- 1 - ! "# $ ## #%% &' &(& (( ) !"# $$ $ $% !& $ !"# & ' $ ! ! ( )$ $$ * Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $$ % $ $ $ ! "& $ $ $ !"& ( )$$$ + * $ ,)* )* $ "," ,, " $ $ - $ & ", $$ % $ )* !#)* #)* #)&* "& % #" "& &)*)* )* " %$$ % $$ - ) * ", $ - 3 - $ $ %$ $ . $# )$ . * /0 1220331456 70849 1::;60< =6 & 14< 1>0 70?=>0 5/86 =;>5 600@849 9>145 =? 7183 ;4<0> 0:58=4 ,)* =? 5/0 :/0<;30< 16506 14< :/0<;30< >8706 )>0A0458=4 =? 5>=:85806* B04<B045 :5 " )/0>0841?50> >0?0>>0< 5= 16 C5/0 :5- ?=> 6/=>5* 84 >8B0 = ",=? 14</8/=D@=38:05158=48E1F12;>1 >098650>0< ?=> 5/0 =??04:06 2;486/1730 ;4<0> 0:58=46 )* !# #)* "& > D #" =? 5/0 /1>158F1 F1F1 14/851"&)?=>6/=>5C"&-*14<0:58=4&)*)A* =?5/0:/0<;30<1650614<:/0<;30<>8706)>0A0458=4 =? 5>=:85806* B04<B045 :5 " 4=D 204<849 70?=>0 5/0301>40<<<3865>8:514<0668=46G20:813;<90 8E1F12;>18423160) *= ",=45/071686 - 4 - =? 5/0 ?8>65 84?=>B158=4 3=<90< 7F 84?=>B145>1@16/ 0384@0>8 /0 ?1:56 =? 5/0 :160 84 7>80? 1>0 5/15 5/0 84?=>B145>062=4<045 = ?830< 5/0 ?8>65 84?=>B158=4 =4 "!"!",D85/>1??8:=38:05158=48E1F12;>11918465 ;4@4=D4 20>6=46 13309849 :=BB8668=4 =? 5/0 =??04:0 2;486/1730;4<0>0:58=4!H=?5/04<814=5=>0/8:306 :514<;4<0>0:58=46")*14<!=?5/0"& 58665150<5/15=45/0A0>F<150D/045/0<0:0160<1A8 D162>=:00<849=4/86B=5=>:F:305/0<>=A0=?5/044=A1 :1> <>=A0 5/0 61B0 84 1 >16/ 14< 409389045 B1440> 14< <16/0<5=5/0/84<2=>58=4=?5/0B=5=>:F:30161>06;35=? D/8:/5/0>8<0>=?5/0B=5=>:F:30?033<=D4/0<>8A0>=? 5/0 1> /1< 4=5 65=220< 5/0 A0/8:30 7;5 =4 5/0 =5/0> /14< <>1990< 5/0 <0:0160< D85/ 5/0 A0/8:30 ?=> 6=B0 <86514:014<:1;60<5/01::8<04558665150<5/155/0>0 D0>0 5/>00 0F0D85406606 5= 5/0 84:8<045 14< 5/08> 65150B0456 D0>0 136= >0:=><0< 7F 5/0 4A0658915849 ??8:0> - 5 - 4 "!", 5/0 84?=>B145 ?830< 5/0 60:=4< 84?=>B158=4 D85/ 5/0 14</8 /=D@ =38:0 5158=4 8E1F12;>119184655/01::;60<=614<=5/0>613309849 5/0 :=BB8668=4 =? 5/0 =??04:02;486/1730 ;4<0> 0:58=46 "&=?"&/084>8B0= ",:1B05= 70 >098650>0< 14< 5/0 84A06589158=4 D16 ;4<0>51@04 5 86 65150< 5/15 <;>849 5/0 84A06589158=4 1::;60< = D16 122>0/04<0<14<=45/071686=?/8665150B045122033145 =6 14< D0>0 136= 122>0/04<0< =4 &"!", 14< 122033145 =& D16 122>0/04<0< =4 "!", ?50> 122>0/04<849 5/0 1220331456 ?;>5/0> 65150B0456 =? 