1./52=:3?51 - 5 - & 4 >2/H 3< 1./ 52>=: ;341/412346 ?58/9 7G 1./ :/=54/9;3?46/:6<35731.1./0=512/61./032411.=1H3?:9 =526/<35DG;34629/5=123426 ! " # $%&'( G =46H/5 13 1./ =73>/ 03241 26 + <35 1./<3::3H248 ' ./0/121234/5<2:/9=0/121234?49/5/;1234 3< 1./ ;1 6//E248 >=523?6 359/56 3< 0531/;1234 =8=24611./5/60349/416 /60349/413261./.?67=49 3<1./0/121234/5I5/60349/41326D31./53<5/60349/41 3 5/60349/41 36 =49 ' =5/ 1./ 6261/56 3< 5/60349/41 3I 5/60349/41 3& 26 1./ .?67=49 3< 5/60349/41 3I 5/60349/41 3$ 26 1./ .?67=49 3< 5/60349/41 3' 5/60349/41 3 26 1./ 7531./5 3< - 6 - 5/60349/41 3I =49 5/60349/41 3( 26 1./ H2</ 3< 5/60349/41360/51./0/121234<2:/97/<35/1./52=: 3?511./0/121234/5261./5/629/413<249.=4?5=66./26 H35E2481./5/ /60349/413613$=5/1./5/629/4163< =:=7?5=82 /60349/4136=49(=5/1./5/629/4163< />9?58=3< =2;.?5./0/121234/5.=64=55=1/9249/1=2: =73?1./5D=552=8/H21.5/60349/413=49>=523?6=;16 ;3DD211/9 7G 5/60349/41 36 13 ( ?;. 3< 1./ =::/8=12346 =8=2461 1./ 5/60349/416 H/5/ 9?52481./ G/=5 "".3H/>/51./0/121234?49/51./;1;=D/137/ <2:/934$"&"& $ ./ =9D211/9 <=;16 =5/ 1.=1 1./ D=552=8/ 3< 5/60349/41 3 H21. 0/121234/5 H=6 63:/D42J/9 34 """ =49 1./G .=>/ 7/8311/4 = 634 9?5248 "( /60349/41 3 63?8.1 <35 92>35;/ 7G <2:248 3'"" 7/<35/ 1./ =D2:G 3?51 =1 =:=7?5=82 4 1./ D/=412D/ 1./ 0/121234/5 .=6 <2:/9 3'"" 7/<35/ 1./ /4235 2>2: ?98/ =49 249.=4?5 6//E248 5/6121?1234 3< ;34K?8=: 528.16 1 26 61=1/9 1.=1 - 7 - 731. 1./6/ 0/1212346 =5/ 0/49248 <35 ;34629/5=1234 7/<35/ 1./ 3?51 3< 1./ /4235 2>2: ?98/ =49 249.=4?5 ./0/121234/5.=6<2:/9=;3D0:=241=8=24611./ 5/60349/4162452D/3!""=::/8248;3DD2662343< 3<</4;/?49/5/;1234&!(&'"&'"$=49"!5/=9 H21. /;1234 &! 3< % =49 ?49/5 /;12346 =49 & 3< 3H5G%53.2721234;1=491./<24=:5/035126=:5/=9G<2:/9 24 1./ 6=29 ;=6/ 0/49248 24 3("" 3$" H=6 <2:/9 =D34861 1./ 5/60349/416 <35 0=5121234 =49 21 26 61=1/9 1.=1 1./ 6=29 6?21 26 =:5/=9G ;3D053D26/9 /60349/41 3 .=9 <2:/9 = 6?21 24 3"=8=24611./0/121234/56//E248D=241/4=4;/ 1 26 61=1/9 1.=1 1./ 6=D/ ;=D/ 13 7/ 926D266/9 ./ 0/121234/5 .=6 <2:/9 = 6?21 24 3(&" =8=2461 5/60349/4136//E2480/5D=4/4124K?4;1234135/615=24 .2D<53D?49/5832486/;349D=552=8/3" H=6<2:/97G1./0/121234/5=8=24611./9/</49=4161./5/24 =::/82481.