- 1 - !" #!$!! !% &'(&)*+( &** , ! " # ! " $ # %& # ' $ ' $ &( ' $ (( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ' '$# $ # # )$ $ *$'$$ ! *$'$$" +, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- 5,/26 4+, 78890,: /2 1(( 12 4+, ;/<, 1; 4+, <,7-2,: ::/4/127< /./< '9:6, 72: '$# <72: =;1- 0+1-4 >-/7< 19-4?@ /0 /A3962/264+,B9:6A,241;812./84/1272:1-:,-0,24,28, :74,: ( 812./84/26 +/A ;1- 4+, 1;;,28, 392/0+75<, 92:,- ,84/12 C% 1; 2:/72 ,27< 1:, =;1- 0+1-4 > ?@ 72: 0,24,28/26 41 92:,-61 0/A3<, /A3-/012A,24;1-73,-/1:1;4D1E,7-072:737E;/2,1; 0 /2 :,;79<4 41 37E ;/2, 92:,-61 0/A3<, /A3-/012A,24 ;1- 0/F A124+0G 812./84/26 ;1- 4+, 1;;,28, 392/0+75<, 92:,- ,84/12 H 1; 72: 0,24,28/26 41 92:,-610/A3<,/A3-/012A,24;1-73,-/1:1;(E,7-72: 7 37E ;/2, 1; 0( /2 :,;79<4 41 92:,-61 0/A3<, - 3 - /A3-/012A,24;1-4D1A124+0D+/8+/0812;/-A,:/2-< 1&( 12 4+, ;/<, 1; 4+, ::/4/127< /04-/84 72: ,00/120 '9:6, 7<759-76/ =;1- 0+1-4 >#/-04 33,<<74, 19-4?@ #78401;4+,870,/25-/,;7-,4+744+,/2;1-A724 /04+,D/;,1;4+,78890,:+,/0,F7A/2,:70 )+, +70 8124,2:,: 4+74 4+,/- A7--/76, D70 3,-;1-A,: 12 ( ;4,- A7--/76, ) D,24 72: 047-4,: -,0/:/26 D/4+ 78890,: /2 +,- A74-/A12/7< +190, ) <1:6,: 4+, ;/-04 /2;1-A74/12 12 ((( 767/204 4+, 78890,: 7<<,6/26 4+74 4+, 78890,: 92:,- 4+, /2;<9,28, 1; 7<81+1< 90,: 41 7590, 72: 70079<4 +,- .,-E ;-,I9,24<E ;4,-01A,4/A,0+,/2;1-A,:4+/0;78441+,-37-,240 )0C 72: D+1 812.,2,: 4+, 3728+7E74 1; ,<:,-0 .,2 4+196+ ,<:,-0 +7., 7:./0,: 4+, 78890,: 41 5,+7<; 3-13,-<E+,8124/29,:+/0A/05,+7./1-D/4+4+,/2;1-A724 72:4-,74,:+,-D/4+8-9,<4E4/00474,:4+74124+,:74, 1; /28/:,24 4+, 78890,: 7590,: 4+, /2;1-A724 /2 ;/<4+E <726976, 72: 8-/A/27<<E /24/A/:74,: 41 8790, +,- :,74+ - 4 - +,D70;1-8,:4161578J41+,-37-,240+190,,28, 0+, <1:6, 4+, 81A3<7/24 72: -,I9,04,: 4+, 1</8, 41 -,6/04,-4+,870,72:/2.,04/674,4+,A744,-+,#D70 -,6/04,-,: 2.,04/674/12 D70 81A3<,4,: +, 8+7-6, 0+,,487A,415,;/<,:+,78890,:733,7-,:5,;1-,4+, -/7< 19-4 3<,7:,: 214 69/<4E ;1- 4+, 8+7-6,0 <,.,<,: 767/204 +/A -10,894/12 ,F7A/2,: )0( 41 614 A7-J,:F0 (41 413-1.,/408124,24/12+,78890,: +70:,2/,:7<</28-/A/274/26A74,-/7<07.7/<75<,12-,81-: 594+70214<,:72E,./:,28,/209331-41;+/0:,;,28, +, -/7< 19-4 7;4,- 47J/26 /241 8120/:,-74/12 7<<4+,0,A74,-/7<012-,81-:87A,414+,8128<90/124+74 4+, 3-10,894/12 /0 0988,00;9< /2 3-1./26 4+, 69/<4 1; 4+, 78890,: 5,E12: -,701275<, :1954 881-:/26<E 4+, /A3962,: B9:6A,24 1; 812./84/12 72: 1-:,- 1; 0,24,28, 87A,415,3700,: C ,/26766-/,.,:5E4+,07A,4+,78890,:+70 3-,;,--,: -/A/27< 33,7< 1&( 12 4+, ;/<, 1; 4+, #/-04 33,<<74, 19-4 +, ;/-04 33,<<74, 12 -, - 5 - 733-,8/74/12 1; ,24/-, A74,-/7< 7.7/<75<, 12 -,81-: +70 :/0A/00,:4+,733,7<5E812;/-A/26B9:6A,241;812./84/12 72: 1-:,- 1; 0,24,28, 3700,: 5E 4+, -/7< 19-4 ,/26 766-/,.,: 5E 4+, 07A, 4+, 78890,:733,<<724 /0 5,;1-, 4+/019-4 ,7-: -/ 707.7</26 70/ <,7-2,: 81920,< ;1- 4+,-,./0/123,4/4/12,-72:-/137<J-/0+277:7.<,7-2,: /6+19-41.,-2A,24 <,7:,-;1-4+,-,0312:,24474, ,-90,:4+,A74,-/7<012-,81-: H 2 ./,D 1; 4+, -/.7< 8124,24/120 9-6,: 5E 4+, <,7-2,:81920,<0;1-514+4+,37-4/,04+,31/244+74D19<: 7-/0,;1-AE8120/:,-74/12/0 - 6 - $E 720D,- 41 4+, 751., 31/24 /0 ;1-4+,;1<<1D/26 & 4/04+,8124,24/121;4+,3-10,894/124+74 ) /0 4+, D/;, 1; 4+, 78890,: 72: 4+,/- A7--/76, D70 3,-;1-A,: 12 ( ;4,- A7--/76, 0+, D70 -,0/:/26/2+,-A74-/A12/7<+190,7<126D/4+4+,78890,: +,0, ;7840 7-, 7:A/44,: 5E 4+, 78890,: 4 /0 4+, 8124,24/12 1; ) 4+74 0+, D70 5,/26 7590,: 72: 70079<4,: 5E 4+, 78890,: .,-E ;-,I9,24<E 0+, +7: 7<01 8-/A/27<<E /24/A/:74,: 41 8790, +,- :,74+ ) +70 :,310,: 5,;1-, 4+, 19-4 -,67-:/26 4+, /28/:,24 .,2 4+196+ 0+, D70 095B,84,: 41 8-100,F7A/274/12 214+/26 +705,,2,</8/4,:41:/05,</,.,+,-.,-0/12 )0C72: 7-, 4+, 37-,240 1; ) +,E +7., 7<01 :,310,: /2 09331-4 1; 870, 1; 4+, 3-10,894/12 72: 0474,: 4+74 4+,E +7.,7--726,:3728+7E74417:./8,4+,78890,:/203/4,1; 4+74 +, +70 214 81--,84,: +/A0,<; .,2 :9-/26 8-100 ,F7A/274/121;4+,0,D/42,00,0214+/26+705,,2,</8/4,: - 7 - 2:,- 098+ 8/-89A04728,0 7A 1; 4+, 13/2/12 4+74 4+, 3-10,894/12 /0 0988,00;9< /2 3-1./26 4+, 69/<4 1; 4+, 78890,: 5,E12: -,701275<, :1954 72: +, /0 </75<, ;1- 812./84/12 ,7-2,: 81920,< ;1- 