- 1 - ! " # $$ %$& ' !"!"#$ " % & % '' "( # ") * ' !"!"#"# & $ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $ ' ( ' $ $ # ' $ $ %+ ' $ $ %" ' $ $ ") ' ' " ,--.// # % ! - 3 - # ' ! ' ' * $ $012 $ !!"!"" " "!!+"!"% $ ' & % # $ & !!& ' & & 3 & & + "!% & & 4 4' !!)"! " "!! & & 4 !%"!" & 4' & 5 && & & 4' "!"!" ' & 6 ' & 4'7 & - 4 - ' 3' 4 '' (# 89: :;<=12 0>>;0? 9: @A B8; >?091B9CC: 0DDE9;F;2 @A B8; GH2DI;1B 012 2;<E;; 20B;2 !%"!" >0::;2 91 =" "!!=1B8;C9?; 229B9=10?9F9?4H2D;920E C=E :8=EB 6B8; E90? =HEB7$ 012 <=1C9EI;2 @A B8; GH2DI;1B 012 2;<E;; 20B;2 !!)"! >0::;2 91 =+ "!% =1 B8; C9?; =C E? ;19=E 9F9? 4H2D; 012 4'920E C=E:8=EB6B8;&9E:B>>;??0B;=HEB7$91012@A J89<8 :H9B =C B8; >?091B9CC: C=E >0EB9B9=1 012 :;>0E0B; >=::;::9=180:@;;129:I9::;2 " 8; :H@G;<B I0BB;E =C :H9B 0E; B8; C=??=J91D >E=>;EB9;: C=E:8=EB6:H9B:<8;2H?;>E=>;EB9;:7$ ?= A= KB;1B ?012 05D:$ ;F;1H; 0::;::I;1B =<0B9=1 ( % 5%% 5(# 0>HE L920E " ( + 5+ #5#( 0>HE L920E % ! " 5"! #5 '0110;M8;?9 =B0? #5" #" - 5 - % 8;<0:;=CB8;>?091B9CC:9:B80BN %1; E0>>0J0:B8;=J1;E=CB8;:H9B:<8;2H?; >E=>;EB9;: ; >0::;2 0J0A ?;0F91D @;8912 2;C;1201B: =:B=%012=1;801M;E801M;E0>>0?091B9CC= 9:B8;J9C;012>?091B9CC=:"B=0E;B8;<89?2E;1=C:092 801M;E0>>0 1 B8; 2;0B8 =C :092 E0>>0 E;F;1H; E;<=E2: 91E;:>;<B B= B8; :H9B >E=>;EB9;: J;E; IHB0B;2 91 B8; 10I; =C B8; 2;C;1201B: 012 2;<;0:;25801M;E0>>0 CB;E2;0B8=C801M;E0>>02;C;1201B=:B=%D=B89: 10I;2;?;B;2CE=IB8;E;F;1H;E;<=E2:012E;B091;2=1?A B8;9E 10I;: 0: =J1;E: 012 >=::;::=E: =C B8; :H9B >E=>;EB9;: %" 80BH>=1 B8; 2;0B8 =C 801M;E0>>0 >?091B9CC: :H<<;;2;2B= #B8:80E;91B8;:H9B>E=>;EB9;:0:89:=1?A 8;9E: 8=HD8 2;C;1201B: D0F; :80E; 91 B8; >E=2H<; =C C==2 DE091: CE=I B8; :H9B >E=>;EB9;: C=E 0@=HB BJ= A;0E: 0CB;E2;I9:;=C801M;E0>>0B8;E;0CB;EB8;A2;19;2;F;1 B8;:092:80E;<=1:BE09191DB8;>?091B9CC:B=C9?;B8;:H9BC=E >0EB9B9=1012:;>0E0B;>=::;::9=1 - 6 - # ;C;1201B=:B=%91B8;9EJE9BB;1:B0B;I;1B J89?;02I9BB91DB8;E;?0B9=1:89><=1B;12;2B80BN #80B 0CB;E B8; 2;I9:; =C E0>>0 10I;: =C 