- 1 - ! " #$%!$!$ &!'$( ! " #! #! $ Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % # " ! % " % #! $" % # ! " #& '% "" # &'% # &'% - 3 - # # $ # &'% $ # ! # &'% % # $% " ! #! % % #! $ # #! " - 4 - # # # % $ # % $$ % $ # & '% % ## # %" " ( ! % # ! " "" !# - 5 - $ ! $$ " $ ( ! % % %% " $ % " #& '% ) * !# + , , ' - 6 - ' , ' # & '% , ' # #& '% ,,, # &'% #& '% , % $ #! % $ & " #& - 7 - ) *# , - !!# , - !# , "+ , , , + *+ *.'/0+ , ' # "" , 1 # # # , 1 , , # ('- + , & (' #1 # , - + , , ' , , , *+*.'/0+ ' # - + , , # , - + , , , 2! - 8 - * 2!+ 3/4567/7/89/4:/;6<466=/9>:8;;8?/9>@6;/6:4 .+ 6A;.@6 73.7 6A *+ *.'/0+ 8: 736 .@9.7.=. 8' 56@.7/06 8A/67/64 A7 "" .4 /946@76< BC 6A7/898:.@9.7.=.A7 8 5DB;/436</9 736 >.E6776 89 /9 D;7@. 0/@64 .9< ;.A=4 ;6>/4;.7/06A8F56769AC/90/6?8:@7/A;6 .9< 1 8:7368947/7D7/898:9</.0/<6996GD@6'- B+ 44D6 . ?@/7 8@<6@ 8@ </@6A7/89 /9 9.7D@6 8: A6@7/8@.@/ HD.43/9> 996GD@6' 9< 0/E 736 /96;/>/B;60876@4;/474F6FB6@4<.76<9/;5DB;/436<BC 736 @64589<697 98 /9 48 :.@ .4 736 567/7/896@4 36@6/9.@6A89A6@96<- A+ 44D6 . ?@/7 /9 736 9.7D@6 8: F.9<.FD4 8@ .9C 8736@.55@85@/.76?@/78@8@<6@8@</@6A7/89</@6A7/9> 736 @64589<6974 78 A89<DA7 736 6;6A7/894 78 736 @64589<69749848A/67C:8@73676@F'/9 .AA8@<.9A6?/73736;/478:F6FB6@48A/67/64?/738D7 /94/47/9> :8@ A8F5;/.9A6 8: 46A7/89 *+*.'/0+ 736 .@9.7.=.8' 56@.7/068A/67/64A7- <+44D6.?@/7/97369.7D@68:F.9<.FD4</@6A7/9> 736@64589<69798 .9<78/9A;D<67369.F648: 736567/7/896@4/97366;/>/B;60876@4;/478:@64589<697 9848A/67C-.9< 6+.444DA38736@8@<6@4.4F.CB6.55@85@/.76/9 736:.A74.9<A/@ADF47.9A648:736A.46 9 /976@/F 8@<6@ ?.4 >@.976< BC 73/4 8D@7 <.76<?3/A3@6.<4.4D9<6@ - 9 - !"# ! $ % & ! !! " # '(')') !* ! !+ ! !, $ - 6.@96< A8D946; :8@ 736 567/7/896@ :D@9/4364 A85/648: @<6@4<.76<$.9< %5.446< BC 736 8'8@</9.76 69A3 8: 73/4 8D@7 /9 8 .9< 8% @6456A7/06;C .9< 4DBF/7 73.7 736 8'8@</9.76 69A3 8: 73/4 8D@7 /9 4/F/;.@A/@ADF47.9A643.4</@6A76<73667D@9/9> ::/A6@78 .998D9A6 736 @64D;74 ?/73/9 46069 <.C4 7.=/9> /978 .AA8D97 736 0876 A.476< ?/73 736 567/7/896@4 736@6/9 6 736@6:8@6 4DBF/74 73.7 /9 736 /947.97 A.46 .4 ?6;; . </@6A7/89B6/44D6<78736@64589<697'67D@9/9> ::/A6@78 - 10 - 7.=6/978A894/<6@.7/897360876A.47BC736567/7/896@4.9< 78.998D9A6736@64D;74 6.@96< A8D946; .556.@/9> :8@ @64589<697 8478"897368736@3.9<4DBF/7473.74DA3.@6HD647 A.9987 B6 .AA8FF8<.76< .9< /9.4FDA3 .4 BC 736 @6;/6: 48D>37BC736567/7/896@/9736?