- 1 - !" #"$"" %& ! " # # $ # # Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ## & ## # # & ! " & # $ ' ( # # ) ( % $ *+ ) % , *+ # & - - . " - 3 - -. " /010123/45 64/ 7/824/ 0915 2:40 7/13;6;;41/</=7> 09/ 24=/4 =60/= ( ?655/= 7> 4/5?23=/30 2 @109=46@13; 09/ ;46301361= /A0/3=/= :3=/4 /B0123 % 28 09/ 643606C6 =:B60123 B0 D% @109 1EE/=160/ /88/B0 65 @/FF 65 09/ 24=/4 =60/= % =15E15513; 09/ 6??/6F 81F/= 7> 09/ ?/010123/4 6;61350 09/ 6824/561=24=/4?42=:B/=6033/A:4/ 65/2809/?/010123/45150960?/010123/4215 6 52B1/0> 4/;150/4/= :3=/4 09/ 643606C6 2B1/0> /;150460123 B0 D$ 7/F23;13; 02 09/ /E7/45 28 B9/=:F/= 650/96009/81450?/010123/452B1/0>9657//3 4:3313;82:4=:B601236F 35010:0123536E/F>G 6E06C59E1:45/4>6336=61;9/441E64>B922F 741963C64F13;/59@6461;9/441E64>B922F BE0656E6 /E2416F1;9/441E64>B922F =4163;636656</59@6466336=61;9/441E64> B922F606F67:46;1 - 4 - % 9/ 5/B23= ?/010123/4 15 09/ 656EE6 /E2416F 1;9/4 41E64> B922F 4:3 7> 09/ ?/010123/4 296009/?/4E155123,4/B2;310123024:309/?/010123/4 2 35010:0123 @65 270613/= 7> ?/010123/4 2 63= 09/ 56E/ @65 ;4630/= 23 DD% 9/ 4/5?23=/30 2 96=6F52;1</3?/4E1551238244:3313;3=63=095063=64= BF655/5 7> ?/010123/4 2 35010:0123 9/ 4/5?23=/30 2%96=09/4/680/4155:/=63/3=245/E/30?/4E10013;09/ ?/010123/42024:309/BF655/5842E505063=64=0209 5063=64= 842E 09/ >/64 DDD /5?23=/305 96= 6F52 155:/= #24E 2D 4/B2;31H13; 09/ ?/010123/4 2 60 09/ B2EE/3B/E/30 28 =:B60123 B0 /5?23=/30 2 96= ;1</3?/4E1551230209/?/010123/42024:3$0963=(09 BF655/5 /88/B01</ 842E %( /5?23=/30 2% 96= 4/B2;31H/= 4:3313; 28 09/ BF655/5 842E 81450 5063=64= 02 5/</3095063=64=<1=//3=245/E/30=60/= 960 :?23 09/ 4/B2EE/3=60123 E6=/ 7> 09/ 4/5?23=/305 ?/010123/4 2 35010:0123 @65 6=E100/= 02 ;46301361= 824 ( 0/6B9/45 913;5 5022= 09:5 09/ - 5 - ?/010123/45@/4/13824E/=7>09/2881B16F52809/==101236F 2EE155123/4824:7F1B 3504:B01235096050/?596</7//3 06C/302=/4/B2;31H/09/?/010123/422309/6FF/;60123 28 5:7E155123 28 86741B60/= =2B:E/305 2 /3I:14> @65 B23=:B0/= 32 2??240:310> @65 ;1</3 02 09/ ?/010123/45 4=/4 @109=46@13; 09/ 4/B2;310123 @65 ?655/= 23 ( 63= B6FF13; :?23 09/ ?/010123/45 02 BF25/ 09/ 5B922F </3 09/ 561= 24=/4 @65 320 8:43159/= 02 09/ ?/010123/45/5?23=/30213;4255<12F6012328?413B1?F/ 28360:46FJ:501B/96=?655/=09/24=/4=60/=( @109=46@13; 09/ ;46301361= 563B0123/= 02 ?/010123/4 2 35010:0123 /010123/4 2 5:7E100/= 6 4/?4/5/3060123 02 4/5?23=/30 2 23 % 02 13504:B0 4/5?23=/30 2 02 </418> 09/ 4/B24=5 63= 02 5:7E10 09/ 4/?240 2@/</4 09/ 56E/ @65 320 B2351=/4/= ?/010123/45 ?4/8/44/= 63 6??/6F 7/824/ 09/ 413B1?6F /B4/064> =:B60123 /?640E/30 41E64> 63= 1;9/4 B922F =:B60123 @91B9 15 09/ 6??/FF60/ 6:092410> :3=/4 09/ - 6 - 643606C6 =:B60123 B0 9/ 561= 6??/6F B6E/ 02 7/ =15E155/=<1=/24=/4=60/=%/010123/4F/80@109 32209/42?0123157/824/0915 2:40 $ /643/= B2:35/F 824 09/ ?