- 1 - ! " " #$ " #$ "" %&' ( ! " # " $ Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! % ! & '' () ' #*+ , ' '' " # ' + () ' #*+ - --!%$ ' -* " .+ + , ' & / *+ + / - 3 - & & % & $** & " +* + / % +$' ) ".' & !$++++- $0 $ #+++- 0 &" ( & " 1'" 1'" & $ 1'" 234 345677896:;4 &3<4= >>687 34 ?376@ AB =26 5783C89= 84 8D8394= =26 E;@DC69= 89@ 8F8<@ @8=6@ +* + 39 : % +$ >8446@ AB @@7 693:< 3G37 ";@D6 89@ '3@8< 26<6398?=6< <6?6<<6@ =: 84 H<3A;987I 26 C839 5:9=69=3:9 ;<D6@ 39 =26 8>>687 ?376@ AB=265783C89=4466J39D5:C>6948=3:9:9855:;9=:?=26 - 4 - @68=2 :? 937 937 ;C8< 8=37 F2: C6= F3=2 89 8553@69=:9+#+ +$26@656846@F84><:566@39D=: 234 G3778D6 738A8@ :9 234 C:=:<5B576 8= 8 9:<C87 4>66@ 89@ :9 =26 ><:>6< 43@6 :? =26 <:8@ 8?=6< 5:C>76=39D 234 F:<J8=8<J287G3778D6=8A:;=%+8CF26926F84 968<=26789@:?:968266C:@@398@@6:9=268<J287. 738A8@<:8@=26@<3G6<:?8942:J6B789@7:<<B@<3G39D 8=823D24>66@398<84289@96D73D69=C8996<G3:769=7B @8426@ 8D8394= =26 @656846@ 4 8 <64;7= :? =26 483@ 8553@69= =26 @656846@ ?677 39=: =26 A<3@D6 4;4=8396@ D<36G:;4 39E;<364 =: 234 ?:<6268@ 5264= 268@ 89@ 9:46 89@4;A46K;69=7B4;55;CA6@=:=2639E;<364 265783CC8@6A6?:<6=26<3A;987F84?:<89 8C:;9= :? 4$ #+++- F26<684 <3A;987 8F8<@6@ 89 8C:;9=:?4!$++++-89@39=26><6469=8>>6873=34 5:9=69@6@ =28= 5:C>6948=3:9 8F8<@6@ 34 :9 =26 76446< 43@6 26 <3A;987 284 =8J69 =26 395:C6 :? =26 @656846@ 84 4+++- >6< C:9=2 F26<684 3= :;D2= =: - 5 - 28G6 A669 =8J69 84 4#%*+- >6< C:9=2 26 5:C>6948=3:98F8<@6@;9@6<:=26<268@434874:C68D6< 89@269563=<6K;3<6439=6<?6<6956AB=234:;<= # 6< 5:9=<8 =26 5:;9467 8>>68<39D ?:< =26 <64>:9@69=4 4;AC3==6@ =28= =2:;D2 3= 34 5:9=69@6@ =28= =26@656846@ F84 F:<J39D 848?3<6C89 8= 893 <D89354 G= =@ :728< 9: @:5;C69=8<B ><::? F84 >7856@ :9 <65:<@ =: 4;A4=89=38=6 =26 48C6 6L56>= ?:< ><:@;539D L*4878<B 56<=3?358=6 :? =26 @656846@ 26 <3A;987 <3D2=7B 8446446@ =26 395:C6 :? =26 @656846@ 8= 4+++->6<C:9=289@F23768F8<@39D5:C>6948=3:9 D<89=6@8C:;9=4;9@6<877268@46956=268F8<@@:64 9:=<6K;3<689B39=6<?6<6956AB=234:;<= ! 8G39D 268<@ =26 768<96@ 5:;9467 ?:< =26 8>>67789=4 89@ =26 768<96@ 5:;9467 8>>68<39D ?:< =26 <64>:9@69=4 =26 >:39= =28= F:;7@ 8<346 ?:< 5:943@6<8=3:9 :?=234:;<=8<6- - 6 - % 8G39D 268<@ =26 <64>65=3G6 5:;9467 89@ :9 >6<;487 :? =26 C8=6<387 :9 <65:<@ 3= 34 9:=6@ =28= =26 5783C89=48<6=26F3?689@5237@<69:?=26@656846@43L39 9;CA6< =34=263<5846=28==26@656846@F84F:<J39D84 8 ?3<6C89 8= 893 <D89354 G= =@ :728< 68<939D 4#%*+->6<C:9=289@=28==2648C6:;D2==:28G6 A669 =8J69 84 234 395:C6 26 <3A;987 2:F6G6< 5:CC3==6@896<<:<39=8J39D=26395:C68=4+++- * 9 :<@6< =: ><:G6 =26 395:C6 L*4878<B 56<=3?358=6:?