- 1 - ! " " #$ " #$ "" %&' () "" %&' ( ) ! ! ! " #$ $ % & ' Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( & & & ! ( $ )*' * + & $ ( &! , *'*' !!!'! " #$ $$ - - $. & * * % & #% !'' $ ( & $ ( $ ( , - 3 - ( ) & ( & & & ' ( $ *' " #$ $$ % + & $ ( &! , *' !!!'! - 4 - *' ! ! ! " #$ $ . & * % & #% !'' $ ( $ ( & ( , ( / / 0$ ( 0$ ( $ #/ 0$ ( % 1232 456 7882793 :; 88299742 <3=>7<?2 6@87<; 73 5299 73 7882997<43&?97A@7<43 ?799A<B A< C=234A6< 412 D=EB@2<4 7<E 757>E E742E A< 6&87332E:;EEA4A6<79A34>A?4233A6<3 - 5 - (=EB2 7<E 74 7A?1=> #F6> 316>4 G412 >A:=<79H% $64141278827937>26<C=7<4=@6F?6@82<374A6< 12 E742 6F 7??AE2<4 A<I69I2@2<4 6F I21A?92 E27416F1AI7A717<E9A7:A9A4;4687;412?6@82<374A6<7>2 <64A<EA38=42.4126<9;EA38=42A3A<>2382?46FC=7<4=@6F ?6@82<374A6< 27>E >A 17>7<7:737887 74A9 927><2E ?6=<32978827>A<BF6>4127882997<4)<3=>7<?26@87<; A< 6& 7<E @4 74A9 17<47:7A =:1731 927><2E ?6=<329 78827>A<B F6> 412 7882997<43&?97A@7<43A< 6&* >A17>7<7:737887 74A95A41799I212@2<?2 3=:@A442E 4174 412 6<9; A33=2 A<I69I2E A< 41A3 788279 A3 2J6>:A47<4?6@82<374A6<757>E2E=<E2>412127EG96336F E282<E2<?;H382>@7>K3?7>E412E7426F:A>416F E2?2732E 573 3165< 73 !' 12 7??AE2<4 6??=>>2E6<*33=?14127B26FE2?2732E73 6< 412 E742 6F 7??AE2<4 573 ;27>3 652I2> 412 - 6 - >A:=<79 173 47K2< 412 7B2 74 * ;27>3 A< 42>@3 6F 8634@6>42@>286>474J<IA256F412E7426F:A>41 3165< A< 412 @7>K3 ?7>E 412 37@2 6=B14 46 17I2 :22<?6<3AE2>2E:;412>A:=<793412E2?2732E573 ;27>3 412 @=94A89A2> 7889A?7:92 A3 GH 7<E 412 A<?6@2 4657>E3 F=4=>2 8>6382?43 A3 *L 46 :2 7EE2E 1652I2> 412 >A:=<79 173 47K2< GH 73 412 @=94A89A2> 7<E 7EE2E L 4657>E3 F=4=>2 8>6382?43 412 37@2 >2C=A>23 >2 ?6<3AE2>74A6< * 27><2E ?6=<329 F=>412> 3=:@A43 4174 412 >A:=<79 173 6>E2>2E A<42>234 74 412 >742 6F !L 87 7<E 5A41 7 E2F7=94 ?97=32 6F L 82> 7<<=@ 12 E2F7=94 ?97=327382>41297597AEE65<:;4126<H:9282J6=>4 A3 =<3=347A<7:92 6F7> 73 A<42>234 74 !L 82> 7<<=@ A3 ?6<?2><2E412>2A3<6@742>A79897?2E:;412?97A@7<437<E <6 >2736<3 733AB<2E :; 412 >A:=<79 F6> 757>EA<B 412 A<42>234 74 !L 82> 7<<=@ 12 A<42>234 B2<2>799; @7A<47A<2E A3 L 82> 7<<=@ 2A412> :2F6>2 41A3 6=>4 73 529973:;4126<H:9282J6=>4<41232?A>?