- 1 - ! " # $%&$'()%*&$(( + ! " #$ % & ! " ' #$ ( " )$ # ! # &! ( " )$ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # '* # " $ ' # "+$ +) *%&% # # ## &% '*%"%$ +"$# %&% ##,#-"- $ -# # + .- /01234 05121234 26 72859 :; /<<=659 36 /49 ' =495> 5<1234' 37?/>/12;//@/>2A =>/A6?/ /4?21/ %&%655A24@@>/4137>5@=8/>:/2824>2B53*%&%37 /8A?59 382<5 1/1234 261 /8/:=>/@2 73> 1?5 37754<56 0=426?/:85=495> 5<12346&% '*%"%$>5/9 C21? 5<1234 "$ 37 ?/>/12;/ ;/;/ /4?21/ %&% 054924@341?572853785/>4592D28-=9@5"-=423> 2D26234$ /49-#3=>1 59/B % ?5 @261 37 1?5 <3B08/241 839@59 :; 1?5 72>61 2473>B/41261?/1?5?/6:554C3>A24@/6/C5895>241?5 5<?/42</8 50/>1B541 37 81>/15<? 5B541 3B0/4; - 3 - /8A?59 624<5 **! /49 26 :856659 C21? 73=> <?289>54 24<8=924@ 1?5 95<5/659 ?/@;/6?>55 45 ;5/> 0>23> 13 839@24@ 1?5 0>56541 <3B08/241 ?5 C/6 585<159 /6 1?5 4234>562954145)2439634376?3AC?3?/9:554 C3>A24@ 24 1?5 6/29 <3B0/4; 34 / <341>/<1 :/626 73> 1?5 8/61&;5/>6<3BB211596=2<295:;<346=B24@03263434 1?5 @>3=49 1?/1 ?26 5B083;B541 C/6 431 >5@=8/>2E59 24<5 1?5 72>61 2473>B/41 C/6 1?5 4234 >5629541 /1 1?5 >585D/41 12B5 1?5 7/B28; B5B:5>6 37 )2439 ?589 ?2B >5603462:85 73> 1?5 434>5@=8/>2E/1234 37 )2439,6 F3: /49 <3465G=5418;?2695/1?126/885@591?/11?5;<34602>5913 582B24/15 63B5345 7>3B 1?5 72>61 2473>B/41,6 7/B28; ?5 <3B08/2417=>1?5>/885@561?/1/715>)2439,695/1?/<<=659 3/4F=4/1? 15850?342</88; /:=659 1?5 2473>B/41 24 7281?;8/4@=/@5/49266=5982751?>5/16 4 &*%&% /1 /:3=1 !&& 0B 1?5 2473>B/41,6 9/=@?15> ?/@;/6?>55 C541 73> /4 5D5424@ C/8A/715>6=005>/49929431>51=>45D54:;&&&0B ?5 2473>B/41 /834@ C21? ?26 C275 /49 31?5>6 65/><?59 - 4 - 73> ?5> :=1 C/6 =4/:85 13 1>/<5 ?5> =4128 B2942@?1 37 %&*%&% 0>3B0124@ ?2B 13 839@5 / B26624@ <3B08/241 24>2B53 %&% ' 4 &*%&% /1 /:3=1 !& /B 1?5 2473>B/41>5<52D592473>B/12347>3B83</8>562954161?/1/ 95/9:39;C/68;24@45/>1?5638/>0/458<3B03=49371?5 <3B0/4;4>5/<?24@1?56031?573=491?595/9:39;37 ?26 9/=@?15> /659 34 1?26 / <3B08/241 C/6 839@59 <=8B24/124@ 24 >5@261>/1234 37 1?5 0>56541 <>2B5 ?5 0>56541051212345>6C5>5/00>5?5495934%&*%&%/49 24D5612@/1234260>565418;34@324@ 5/>459<3=465873>1?5051212345>6>575>>24@13 1?5<3B08/241/D5>B5416<34154961?/11?5348;/885@/1234 /@/2461 1?5 051212345>6 26 1?/1 1?5; /885@598; 24612@/159 /<<=659 3 13 <3BB21 1?5 37754<5 5 6=:B216 1?/1 051212345>6 ?/D5 :554 7/8658; 2B082</159 /49 1?/1 24 1?5 B26624@ <3B08/241 839@59 34 %&*%&% /1 /:3=1 && 0B 1?5 2473>B/41 929 431 5D54 C?2605> 1?5 4/B56 37 1?565 051212345>6 1 26 7=>1?5> 6=:B21159 1?/1 1?5 - 5 - 051212345>6 C?3 ?/D5 :554 24 F=92<2/8 <=6139; 624<5 %&*%&% />5 2B082</159 63858; 34 1?5 :/626 37 <2><=B61/412/8 5D2954<5 /49 1?52> <34124=59 24</><5>/1234 C3=89 65>D5 43 0=>0365 /49 C3=89 D238/15 1?52> >2@?1 13 82:5>1;/49 92@421; =495> >12<85 % 37 1?5 346121=123437 492/5/>459<3=46585B0?/62E561?/14392>5<13D5>1/<1 26 /11>2:=159 13 1?5 051212345>6 /49 /885@/12346 37 24612@/1234 />5 D/@=5 5 6=:B216 1?/1 051212345>6 />5 C28824@ 13 <3305>/15 C21? 