5/0 0F0D85406606 D/= 1>0 :850< 16 %6! 5= " D0>0 >0:=><0< 1::=><849 5= D/8:/ 5/0 0F0D85406606 618< 5= /1A08<0458?80<1335/06012203314565=651505/151::;60< =D16<>8A8495/0:1>84I;0658=41::;60<=6&14< D0>05/084B1506=?5/0:1>155/058B0=?1::8<045586 65150<5/151::;60<=/1<:1B05=5/02=38:065158=484 5/0 A0>F 61B0 =??04<849 :1> 14< 5/0 61B0 D16 608J0< D/04 85 D16 21>@0< 84 ?>=45 =? 5/0 2=38:0 65158=4 /0 - 6 - 4A0658915849 ??8:0> 1?50> :=4<;:5849 84A06589158=4 ?830< 5/0 :/1>90 6/005 1918465 1::;60< =6 5= =D 5/0 B1550>86204<849?=>5>81370?=>05/0>813=;>5 & $01>< >8 /1B ;4<1> 301>40< 048=> =;460312201>849?=>>81KB8@145/ 301>40<:=;4603 ?=> 5/0 1220331456 14< >8 1B1<1> /1/17;<<84 301>40< $89/ =;>5 =A0>4B045 301<0> ?=> >062=4<045 = 5150 062=4<045 = 5/=;9/ 60>A0< /16 >0B1840< ;4>02>060450<0>;60<5/0B150>8136=4>0:=>< , 4 A80D =? 5/0 >8A13 :=450458=46 ;>90< 7F 5/0 301>40<:=;4603?=>7=5/5/021>58065/02=8455/15D=;3< 1>860?=>BF:=468<0>158=486 !! " #$%&' F 146D0> 5= 5/0 17=A0 2=845 86 84 5/0 C??8>B158A0-?=>5/0?=33=D849 - 7 - /0 ?1:56 41>>150< 17=A0 <86:3=606 5/15 5/0 84?=>B145?830<5/084?=>B158=4=4"!"!",80=45/0 A0>F <150 =? 5/0 1::8<045 D85/ >1??8: =38:0 5158=4 8E1F12;>1 1918465 ;4@4=D4 20>6=46 13309849 5/0 >=1< 5>1??8:1::8<045D/8:/>06;350<845/0<015/=?/867>=5/0> /0 65150B0456 =? %6! 5= " D0>0 >0:=><0< D/8:/ <028:565/1514;4@4=D420>6=4/1<<>8A045/0A0/8:3084 1>16/14<409389045B1440>14</855/0B=5=>:F:30=?5/0 <0:0160<?>=B70/84<2=>58=4=4D/8://0D162>=:00<849 14< :1;60< 5/0 1::8<045 ;760I;0453F =4 "!", 5/0 84?=>B145 ?830< 5/0 60:=4< 84?=>B158=4 D/8:/ D16 >098650>0< 84 >8B0 = ", 1918465 1::;60< =6 14< =5/0>6 ?=> /1A849 :=BB8550< 5/0 =??04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0> 0:58=4 "& =? "& 1918465 5/0B 5 86 5/0>01?50> 1::;60< = D16 122>0/04<0< 14< =4 5/0 71686 =? /86 65150B045 5/0 1220331456 D0>0 136= 122>0/04<0< - 8 - H 5 86 20>584045 5= 4=50 5/15 1?50> 122>0/04<849 5/06012203314565/0?;>5/0>65150B0456=?%6!5=" :1B05=70>0:=><0<::=><8495=5/0?;>5/0>65150B0456 5/0 0F0D85406606 1>0 618< 5= /1A0 8<0458?80< 1::;60< =6&14<D/=1>05/01220331456/0>08470849<>8A0> 14<5/084B1506=?:1>84I;0658=4155/058B0=?1::8<045 ! 