=@347<?23 - 7 - 412A<42>2346=B144617I2:22<47K2<74L82>7<<=@ A4141A3927><2E?6=<32936=B1446799654127882797<E EA3@A33 412 788279 FA92E :; 412 7882997<43&?97A@7<43 >2E=?A<B412?6@82<374A6< 2F=4A<B 412 3=:@A33A6< 6F 927><2E ?6=<329 F6> 412 7882997<4 ) A<3=>7<?2 ?6@87<; @4 74A9 17<47:7A =:1731 I212@2<49; 3=:@A442E 4174 412 ?97A@7<43 17I2 8>6E=?2EJ3!7<E*A<6>E2>463165 4174 E2?2732E 17E 6:47A<2E ?2>4AFA?742 F>6@ =47< 79A4 797 717IAE1;797;77A?1=>737<>4A341A3?2>4AFA?742 ?927>9; 31653 4174 E2?2732E 573 7< >4A34 7<E 7 3KA992E 82>36<4127@6=<4FAJ2E=<E2>41217>48>287>2E:;412 7><747K747422B792>IA?23=416>A4;F6>4127??AE2<4 6F412;27>743*& A3A<>2382?46F=<3KA992E 97:6=><IA256F412F7?441742I2<A4A3?6<3AE2>2E4174 E2?2732E 573 ;27>3 12 A3 7< 2J82>A2<?2E >4A34 ??6>EA<B9; 412 A<?6@2 6=B14 46 17I2 :22< 47K2< 74 3& 82>@6<4173?97A@2E:;412?97A@7<43:2F6>2 - 8 - 412>A:=<797<E36=B144679965412788279:;EA3@A33A<B 412788279FA92E:;412<3=>7<?2?6@87<; 7IA<B 127>E 412 927><2E ?6=<329 F6> 412 87>4A2382>=32E:6417882798782>3735299734>A796=>4 >2?6>E41286A<4341747>A323F6>6=>?6<3AE2>74A6<7>2/ 12412> 412 ?6@82<374A6< 757>E2E :; 412 >A:=<79 A3 D=34AFA2E 6> 512412> 412 37@2 >2C=A>23 7<; A<42>F2>2<?2 74 412 17<E36F41A36=>4M 12412> 412 A<42>234 74 412 >742 6F !L 82> 7<<=@ 5A41 E2F7=94 A<42>234 6F L 82> 7<<=@ 757>E2E :; 412 >A:=<79 A3 3=347A<7:92A<975M ' =>7<352>3464127:6I286A<437>273=<E2>/ 6A<4 6/7>49;A<FFA>@74AI2 6A<4 6/< 2B74AI2F6>412F69965A<B/ - 9 - ! $2F6>2 E5299A<B 6< 86A<4 6 52 F229 A4 <2?2337>;46?6<3AE2>86A<4 6FA>3412>A:=<7951A92 B>7<4A<B?6@82<374A6<757>E2EA<42>23474412>7426F!L 82>7<<=@6<412?6@82<374A6<F>6@412E7426F824A46< 4A99A43>279AN74A6<5A41E2F7=94?97=326FLA<42>234AF412 757>E7@6=<4A3<64E2863A42E5A41A<456@6<413382> 412 324492E 863A4A6< 6F 975 :; 412 6<H:92 82J 6=>4 E2F7=94A<42>234A3<643=347A<7:92A<975 <41A386A<452 FA<E F6>?2 A< 412 7>B=@2<4 7EI7<?2E :; 412 927><2E ?6=<329 F6> 412 A<3=>7<?2 ?6@87<; ??6>EA<B9; 412 E2F7=94A<42>2346>E2>2EA3<643=347A<7:927<E>2C=A>2346 :232473AE2??6>EA<B9;A4A332473AE26F7>73A<42>234 74412>7426F!L82>7<<=@A3?6<?2><2E73<6@742>A79 A3897?2E:2F6>2412>A:=<7946322KF6>3=?17<2J42<46F A<42>234 2I2< 412 A<42>234 6< 412 FAJ2E E2863A4 8>2I7A92E E=>A<B412;27>A3<27>9;L46L12?6<3A342<?; A3 :797<?2E :;41A36=>4 73 5299 73 :; 412 6<H:9282J 6=>4 51A92 757>EA<B ?6@82<374A6< @7A<47A<A<B A<42>234 - 10 - O L 82> 7<<=@ < 412 7:32<?2 6F 2J?284A6<79 ?732 @7E2 6=4 :; 412 ?97A@7<43 73 5299 73 A< 412 7:32<?2 6F 7<;E6?