- 1 - ! "#$ $$ % &'( ) ! "# # $ % # & '( % & & && && # ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #*%( ! "#&& %+ * %,%%,% -$ & ."$ & - %/ # & && # & & - ,,%,% # &&#*&* & (( %,%% & & &-0 &0 1#& # 234566758349387:;<=27>853?5@=5A53@4==27 BC:A?7@= 5@: 5D5E: :5=7: ,,%,% 65447: ;< =27 E3@>3658 7@3FE 3G38 C:A7 5@: &* 3B5<56CE5 H9FE 42FE= IE3;C@58JK 3@ & F(( %,%% 477L3@A 7@25@>7?7@=F9>F?67@45=3F@ - 3 - % 27 3@BCE7: >853?5@= 5A7: <75E4 :F3@A 5AE3>C8=CE7 ?7= D3=2 5@ 5>>3:7@= F@ % , %,%% 5@: 4C4=53@7:AE37GFC43@BCE37479387:>853?67=3=3F@;79FE7 =27E3;C@58477L3@A>F?67@45=3F@F94,,,,,, *27 E3;C@58 59=7E >F@43:7E3@A =27 7@=3E7 7G3:7@>7 F@ E7>FE: 5D5E:7:=27>F?67@45=3F@F94%. *D3=23@=7E74=5= /67E5@@C?9EF?=27:5=7F967=3=3F@=388E7583M5=3F@5@: :3E7>=7:E746F@:7@=F%*@4CE5@>7F?65@<=F65< / F9 =27 >F?67@45=3F@ =F =27 >853?5@= 93N3@A >F@=E3;C=FE< @7A83A7@>75=%/F@=27>853?5@=AAE37G7:;<=27453: 5D5E:=275667885@=*>853?5@=2546E797EE7:=234566758 . 75E: 5EAC?7@=4 F9 ;F=2 =27 65E=374 5@: 67EC47:=27?5=7E35845G5385;87F@E7>FE: 75E@7:>FC@478 9FE =275667885@= >853?5@= 254 >F@=7@:7:=25=E3;C@582545D5E:7:A8F;58>F?67@45=3F@ F94%. *3@>8C:3@A?7:3>587N67@474D23>234=F;7 7@25@>7: E754F@5;8< ;< 5D5E:3@A >F?67@45=3F@ C@:7E E787G5@= 275:4 7 584F >F@=7@:7: =25= =27 5667885@= 4C4=53@7:AE37GFC43@BCE374=E75=7:543@65=37@=9FE:5<4 - 4 - 5@: 3@>CEE7: ?FE7 =25@ 4%,,,,, * ?7:3>58 7N67@474 7 9CE=27E >F@=7@=7: =25= =27 F83>7 9387: >25EA7*4277= 5A53@4= =27 5667885@= F@8< D3=2 E7A5E: =F @F@*6F447443@A F95@:3=344C;?3==7:=25=?7E7@F@*6F447443F@F9 34@F=5E754F@9FE>5C43@A=275>>3:7@=5@:=2C4E3;C@58 34 @F= BC4=3937: 3@ 93N3@A %/ >F@=E3;C=FE< @7A83A7@>7 F@ =2765E=F9>853?5@=5@:=2C4E7OC74=7:9FE7@25@>3@A=27 >F?67@45=3F@ ?F:39<3@A =27 FE:7E E7A5E:3@A >F@=E3;C=FE< @7A83A7@>7 3@ 234 95GFCE 5@: 5D5E: E754F@5;87 >F?67@45=3F@ C@:7EE787G5@= 275:4 D3=2 (/ 3@=7E74= 67E 5@@C?3@4=75:F9/5D5E:7:;<=27E3;C@58 = 34 4C;?3==7: ;< =27 875E@7: >FC@478 9FE E746F@:7@=F%@4CE5@>7F?65@<=25==273?6CA@7: BC:A?7@= 5@: 5D5E: 65447: ;< =27 E3;C@58 34 BC4= 5@: 6EF67E5@:@77:4@F3@=7E97E7@>7 4 67E N. -FC@: 7E=393>5=7 5667885@= 4C4=53@7:=275;E543F@FG7E879=9EF@=585E755@:85>7E5=7: DFC@:FG7E?7:3585467>=F9E3A2=5@L87BF3@=273@BCE< F 34 AE37GFC4 3@ @5=CE7 5@: 3@BCE< F% 34 43?687 3@ - 5 - @5=CE7 3@>7 =27 >853?5@= 254 @F= 5::C>7: F>=FEJ4 7G3:7@>7=27E3;C@58254@F=5D5E:7:5@<>F?67@45=3F@ C@:7E E787G5@= 275:4 D23>2 E7OC3E74 3@=7E97E7@>7 F9 =234 FCE= 2FCA2 =27 >853?5@= 4=5=74 =25= 27 D54 75E@3@A 4%,,,, * 67E ?F@=2 27 254 @F= 6EF:C>7: 5@< :F>C?7@= =F 6EFG7 =27 45?7 4 =27 5>>3:7@= 34 F9 =27 <75E%,%%5467E=27>25E=344C7:;<=275E@5=5L5=5=7 7A58 7EG3>74 C=2FE3=< =234 FCE= :77?4 3= 566EF6E35=7 =F>F@43:7E=273@>F?7F9=27>853?5@=5=4 , *67E ?F@=2 27>853?5@=D545:?3==7:3@=272F463=589FE :5<4F@43:7E3@A=2767E3F:F92F463=583M5=3F@@5=CE7F9 3@BCE374 5@: F=27E E787G5@= 95>=FE4 3@ 5::3=3F@ =F A8F;58 >F?67@45=3F@5D5E:7:;<=27E3;C@585=4%,,, *=234 FCE= 93@:4 3= E754F@5;87 =F 5D5E: 5@ 5?FC@= F9 4,,,, * 9FE 653@ 5@: 4C997E3@A 5@: 9FE 8F44 F9 5?7@3=374 5@: 4,,,, * 9FE =E5@46FE=5=3F@ 5@: 7N=E5 @FCE342?7@=CE=27E:C7=F3@BCE374=27>853?5@=?3A2= @F= 25G7 5==7@:7: 5@< DFEL 5=8754= 9FE 5 67E3F: F9 % - 6 - ?F@=24 27@>7 =234 FCE= 93@:4 3= E754F@5;87 =F 5D5E: 4%(,, * 9FE 8F44 F9 3@>F?7 :CE3@A 853: C6 67E3F: FD7G7E =27 >F?67@45=3F@ F9 4%%. * 5D5E:7: ;< =27E3;C@589FE?7:3>587N67@474@77:4@F3@=7E97E7@>7 27 >F?67@45=3F@ 5D5E:7: ;< =27 E3;C@58 34 ?F:3937:54C@:7E0 8 F 75:4 D5E:;<=234 FCE= 53@ 5@: 4C997E3@A ' 8F44F95?7@3=374 4,,,, * % &7:3>58N67@474 4%%. * . E5@46FE=5=3F@ 7N=E5 @FCE342?7@= 5@: 5==7@:5@=>25EA74 4,,,, * F44 F9 3@>F?7:CE3@A 853:C667E3F: 4%(,, * 8C4 8F;58 >F?67@45=3F@ 5D5E:7:;<=27E3;C@58 4%,,, * F=58 4( . * ( -2387 =27 5667885@= D54 E3:3@A =27 ?F=FE><>87 ;75E3@A F* * 58F@A D3=2 5 63883F@ E3:7E "67=3=3F@7E 3@ & F( %,%%$ 5 >5E ;75E3@A - 7 - E7A34=E5=3F@ F*% *%% >5?7 3@ 5 E542 5@: @7A83A7@= ?5@@7E D3=2 23A2 4677: 5@: :5427: =F =27 ?F=FE><>87 F9 =27 5667885@= >853?5@= 54 5 E74C8= 27 9788 :FD@ 5@: 4C4=53@7: AE37GFC4 3@BCE374 27 E3;C@58 F;47EG7: =25= =27 >853?5@= 23?4789 34 5 =FE=*9754FE 5@: 278: =25= >853?5@= 584F >F@=E3;C=7: @7A83A7@>7 =F =27 5>>3:7@= 3@ =27 E5=3F F9 %/ 5@: 278: / >F@=E3;C=FE< @7A83A7@>7F@=2765E=F9>5E:E3G7E , 27 >FC@478 9FE =27 5667885@= >F@=7@:7: =25= =27>25EA7*4277=349387:5A53@4=:E3G7EF9=27F997@:3@A>5E 5@: 584F F@ =27 >853?5@= 9FE =27 E754F@ =25= >853?5@= 34 @F=25G3@AG583:E3G3@A3>7@4754F@=27:5=7F95>>3:7@= 27 F@J;87 67N FCE= 3@ =27 >547 F9 E76FE=7:3@ 254278:=25=?7E78<;7>5C47=27>25EA7*4277= 349387:9FE@F=2F8:3@A=27:E3G3@A83>7@>7=27>F@=E3;C=FE< @7A83A7@>7>5@@F=;793N7:C6F@=27:7>7547: - 8 - % 75E@7: >FC@478 9FE E746F@:7@= F% @4CE5@>7 F?65@< E7837: F@ =27 :7>343F@ F9 3G343F@ #7@>2 F9 =234 FCE= 3@ & F%,,, %,% 5@: >F@@7>=7:?5==7E4:346F47:F9F@,%,(%,%3@D23>23= 254 ;77@ 278: =25= =27 :E3G7E F9 =27 EC347E G723>87 D54 @F=6F447443F@7997>=3G75@:G583:E3G3@A3>7@47544C>2 6F83>7 25G7 3@GFL7: 7>=3F@4 , 5@: F9 & >= 5A53@4==27 FD@7EF9 =27 >EC347E G723>87 5@:=27 E3;C@58 254 E3A2=8< >5?7 =F =27 >F@>8C43F@ =25= :E3G7E F9 =27 >EC347ED54584FE5425@:@7A83A7@=5@:>F@=E3;C=7:9FE=27 5>>3:7@=5@:954=7@7:%,/F9=27>F@=E3;C=FE<@7A83A7@>7 5@:3=34>F@93E?7: . @G37DF9=27E5=3F853::FD@;<=2767NFCE= E797EE7:3@=273@4=5@=>547=234FCE=93@:43=BC4= 5@:E754F@5;87=F93NC6=277@=3E7@7A83A7@>7F@=2765E= F9=27>5E:E3G7E5@:=27E734@F@7A83A7@>7F@=2765E=F9 =27 >853?5@= 27E73@ D2F D54 =27 E3:7E F9 =27 ?F=FE><>87 ;75E3@A E7A34=E5=3F@ F* * 27E79FE7 - 9 - E746F@:7@=F% @4CE5@>7F?65@<34835;87=F3@:7?@39< =277@=3E7>F?67@45=3F@5?FC@= = =234 4=5A7 3= 34 4C;?3==7: =25= E746F@:7@= F%@4CE5@>7F?65@<25458E75:<:76F43=7: /F9 =27 >F?67@45=3F@ 5?FC@= 5D5E:7: ;< =27 E3;C@58 >>FE:3@A8< E746F@:7@= F% @4CE5@>7 F?65@< 34 :3E7>=7: =F :76F43= =27 ;585@>7 5?FC@= F9 >F?67@45=3F@ 58F@AD3=2=277@25@>7:5?FC@=D3=23@=7E74=5=/67E 5@@C?9EF?=27:5=7F967=3=3F@=388E7583M5=3F@ @=27E74C8==279F88FD3@AFE:7E3465447:0 "3$ 6675834 "33$ 27 >853?5@= 34 7@=3=87: 9FE =27 >F?67@45=3F@ F9 4( . * D3=2 3@=7E74= 5= /67E5@@C?9EF?=27:5=7F967=3=3F@=388=27 :5=7 F9 E7583M5=3F@ 54 5A53@4= 4%. * 5D5E:7:;<=27E3;C@58 "333$ 746F@:7@= F% @4CE5@>7 F?65@< 34 :3E7>=7: =F :76F43= ;585@>7 - 10 - >F?67@45=3F@ 5?FC@= 58F@A D3=2 3@=7E74= "7N>8C:3@A 3@=7E74= 9FE . :5<4 =27 :785< >5C47: 3@ 9383@A =27 566758$ D3=23@ F@7 ?F@=2 9EF?=27:5=7F9=234BC:A?7@= "3G$ @ 4C>2 :76F43= =27 >853?5@= 34 67E?3==7:=FD3=2:E5D=277@=3E75?FC@=58F@A D3=23@=7E74=5>>EC7:F@3= *% &$( # # 34=F08F0 0