2;C;1201B:012801M;E0>>0B8;8H:@012=C>?091B9CC= 012C0B8;E=C>?091B9CC=:"B=#J0:IHB0B;291E;:>;<B=C ?012@;0E91DA=( I;0:HE91D%+DH1B0:;K<;>BB8; :092?0121==B8;E?012:J;E;BE01:C;EE;291B8;10I;=C 801M;E0>>0::H<8B8;E;9:1=LH;:B9=1=C2;?;B91DB8; 10I; =C 801M;E0>>0 0: 0??;D;2 80B 10I; =C E0>>0 <=1B91H;291E;:>;<B=C?012@;0E91DA=( +I;0:HE91D ! 0<E; + DH1B0: 012 A=( # I;0:HE91D ! 0<E; ;F;10CB;E89:2;0B8 #" 80B B8;E; J0: 0 C0I9?A >0EB9B9=1 @;BJ;;1 B8; BJ=@E01<8;:=C E0>>001289:@E=B8;E80110@0:0>>091 J89<8 <;EB091 >E=>;EB9;: 10I;?A ?012 91 A=( % I;0:HE91D ! 0<E; 012 %% DH1B0:N ?012 91 A=( + I;0:HE91D ! 0<E; 012 + DH1B0:N ?012 91 A=( I;0:HE91D %+ DH1B0:N 012 ?012 91 A=( # I;0:HE91D ! 0<E; J;E; >0EB9B9=1;2 012 0<<=E291D?A ?012 91 - 7 - A=( +I;0:HE91D!0<E;+DH1B0:012A=( % I;0:HE91D!0<E;%%DH1B0:J;E;0??=BB;2B=B8;8;9E:=C ?0B; E0>>0 012 =B8;E ?012: 91 A=( J;E; 0??=BB;2 B= 0:80>>00120120>>0:=1:=C80110@0:0>>0 #%80BB8;?012@;0E91DA=! "I;0:HE91D! 0<E;"!DH1B0:012?012@;0E91DA=+ I;0:HE91D%" DH1B0:0E;B8;?012:B80BJ;E;:9BH0B;291'0110558;?9 B80BJ;E;0??=BB;2B=B8;:80E;=C>?091B9CC= ## 80B B8; 0C=E;:092 >0EB9B9=1 J0: :H@:;LH;1B?A E;2H<;2 91B= JE9B91D 91 B8; 2=<HI;1B <0??;2 0: 601<89M; 0BE07 # 80B 0>0EB =1 #!""!!" :91<; B8; 10I; =C 2;C;1201B =: 012 % 0?=1D J9B8 >?091B9CC = J0: 0>>;0E91D 91 B8; E;F;1H; E;<=E2: 012 :91<; B8; ?012 91 A=+ I;0:HE91D %" DH1B0:J0: ;K<?H:9F;?A 0??=BB;2 B= B8; :80E; =C >?091B9CC = 0: B8; >?091B9CC: J;E; 91B;1291DB=:;??B8;:0I;2;C;1201B=:012"G=91;2 B8;>?091B9CC=91:;??91DB8;:092?01291A=+ 91 - 8 - C0F=HE =C =1; 0MM0>>0 1 B8; :092 2;;2 =C :0?; 9B 9: :>;<9C9<0??A I;1B9=1;2 B80B B8; ?012 J0: :=?2 C=E >;EC=EI01<; =C B8; I0EE90D; =C B8; 20HD8B;E: =C >?091B9CC =50:BHE9@098H:;1B9E;:0?;<=1:92;E0B9=1J0:H:;2 @A >?091B9CC = C=E >;EC=EI01<; =C I0EE90D; =C 8;E 20HD8B;E:8;10I;:=C2;C;1201B=:012%J0:GH:B :8=J11=I910??A8;>?091B9CC:80F;1=B91<?H2;2B8;:092 ?012 91 A=+ I;0:HE91D %" DH1B0: 91 B8; :H9B >E=>;EBA01280F;B8H::H>>E;::;2B8;BEH;012I0B;E90? C0<B: #+ 80BE;<=E2:=CE9D8B>;EB09191DB=?012@;0E91D A=! " I;0:HE91D ! 