- 1 - !"#$ %#& # # '( ! " " #$! % #&'&!$! ( #&'&!$% #&'&($% Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) " %% %%* " " " %# !$#$!#%$%( +#") )" !*& * % " %$!() ", " " ) - ./0/012.3456078/19./:.1;2.31<6=304>5/>365562? 9.6302= @1!*& * 7.68>302= % 643.8 80/>6/.? 6/ 0556=. 6220A.36 :0//6B>3 65>A 6569>36=0 08/304/ :6C02= B>34:68.? /:. 867. <317 0/8 B3.C01>8 1;2.3 02 /.3781<?..?1<865.?6/.?%'$'%$!%./0/012.3456078 /:6/ :08 267. ;68 7>/6/.? 02 /:. 3.C.2>. 3.413?8 C0?. >/6/0121!%62?<13/:.@.63%$!#!&62?/:6/ :.;6802B.64.<>5B188.8801262?.2D1@7.2/1</:.867. - 3 - 1;.C.3 ?>302= /:. @.63 %$%%#%( /:. 267. 1< /:. 6326/6A61C.327.2/;68.2/.3.?02/1026/415>72 18E62?!%C0?.1#!?6/.?$'$E%$%% % >98.F>.2/5@ 0/ ;68 5.632/ 9@ /:. B./0/012.3 /:6/ 3.8B12?.2/ 1 % # .B>/@ 177088012.3 02 B>3B13/.? .G.3408. 1< /:. B1;.38 412<.33.? >2?.3 .4/012 (' 1< /:. 6326/6A6 62? .<1378 4/ !E! H:.3.026</.33.<.33.?/168/:.I4/!E!J<1393.C0/@K:6? 088>.? 6 1/0<046/012 02 "137 1% 8>9#3>5. ( 1< >5. E ?6/.?!$$!%$%(21/0<@02=/:.562?802 @1!*& * 7.68>302=%643.868L>23.413?.?:690/6/012M:02=8?0? 21/ 8/1B 6/ /:6/ 6C02= .2/.3.? 81 3.8B12?.2/ 1 # 6:6805?63:68=12.6:.6?026551//02=B13/01281</:.860? B31B.3/@/1/:03?B63/0.862?:68088>.?4.3/0<046/.8;11< /:.4.3/0<046/.8B31?>4.?6/22.G>3.8#62?!02?046/. /:6/ 62 .G/.2/ 1< !&*& 8F>63. <../ :68 9..2 6551//.? 02 <6C1>31<4.3/602 :0C6A>76362?621/:.3.G/.2/1<($$ 8F>63. <../ :68 9..2 6551//.? 02 <6C1>3 1< 4.3/602 - 4 - 62036/:26./0/012.345607.?/:6/8070563.G/.2/81<562?8 :6C.9..26551//.?/1C6301>81/:.3B.38128 ( .632.? 41>28.5 <13 /:. B./0/012.3 /6A02= /:08 1>3/ /:31>=: /:. 3.413?8 8>970/8 /:6/ ;:.2 /:. B./0/012.3B>34:68.?/:.B31B.3/@02/.3781</:.?..?1< 865.62?:08267.9.02=3.<5.4/.?02/:.3.C.2>.3.413?8 /:. 3.8B12?.2/ # /6/. 1>=:/ 21/ /1 :6C. 21/0<@ :08 B31B.3/@>2?.3 .4/012('1</:.4/!E!?.456302=0/ /1 9. /:. L>23.413?.? :690/6/012M 62? <>3/:.3 8/63/ 6551//02= /:. B31B.3/@ 02?084307026/.5@ /1 B.38128 1< /:.03 4:104..8>970/8/:6/6//:.<038/028/624./:. /6/.:6? 216>/:130/@/1055.=655@21/0<@?.B30C02=/:.B31B.3/@30=:/8 1< /:. B./0/012.3 =>6362/..? >2?.3 3/045. ($$ 1< /:. 128/0/>/012 .412?5@.C.20<62@8>4:64/012;68/6A.2 ;0/:1>/B6@02=/:.417B.286/01202/:.7622.3A21;2/1 56;/:.@41>5?21/:6C.B314..?.?/16551//:.B31B.3/0.8 02?084307026/.5@ 02 <6C1>3 1< /:03? B63/0.8 . 6581 3608.8 /:.F>.8/01268/1/:.7622.302;:04:/:.860?6551/7.2/8 :6C. 9..2 76?. :.3.<13. :. 