Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63749 (KAR)

KESU v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

WP/203768/2025 · 2025-12-01

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"! # $ %$&!$!$ '( !" " !" # ! !" $ %& ' ( & & & Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ! # ! ) ! $ %& ' * ( ""! ""+ ( ( ' * ( ( "+""# & ( " , & " ! """# & ), &' * ( ) ( , ( ! "+ "# ' * -& ( ( * * ( * .& - 3 - % .& ' /010123/45 6/4/13 74/ 8/924/ 0615 2:40 5//;13< 92==2>13<4/=1/95 7' 55:/ 7 >410 13 06/ 370:4/ 29 ?/40124741 @:756 06/ 1AB:<3/C 23=13/ 320191?70123 C70/C "+""# 8/7413<2 13(24A2"/ D1C/ 33/E:4/ B755/C 8F 06/ "3C 4/5B23C/30 73C ?235/@:/30=F @:756 06/ 2! C70/C """# B755/C 8F 4/5B23C/30 2) D1C/ 33/E:4/ 8' 155:/ 7 >410 13 06/ 370:4/ 29 A73C7A:5 C14/?013< 4/5B23C/30 2) 02 4/5024/ 06/ 37A/ 29 B/010123/45 0206//E0/3029!7?4/5"+<:307513F2"# 510:70/C 70 /<C1F7= D1==7</ 7=:; 73C 150 1G7F7B:4 ?' 55:/ 5:?6 206/4 >410 24 24C/4 24 C14/?0123 75 0615 23-8=/?2:40C//A5G:5073CB42B/4:3C/406/97?05 73C ?14?:A5073?/5 29 06/ ?75/ 73C 7==2> 0615 >410 B/010123 " 75/2906/B/010123/4515067006/=73C8/7413< F2"# A/75:413< ! 7?4/5 "+ <:3075 510:70/C 70 /<C1F7= 1==7</ 1G7F7B:47 15041?0 73C 7=:; 15 2>3/C 73C B255/55/C 8F 06/ 73?/50245 29 06/ B/010123/45 37A/=F 1A8: /A: 7A731 6/ 67D13< B:4?675/C 06/ 57A/ 13 0/4A5 29 4/<150/4/C C//C 29 57=/ C70/C - 4 - "!# 1537A/>75A:070/C1306/4/D/3:/4/?24C5 23 "!# 6/ 571C 1A8: /A: 7A731 73C 615 84206/48F37A///0:/A: 7A731/99/?0/CB7401012313 >61?6=73C13F2"#A/75:413<!7?4/5"+<:3075 6758//37==200/C0206/5674/29 1A8:/A: 7A731 # 39:406/473?/06/4/924/37A/29 1A8:/A: 7A731 ?7A/ 02 8/ A:070/C D1C/ :070123 2"+! 23 #! 71C 1A8: /A: 7A731 B755/C 7>7F =/7D13< 8/613C 615 5235 73C C7:<60/45 37A/=F 61D: 73;: &75: :47C: 74/DD7 107871 73C 7A7=7871 >625/ 37A/5 >/4/ A:070/C 13 06/ 4/D/3:/ 4/?24C5 D1C/ :070123 2#" C70/C "+! /010123/45 74/ 06/ =/<7= 6/145 73C 06/14 37A/5 ?7A/ 02 8/ A:070/C 13 06/ 4/D/3:/ 4/?24C5 02 06/ /E0/30 29 ! 7?4/ "+ <:3075 D1C/ :070123 2" # 23 ## 6:5 06/ B/010123/45 67D/ 8//3 13 7?0:7= B255/55123 73C /3G2FA/30 29 06/ 7924/571C B42B/40F 73C06/4/15 32206/4 7<41?:=0:47= =73C 5073C13< 13 06/ 37A/ 29 06/ B/010123/45 13?/ 06/F 8/=23</C 02 06/ 7A731 ?2AA:310F 06/F 74/ :5/C 02 - 5 - 4/51C13< 3/74 06/ 7<41?:=0:47= =73C5 7=23< >106 06/14 ?2AA:310FA/A8/45 ) 613<5 5022C 06:5 4/5B23C/30 2" >1062:0 62=C13<73F/3@:14F155:/C320191?70123:3C/4/?0123# 29 06/ 73C /924A5 ?0 %A/3CA/30' "! >106 /99/?0 942A " "+ C/?