- 1 - ! " # $!%!&!! !!&& '( ) * ! " # $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %% & ' '( )!'*+*(+ && *& '*(( " # &) $ && #$& *((% * ( & ' & & ! & , - 3 - % -./ 011203 ./ 4.325 060.7/8 8-2 090:5 ;4 8-2 :.<=703 .7 ;* (50825*((%10//25<>8-2;=:8;48-2 27.;: .?.3 =562 075 @ 08 056.:. #4;: /-;:8 A8-2 :.<=703B$ 0760CC0 ; 0:=70110 ;950 C28 9.8- 07 0DD.5278 ;7 %(( 075 5.25 2: -=/<075 075 D-.35:27 4.3250D30.C128.8.;7D30.C.76D;C127/08.;7;4/* (( ((( ' -2 :.<=703 0482: D;7/.52:.76 278.:2 C082:.03 ;7 :2D;:5 6:07825070C;=78;4/ % ((( '9.8-.782:2/8088-2:082 ;4E12:077=C4:;C8-25082;4128.8.;78.33:203.F08.;7 66:.2?25 <> 8-2 /0.5 ;:52: 8-2 D30.C078/ 011233078 1:242::25 8-./ 011203 .7 9-.D- .8 ./ C0.73> D;78278258-08 0760CC090/20:7.76/* ((( '12:C;78- <>5;.7606:.D=38=:29;:G <=88-2:.<=7032::25.780G.768-2 /0C20// ((( '12:C;78-&=:8-2: (E2/D0308.;790/ 7;8 6:07825 8;90:5/ 3;// ;4 D;7/;:8.=C 075 4=72:03 2H127/2/ 075.782:2/8./8;<26.?27088-2:082;4E.7/8205;4E -=/ :2I=2/8254;:C;5.4.D08.;7;48-2;:52: % 20:58-20:6=C278/;4<;8-/.52/ - 4 - * -2D30.C078/-0?27;84.32507>1:;;4;4.7D;C2;4 8-252D20/25//-2C289.8-070DD.5278;7%(( -2: 7;8.;703 .7D;C2 ./ 8; <2 80G27 08 /% *( ' 0/ 12: 8-2 6=.523.72/;48-20:7080G0808226032:?.D2/=8-;:.8>/ 8-2 52D20/25 90/ 0625 ( >20:/ 0/ 12: 8-2 21;:8 8-2 C=38.13.2: ./ 8; <2 80G27 0/ AJB 075 /-2 ./ 278.8325 4;: (E 8;90:5/ 4=8=:2 1:;/12D8/ 0/ 12: 8-2 D.808.;7 :21;:825 .7 &=:8-2: :5 ./ 8; <2 525=D825 8;90:5/ 12:/;703 2H127/2/ -2:24;:2 8-23;//;452127527D>D;C2/8; K#% *(L(E$@ :5HHJMN + (( ' 11233078 ;/ 075 0:2278.8325 4;: /%% ((( ' 20D- 8;90:5/ 10:27803 D;7/;:8.=C 075 011233078 ; .2 -=/<075 ;4 8-2 52D20/25 ./ 278.8325 4;: /%% ((( ' 8;90:5/ /1;=/03D;7/;:8.=C075033;48-2C0:2278.83254;:/ ((( ' 8;90:5/ D;7?278.;703 -205/ 0/ 12: 8-2 D.808.;7 .7 :21;:825.7!"#$%$&# 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 - 5 - 7 033 8-2 8;803 D;C127/08.;7 D;C2/ 8; / (( '9.8-.782:2/8088-2:082;4E12:077=C4:;C 8-25082;4128.8.;78.33:203.F08.;7 + -2 090:5 10//25 <> 8-2 :.<=703 ./ C;5.4.25 0/ =752: +,-. /01231. ;//;42127527D> + (( ' ;//;4;7/;:8.=C#/1;=/03075 10:27803D;7/;:8.=C$ ((( ' ;//;42/80820753;//;44=72:03 2H127/2/ ((( ' 2,4 5#55# 6 DD;:5.763> 8-2D30.C078/ 011233078/0:2278.83254;:07 27-07D25D;C127/08.;7;4. ## 6.2 27-07D254:;C / % ((( '8;/ (( ' J 78-2:2/=38 8-24;33;9.76;:52:./10//25 .$ -2011203./' ..$ -2 D30.C078/ 0:2 278.8325 4;: 0 8;803 D;C127/08.;7;4/ (( '9.8-.782:2/808 E 12: 077=C 4:;C 8-2 5082 ;4 128.8.;7 8.33 :203.F08.;7 - 6 - ...$ 2/1;75278 ; ' 7/=:07D2 D;C107> -0/ 03:205> 521;/.825 8-2 0C;=78 090:525 <> 8-2 :.<=703 8-2:24;:2 :2/1;75278;./5.:2D825 8; 521;/.8 8-2 27-07D25 D;C127/08.;7 ;4 / (J (( ' 9.8- .782:2/8 08 E 12: 077=C 9.8-.7;72C;78-4:;C8-25082;48-./;:52: .?$ 7/=D-521;/.8 8-2011233078; -=/<075;4 8-252D20/25./12:C.88258;9.8-5:098-2/0.5 0C;=78 .-6 '&!! ) % ./8;3;*(