4+, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- 8124,2:0 4+74 4+, -/7< 19-4 /A310,: 0/A3<, /A3-/012A,24;1-4D1E,7-0;1-4+,1;;,28,92:,-,84/12 C% 1; 72: 12, E,7- ;1- 4+, 1;;,28, 92:,- ,84/12 H 1; D+/8+ /0 :/03-131-4/1274, 41 4+, 1;;,28, /2 I9,04/12,28,+,3-7E0;1-0+1D/26<,2/,28E/2;7.19- 1;4+,-,./0/123,4/4/12,-78890,: % ,7-2,: /6+ 19-4 1.,-2A,24 <,7:,- ,.,2 4+196+13310,:098+095A/00/12095A/44,:4+74/4/0<,;4 41 4+, :/08-,4/12 1; 4+, 19-4 D+/8+ 872 5, ,F8/0,: /40 B9:/8/190A/2: ( 2 3,-907< 1; 4+, -,81-:0 /4 /0 8<,7- 4+74 4+, A7--/76,1;4+,37-4/,03,-;1-A,:12( -,0,24 81A3<7/24 87A, 41 5, ;/<,: 12 ((( 4 /0 0474,: - 8 - 4+744+,78890,:D70/2B9:/8/7<89041:E;1-73,-/1:1;(K A124+0 :9-/264-/7< :1 214 ;/2: 72E -,701241 /A310, A7F/A9A 0,24,28, 41 4+, 78890,: 2:,- 098+ 8/-89A04728,0 7A 1; 4+, 13/2/12 4+74 4+, /A3962,: 1-:,- 1; 0,24,28, A7E 5, A1:/;/,: /2 4+, /24,-,04 1; B904/8, 881-:/26<E 720D,- 4+, 751., 31/24 37-4<E /2 4+,7;;/-A74/.,72:3-18,,:4137004+,;1<<1D/26 (i) +, -/A/27<,./0/12 ,4/4/12 /0 (ii) +, /A3962,: B9:6A,24 1; 812./84/12 :74,: ( 3700,: 5E 4+, -/7< 19-4 812./84/26 4+, 78890,: ;1- 4+, 1;;,28,0 392/0+75<,92:,-,84/120C%72:H1; /0+,-,5E812;/-A,: (iii) +,1-:,-1;0,24,28,3700,:5E4+,-/7< 19-4/0A1:/;/,:7092:,- - 9 - 7" +, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- /0 0,24,28,: 41 92:,-610/A3<,/A3-/012A,24;1-73,-/1: 1;C:7E072:4137E;/2,1;0( ;1- 4+, 1;;,28, 392/0+75<, 92:,- ,84/12 C%1; 72:/2:,;79<44137E;/2,+, 0+7<< 92:,-61 0/A3<, /A3-/012A,24 ;1- 12,A124+ 5" +, 78890,: /0 0,24,28,: 41 37E ;/2, 1; 0( ;1- 4+, 1;;,28, 392/0+75<, 92:,-,84/12H1; 72:/2:,;79<441 37E ;/2, +, 0+7<< 92:,-61 0/A3<, /A3-/012A,24;1-12,A124+ 8" +, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,-78890,: /0 ,24/4<,: 41 0,4 1;; 70 3-1./:,: 92:,- ,84/12 C 1;- :" +,1-:,-3700,:5E4+,-/7<19-492:,- ,84/12&1;- /0A1:/;/,:#-1A 194 1; 4+, ;/2, 7A1924 7 09A 1; - 10 - 0( /0 1-:,-,: 41 5, 37/: 41 4+, /2;1-A724 ) 70 81A3,2074/12 12 :9, /:,24/;/874/12 ," +,;/2,7A1924/0415,:,310/4,:D/4+/2 4+-,,A124+0;-1A4+,:74,1;4+/01-:,- -+ &!!* $ /041(<1