=26@656846@F84><:@;56@A6?:<6=234:;<= :64=8A7342L*=265783C89=46L8C396@ F2:34 483@ =: A6 8 <6=3<6@ 898D6< 39 =26 ;C89 64:;<56 6>8<=C69= ;<39D 5<:44-6L8C398=3:9 2:F6G6< 8@C3==6@=28=9:@:5;C69=F84><:@;56@=:42:F=28=26 F84F:<J39D84898D6<39=26483@?3<C9:<F8489B - 7 - >6<C3443:9><:@;56@?<:C=26483@?3<C8;=2:<3M39D23C=: @6>:46A6?:<6=26:;<=&;<=26<=26><6469=898D6<:? =26?3<CF849:=6L8C396@6956=26<3A;987<3D2=7B@3@ 9:=8556>==26483@6G3@6956 $ :F6G6< 43956 =26 8553@69= :55;<<6@ 39 =26 B68< +$=269:=3:987395:C6:;D2==:28G6A669=8J69 8= 4 #+- 84 >6< =26 528<= 89@ =26 <3A;987 5:CC3==6@896<<:<39=8J39D=26395:C68=4+++- + 26 5783C89=4 5:9=69@ =28= =26 @656846@ F84 8D6@ 8A:;= B68<4 =2:;D2 9: @:5;C69=8<B ><::? F84 ><:@;56@ :F6G6< =26 :4= :<=6C 6>:<= 5768<7B @3457:464=28=26F848D6@8A:;= B68<489@26956=26 8>>7358A76C;7=3>736<3439G36F:?=26E;@DC69=39 ! 26 5783C89=4 8<6 =26F3?6 89@ 5237@<69:? =26@656846@ 26 <3A;987=::J9:=6=28=5783C89=:4 89@8<6C8E:< 89@F23765875;78=39D=26@6>69@695B89@7:44:?395:C6 <3D2=7B8@@6@ #0=:F8<@4?;=;<6><:4>65=4:F6G6<=26 <3A;9875:CC3==6@896<<:<39@6@;5=39D:97B<@:9=26 - 8 - D<:;9@=28==26@6>69@69=48<6:97B=2<66399;CA6<234 ?39@39D346<<:96:;4A658;466G69=2:;D2=265237@<698<6 C8E:<9:=239D34>7856@:9<65:<@=:42:F=28==26BF6<6 9:=@6>69@69=4:?=26@656846@&;<=26<28G39D<6D8<@=: =263< 8D64 B68<4 B68<4 89@ * B68<4 3= :;D2= =: 28G6A6698@6@;5=3:9:?=26956=265875;78=3:9:? 5:C>6948=3:9 <6K;3<64 <65:943@6<8=3:9 55:<@39D7B 5:C>6948=3:9 ;9@6< =26 268@ :? 7:44 :? ?;=;<6 68<939D 5:C64=:4 +*!*%#- 26 5783C89=4 8<6 69=3=76@ ?:< 5:C>6948=3:9 :? 4++++-68523956=26B8<6=26F3?689@5237@<6939 877 ! 3= 5:C64 =: 4 ++++- 26 5783C89=4 8<6 874: 69=3=76@ ?:< 5:C>6948=3:9 :? 4#+++- :9 =26 268@ :? ?;96<876L>6946489@=<894>:<=8=3:9528<D6489@874:7:44 :?64=8=6344#+++-55:<@39D7B5:C>6948=3:9;9@6< =26 5:9G69=3:987 268@4 F:<J4 :;= =: 4 %++++- 234 8553@69= F84 =8J69 >785639 +$89@ 26956 69=3=76@ ?:< +0 645878=3:9 36 4 +++- 4 %++++ N +0 - 9 - 695639877=265783C89=48<669=3=76@?:<5:C>6948=3:9:? 4 +*%#-848D8394=4!$++++- 26 <3A;987 2:F6G6< 8F8<@6@ 89 39=6<64= :? $0 A;= 9: 4>65387 <684:9 34 8443D96@ 8F8<@39D $0 39=6<64=89@2695648C6348F8<@6@84!039=268A46956 :? 4>65387 <684:94 89@ 6G69 9: 8>>687 AB =26 94;<8956 5:C>89B=234:;<=589C:@3?B=2648C639=268A46956 :?<684:94=:23D26<39=6<64= 9G36F:?=26@345;443:94C8@68A:G6F6>844 =26?:77:F39D 3 &: +$$ + ?376@ AB =26 8>>67789=4 34 877:F6@ 39 >8<= AB C:@3?B39D =26E;@DC69=89@8F8<@@8=6@ +* + 39 : % +$ >8446@ AB =26 @@7 693:< 3G37 ";@D6 89@ '3@8< AB 69289539D =26 5:C>6948=3:9 =: 4 +*%#- 84 8D8394= 4!$++++- - 10 - F3=2 !0 39=6<64= ?<:C =26 @8=6 :? >6=3=3:9 =3773=4<6873M8=3:9 33 26 8>>:<=3:9C69= :? 5:C>6948=3:9 34 ;987=6<6@89@=2648C63484>6<=26:<@6< :?=26<3A;987 333 26 <64>:9@69= 34 @3<65=6@ =: @6>:43= =26 @3??6<6956 5:C>6948=3:9 8C:;9= F3=2 39=6<64= F3=239 ! F66J4 ?<:C =26 @8=6 :? <6563>=:?5:>B:?=234:<@6< )* %" ' $ )* %' $ 34=:7: !