0<E;: "! DH1B0: :9BH0B;2 91 '0110558;?9B8=HD8:B01291B8;10I;=C>?091B9CC= 0122;C;1201B=:012%10I;=C2;C;1201B=012" 0E; 1=I910??A 0>>;0E91D ?091B9CC: 0E; 91 ;K<?H:9F; >=::;::9=1012;1G=AI;1B=CB8;:092?0128;2;C;1201B =:012%80F;D=B1=E9D8BB9B?;01291B;E;:B91E;:>;<B B=B8;:092?0120:B8;:0I;80:@;;1;K<?H:9F;?A0??=BB;2 - 9 - B=B8;:80E;=C>?091B9CC:=1B;1291D0:0@=F;:=HD8BC=E 29:I9::0?=CB8;:H9B 1 B8; 0@=F; :092 >?;0291D: B8; E90? =HEB CE0I;2B8;C=??=J91D9::H;: + ?091B9CC: ;K0I91;2 8;E:;?C 0: 5 012 D=B ;K89@9B;2 :9K 2=<HI;1B: 0: K: B= + 1 @;80?C =C 2;C;1201B: 2;C;1201B = ;K0I91;2 89I:;?C 0: 012 BJ= =B8;E J9B1;::;: 0: :" 012 % 012 ;K89@9B;2 B8E;;2=<HI;1B:J89<80E;0BKB=% ( 1 0>>E;<90B9=1 =C ;F92;1<; B8; E90? =HEB 01:J;E;2 9::H; =: 012 0229B9=10? 9::H; = 91 - 10 - 1;D0B9F; 012 9::H; =:" %012 # 91 B8; 0CC9EI0B9F; 012 <=1:;LH;1B?A29:I9::;2B8;:H9B=CB8;>?091B9CC: ) ;91D0DDE9;F;2>?091B9CC:>E;C;EE;2B8;E;DH?0E 0>>;0? 91 =+ "!% 1 E;50>>E;<90B9=1 B8; &9E:B >>;??0B; =HEB CE0I;2 B8; C=??=J91D >=91B: C=E 9B: <=1:92;E0B9=1 ! " # ! $ " 8;&9E:B>>;??0B;=HEB01:J;E;2>=91B=: 012 " 91 B8; 1;D0B9F; 012 <=1:;LH;1B?A 29:I9::;2 B8; 0>>;0? ;91D 0DDE9;F;2 @A B8; :0I; B8; >?091B9CC: 0E; @;C=E;B89:=HEB ! 89: =HEB @A 01 =E2;E 20B;2 !(!("!"% 02I9BB;2 B89: 0>>;0? C=E <=1:92;E0B9=1 =C C=??=J91D :H@:B01B90?LH;:B9=1=C?0J5 % " & & ! ! - 11 - '() & '() & & ! % " & ! & ! E9'80B;B8;?;0E1;2<=H1:;?0>>;0E91D C=E B8; >?091B9CC: B0M91D B89: =HEB B8E=HD8 B8; E;<=E2: :H@I9BB;2 B80B B8; E90? =HEB 012 B8; &9E:B >>;??0B; =HEB80F;DE=::?A;EE;291E;?A91DH>=1B8;I;I=E012HI =C >0EB9B9=1 01<89M; 0BE0$ 20B;2 !!)"!!# >E=2H<;2 0BK%J89<89:02=<HI;1B<E;0B;2@AB8;2;C;1201B: 8;:0922=<HI;1B1=B80F91D@;;1E;D9:B;E;2<011=B@; 0<B;2H>=18;E90?=HEB012B8;&9E:B>>;??0B;=HEB E;?A91D H>=1 B8; :BE0A 02I9::9=1 I02; @A >?091B9CC = 80F;>E=<;;2;2B=29:I9::B8;:H9B8;802I;E;?A 02I9BB;2 B= B8; :HDD;:B9=1 I02; E;D0E291D B8; >0EB9B9=1 B80B 802 B0M;1 >?0<; @;BJ;;1 E0>>0 0:80>>0 012 0120>>0 J89<8 0E; BJ= 29CC;E;1B@E01<8;: 8;>?091B9CC - 12 - = 802 :>;<9C9<0??A 2;19;2 01A >0EB9B9=1 0I=1D:B B8; C0I9?AI;I@;E:=C E0>>07:E01<88;>?091B9CC:80F;1=B @;;1D9F;101A:80E;91B8;C0I9?A>E=>;EBA=J;F;EB8; =HEB: JE=1D?A 0<<;>B;2 >0EB9B9=1 80F91D B0M;1 >?0<; =1 !!)"