6 20> 5/0 84?=>B145 84 >8B0 = ", 5/0>0 D16 14 01>380> 84:8<045 D/0>0 1::;60< = 14< =5/0>6/1A0/;B838150<5/0<0:0160<D/=D1612>1:58:849 <A=:150 84 5/0 =;>5 2>0B8606 15 8E1F12;>1 ;760I;0453F 5/0 84?=>B145 13=49 D85/ /86 7>=5/0> I;0658=40<5/0/89//14<0<1:56=?5/01::;60<14<5/15 D165/0B=58A0?=>5/01::;60<5=:1;605/0<015/=?5/0 <0:0160< /0 1::;60< /1< :=4628>0< 5=905/0> 5= :1;60 5/0<015/=?5/0<0:0160<14<840K0:;58=4=?5/061B0 1::;60< = <>=A0 5/0 :1> 84 I;0658=4 D/8:/ D16 =::;280<7F1::;60<=6&14<14<<03870>1503F/855/0 B=5=>:F:30?>=B70/84<D/8:/>06;350<845/0<015/=?5/0 <0:0160<D/=D165/0>8<0>=?5/0B=5=>:F:30 - 9 - # 5 86 20>584045 5= 4=50 5/15 0A04 5/=;9/ 5/0 0F0D85406606 D/= 1>0 4=D 6850< 16 %6! 5= " /1A0 65150< 5/15 14 ;4@4=D4 20>6=4 D16 <>8A849 5/0 :1> 84 I;0658=4155/058B0=?1::8<04514<5/0F:148<0458?F/8B 4= 5065 8<0458?8:158=4 21>1<0 D16 :=4<;:50< 7F 5/0 4A0658915849 ??8:0> 5= :=4?8>B 5/15 /0 86 2>=:00<849 84 5/0>89/5<8>0:58=484122>0/04<8495/01::;60<5>14903F 5/06012203314561>0618<5=/1A070046/=D45=%6! 5= " 14< 16@0< 5/0B 5= 8<0458?F 5/0B 84 5/0 2=38:0 65158=4 6 1 >06;35 5/0 0F0D85406606%6! 5= " 1>0 618< 5= /1A0 8<0458?80< 1::;60< = 16 5/0 <>8A0> =? 5/0 =??04<849A0/8:3014<1::;60<=6&14<165/084B1506 =?5/0:1>/;61<B8550<3F5/04A0658915849 ??8:0>/16 4=5:=4<;:50<5/050658<0458?8:158=421>1<0841::=><14:0 D85/ 31D 5= 041730 5/0 0F0D85406606 5= 8<0458?F 5/0 1::;60< 5 5/86 65190 8<0458?8:158=4 =? 5/0 1220331456 7F %6!5="845/02=38:065158=4:144=5701::0250<161 :8>:;B6514:0 0A8<04:0 5= :=440:5 5/0B 5= 5/0 =??04:0 84 I;0658=4 - 10 - " /0 60:=4< :8>:;B6514:0 >0380< =4 7F 5/0 2>=60:;58=4 5= :=440:5 5/060 1220331456 5= 5/0 =??04:0 84 I;0658=4865/0608J;>0=?5/0=??04<84944=A1:1>7>=;9/5 7F1::;60<=14<21>@0<84?>=45=?5/02=38:065158=4 58665150<5/15%865/0=D40>=?5/0=??04<849:1> 14<5/061B0D167>=;9/57F1::;60<=D/04/0D16 :=B849 5= 5/0 2=38:0 65158=4 5 5/86 65190 85 86 /1>< 5= 70380A05/151::;60<=:1B05=5/02=38:065158=4845/0 A0>F61B0=??04<849A0/8:3014<21>@0<8584?>=45=?5/0 2=38:0 65158=4 =4 &"!", D85/ 5/0 73==< 651846 ?=;4< =4 856 7=<F 0A04 1?50> 31260 =? ?8A0 <1F6 $=D0A0> 5/0 2>=60:;58=4 D833 /1A0 5= 2>=A0 856 :=450458=4 70?