- 1 - !" #$% $$ $ & &'() & (( * !" # "$ % " " "" % & "" ' ( ! " # "%) * %$ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " % % " #$ % # $ " ( " +& % + " " % %% , +&&,% " % - " %% * *% " % ' ' .* #"' .* $ /01 23404056 01 70839 :; <==>139 5+ < 2?<=40=06@ 95=45?<4 099/<?>9/</<?04<:8351204<809<?A/5/<9 4?3<4395638<9;:;6<B3/066<BB< /3=<13574/32?513=>405606:?037014/<4563 <@<22< 4/3 :?54/3?068<A 57 /066<BB< 859@39 < =5B28<064 <883@06@ 4/<4 /066<BB< A<1 B<??039 45 /0C<?<DE /0C@569<694/3=5>283/<965=/089?36401 - 3 - <883@39 4/<4 4/3 2?523?4031 06 F>314056 <?3 <6=314?<8 06 6<4>?3<694/<4>2564/393B01357 /0C<?<DE /0C@569 /066<BB<:306@/01A095A1>==3393945/3?/>1:<69G1 314<43/3=5B28<0647>?4/3?<883@314/<4/066<BB<9039 064314<43 <69 <743? /3? 93<4/ 4/3 <==>139 23?1561 7<:?0=<439 <69 :?5>@/4 0645 3H01436=3 < 7<813 95=>B364 14;839<1<I074339J2>?25?4398;3H3=>439067<C5>?57 "?<:/<K<? 5<B<;;<#<==>139 5$ + /3 7>?4/3? =<13 57 4/3 2?513=>4056 01 4/<4 4/3 2?31364234040563?A/501<B390=<82?<=4040563?<883@398; <1101439<==>139 51<6945064/32?32<?<405657 4/3 <75?31<09 75?@39 95=>B364 :; 011>06@ < B390=<8 =3?4070=<43=3?407;06@4/<4/066<BB<A<106<15>69<69 90125106@ 14<43 57 B069 <4 4/3 ?383C<64 25064 57 40B3 <139564/01<883@<40564/3D>?0190=4056<82580=3=569>=439 <6 06C3140@<4056 <69 /<C3 65A 8<09 < =/<?@31/334 <??<;06@ 4/3 2?31364 234040563? <1 <==>139 5+ 56 4/3 @?5>69 4/<4 /3 /<9 4?3<439 /066<BB< <69 <883@398; 7<=0804<4394/33H3=>4056574/30B2>@63995=>B364 - 4 - 3<?639 =5>6138 <223<?06@ 75? 4/3 234040563? ?3043?<406@ 4/3 @?5>691 >?@39 06 4/3 23404056 /<1 28<=39 14?56@ ?380<6=3 56 4/3 D>9@B364 ?3693?39 :; 4/3 5 5?906<43 36=/ 57 4/01 5>?4 06 ?0B06<8 "3404056 5 & + 6 4/3 1<09 =<13 4/3 2?0B3 <==>139 6<B38; <==>139 5 /<9 15>@/4 F><1/06@ 57 4/3 2?5=33906@1 <?0106@ 5>4574/3 1<B3 4?<61<=4056 /3 5 5?906<43 36=/ :; 5?93? 9<439 & + <885A39 4/3 23404056 <69 F><1/39 4/3 2?5=33906@1 06157<? <1 4/3; 23?4<06 45 <==>139 5 /58906@ 4/<4 4/3 <883@<40561 909 654901=85134/306@?3903641574/3<883@3957736=31 83<?639 =5>6138 <223<?06@ 75? ?312569364 5L937<=45 =5B28<06<64 <69 4/3 83<?639 0@/5>?45C3?6B364"83<93?<223<?06@75??312569364 5L 4<43 ?373??06@ 45 4/3 =/<?@31/334 B<43?0<8 C3/3B3648; =56436939 4/<4 4/3?3 3H014 =3?4<06 B<43?0<81 0690=<406@ 4/3 234040563?G1 06C58C3B364 06 4/3 <883@39<=41/3;1>:B044394/<44/3D>9@B364574/35 5?906<4336=/F><1/06@4/32?5=33906@1<@<0614<==>139 - 5 - 5 =<6654 <>45B<40=<88; :3 3H436939 45 4/3 :363704 57 4/3 2?31364 234040563? <1 4/3 6<4>?3 57 4/3 <883@<40561 <@<0614 /0B 14<691 56 < 901406=4 755406@ <69 ?3F>0?31 06932369364=561093?<4056 <C06@/3<?94/383<?639=5>613875?4/32<?4031 <6956<=<?37>823?>1<8574/3=/<?@31/334B<43?0<84/01 5>?4/<1:3145A39041<6H05>1=561093?