!!# " 80BE;?901<;>?0<;2=1@AB8;2;C;1201BB=B8; 2;;2 =C :0?; 20B;2 #!""!!" H12;E J89<8 ?012 91 A=+ :9BH0B;2 '0110558;?9 J0: :=?2 91 C0F=HE =C =1;0MM0>>0B=<=1B;12B8;>0EB9B9=1802@;;1;CC;<B;2 J0:;EE=1;=H:8;:0922;;2=C:0?;J0:;K;<HB;2G=91B?A @A >?091B9CC = 012 2;C;1201B =: 012 % ?? =C B8;I 80F; E;<;9F;2 B8; :0?; <=1:92;E0B9=1 91<; B8; :092 E;D9:B;E;22=<HI;1BE;C?;<B:0??B8;B8E;;=CB8;I80F91D :=?2 B8; >E=>;EBA B8; :0I; <011=B @; <=1:92;E;2 B= ;F92;1<;B8;0??;D;2>0EB9B9=180F91DB0M;1>?0<;0I=1D:B B8; I;I@;E: =C E0>>07: E01<8 % B8; J9B1;:: J0: ;K0I91;2 012 B8; >?091B9CC: 80F; 2;>=:;2 B80B <=1:92;E0B9=10I=H1B>092H12;EB8;:0922;;2=C:0?;J0: - 13 - 1=B =1?A H:;2 C=E B8; I0EE90D; @HB J0: 0?:= H:;2 C=E =B8;E;K>;1:;:@A0??B8;>?091B9CC:012B8;2;C;1201B: % 80B 91 B8; <E=::5;K0I910B9=1 80: 02I9BB;2 B80B B8; >0EB9B9=1 2=<HI;1B =C B8; A;0E "!!# 2=;: 1=B @;0E B8; 20B; I=1B8 012 A;0E 8; :092 2=<HI;1B1=B80F91D@;;1>E=F;2910I011;EM1=J1B= ?0J<=H?21=B80F;@;;1E;?9;2H>=1@AB8;E90?=HEB012 B8; &9E:B >>;??0B; =HEB 8; >0EB9B9=1 2;;2 >E=2H<;2 0B K% 9: <?;0E?A 0 <=1<=<B;2 2=<HI;1B J89<8 292 1=B <E;0B; 01A E9D8B B9B?; =E 91B;E;:B 91 B8; >E=>;EB9;: 0: B8;E; J0: 1= >0EB9B9=1 =C B8; C0I9?A >E=>;EB9;: 8; E90? =HEB 012 B8; &9E:B >>;??0B; =HEB 80F; 1=B 0>>E;<90B;2 B89: 0:>;<B =C B8; I0BB;E E;:H?B91D 91 >;EF;E:9BA =C B8; GH2DI;1B # * # E9 0E:8F0E2801 '0?9>0B9? ?;0E1;2<=H1:;?0>>;0E91DC=EB8;2;C;1201B::H@I9B:B80B B8; 2=<HI;1B 0B K% E;<=E2: B8; C0<BHI =C >E;F9=H: >0EB9B9=1 B80B 802 B0M;1 >?0<; @;BJ;;1 BJ= E01<8;: =C C0I9?9;: =C E0>>0 012 80110@0::0>>0 J8= 0E; B8; - 14 - 2;:<;1201B: =C <=II=1 >E=>=:9BH: '02;>>0 92DH129 80BB8;>;EH:0?=CB8;:0922=<HI;1BJ=H?29129<0B;B80B B8; >E=>;EB9;: J89<8 0E; 8;?2 @A '02;>>0 92DH129 J0: >0EB9B9=1;2 012 B8;E; J0: ;LH9B0@?; 29:BE9@HB9=1 =C B8; :80E;: B0?:=;F92;1<;:B80BB8;>0EB9;:802912;;20<B;2 H>=1B8;:092>0EB9B9=191B80B>?091B9CC:J8=J;E;0??