8>970/8 /:6/ 13?.3 6/ - 5 - 22.G>3.#" 9. F>68:.? 13 02 /:. 65/.326/. 6 ;30/ 02 /:. 26/>3. 1< 762?67>8 9. 088>.? /1 /:. 3.8B12?.2/ # 6>/:130/0.8/164F>03./:.562?9.512=02=/1/:.B./0/012.3 02/:.7622.3A21;2/156;62?/1B6@/:.417B.286/012 >2?.3/:.B3.C65.2/B31C0801281<56;3.=63?02=64F>080/012 1<562? .632.? ??0/01265 1C.327.2/ ?C146/. /6A02= 21/04. <13 /:. 3.8B12?.2/8 02 3.8B128. <6035@ 8>970/8 /:6/ 2.0/:.3 62@ 64F>080/012 B314..?02=8 :6C. 020/06/.?213/:.417B.286/012:689..2B60?1;.C.3:. B102/8 1>/ /1 8>9#8.4/012 ( 1< .4/012 (' 1< /:. 4/ !E!62?8>970/8/:6//:.3.086B31C08012<13B6@7.2/1< 417B.286/012 62? 30=:/8 1< /:. B./0/012.3 0< 62@ ;055 9. 41280?.3.? & .63?.3>8.?/:.3.413?8 :081>3/:6821/04.?<5>33@1<B./0/01281</:08 26/>3.;:.3.02/:.3.8B12?.2/N /6/.>2?.3/:.=6391< .G.340802=B1;.3>2?.3 .4/012('1</:.4/!E!:68 - 6 - 9..221/0<@02=/:.B31B.3/0.8;:04:63.>2?.3/:.B30C6/. 1;2.38:0B 8>BB13/.? 9@ /:. ?..?8 1< 865. 62? 3.C.2>. 3.413?8 62? :68 /:.3.6</.3 B314..?.? /1 ?08/309>/. /:. 867.02?084307026/.5@ * 31C0801281< .4/012('1</:.6326/6A662? .<1378 4/ !E! 3.6? ;0/: >5. E /1 E 1< /:. 6326/6A6 62? .C.2>. >5.8 !E* .569136/.5@ 8./#1>/ /:.B314.?>3.<13088>02==362/4.3/0<046/.1<1;2.38:0B/1 /:.6=304>5/>3655691>3.38 ' .3>865 1< /:. 21/0<046/012 6/ 22.G>3.#" 02?046/.8/:6//:.?.45636/0121<562?80245>?02=/:.562?1< /:. B./0/012.3 08 8:1;2 68 >23.413?.? :690/6/012 <65502= ;0/:02 67626@6A6 :62?6 6220A.36 7.3.5@ 12 /:. 968081<63.B13/8>970//.?9@/:.8808/62/177088012.3 .?67 22.G>3.#" <>3/:.3 02?046/.8 /:6/ 21 21/04. 1< B314..?02=8:6C.9..2020/06/.?9.<13.088>02=/:.867. E :.3.413?88>970//.?9@/:.B./0/012.3B31?>4. 6/22.G>3.8#/102?046/./:./0/5.1</:.B./0/012.362? - 7 - /:6/ /:. 267. 1< /:. B./0/012.3 :68 412/02>.? 02 /:. 3.C.2>.3.413?8 !$ :. 1#13?026/..24: 1< /:08 1>3/ >2?.3 /:. 8070563 4034>78/624.8 02 0/8 13?.3 ?6/.? %'$%%$%& B688.? 02 02 /:. 468. 1< :6? F>68:.? 8070563 21/0<046/012 ?03.4/02= /:. .B>/@ 177088012.3 /1 C.30<@ /:. 3.C.2>. 3.413?8 62? /:.3.6</.3 /1 B688 6BB31B306/. 13?.3 ;0/: 509.3/@ 02 /:. .C.2/ 1< .B>/@ 177088012.3 41702= /1 /:. 41245>8012 /:6/ /:. 562?8 3.F>03.? <13 B>9504 B>3B18. /1 020/06/. 64F>080/012B314..?02=80264413?624.;0/:6BB504695.56; 0705635@/:081>3//6A02=21/.1</:.6<13.860?13?.31< /:. 113?026/. .24: 9@ )*+) *,-+* !!!! B688.? 02 ! . :6? F>68:.? /:. 07B>=2.? 21/0<046/012 ?03.4/02= /:. 