Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63790 (KAR)
ASHWIN KUMAR v. THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER/SECRETARY MSRTC
MFA/203931/2023 · 2025-12-01
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63790 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63790 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! "
#!$!%!! !!%%
&'( )
!! " # $
! !%
" #
$
&& !'#!$
& $ & %%%%! &
& ( #$$ & ( )!%%
%%%%! (
#
$
& ) * !)!%*
&
( +
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+ , (
$
! -.//.0121345671668450 .%%%%! 104 .%%%!.0)!%%9:8-;15/10950
.%%%%!-;15/84-./7806195.0.<6!)1;.0= 259:50983869:8935>?01;-.06548350=9:88095388@5480-8.0 38-.34121348416?/.<61;.0=259:50983869 199:83198.<)*783100?/<3./9:84198.<789595.095;;9:8 4198 .< 381;5A195.0 ==358@84 >B 9:8 6154 (?4=/809 104 12134 9:8 -;15/109 :16 738<83384 9:8 7386809 17781; 688C50=80:10-8/809.<9:8-./7806195.0
% 0 9:8 7386809 17781; 59 56 -.0980484 9:19 9:8 1/.?096=310984?04839:8.9:83:8146138/81=83:.?=:
9:8 .-9.3 :16 16686684 9:8 4561>5;59B 19 * 9. 9:8 ;5/> 9:8 935>?01; :16 91C80 .0;B !* :80-8 38D?86984 <.3 80:10-8/809.<9:8-./7806195.0
81349:813=?/8096<3./>.9:65486
- 3 -
:8-;15/841=84%B8136/89259:1--54809.0 % !%%! :8 -;15/109 216 2.3C50= 50 9:8 191 .06?;910-B83@5-86783E9:8-;15/109216=89950= 161;13B.<6%!')%:838<.389:8935>?01;:1691C80:56 50-./8 16 6%% 783 /.09: 104 59 08846 0. 50983<8380-8 :8 -;15/109 216 1=84 % B8136 104 9:8 /?;957;583 56 9. >8 91C80 19 F!'G 6 783 E H 2.?04 -8395<5-1989:8-;15/1096?6915084-?9;1-8319842.?0435=:9 /544;8 ;8= .780 <31-9?38 .< 35=:9 95>51 104 <5>?;1 -.//?05984<31-9?38/544;89:53495>51104<31-9?3808-C104 6:1<9.<<5>?;135=:9;8=0I?3B.!5665/7;850019?38104 50I?3B .6% 9. 138 =358@.?6 50 019?38 :8 -;15/109 216 :.67591;5A84 <.3 0508 41B6 16 783 9:8 456-:13=8 6?//13B :8 .-9.3 16686684 9:8 4561>5;59B 19 * 9. 9:8 ;5/> 104 !* 9. 9:8 2:.;8 >.4B :838<.38 !34 .< * -./86 9. !* ?9 9:8 935>?01; :16 91C80 !* 80-8 9:8 ;.66 .< <?9?38813050=-171-59B5616?0483+
6%%J!%J!'J!*K6)'%
- 4 -
:8 935>?01; :16 1213484 1 6?/ .< 6 9.21346/845-1;8E780686:861/856-.338-9104088460. 50983<8380-8 .06548350= 9:8 019?38 .< 50I?3B 7835.4 .< :.67591;5A195.0104.9:8338;8@109<1-9.369:56.?39<504659 3816.01>;89.1213416?/.<6'9.213467150104 6?<<8350=6 6 9.21346 ;.66 .< 1/8059586 6 9.21346 931067.39195.0 8E931 0.?356:/809 104 199804109 -:13=86 :8 935>?01; :16 1213484 1 6?/ .< 6%%9.21346;.66.<50-./84?350=;154?77835.4<.3 .08/.09::861/856-.338-9104088460.50983<8380-8 80-89:89.91;-./7806195.05616?0483+
!* +,-./01+2.,342 0523 ! .66.<<?9?38813050=-171-59B 6)'% %
845-1;8E780686 6
1501046?<<8350=6 6'
.66.<1/8059586 6
31067.39195.0 8E931 0.?356:/809 104 199804109 -:13=86 6 ) .66 .< 813050= 4?350= ;154 ?7 7835.4 6%%
3,* .666 7
) 813084 -.?068; <.3 9:8 06?310-8 -./710B 6?>/596 9:19 9:81/.?09 1213484 >B 9:8 935>?01;:16>880 487.65984>8<.389:8935>?01;
- 5 -
' --.3450=;B9:8<.;;.250=+
#5$ :817781;561;;.284507139L
#55$ :8 -;15/109 56 80959;84
9. 9.91; -./7806195.0.<6%1;.0=259:50983869 19 9:8 3198 .< )* 783 100?/ <3./ 9:8 4198 .< 789595.0 95;; 9:8 4198 .< 381;5A195.0 16 1=15069 61213484>B9:8935>?01;L
#555$ :8 06?310-8 -./710B 56 4538-984 9. 487.659 9:8 80:10-84 -./7806195.0 .< 6 1;.0=259:50983869259:50.08/.09: <3./9:84198.<9:56.3483L
#5@$ :8 -;15/109 56 783/59984 9.
259:4312 9:8 80:10-84 -./7806195.0 1/.?09 1;.0= 259: 509838691--3?84.059
#@$ 0 @582 .< 9:8 .3483 41984 % %% 9:8 -;15/109 56 0.9 80959;84 <.3 50983869 <.3 9:8 48;1B847835.4.<!'41B650<5;50=9:817781;
.-7 &%!! ( $
569.+!;.+' +(