=BB;2 ?01291A=+ I;0:HE91D%"DH1B0:=C?01291F9??0D; '0110558;?9 802 :=?2 012 E;<;9F;2 B8; ;1B9E; :0?; <=1:92;E0B9=1B=I;;B8;EC9101<90?E;LH9E;I;1B:8;C0<B B80B :8; 80: 1=B 91<?H2;2 B8; :092 >E=>;EBA 91 B8; :H9B >0EB9B9=1 <?0E9C9;: B8; >=:9B9=1 =C B8; >E9=E >0EB9B9=1 E;<=E2=C>E;F9=H:>0EB9B9=11;;21=B@;E;D9:B;E;2 80B B8; =F;E0?? E;0291D =C B8; <9E<HI:B01<;: J=H?29129<0B;B80BB8;>E=>;EBA@;?=1D:B=B8;G=91BC0I9?A J0: ;LH9B0@?A 29:BE9@HB;2 91 B8; >0EB9B9=1 B80B 802 B0M;1 >?0<; ;F;1 >E9=E B= ;K;<HB9=1 =C B8; 01<89M; 0BE0 >0EB9B9=1=1!!)"!!#8;?01DH0D;H:;291K%8; :H@I9BB;2B8;:0I;9:E;<=E2=C>0:BBE01:0<B9=1J89<89: J;?? J9B891 B8; M1=J?;2D; =C B8; >?091B9CC: ; :H@I9BB;2 - 15 - B80BB8;?01291A=! "I;0:HE91D!0<E;"!DH1B0: :9BH0B;2 91 '0110558;?9 F9??0D; 9: :B9?? 0F09?0@?; J89<8 J0: 0??=BB;2 B= B8; :80E; =C >?091B9CC: 91 B;EI: =C B8; 0C=E;:092 01<89M; 0BE0 012 B8; 2;C;1201B: 0E; E;02A 012 J9??91D B= <=I>?A J9B8 B8; E;LH9E;I;1B: 9C 01A 91 I0M91D =F;E B8; :092 >E=>;EBA CH??A 012 0@:=?HB;?A 91 C0F=HE =C >?091B9CC: ;1<; :H@I9B: B80B B8; :H@:B01B90? LH;:B9=1: =C ?0J E09:;2 @; 01:J;E;2 91 C0F=HE =C B8; 2;C;1201B:01229:I9::;2B8;:H9B + ;0E2;EH:;2B8;E;<=E2: ( ;C=E; 02F;EB91D B= B8; E9F0? <=1B;1B9=1: 9B 9: 0>>E=>E90B; B= E;C;E B= B8; 02I9BB;2 D;1;0?=DA =C B8; >0EB9;:J89<89:0:H12;E5 &' '02;>>092DH129 E0>>0 801@0:0>>0 HE0>>05 801ME0>>0 K>9E;2 9C; 0:BHE9@09 ?BC5 29;2$ 11;>>0 5" 80E10>>0 5% 0120>>0 0:80>>0 8=@80 ?BC5" 0F9B80 ?BC5% 801B0II0 ?BC5# E92;F9 ?BC5 - 16 - ) : >;E D;1;0?=DA '02;>>0 92DH129 B8; >E=>;EB9;: 802 BJ= :=1: 10I;?A E0>>0 012 80110@0:0>>0 E0>>0 802 C=HE :=1: 10I;?A HE0>>0 2;C;1201B=$801M;E0>>0 8H:@012=C>?091B9CC= 012 C0B8;E =C >?091B9CC =:" B= $ 11;>>0 2;C;1201B ="$ 012 80E10>>0 2;C;1201B =%$ 80110@0:0>>0 802 BJ= :=1: 10I;?A 0120>>0 012 0:80>>0 8;E; 9: 1=29:>HB;J9B8E;D0E2B=B89:D;1;0?