@/7567/7/89/4HD647/89/9> 736 A8947/7D7/89.; 0.;/</7C 8: 6A7/89 *+ *.'/0+ 8: 736 .@9.7.=. 8'856@.7/06 8A/67/64 A7 "" ?3/A3 /44D6 3.4 B669 467 .7 @647 BC 736 8'8@</9.76 69A3 8: 73/4 8D@7 BC /74 8@<6@ <.76< 5.446< /9 B.7A3 8: ?@/7567/7/894/9 84 "'8:%.9<A8996A76< F.776@4 D538;</9> 736 A8947/7D7/89.; 0.;/</7C 6 .;48 4DBF/74 73.7 736 567/7/896@4 ?38 3.< @./46< 736 6;6A7/89 </45D76/97364./<567/7/89?6@6</@6A76<78466=@6F6<C BCA8947/7D7/9>6;6A7/89567/7/89 6 .;48 @6;/64 D589 736 8@<6@4 5.446< BC 736 8'8@</9.76 69A3 8: 73/4 8D@7 /9 /9736A.468:I - 11 - J .4 ?6;; .4 /9 !! " /9736A.468:I#"" $% J 78 4DBF/7 73.7 736 </45D76?/73@6>.@<785@65.@.7/898:0876@42;/47/489678 B6.<KD</A.76<D9<6@6A7/89$*+8:736.@9.7.=.8' 856@.7/06 8A/67/64 A7 .9< D97/; 4DA3 </45D76 /4 <676@F/96<73608764A.476<BC736567/7/896@4A.9987B6 7.=69 /978 A894/<6@.7/89 6 4DBF/74 73.7 736 567/7/89 B6 </45846<8:</@6A7/9>736F78.998D9A6736@64D;7?/738D7 7.=/9>/978A894/<6@.7/89736567/7/896@420876 6.@<6@D46<736@6A8@<4 $ 36 /44D6 .4 @./46< /9 73/4 567/7/89 /4 736 A8947/7D7/89.; 0.;/</7C 8: 6A7/89 *+ *.'/0+ .9< /9A/<697.; HD647/89 ?/73 @6>.@< 78 736 0.;/</7C 8: 736 6;6A7/89 /F/;.@ </45D76 3.4 B669 467 .7 @647 BC 736 8' 8@</9.7669A38:73/48D@7/9/748@<6@<.76< /9 84 "' 8: % 9876< ?36@6/9 736 - 12 - 8'8@</9.76 69A3 ?3/;6 D538;</9> 736 A8947/7D7/89.; 0.;/</7C8:7364./<46A7/893.4@646@06<736;/B6@7C78736 567/7/896@4 736@6/9 78 5@64697 6;6A7/89 567/7/89 B6:8@6 KD@/4</A7/89.; .D738@/7C 36 8'8@</9.76 69A3 8: 73/4 8D@7/9 .4?6;;.4/9 3.06 .;48 7.=69 . 4/F/;.@ 0/6? 78 @./46 736 6;6A7/89</45D76D9<6@6A7/89$*+8:736.@9.7.=.8' 856@.7/06 8A/67/64 A7 /9A6 736 /44D6 /908;06< /9 736 5@64697567/7/89/4</47/9>D/43.B;6?/738964DBK6A7F.776@ 8: ?@/7 567/7/89 /9 8 8: .9< /9 8% ?36@6/9 736@6 .556.@4 78 B6 98 A3.;;69>678@7/A;67364./<KD<>F6974.@68:98.0./; % @/7 567/7/89 /4 &' </@6A7/9> 736 67D@9/9> ::/A6@ 78 .998D9A6 736 @64D;74 7.=/9> /978 A894/<6@.7/89736;/478:0876@4.46G/476<5@/8@78<.768: 6;6A7/89 67/7/896@4 /: .>>@/606< .9< .<0/46< .@6 .7 ;/B6@7C78@./46736</45D76.9<466=<676@F/9.7/898:736 4.F6B6:8@6736A8F567697.D738@/7CD9<6@6A7/89$*+ 8: 736 .@9.7=. 8'856@.7/06 8A/67/64 A7 9 4DA3 .9 - 13 - 60697 736 7/F6 A894DF6< /9 5@846AD7/9> 73/4 F.776@ ?/;; B66GA;D<6<:8@7365D@58468:;/F/7.7/89:4DA3567/7/89 /4:/;6<736A8F567697.D738@/7C43.;;</458468:7364.F6 ?/73/9.98D76@;/F/78:<.C4:@8F736<.768::/;/9>8: 7364./<567/7/89 !)' &$!$( % /47 8; 8