=@2<4464122FF2?4412EA>2?4A6<6F412>A:=<7974 !L 82> 7<<=@ 6< 412 757>E 7@6=<4 A3 <64 3=347A<7:92 7<E37@2A3>2E=?2E46L82>7<<=@??6>EA<B9;86A<4 6 A3 7<352>2E A< 2B74AI2 7<E 7B7A<34 412 ?97A@7<43 7<EA<F7I6=>6F4127882997<4 <3=>7<?2?6@87<; "*+, 3 ?6=9E :2 322< F>6@ 412 4>A79 6=>4 >2?6>E3 897?2E :2F6>2 =3 412 E742 6F :A>41 6F E2?2732EA33165<73!'A<412@7>K3?7>E 74JF4174:236E2?2732E573;27>3736<412 E7426F7??AE2<451A?117E6??=>>2E6<*12 >A:=<79A<4128>232<?26F@7>K3?7>E>29A2E6<412 8634 @6>42@ >286>4 74 J 512>2A< 412 7B2 6F 412 E2?2732E5733165<73*;27>312>A:=<79173@A332E 412 @7>K3 ?7>E 51A?1 A3 7 8>66F 6F 7B2 7<E A3 7E@A33A:92 A< 2IAE2<?2 <E2> 41232 ?A>?=@347<?23 412 7B2 6F E2?2732E >2C=A>2E 46 :2 47K2< 73 ;27>3 73 6< 412E7426FE2741<41742I2<4=79A4;412@=94A89A2>7<E - 11 - 412F=4=>28>6382?43?6<3AE2>2E:;412>A:=<79>2C=A>2E46 :2>2E=?2E<IA256F4127B2:2A<B47K2<74;27>3 *L6F412A<?6@2A3>2C=A>2E46:27EE2E4657>E3F=4=>2 8>6382?437<E@=94A89A2>A346:247K2<17IA<B>2B7>E46 4127B26FE2?2732E 6F7>73412A<?6@2A3?6<?2><2E412>A:=<79 173 47K2< 412 A<?6@2 74 3*& 73 FAJ2E =<E2> 412 17>4 8>287>2E :; 412 7><747K7 4742 2B79 2>IA?23 =416>A4;4?7<<64:296343AB14417441237AEA<?6@2A3A< >2382?4 6F 7< =<3KA992E 97:6=> 12 ?97A@7<43 17I2 8>6E=?2E E6?=@2<43 46 3165 4174 412 E2?2732E B64 7 ?2>4AFA?742 F>6@ =47< 79A4 797 717IAE1;797;7 7A?1=> 73 7< >4A34 7<E 7 ?2>4AFA?742 F6> 17IA<B 87332E E>75A<B 7<E87A<4A<B?6<E=?42E:;41237AE 717IAE1;797;71A3 ?927>9; 31653 4174 E2?2732E 573 7 3KA992E 82>36< A< 412 F6>@6F7<>4A346>7<>4A34A<4127:32<?26F8>66F6F A<?6@2 412 A<?6@2 AF 47K2< 74 3& 82> E7; F6> 412 ;27> 412 37@2 56=9E @224 412 2<E3 6F D=34A?2 ??6>EA<B9;41237@2A3?6<3AE2>2E:;=3<IA256F412 - 12 - 37@2 3& 82> E7; AF 47K2< 73 A<?6@2 412 37@2 56=9E ?6@23 46 3'& 82> @6<41 16=B1 412 7882997<43&?97A@7<43 3=:@A442E 4174 412 A<?6@2 6F E2?2732E6=B144617I2:22<47K2<743& 8@ :=4 412; 17I2 <64 8>6E=?2E 7<; ?6B2<4 2IAE2<?2 46 3=:347<4A742 412A> ?97A@ 4174 E2?2732E 573 27><A<B 3& 82> @6<41 < 412 7:32<?2 6F 7<; A<?6@2 8>66FA<4128>232<?26F4122IAE2<?2417412A37<>4A34 412A<?6@234742E:;=33=8>7A37??6>EA<B9;47K2< 27><2E ?6=<329 F6> 412 7882997<43&?97A@7<43 173 F=>412> 3=:@A442E 4174 412 >A:=<79 173 <64 757>E2E L 23?7974A6< F>6@ 412 ;27> F6> 27?1 ?6@89242E 82>A6E6F41>22;27>36<412?6@82<374A6<757>E2E=<E2> 412?6<I2<4A6<79127E3127??AE2<4A<412?7326<17<E 6??