=DA 8;E; 9: 0?:= 1= 29:>HB; J9B8 E;D0E2 B= C0I9?A >=::;::91DB8;:H9B>E=>;EB9;:=J;F;E0<<=E291DB=B8; 2;C;1201B:B8;E;9:01=B8;E?01291A=+ =C'01105 58;?9F9??0D;J89<89:1=B91<?H2;291B8;:H9B "! ?091B9CC:<=1B;12;2B80BB8;E;9:1=>0EB9B9=1=C B8; G=91B C0I9?A >E=>;EB9;: 012 B8;A 0E; ;1B9B?;2 C=E #B8 :80E; 91 B8; :H9B :<8;2H?; >E=>;EB9;: J89<8 0E; B8E;; 9B;I:=CB8;>E=>;EB9;:0:I;1B9=1;20@=F; " ;C;1201B:=1=B8;E801280F;<=1B;12;2B80B H>=1 B8; 2;I9:; =C 801M;E0>>0 B8;E; J0: 0 >0EB9B9=1 - 17 - @;BJ;;1 B8; BJ= @E01<8;: =C C0I9?A =C E0>>0 012 80110@0:0>>0 J89<8 J0: :H@:;LH;1B?A E;2H<;2 91B= JE9B91D0:>;EK%012B8;>0EB9;:80F;0?:=0<B;2H>=1 B8; :092 >0EB9B9=1 8=HD8 >?091B9CC: 80F; 91<?H2;2 B8E;; 9B;I: =C >E=>;EB9;: E;C;EE;2 B= 0@=F; :8; 80: 1=B I;1B9=1;20@=HBA=+ I;0:HE91D%"DH1B0:J89<8 J0:02I9BB;2?A:=?2G=91B?A@A>?091B9CC:012B8;2;C;1201B =:B=% "" ;EH:0?=CK%501<89M;0BE09129<0B;:B80B >E9=E >0EB9B9=1 802 @;;1 ;1B;E;2 91B= @;BJ;;1 BJ= @E01<8;: =C E0>>0 012 80110@0:0>>0 91 B;EI: =C :092 >0EB9B9=1 :80E;: 91 B8; C0I9?A >E=>;EB9;: 80F; @;;1 0??=BB;20:H12;E5 & )*+,-./0*-.11.2 0 ?012 91 A=( % I;0:HE91D ! 0<E; %% DH1B0: 012 A=( + I;0:HE91D ! 0<E; + DH1B0: 80: @;;1 0??=BB;2 B=B8; :80E;=C HE0>>0 11;>>0 012 80E10>>0 2;C;1201B:="012%E;:>;<B9F;?A @ ?012: :9BH0B;2 0B '01105580??9 F9??0D; 80F; @;;1 0??=BB;2 B8; >?091B9CC = IB - 18 - 0:BHE9@09 J9C; =C 2;<;0:;2 801ME;>>0 E;>E;:;1B91DB8;:80E;=C801ME;>>0 & )*+,-./0**./.,.3.11.2 8;?01291A=( I;0:HE91D%+DH1B0: 012 ?012 91 A=( # I;0:HE91D ! 0<E; 80: @;;1 0??=BB;2 B= B8; :80E; =C 0:80>>0 0120120>>0:=1:=C80110@0:0>>0 "% 8=HD8 J89?; I;1B9=191D B8; :80E;: B80B 9: 0??=BB;2 B= >?091B9CC = E;>E;:;1B91D 8;E 8H:@012 O 801ME;>>01=:HEF;A=CB8;?0129:I;1B9=1;2 B9:1=B 9129:>HB;B80B=1?ABJ=9B;I:=C?012:@;0E91DA=+ 012 A=! " 0E; :9BH0B;2 0B '0110558;??9 F9??0D; J89<8 0<<=E291D B= B8; 2;C;1201B: J;E; 0??=BB;2 B= B8; :80E; =C >?091B9CC: =J;F;E >?091B9CC: 80F; 2;19;2 B89: 0:>;<B=CB8;I0BB;E "# '0B;E90? ;F92;1<; I02; 0F09?0@?; =1 E;<=E2 10I;?AB8;:0?;2;;2>E=2H<;20BK9129<0B;:B80BB8; :0I; 80: @;;1 ;K;<HB;2 =1 #!""