=>0 5/0 >813 =;>5 7F 1<<;:849 0A8<04:0 84 5/15 >091>< 5 5/86 6519085866;??8:05=61F5/155/0>01>04=65>=49 ! B150>8136 5= <05184 5/0 1220331456 84 :;65=<F <B8550<3F 5/0 84A06589158=4 86 :=B23050< 14< :/1>90 6/00586?830<4<0>6;:/:8>:;B6514:06?84<4=>016=4 5=<051845/0122033145684:;65=<F016=41730:=4<858=46 B1F 70 8B2=60< D/830 0431>9849 5/0 1220331456 =4 7183 - 11 - D/8:/ D833 51@0 :1>0 =? 5/0 8450>065 =? 5/0 2>=60:;58=4 16 D033168450>065=?5/0:=B2318414514<5/0D85406606 /1A0 9=40 5/>=;9/ 5/0 8B2;940< =><0> 21660<7F5/0>813=;>5>0E0:58495/07183205858=46?830< 7F 5/0 1220331456 /0 >813 =;>5 12201>6 5= /1A0 7004 6D1F0<1D1F7F5/060>8=;613309158=46B1<019184655/0 12203314565=<04F5/08>:318B?=>71835/164=51668940< 14F:=9045>016=46?=><04F8495/0718314<<051840<5/0B 84 :;65=<F 0A04 1?50> ?83849 =? 5/0 :/1>90 6/005 4<0> 6;:/:8>:;B6514:061B=?5/0=2848=45/155/08B2;940< =><0>21660<7F5/0>813=;>5>0E0:58495/0:318B=?5/0 1220331456?=>7183/165=70605168<0 ::=><8493F 146D0> 5/0 17=A0 2=845 84 5/0 1??8>B158A014<2>=:00<5=21665/0?=33=D849 8* /012201386 88* /0 1220331456 1>0 =><0>0<5= 70 0431>90< =4 7183 84 >8B0 = ", =? 14</8 /=D@ =38:05158=4=4=751848495/07=4<68416;B - 12 - =? 6""""" );2006 D= 1@/6 =43F* 01:/D85/5D=6;>0580601:/?=>5/038@06;B5= 5/0 61586?1:58=4 =? 5/0 E;>86<8:58=413 =;>5 6;7E0:55=5/0?=33=D849:=4<858=46 1* /0 1220331456 6/133 4=5 :=BB85 68B831> =??04:06 7* /012203314566/1334=55/>01504=>51B20> D85/5/02>=60:;58=4D85406606 :* /012203314566/13312201>70?=>05/0=;>5 1614<D/04>0I;8>0< 888* ? 84 :160 5/0 1220331456 A8=3150 14F =? 5/0 :=4<858=46 16 65150< 17=A0 5/0 2>=60:;58=4 D833 70 15 3870>5F 5= B=A0 5/0 >813 =;>5 600@849:14:033158=4=?7183 8A* 4 ?;>486/849 5/0 6;>05806 7F 5/0 1220331456 5/0 >813 =;>5 86 15 3870>5F 5= <8>0:5 5/0 4A0658915849 ??8:0> 5= A0>8?F 5/0 :=>>0:54066 =? 5/0 1<<>066 14< 1;5/0458:85F =? 5/0 - 13 - <=:;B0456?;>486/0<7F5/012203314514<5/0 6;>0580614<1>02=>5B1F70:1330<?=>845/15 >091>< D/8:/ 86 5= 70 6;7B8550< 7F 5/0 4A0658915849 ??8:0> D85/84 <1F6 /0 >813 =;>5 =4 61586?1:58=4 B1F 2>=:00< 5= 1::025 5/0 6;>05806 ?=> 5/0 2;>2=60 =? >03016849 5/0 1220331456=47183 *' &##( $ 865=3=,