1?5 24D5612@/1234 /005/> :573>5 1?54D5612@/124@772<5>C?545D5>>5G=2>59/491?/11?5; :5834@ 13 / >5605<1/:85 7/B28; C21? 43 <>2B24/8 /415<595416 85/D24@ 43 6<305 73> 1/B05>24@ C21? C21456656 5> <341>/ 85/>459 2@? 3=>1 3D5>4B541 85/95> 6=:B216 1?/1 1?5 051212345>6 />5 /863 0>2B5 6=605<16/491?/1/624D5612@/12342661288240>3@>5661?52> >585/65 /1 1?26 61/@5 C3=89?/B05> 1?5 24D5612@/1234/49 /9D5>658; /775<1 1?55773>16 37 1?54D5612@/124@ 772<5> 24 65<=>24@<>=<2/85D2954<5 - 6 - ! /D24@?5/>91?585/>459<3=465834:31?62956 1?573883C24@03241/>265673><346295>/1234 H+?51?5> 1?5 051212345>6 ?/D5 B/95 3=1 / </65 73> @>/41 37 >5@=8/> :/28 /49 C?51?5> 1?26 3=>1 3=@?1135I5><265216926<>51234241?52>7/D3=>JK 4/<83655I/B24/1234371?5#21265D29541 1?/1 21 C/6 1?5 :>31?5> 37 051212345> 3 /49 1?5 634 37 051212345>3%4/B58;)2439C?3<3BB211596=2<295/49 1?2624<295412643C63=@?113:5824A59131?595/1?371?5 2473>B/41,6 9/=@?15> ?5 <3B08/241 /11>2:=156 605<272< 3D5>1/<16348;13/<<=6593605>1?54/>>/12D52126 /<<=6593C?3/885@598;5415>591?5@/>954/>3=491?5 12B51?595<5/659?/95415>59?5/885@/1234/@/24611?5 051212345>6 26 B5>58; 1?/1 1?5; 24612@/159 /<<=659 3 C?2<?26605<=8/12D5244/1=>5 51/2424@1?5051212345>624 F=92<2/8 <=6139; 24957242158; 34 1?5 :/626 37 6=602<234 /49 <34F5<1=>526=4C/>>/4159346295>24@1?/11?5051212345>6 ?/D5:55424<=6139;624<5%&*%&%2126>5/634/:8513 0>56=B5 1?/1 1?5 4D5612@/124@ 772<5> ?/6 /8>5/9; ?/9 - 7 - /95G=/15 3003>1=421; 13 2415>>3@/15 1?5B #=>1?5> <34124=/1234 37 F=92<2/8 <=6139; C288 431 65>D5 /4; 6=:61/412/8 0=>0365 /49 5D54 27 >585/659 1?5 4D5612@/124@ 772<5> </4 6=BB34 1?5B /6 /49 C?54 >5G=2>59 >3D2959 61>24@541 <349212346 />5 2B03659 13 546=>5 1?/1 1?5 051212345>6 93 431 2415>75>5 C21? 1?5 24D5612@/1234 43 0>5F=92<5 C3=89 :5 </=659 13 1?5 0>365<=1234 4 82@?1 37 1?5 /885@/12346 <341/2459 24 1?5 72>612473>B/12341?263=>17249621/00>30>2/15135I5><265 216926<>51234247/D3=>371?5051212345>6<<3>924@8;1?5 0324126/46C5>59241?5/772>B/12D5 2?50512123426 22?5051212345>6/>592>5<15913:5548/>@5934:/28 24>2B53*%&%37/8A?59382<5 1/1234 /8/:=>/@2 261>2<1 73> 1?5 37754<56 0=426?/:85 =495> 5<12346 & % '* % "%$ >5/9 C21? 5<1234 "$ 37 1?5 ?/>/12;/;/;/ /4?21/%&%054924@:573>51?53=>1 - 8 - 37 1?5 2D28 -=9@5 "-=423> 2D26234$ /49 -# 59/B 6=:F5<1131?573883C24@<349212346 /$ 51212345>6 6?/88 5I5<=15 / 05>634/8 :349 73> 6&&&&&5/<?C21?1C36=>5125673>1?582A5 6=B 13 1?5 6/1267/<1234 37 1?5 F=>2692<1234/8 3=>1L :$ 51212345>6 6?/88 >5@=8/>8; /005/> :573>5 1?5 >2/83=>134/88?5/>24@9/156=485665I5B0159 73>D/829>5/6346L <$ 51212345>6 6?/88 431 92>5<18; 3> 2492>5<18; 1?>5/154 2478=54<5 3> 1/B05> C21? 0>365<=1234 C21456656L 9$ 51212345>6 6?/88 431 24D38D5 1?5B658D56 24 62B28/>37754<56247=1=>5L 5$ 51212345>6 6?/88 431 85/D5 1?5 15>>213>2/8 F=>2692<1234 37 1?5 >2/8 3=>1 C21?3=1 0>23> 05>B266234=4128926036/8371?5</65L - 9 - 7$ 24<524D5612@/12342634@324@051212345>66?/88 7=88;<3305>/15C21?1?54D5612@/124@772<5>/49 6?/880>3B018;<3B08;C21?/4;6=BB346266=59 /49 7=>426? /88 2473>B/1234 C21?24 1?52> A43C859@5 ,) $ ( # - 2613 83