=7413< 06/ &757D737<74 75 73 :34/?24C/C 6781070123 875/C 23 06/ B42B257= B:4B240/C=F 5/30 8F 4/5B23C/30 2" H55150730 2AA155123/4 6/ 571C 4/?2AA/3C70123 >75 155:/C >1062:0 155:13< 73F 3201?/ 73C B42D1C13< 73F 2BB240:310F 06/ /E0/30 29 =73C >61?6 15 52:<60 02 8/ 13?=:C/C :3C/4 06/ :34/?24C/C 6781070123 74/7 15 782:0 # 7?4/5 #" <:3075 2:0 29 ! 7?4/5 "+ <:3075 29 =73C 13 F2"# 8/=23<13< 02 06/ B/010123/456705:85/@:/30155:73?/29320191?7012337A/ 2906/2D/43A/3073C&757D737<74?7A/028/A:070/C D1C/2! C70/C"""# == 06/5/ B42?//C13<5 67D/ 8//3 6/=C 8/613C 06/ 87?; 29 06/ B/010123/45 /5B23C/305 23 )"" ?7A/ 3/74 06/ =73C 29 06/ B/010123/45 23 06/ B4/0/E0 29 - 6 - A/75:413<06/57A/01523=F06/306/B/010123/45=/7430 782:0 06/ 4/5B23C/307:0624101/5 67D13< 155:/C 06/ 320191?70123 23 "+""# &/13< 7<<41/D/C >106 06/ B4/5/30B/010123 ! 6/ =/743/C ?2:35/= 924 06/ B/010123/45 4/=1/5 :B23 06/ 24C/4 C70/C " """ B755/C 13 *2#+""" 75 >/== 75 24C/4 C70/C "" B755/C 13 *2""+!"" 5:8A105 0670 :3C/4 1C/301?7= 97?05 29 06/ A700/4 0615 2:40 675 @:756/C 06/ 320191?70123 73C C14/?0/C 06/ 4/5B23C/305 02 ?2351C/4 06/ 4/B4/5/3070123 29 06/ B/010123/45 06/4/13 73C 02 B755 7BB42B4170/ 24C/45 790/4 62=C13< 73 /3@:14F 75 ?230/AB=70/C :3C/4 =7> / 5:8A105 0670 06/ B/010123/45 6/4/13 >62 74/ 51A1=74=F 510:70/C A7F 7=52 8/ /E0/3C/C >10651A1=748/3/9105 + /743/C CC101237= 2D/43A/30 CD2?70/ 62>/D/45:8A1050670/D/38/924/155:73?/29320191?70123 7 5:4D/F >2:=C 67D/ 8//3 ?23C:?0/C 73C >1062:0 ?23C:?013<5:?675:4D/F06/1367810/C74/7>2:=C3208/ - 7 - ?74D/C2:0 /62>/D/45:8A105067006/B/010123/45513?/ ?=71A13< 0670 06/F 67D/ 320 155:/C 73F 3201?/ 24 2BB240:310F7C14/?0123>1==8/155:/C0206/B/010123/4502 5:8A10 7 4/B4/5/3070123 >61?6 >1== 8/ ?2351C/4/C 13 7??24C73?/>106=7> :8A15512307;/3234/?24C 42D15123529/?0123# 2906/743707;7 73C /924A5 ?0 ! 4/7C >106 :=/ & 02 29 06/ 743707;7 73C /D/3:/ :=/5 +) /=782470/=F 5/02:0 06/B42?/C:4/924155:13<<4730?/40191?70/292>3/4561B02 06/7<41?:=0:47==782:4/45 /4:57= 29 06/ 320191?70123 70 33/E:4/ 13C1?70/5067006/C/?=747012329=73C513?=:C13<06/=73C29 06/ B/010123/45 15 562>3 75 :34/?24C/C 6781070123 97==13< >10613 &757D7 7<74 A/4/=F 23 06/ 87515 29 7 4/B240 5:8A100/C8F06/551507302AA155123/42971?6:4:8 1D15123 33/E:4/ 9:406/4 13C1?70/5 0670 32 3201?/ 29 B42?