/010123/45 06C13; 0915 B2:40 0942:;9 09/ 4/B24=5 5:7E105 0960 09/ 24=/4 1E?:;3/= 36E/F> 24=/4 =60/= ( ?42=:B/= 60 33/A:4/ 965 7//3 ?655/= @1092:0 B23=:B013; 63> /3I:14> 65 B230/E?F60/= :3=/4 /B0123 % 28 09/ 643606C6=:B60123B0/5:7E105096009/24=/4280915 360:4/96<13;=46501B4/5:F052:;900296</7//3?4/B/=/= 7>B23=:B013;09//3I:14>65B230/E?F60/=:3=/409/F6@ /4/F1/5:?2309/24=/42809/ 224=1360//3B9280915 2:40=60/='( ')?655/=13* *+, ' 13 09/ B65/ 28 13 5:??240 28 915 5:7E155123 / 8:409/4 5:7E105 0960 24=/4 =60/=%6033/A:4/?655/=7>09/6??/FF60/ 6:092410>1532023E/41059/561=24=/496=7//3?655/= E/4/F> 7/B6:5/ 6 @410 ?/010123 96= 7//3 81F/= 7> 09/ - 7 - ?/010123/4 /64F1/4 13 &2$,( 63= @1092:0 6=</4013;0209/E/41052809/B65/9/4/824/9/5:7E105 720924=/456033/A:4/63=33/A:4/1523/@1092:0 =:/ B2E?F163B/ 02 09/ 4/I:14/E/30 28 F6@ E24/ ?6401B:F64F> 02 09/ ?413B1?F/5 28 360:46F J:501B/ /3B/ 5//C58246FF2@13;2809/?/010123 ( 3 4/5?235/ F/643/= ==101236F 2</43E/30 =<2B60/ J:5018>13; 09/ 24=/4 ?655/= 5:7E105 0960 09/ =2B:E/305 8:43159/= 7> 09/ ?/010123/45 60 09/ 01E/ 28 135?/B0123 @/4/ 6FF 86741B60/= 63= 824;/= =2B:E/305 63= 6:0924101/5 96= 3/</4 155:/= =2B:E/305 65 52:;90 02 7/ ?42=:B/=7>09/?/010123/4513J:50181B601232809/14BF61E28 09/> 96<13; 7//3 4/B2;31H/= 63= 6=E10013; 1302 09/ ;46301361=/5:7E105096009/24=/46033/A:4/965 ?4/B/=/= @109 63 /3I:14> @64463013; 32 8:409/4 B2351=/460123/3B/5//C5824=15E1556F2809/?/010123 /64=?/4:5/=09/4/B24=5 - 8 - D /4:56F28B230/3052833/A:4/13=1B60/0960 B/40613 6FF/;601235 96</ 7//3 E6=/ @109 4/;64= 02 ?/010123/4 35010:0123 27061313; 09/ ?/4E155123 02 4:3 50 5063=64= BF655/5 23 DD% @91B9 96??/3/= 02 7/ :3=6>#:409/46FF/;60123564/E6=/096009/?/4E155123 F/00/45 8:43159/= 7> 09/ ?/010123/45 824 09/ ?:4?25/ 28 4:3313; 09/ BF655/5 842E 3= 02 09 5063=64= 50 02 09 5063=64= @/4/ 320 155:/= 7> 09/ B23B/43/= 6:0924101/5 9/4/3/@6FB/40181B60/5@/4/320155:/=7>09/B23B/43/= 6:092410> #:409/4 32 =2B:E/305 64/ 6<61F67F/ 13 09/14 2881B/ 824 6BB24=13; ?/4E155123 02 4:3 BF655/5 $09 02 (09 5063=64=5 0 15 8:409/4 6FF/;/= 0960 @9/3 09/ 135?/B0123 @65 B23=:B0/= 7> 09/ 881B/4 28 09/ /?640E/30 32 4/B24=5@/4/6<61F67F/1309/ 35010:01232809/?/010123/4 9/4/@656F52324/B24=@1094/;64=02K1FF663B96>609 B23=:B013; 63> E//013; 24 ?65513; 63> 4/52F:0123 23 $$ 4/B2EE/3=13; 09/ 35010:0123 824 6=E10013; ;46301361= 0 6F52 4/8/45 02 592@B6:5/ 3201B/ 96<13; - 9 - 7//3 155:/= 63= 09/ 4/?F> ;1</3 7> 09/ ?/010123/45 320 7/13;5601581/=4/5:F013;13?65513;09/1E?:;3/=24=/4 F/64F> 092:;9 5/412:5 6FF/;601235 96</ 7//3 E6=/ 4/;:F64F> 1E?42?41/0> 23 09/ ?640 28 09/ ?