=>>2E A< 412 ;27> 3 3=?1 412 7882997<43&?97A@7<43 7>2 2<4A492E F6> 6<2 42>@ 6F 41>22 ;27>3=<E2>412127EL23?7974A6<6<412?6<I2<4A6<79 127E3 < IA25 6F EAFF2>2<?2 6F A<?6@2 73 5299 73 L - 13 - 23?7974A6< 412 ?6@82<374A6< 757>E2E :; 412 >A:=<79 >2C=A>23>2 ?6<3AE2>74A6< <IA256F412A<?6@234742E7<E6<>2 E242>@A<74A6< 412 G633 6F 282<E2<?;H 56>K3 6=4 73 F699653/ 3'& P*LJJJ&41Q3'*& 382>412D=EB@2<46F4126<H:9282J6=>4 A< 412 ?732 6F 412?97A@7<437>22<4A492E463& 27?1 =<E2> 412 127E 6F G633 6F 6<36>4A=@ A9A79 6<36>4A=@ 7<E 7>2<479 6<36>4A=@H ??6>EA<B9; 412 7882997<43&?97A@7<43 7>2 2<4A492E F6> 7 3=@ 6F 3& #3 J % 4657>E3 633 F 6<36>4A=@ A<?9=EA<B 633 F A9A79 6<36>4A=@ 7<E 7>2<4796<36>4A=@H 1 - 14 - * =>412> 7 ?6@82<374A6< 6F 3*& 27?1 A3 757>E2E =<E2> 412 127E G633 F 34742H <E G=<2>79 2J82<323<E>7<386>474A6<H =>412>A<IA256F412D=EB@2<46F4126<H:92 82J 6=>4 A< 412 ?732 6F ! " # $% %412>231799:27<2<17<?2@2<46FL6<412 ?6<I2<4A6<79127E3F6>2I2>;41>22;27>3<412?7326< 17<E 412 7??AE2<4 6??=>>2E A< 12>2F6>2 412 ?97A@7<437>22<4A492EF6>L23?7974A6<6F41>22;27>3F6> 6<2 42>@ 6< 412 ?6<I2<4A6<79 127E3 A2 3!& #3 P * P *Q3! J L% 1=36<>2 E242>@A<74A6<7<E>2 ?6<3AE2>74A6< 412 7882997<43&?97A@7<43 7>2 2<4A492E F6> 46479 ?6@82<374A6<73F699653/ #% - 15 - -./0123-+0.,*+ 24+, 6336F282<E2<?; 3 '*& 6336F34742 3 *& 6336F=<2>79J82<323 3 *& 633 6F 6<36>4A=@ A9A79 6<36>4A=@ 7<E 7>2<479 6<36>4A=@#3J% 3 & L 23?7974A6< F6> 41>22 ?6@89242E ;27>3 6F 6<2 42>@ 6< ?6<I2<4A6<79 127E3 R3 P * P *JLS 3 !& 0 ( ' 12 46479 ?6@82<374A6< >2 E242>@A<2E :; 41A3 6=>4 56>K3 6=4 46 3& 73 7B7A<34 3'& 757>E2E :; 412 >A:=<79 12 >2 E242>@A<2E?6@82<374A6<31799?7>>;A<42>23474412>7426F L 82> 7<<=@ F>6@ 412 E742 6F FA9A<B 6F 412 824A4A6< 4A99 >279AN74A6<??6>EA<B9;86A<4 6A37<352>2E87>49;A< 7FFA>@74AI2 ! 6> 412 F6>2B6A<B >2736<3 41A3 6=>4 8>6?22E3 468733412F69965A<B/ - 16 - A% $64141278827937>2799652EA<87>4. AA% 12D=EB@2<47<E757>EE742E 87332E :; 412 EEA4A6<79 A34>A?4 7<E 233A6<3 (=EB2 7<E 7A?1=> A< 6&A312>2:;@6EAFA2E. AAA% 127882997<43&?97A@7<437>22<4A492EF6>7 46479 ?6@82<374A6< 6F 3& 73 7B7A<34 3'& 796<B 5A41 A<42>234 74L82>7<<=@F>6@412E7426FFA9A<B6F 412824A4A6<4A99>279AN74A6<. AI% 12 7@6=<4 A< E2863A4 :; 412 7882997<4 ) <3=>7<?2?6@87<;A< 6& :2 4>7<3@A442E 46 412 ?6<?2><2E >A:=<79 F6>415A41F6>EA3:=>32@2<4. I% 12 7882997<4 ) <3=>7<?2 ?6@87<; 31799 E2863A4 412 :797<?2 >2 E242>@A<2E ?6@82<374A6< 7@6=<4 796<B 5A41 7??>=2E - 17 - A<42>234 34742E :2F6>2 412 ?6<?2><2E >A:=<79 5A41A< 7 82>A6E 6F 3AJ 522K3 F>6@ 412E7426F>2?2A846F?68;6F41A36>E2>. IA% 886>4A6<@2<4 7<E EA3:=>32@2<4 A3 73 82> 4126>E2>6F412>A:=<79. IAA% 66>E2>7346?634 /( %" ' $ /( %' $ /7>7 637<E $/7>7 63462<E A34 6/9 6/ /(