//C13<567D/8//31310170/C8/924/155:13<06/57A/ - 8 - 6/ 4/?24C5 5:8A100/C 8F 06/ B/010123/45 B42C:?/7033/E:4/502(13C1?70/067006/37A/2906/ B/010123/45675?23013:/C1306/4/D/3:/4/?24C5 " 6/ 224C1370/&/3?6 29 0615 2:40 :3C/4 06/ 51A1=74 ?14?:A5073?/5 13 105 24C/4 C70/C " """ B755/C 13 13 06/ ?75/ 29 67C @:756/C 51A1=74 320191?70123 C14/?013< 06/ /B:0F 2AA155123/4 02 D/419F 06/ 4/D/3:/ 4/?24C5 73C 06/4/790/4 02 B755 7BB42B4170/ 24C/4 >106 =18/40F 13 06/ /D/30 29 /B:0F 2AA155123/4 ?2A13< 02 06/ ?23?=:5123 0670 06/ =73C5 4/@:14/C 924 B:8=1? B:4B25/ 02 1310170/ 7?@:1510123B42?//C13<5137??24C73?/>1067BB=1?78=/=7> 1A1=74=F06152:4007;13<320/2906/7924/571C24C/429 06/ 224C1370/ &/3?6 8F )*+) *,-+* """" B755/C 13 " . 67C @:756/C 06/ 1AB:<3/C 320191?70123 C14/?013< 06/ 4/5B23C/305 02 ?2351C/406/4/B4/5/307012329B/010123/473C790/4/3@:14F 19 10 >75 92:3C 06/ B/010123/4 15 13C//C 06/ 2>3/4 73C - 9 - B255/55242906/=73C024/5024/61537A/1306/4/D/3:/ 4/?24C5 # 3 0670 D1/> 29 06/ A700/4 06/ B/010123 15 1306/92==2>13<C14/?01235 1' 20191?70123 C70/C "+""# B42C:?/C 70 33/E:4/155:/C8F4/5B23C/302"/B:0F 2AA155123/4 02 06/ /E0/30 29 06/ =73C A/75:413< # 7?4/5 #" <:3075 13 F2"# 8/=23<13<0206/B/010123/4515@:756/C 11' /010123/45 567== 5:8A10 7 4/B4/5/3070123 7=23< >106 C2?:A/30 G:5019F13< 06/14 /3010=/A/305 >10613 C7F5 942A 06/ C70/ 29 4/?/1B0 29 06/ ?/40191/C?2BF29061524C/4 111' B23 5:8A155123 29 5:?6 4/B4/5/3070123 4/5B23C/30 2" /B:0F 2AA155123/4 567== ?2351C/4 06/ 4/B4/5/3070123 90/4 62=C13< 73 /3@:14F75?230/AB=70/C:3C/4=7>B75524C/45 23/>7F2406/206/4?2AA:31?70/06/57A/02 06/ B/010123/45 13 >41013< >10613 C7F5 06/4/790/4 1D' /5B23C/30 2" /B:0F 2AA155123/4 567== :3C/407;/ 06/ /E/4?15/ 75 C14/?0/C 782D/ 73C - 10 - B7557BB42B4170/24C/45>10613#A230652306/ C70/29B/010123/455:8A10013<06/4/B4/5/3070123 75C14/?0/C D' 90/4 06/ /3@:14F 19 10 15 92:3C 0670 06/ B/010123/4574/13C//C06/2>3/4513B255/55123 2906/=73C13F2"#A/75:413<!7?4/5 "+ <:3075 75 ?=71A/C 73C 19 06/ 571C =73C 15 4/@:14/C 8F 4/5B23C/307:0624101/5 3/?/5574F B42?//C13<58/1310170/C73C06/?2AB/3570123 1973F8/B71C0206/B/010123/45137??24C73?/ >106=7> D1' 13?/ 06/ C2?:A/30 B42C:?/C 70 33/E:4/ 02 06/ >410 B/010123 C70/C "+""#13C1?70/06/37A/2906/B/010123/45 8/13< 4/9=/?0/C 13 06/ 4/D/3:/ 4/?24C5 D1C/ 2! 73C1306/=1<602906/320191?70123 67D13< 8//3 B755/C 75 782D/ 37A/5 29 06/ B/010123/45 >1== 8/ 4/5024/C 01== 06/ 24C/4 75 C14/?0/C782D/15B755/C !*. '$!$( & 53 1502=2!