!!" J8;E;91 10I;: =CB8E;;F;12=E:0E;:8=J18;A0E;HE0>>0 2;C;1201B =$ IB 0:BHE9@09 >?091B9CC =$ 012 80E010>>0 - 19 - 2;C;1201B=%$8;E;<9B0?:012:0922;;2=C:0?;E;02 B80B F;12=E: = 012 % 012 B8; 2;<;0:;2 8H:@012 =C F;12=E="J;E;B8;G=91B=J1;E:012>=::;::=E:=CB8; ?012 91 A=+ I;0:HE91D %" DH1B0: 012 B80B B8;A @;91D 91 1;;2 =C I=1;A C=E B8; C0I9?A 1;<;::9BA 012 F;12=E =" @;91D B8; I010D;E 012 8;02 =C B8; C0I9?A C=E29:<80ED91DB8;2;@B:91<HEE;2C=EB8;I0EE90D;=C8;E 20HD8B;E: 802 2;<92;2 B= :;?? B8; :092 ?012 C=E :"!!!! 5 B9:B89:I0B;E90?;F92;1<;E;?9;2H>=1@AB8; 2;C;1201B: B= <=1B;12 B80B A=+ I;0:HE91D %" DH1B0:9:=1;=CB8;BJ=9B;I:C=EB8;>E=>;EB9;::9BH0B;2 0B'0110558;?9F9??0D;J89<89:0??=BB;2B=B8;:80E;=C >?091B9CC:012B80B91;K;E<9:;=C8;EE9D8B:8;80::=?2B8; :092 ?012 80B :91<; B8; :092 ?012 :B==2 91 B8; G=91B 10I;:=C2;C;1201B:=012%0128H:@012=C>?091B9CC = 10I;?A 801ME;>>0 B8;A 802 G=91;2 1=I910??A 0: F;12=E: - 20 - " &HEB8;E B8; C0<B =C B8; 0C=E;:092 2;;2 =C :0?; @;91D ;K;<HB;2 @A >?091B9CC = 0?=1D J9B8 2;C;1201B =:012%9:1=BC=EB8<=I91D91B8;>?091B "+ 8;=B8;E<=1B;1B9=1:=CB8;2;C;1201B:9:B80B B8; :;<=12 9B;I =C B8; ?012 @;0E91D A=! " I;0:HE91D!00<E;"!DH1B0::9BH0B;20B'0110558;?9 F9??0D;9:0??=BB;2B=B8;:80E;=C>?091B9CC:012B80BB8;:092 ?012 9: :B9?? 0F09?0@?; 012 B8; 2;C;1201B: 80F; 1= <?09I =F;EB8;:0I; "( 8; 0C=E;:092 :B0B;I;1B 91 B8; JE9BB;1 :B0B;I;1B 012 91 B8; 2;>=:9B9=1 E;02 91 B8; ?9D8B =C <=1B;1B:=CB8;2;;2=C:0?;20B;2#!""!!">E=2H<;20B K>E=@0@0?9P;:B8;C0<BHI=C>E9=E>0EB9B9=1;1B;E;2 91B= 0I=1D:B BJ= @E01<8;: =C B8; C0I9?A7: =C E0>>0 012 80110@0:0>>08;:80E;:0??=BB;2B=B8;>0EB9;:@;91D0? I=:B ;LH0? 0?:= >E=@0@0?9P;: ;LH9B0@?;29:BE9@HB9=1=C B8; :80E;: - 21 - ") :E9D8B?A<=1B;12;2@A?;0E1;2<=H1:;?C=EB8; 2;C;1201B:B80BK%9:0E;<=E2=C>E9=E>0EB9B9=10?; 2;;2 20B;2 #!""!!" 9: B8; ;F92;1<; =C :0I; 80F91D @;;10<B;2H>=1@AB8;>0EB9;:IH<8>E9=E=CE;2H<91DB8; C0<BHI =C >E9=E >0EB9B9=1 91B= JE9B91D 0: >;E K% 8; :092 2=<HI;1B @;91D 0 I;I=E012HI =C >E9=E >0EB9B9=1 2=;:1=BE;LH9E;E;D9:BE0B9=1 " 8;>;K=HEB91B8;<0:;=C E;>=EB;29180:8;?20:H12;E910E0 =!5 + , & ! - # & ! . /0$ 1 & 2 /0$ # 2 /0 $ ! & ! 