<405645<1=3?4<06 A/34/3? <6; =<13 01 B<93 5>4 <@<0614 4/3 2?31364 234040563? H=324 75? < B3?3 ?373?36=3 45 4/3 234040563?G1 6<B3 06 58>B6 5& 57 4/3 =/<?@31/334 4/3?3 01 <:158>438; 65 B<43?0<8 0690=<406@ /01 <=40C3 2<?40=02<4056 5? =5B280=04; 06 4/3 <883@39 57736=31 /3 6C3140@<406@ 770=3?/<1 654 =5883=439 <6; 1>:14<640C3 5? =5??5:5?<40C3 3C0936=3 4/<4 =5>89 D>1407; 4/3 234040563?G1 2?513=>4056 & 401<6>69012>4397<=44/<44/32?0B3<==>139 6<B38;<==>139 5/<93<?803?<22?5<=/394/015>?406 ?0B06<8 "3404056 5 & + A/3?306 4/01 5>?4 - 6 - <743? <934<0839 3C<8><4056 57 4/3 1<B3 134 57 <883@<40561 <69 B<43?0<81 A<1 283<139 45 F><1/ 4/3 2?5=33906@1 <1 <@<0614 /0B /36 4/3 2?06=02<8 <==>139 06 4/3 <883@39 57736=3 /<1 <8?3<9; :336 901=/<?@39 7?5B =?0B06<8 2?513=>4056 =56406><4056 57 2?5=33906@1 <@<0614 4/3 2?31364 234040563? A/5 01 B3?38; < B390=<8 2?<=4040563? <883@3945/<C3011>39<=3?4070=<43064/35?906<?;=5>?13 57 /01 2?57311056<8 9>4; A5>89 13?C3 65 B3<606@7>8 2>?2513 2?<=40=06@ 95=45? A/5 /<9 <4436939 45 /066<BB< 9>?06@ /3? 807340B3 =<6654 :3 1>:D3=439 45 =?0B06<82?513=>4056064/3<:136=357123=070==5@364<69 06=?0B06<406@B<43?0<81/5A06@/01064364056<82<?40=02<4056 064/3<883@39<=415775?@3?;5?=56120?<=;/3011><6=3 57<B390=<8=3?4070=<43:;041387A04/5>42?55757=588>1056 5? B<8< 70931 =<6654 <44?<=4 =?0B06<8 80<:0804; /3 2?513=>4056 4/3?375?3 <223<?1 45 :3 :<139 56 2?31>B240561?<4/3?4/<63C0936=3 - 7 - , /015>?4<815=<6654851310@/4574/37<=44/<4 4/3 55?906<43 36=/ A/083 F><1/06@ 4/3 2?5=33906@1 <@<0614<==>139 5/<1<8?3<9;3H<B06394/36<4>?357 <883@<40561<6975>694/3B45:393C50957=?0B06<8064364 /3 2?31364 =<13 14<691 56 <6 3C36 A3<K3? 755406@ <1 4/3?3<?36506932369364<883@<40561<@<06144/3234040563? 3H=324<2<1106@?373?36=345/016<B3C36074/33640?3 =/<?@31/334 B<43?0<8 01 4<K36 <4 7<=3 C<8>3 04 9531 654 901=8513 4/3 06@?3903641 57 <6; 57 4/3 57736=31 <883@39 885A06@ 4/3 2?5=33906@1 45 =56406>3 06 1>=/ =0?=>B14<6=31A5>89<B5>6445/<?<11B364<69<6<:>13 574/32?5=311578<A 6C03A574/3<:5C3901=>110564/015>?40157 4/3 =561093?39 5206056 4/<4 45 13=>?3 4/3 3691 57 D>140=3 <69452?3C3644/3<:>1357D>90=0<82?5=3110401D>14<69 2?523?4506C5K34/306/3?36425A3?1C31439>693? 3=4056 57 4/3 593 57 ?0B06<8 "?5=39>?3 45 F><1/ 4/3 2?5=33906@106040<439<@<06144/3234040563? - 8 - ==5?906@8;4/015>?42<11314/375885A06@' #0$ /3?0B06<8"340405601<885A39 #00$ /3 2?5=33906@1 06 5+& <?0106@ 5>4 57 ?0B3 5+ ?3@0143?39 :; 4/3 <?K34 "580=3 4<4056 09<? 75? 4/3 57736=31 2>601/<:83>693? 3=40561 , + &&?3<9A04/ 3=4056,574/3 690<6"36<8593<694/35?93?57=5@60M<6=3 9<439 236906@ 56 4/3 7083 57 4/3 9904056<8 0C08 *>9@3 <69 *% 09<? <?3 /3?3:; F><1/39 06157<? <1 4/3 2?31364 234040563?01=56=3?639 #000$ 6C03A574/3901251<8574/3B<0623404056<6; 236906@ 0643?85=>45?; <2280=<40561 95 654 1>?C0C375?=561093?<4056<6914<699012513957 <==5?906@8; +) & $$( % " 014 5' 8 5'+ '