=16./261./6/;349H2</3<5/60349/413 - 8 - 052>=1/ ;3D0:=241 24 % 3&" H=6 <2:/9 =8=2461 5/60349/41 3 =::/8248 ;3DD266234 3< 1./ 3<</4;/ 0?426.=7:/?49/5/;12346&!&=49"!3<%=49<24=::G 52D24=:26;3$$"&H=6<2:/9?49/5;1 ( /523?6 =::/8=12346 =5/ D=9/ =8=2461 5/60349/41 3 7/248 1./ .?67=49 3< 1./ 0/121234/5 24;/ 1./ :/=54/9 ;3?46/: <35 1./ 0/121234/56 ./5/24 431 05/66/9 1./ 0/121234 <2:/9 7G 0/121234/5 3 1./ 0/121234 <2:/97G.2D26=:5/=9G926D266/9<1./=::/8=12346D=9/ 7G1./0/121234/57/<35/1./52=:3?51=8=24615/60349/41 3613(=5/1=E/42413;34629/5=123421264312;/91.=1 7=:9=498/4/5=:=::/8=12346=5/D=9/=8=2461=::3<1./D ! /=54/9 ;3?46/: <35 1./ 0/121234/5 7/<35/ 1./ 52=: 3?51 ;341/49/9 1.=1 6/523?6 =::/8=12346 =5/ D=9/ =8=2461 5/60349/41 3& H.3 26 1./ .?67=49 3< 5/60349/413/.=6?6/9>?:8=5:=48?=8/=49?6/9 13 ;=:: 1./ 0/121234/5 >/5G 3<1/4:G ?;. ;34>/56=1234 26 5/;359/9 =49 0539?;/9 24 = %/4 52>/ =E248 2413 - 9 - ;34629/5=1234 3< 1./ 6=D/ 1./ 053;//92486 =8=2461 .2D ;=44317/F?=6./9?121261./;341/412343<1./:/=54/9 ;3?46/: <35 5/60349/41 3& 1.=1 1./ 6=29 ;34>/56=1234 0/51=246131./G/=5""4=::1./053;//924861./6=D/ H=60539?;/91=E248=9>=41=8/3<1./621?=1234 >/424 1./ ;52D24=: ;=6/ =::/8248 ;3DD266234 3< 1./ 3<</4;/ 0?426.=7:/ ?49/5 /;1234 &!( =49 31./5 3<</4;/6 ?49/5 1./%1./6=29%/4 52>/H=65/:2/9343H/>/51./ 6=29 ;52D24=: 053;//92486 26 =:5/=9G F?=6./9 =6 0/5 1./ 359/5 3< 1.26 3?51 3H/>/5 :/=54/9 ;3?46/: <35 1./ 0/121234/5 ;341/496 1.=1 24 >2/H 3< 1./ =00:2;=1234 <2:/9 ?49/5/;1234!3<5%1./053;//92486=8=2461.2D 26 5/>2>/9 =49 0/49248 ;34629/5=1234 7/<35/ 1./ 52=: 3?51 3H/>/5 21 26 431 24 9260?1/ 1.=1 =8=24 1./ 6=29 >/5G 6=D/ %/4 52>/ 26 5/:2/9 34 7G 1./ 0/121234/5 13 <2:/ 0/121234 ?49/5 1./ 053>262346 3< ;1 49/5 6?;. ;25;?D61=4;/6=D3<1./30242341.=15/82615=12343<1./ ;52D24=: 053;//92486 =8=2461 1./6/ 0/121234/56 =6 - 10 - 5/60349/413613(7/<35/1./52=:3?512624=7?6/3< 053;/663<:=H/4;/1./6=D/26:2=7:/137/F?=6./9 " ;;359248:G =46H/5 1./ =73>/ 03241 24 1./ =49053;//9130=661./<3::3H248 +2, ./ ;52D24=: 0/121234 <2:/9 7G 0/121234/53613(26 +22, ./ 0/49248 ;52D24=: 053;//92486 24212=1/9=8=24611./0/121234/563613( $ 5/60349/413613(7/<35/1./52=:3?5124 5: 26; 3$$"& <2:/9 ?49/5 1./ 053>262346 3< /;1234+,+, 3< 1./ ;1 ""'26./5/7GF?=6./9 ,) %!!( $ 2613:3" %