2 - 22 - /0,& ! & ! & ! 3 # & ! ! ! 4 ! , ( ! ! & 5 6/0 7! % ## ! 2 /0 $ & ! # & 4 & ! ' ! 1 4 & ! & # ! & & ! ! 2 /80' # #& ! ! & 1 ! ! 9 %! 8; E90? =HEB 012 B8; &9E:B >>;??0B; =HEB 02F;EB91D B= B8; F;EA 2;>=:9B9=1 =C >?091B9CC = J8= ;K0I91;28;E:;?C0:02I9BB91DB=B8;29:BE9@HB9=1=C B8;:80E;:0:;KBE0<B;20B0E0="=CB8;GH2DI;1B=C B8;&9E:B>>;??0B;=HEB80F;<=I;B=B8;<=1<?H:9=1B80B - 23 - >?091B9CC: 80: 802 B8; M1=J?;2D; =C >E9=E >0EB9B9=1 8;A 80F; 0?:= 02F;EB;2 B= B8; E;F;1H; E;<=E2: E;C?;<B91D B8; 10I; =C >?091B9CC = 91 E;:>;<B =C ?012 91 A=! " I;0:HE91D!0<E;"!DH1B0:<=1C9EI91DB8;>0EB9B9=1802 B0M;1>?0<;91B;EI:=CK%O01<89M;0BE0 % 1B8;?9D8B=CB8;0C=E;:092<=1<HEE;1BC91291D: 012 <=1<?H:9=1 =1 C0<B: 0EE9F;2 0B@A B8; E90?=HEB 012 B8; &9E:B >>;??0B; =HEB B89: =HEB 2= 1=B C912 01A 9??;D0?9BA;EE=E=E9EE;DH?0E9BA9129:I9::91DB8;:H9B012B8; 0>>;0?C9?;2@AB8;>?091B9CC: %" 8; >?091B9CC: 802 C9?;2 01 0>>?9<0B9=1 H12;E E2;EQ H?;"(=C@;C=E;B8;&9E:B>>;??0B;=HEB :;;M91D >E=2H<B9=1 =C <;EB9C9;2 <=>A =C 0DE;;I;1B=C :0?; 20B;2 ""!+"!+ C=E B8; >HE>=EB;2 >HE>=:; =C @E91D91D =1 E;<=E2 B8; C0<B B80B 2;C;1201B: O E;:>=12;1B =% 2HE91D B8; >;12;1<A =C 0>>;0? J0: I0M91D ;CC=EB: B= <801D;B8;0DE9<H?BHE0??012@A0?9;10B91DB8;:0I;B=B8; B89E2 >0EBA 1 B8; 0CC920F9B 0<<=I>01A91D B8; :092 - 24 - 0>>?9<0B9=11=B891D9:I;1B9=10:B=B8;E;?;F01<A=C:092 2=<HI;1B C=E B8; >HE>=:; =C 2;B;EI910B9=1 =C B8; ?9: @;BJ;;1B8;>0EB9;:8=HD8B8;&9E:B>>;??0B;=HEB80: 1=B:>;<9C9<0??A02F;EB;2B=B8;:0920>>?9<0B9=191B8;?9D8B =CB8;29:<H::9=10@=F;J9B8E;D0E2B=B8;>E9=E>0EB9B9=1 =C B8; C0I9?A >E=>;EB9;: B89: =HEB 2= 1=B :;; 01A >E;GH29<; @;91D <0H:;2 B= B8; >?091B9CC: 91 1=15 <=1:92;E0B9=1=CB8;:0920>>?9<0B9=1 %% 8; :H@:B01B90? LH;:B9=1: =C ?0J 01:J;E;2 0<<=E291D?A %# 8;0>>;0?9: % 8; GH2DI;1B 012 2;<E;; 20B;2 !%"!" >0::;2 91 =" "!! =1 B8; C9?; =C 22? 9F9? 4H2D;920E012GH2DI;1B0122;<E;;20B;2!!)"! >0::;2 91 =+ "!% =1 B8; C9?; =C E? ;19=E 9F9? 4H2D;0124'920E0E;<=1C9EI;2 45 % & # 9:B=?="%