3.8B12?.2/8 /1 41280?.3/:.3.B3.8.2/6/0121<B./0/012.362?6</.3.2F>03@ 0< 0/ ;68 <1>2? /:. B./0/012.3 08 02?..? /:. 1;2.3 62? - 8 - B188.88131</:.562?/13.8/13.:08267.02/:.3.C.2>. 3.413?8 !! ):.2 /:. B./0/012.3 6?70//.?5@ 64F>03.? /:. B31B.3/@ 02 /.378 1< ?..? 1< 865. 62? :08 267. :6C02= 9..2 7>/.? 02 /:. 3.C.2>.3.413?8 91/: 1< ;:04: <655 02 /:. 46/.=13@ 1< B>9504 ?14>7.2/8 0/ 08 68/1208:02= 68 /1 :1;/:.3.8B12?.2/#6>/:130/0.8:6C.?.4563.?/:.867. /19./:.>23.413?.?:690/6/012;0/:1>/62@.2F>03@:. 5.68//:6/41>5?:6C.9..2?12.;68/1C.30<@/:.3.C.2>. 3.413?8 ;:04: 63. 6C605695. 02 /:. C.3@ 1<<04. 1< 3.8B12?.2/18%(62?;:163./:.4>8/1?06281</:. 860? 3.C.2>. 3.413?8 :. ?14>7.2/8 B31?>4.? 6/ 22.G>3.# /1 /:. ;30/ B./0/012 08 6 ?..? 1< 865. ?6/.? %'$'%$!% 02 /.378 1< ;:04: /:. B./0/012.3 45607.? /1 :6C. B>34:68.? /:. B31B.3/@ 3.=08/36/012 1< 6 ?..? 1< 865. 08 6 21/04. /1 /:. B>9504 6/ 563=. 14>7.2/ 6/ 22.G>3.#08/:.7>/6/0123.=08/.31</:.@.63%$!%#%$!( 02/.3781<;:04:/:.267.1</:.B./0/012.3;687>/6/.? C0?. 1!% /1 /:. .G/.2/ 1< % 643.8 1< 562? 02 - 9 - @1!*& O * 22.G>3.# 08 /:. .G/364/ 3.<5.4/02= /:.267.1</:.B./0/012.391/:02415>7218E62?!% 62? /:. /362864/012 1< 865. 08 3.<5.4/.? 02 415>72 1!$ :08 9.02= /:.B>9504 3.413?6C605695.6/ /:. 1<<04. 1< /:. 3.8B12?.2/8 62? 7602/602.? 9@ /:.78.5C.8 0/ 08 >2D>8/0<0695. /1 412/.2? /:6/ /:.@ 63. 21/ 6;63. 1< 8>4: B>95043.413?862?/1?.4563./:.B31B.3/@9.512=02=/1/:. B./0/012.3/19.L>23.413?.?:690/6/012M !% 8 653.6?@ 21/.? /:. <>3/:.3 64/ 1< /:. ?08B.286/012 02 6551//02= /:. B13/0128 1< /:. B31B.3/@ 81 ?.4563.? 659.0/ ;0/:1>/ <1551;02= 62@ B31C080128 1< 56; ;:04: 08 @./ 621/:.3 714A.3@ 1< /:. B31C080128 1< .4/012('1</:.4/1<!E!3.6?;0/:>5.E/1E1< /:.6326/6A662?.<1378>5.8!E* !( ./0/01208/:.3.<13.22.G>3.#"?6/.? !$$!%$%( 08 F>68:.? /1 /:. .G/.2/ 1< /:. B31B.3/@ 9.6302= @1!*& *7.68>302=%643.880/>6/.?6/C0556=. 6220A.36 65>A :0//6B>3 08/304/ 6569>36=0 128.F>.2/ /:.3.>B12 62@ 6551/7.2/8 76?. <317 /:. - 10 - B31B.3/@ 9.512=02= /1 /:. B./0/012.3 ;055 :6C. 21 4128.F>.24.8 / 08 :1;.C.3 76?. 45.63 /:6/ 8:1>5? /:. 3.8B12?.2/ # /6/. 02/.2? /1 >/0508. /:. 562? 1< /:. B./0/012.3 /:.@ 8:655 8/304/5@ <1551; /:. B31C080128 1< 56; B31C0?.?<1364F>080/01262?B6@7.2/1<417B.286/01262? 417B5././:.B314.881<64F>080/012;0/:02/:./07.91>2? 7622.3 ! 177>2046/. /:. 41B@ 1< /:08 13?.3 /1 655 /:. 3.8B12?.2/8<13/:.03B.3>86562?2.4.8863@64/012 *. '# #( & ) 08/1! 51!(