/010123/4 32 /3I:14> 13 0915 E600/4 965 7//3 B23=:B0/= 9/ 2 24=1360/ /3B9 28 0915 2:40 13 09/ B65/ 28 4/8/44/= 02 672</ 60 ?646;46?9 2 9659/F=65:3=/4G L 764/ 4/6=13; 28 /B0123% 28 643606C6 =:B60123 B0 D% @2:F= 13=1B60/ 0960 10 /E?2@/45 09/ 060/ 2</43E/30 02 @10992F=4/=:B/24@109=46@09/;46301361=02 @91B9 63 135010:0123 15 6=E100/= 63= B23=10123 ?4/B/=/30824/A/4B1513;5:B9?2@/45</50/=1310 15 02 92F= 63 /3I:14> 63= 680/4 B23=:B013; 5:B9 /3I:14>2</43E/3015/E?2@/4/=02@10992F= 4/=:B/24@109=46@63>;4630?6>67F/=:413;09/ >/640263=:B601236F 35010:012396<13;4/;64= 0209/8:3=560105=15?256F2@/</410@2:F=7/ 680/4/A0/3=13;632??240:310>0209/B23B/43/= 35010:0123 4/6=13; 28 /B0123 % @2:F= 13=1B60/ 0960 09/ 060/ 2</43E/30 E6> 680/4 5:B9 /3I:14> 65 10 =//E5 810 E6> @10992F= 4/=:B/ 24 @109=46@ 63> ;4630 ?6>67F/ 02 09/ /=:B601236F 135010:0123 :3=/4 09/ B23013;/3B1/5 ?4/5B417/= 09/4/:3=/4 <1H 13 5:7BF6:5/ 02 ( :7 BF6:5/ 28 /B0123 % @2:F= 13=1B60/ 0960 @9/4/ 63 135010:0123 861F/= 02 8:F81FF - 10 - 63> 28 09/ B23=101235 28 09/ ;4630 13 5:B9 63 /</30 09/ 060/ 2</43E/30 @2:F= 7/ /E?2@/4/=02@10992F=4/=:B/24@109=46@09/ ;4630 ?6>67F/ 02 5:B9 =:B601236F 35010:0123 9:5 09/ /3I:14> B230/E?F60/= :3=/4 5:7 /B012328/B0123%28643606C6=:B60123 B0 D% B63320 7/ 63 /E?0> 824E6F10> ?6401B:F64F> @9/3 09/ B1<1F 41;905 28 09/ ?6401/5 64/13<2F</=/B0123%2809/B0@9/34/6=65 6 @92F/ @2:F= BF/64F> 13=1B60/ 0960 7/824/ ?42B//=13;0292F= 63/3I:14> 632??240:310>15 02 7/ /A0/3=/= 02 09/ B23B/43/= 35010:0123 02 @91B9 09/ 2</43E/30 ?42?25/= 02 06C/ 6B0123 65 209/4@15/ 09/4/ @2:F= 7/ 13846B0123 28 ?413B1?F/5 28 360:46F J:501B/ 960 6?640 09/ /3I:14>B230/E?F60/=15BF/64F>=15B/4367F/842E 09//A?4/5512382:3=1309/561=/B012336E/F> M680/4 5:B9 /3I:14> 65 09/> =//E 810M 0 @2:F= 3/B/55641F>E/6332023F>;1<13;632??240:310> 0209/B23B/43/= 35010:0123024/?F>0209/92@ 6:5/3201B/7:06F526FF2@13;5:B9 35010:012302 ?F6B/6FF5:B9E60/416F@91B909/>130/3=024/?F> :?23 13 5:??240 28 09/ 4/?F> 5:7E100/= 02 5:B9 92@ 6:5/3201B/N 9/ 24=/4 60 33/A:4/ @91B9 15 =60/= % ?655/= 7> 09/ 6??/FF60/ 6:092410> =2/5 320 6=</400209/E/410524209/4@15/2809/B230/30123:4;/= 7>09/?/010123/459/561=24=/49657//3?655/=E/4/F> 23 09/ ?4/E15/ 28 ?/010123/45 96<13; /64F1/4 6??426B9/= 0915 2:40 13 &410 /010123 25$,( 3 0960 - 11 - <1/@2809/E600/41309/F1;902809/86B05364460/=672</ 63= 09/ F6@ F61= =2@3 7> 09/ 224=1360/ /3B9 28 0915 2:401309/B65/28 4/8/44/= 02672</09/@410?/010123156FF2@/=/3B/09/82FF2@13;G 6 9/?/010123156FF2@/= 7 9/ 24=/4 =60/= ( 60 33/A:4/ 63= 09/ 24=/4 =60/= % 60 33/A:4/64/I:659/= B 600/4 15 4/E100/= 02 4/5?23=/30 2 02 B23=:B0 /3I:14> 7> ?42<1=13; 5:881B1/30 2??240:310>0209/?/010123/4502?4/5/3009/ B65/ 23 09/ 6FF/;601235 E6=/ 09/4/13 63= 09/4/680/4 02 ?655 6??42?4160/ 24=/45 13 6BB24=63B/@109F6@@10913632:0/4F1E1028 D=6>5842E09/=60/284/B/1?028B/40181/= B2?>28091524=/4 = FFB230/30123564/C/?02?/3 -, %""& $ E54 1502-F2-