- 1 - !"#$ %#&## # '( ')* ')) + ! " # !$#$ $#% ! & "'" ( ) * ! +, (!" ) Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ! , ! ,!,, % !! $#$ --- +, (!, ! ,%. % %) , % $# % ! ( ) &# % ,() , , /% % , $ % ! , ! % %% , ! $ $() $() & &()( ) % ! ()( ) ()() ()() % , # , % % " ! $ % &( ,%) , % % 0! " - 3 - (, 0! " ) ,123234516 4 7 8152392 7:45; <32= =39 4:8 7;1 >7615297587?4@5;16A642=167;18?1769761911B35; C@79=35; 4D 2=1 >64E11835;9 35 63F1 4 $ 61;3921618A? ! 7;76,4:3E12723457:7A@67;3D462=1 4DD15E19 >@539=7A:1 @5816 1E23459 $ $() $() & &()(F) 4D 2=1 !=76723?7 ?7?7 75=327 758 1E23459 ()(G7) ()(<) 758 ()(9) 4D 2=1 E=18@:18 79219 758 E=18@:18 63A19 (,61G152345 4D 264E32319) F158F152 E2 $ >15835; A1D461 2=1 88323457: 39263E27581993459"@8;17:7A@67;3 =1 ;392 4D 2=1 E4F>:7352 <=3E= =79 :18 24 61;3926723454DE63F13979D4::4<9 =1 91E458 619>458152 81 D7E24 E4F>:735752 =79 :48;18 2=1 >619152 E4F>:7352 7::1;35; 2=72 2=1 D3692 >123234516 E4FF32218 67>1 45 2=1 D7:91 >6121H2 4D F76637;1819>3219=1=7G35;839E:49182=729=1A1:45;924 2=1E=18@:187921E4FF@532?239D@62=167::1;182=72 - 4 - 7:: 2=1 >1232345169 7A@918 2=1 E4F>:735752 35 D3:2=? :75;@7;1758399@182=6172924=1652=1A79394D2=191 7::1;723459 2=1 I@63983E23457: >4:3E1 =7G1 61;3921618 2=1 3F>@;518 E63F1 <=3E= 39 54< E7::18 35 C@192345 A? 2=1 >1232345169 1768 2=1 :176518 E4@591: 7>>17635; D46 2=1 >1232345169 2=1 :176518 E4@591: 61>61915235; 2=1 91E458 619>458152 758 2=1 :176518 3;= 4@62 4G165F152 ,:17816D462=12721 & =1 F72216 72 =758 =79 7 E=1C@1618 758 94F1<=72 61>12323G1 =39246? 2 39 542 35 839>@21 2=72 2=1 91E458619>458152=78 176:316 :48;18 7 93F3:76 E4F>:7352 45&&$<=3E=E@:F3572183561;3926723454D63F1 4# $ A? @F57A78 ,4:3E1 272345 %46 >64>16 7>>61E3723452=394@62811F9327>>64>637212461>648@E1 2=1176:316E4F>:7352<=3E=617892=@9 !"# $ %& ' &() " *+, -# ./ % - 5 - 0121%.3 4%.35% 6708+, 0+, 9:;<( < =>=? %+, @ AB "CD0"< %<! &(%) < AB" %< %@"896E %@ " .%F%) < % @ G '@@ H--F( 8 A%C '.%F%) ' (%I*0:."CDFJ A%C'-F(%) < <K<@-'@-8%8% & * 0, J K< 8 -# 0#%FI%""< %@G L( 8 A%C'-F% +,<J MH" .%F) < < * < J < % %. 8A%C'-F(%<K% I*0: ."CDF J K%" * .( K% K@ 8 1C ." .%F%) < < < & F IF K% 6 N &%F)< %/H-O%.% +, K< "6 <PQ - R0"6 S - <C&%F) '/ " +, MH % /C 0"T J 0# K% * +, 0# % %/,J -#) C %0"6EM %+,%" 0"&%F%) K <- U C % +, . % < % 6:T 6V+, %" 0"& @ P@ 0C .%F%) K <- % "T J % 5@ U".J 0#%F%) - 6 - K % F 08 6V+, %" 0"& @ P@ 0C .%F%) K % >= - C L;1TW &( 82 / N & K< & J 0# K% -# @ X4+, 82"T0:0#C@8%-'%F%)K-# K< J A%C'.%K%0"@ 0-F% " +, 0"4+, " ""C@ 0" "896E,Y:OE0".%F%) %K<%.% 8K!:O(# 89%F% < < +, -#%F) 0121%.35=>=?. %- #' =>=Z7<- C K : 2:+, % 8< @ 6 % 8< K:!% .%F[ I(< :%+, ."CD/ % @ 0'0"K:!%&%0121%.35% %( "' @ 7%& < : &"8 *+, K$1 " ."CD)\ $ ,@69@752242=161;3926723454D2=1176:316E63F1 2=15G1923;7235;DD3E16=7954<D3:182=1E=76;19=112 >16@97: 4D 2=1 E=76;1 9=112 <4@:8 3583E721 2=72 2=1 5G1923;7235; DD3E16 =79 =4<1G16 864>>18 2=1 4DD15E1 >@539=7A:1@58161E2345&()(F)4D2=1!=76723?7 ?7?7 75=3274591C@152:?323945:?2=1D3692>123234516 - 7 - <=439>619152:?D7E35;2637:352=19738E791763935;4@24D 63F1 4# $ =3:1 F722169 2=@9 92448 2=1 D3692 >123234516 :48;18?127542=16E4F>:735245#$7::1;35;2=72 45 #$ 72 7A4@2 7F 2=1 91E458 619>4581527>>647E=182=1>1232345169J6193815E1758<79 D4@58:4321635;758927:B35;352=1G3E3532?4D2=1=4@912 39D@62=167::1;182=72<=152=1D3692>123234516921>>184@2 4D 2=1 =4@91 24 >64E118 24 =39 81527: E:353E 2=1 91E458 619>4581527997@:218=3F7582=617215182427B1=39:3D1 E235; @>45 2=39 E4F>:7352 2=1 I@63983E23457: >4:3E1 61;3921618 63F1 4 $ 45 #$ EE46835; 24 2=1 D3692 >123234516 2=1 >619152 E4F>:7352 D3:18 A? 2=1 91E458 619>458152 45 #$ 39 542=35; A@2 7 6127:37246?E4@5216A:79235215818245@::3D?2=1>64E11835;9 3563F1 4 $ =1>635E3>7:;631G75E14D2=1D3692>12323451639 2=722=191E458619>458152<=3:161>17218:?35G4B35;2=1 >4:3E1F7E=3516?=79E=4915243F>:3E72154245:?2=1D3692 - 8 - >123234516 A@2 7:94 =39 7;18 >761529 758 =39 ?4@5;16 A642=16 2=4@;= 2=1? 78F32218:? =7G1 54 51H@9 <=72941G16<32=2=1839>@21<=3E=39>619152:?2=19@AI1E2 F722164D78I@83E72345A12<1152=1D3692>1232345167582=1 91E458619>45815235>1E37:791 4$ $763935; 4@24D63F1 4# $239E452158182=729@E=64>35; 35 4D 3554E152 D7F3:? F1FA169 39 7 ;6499 F39@91 4D 2=1 >64E1994D:7< # >45 7 E:491 1H7F3572345 4D 2=1 E4F>:7352 87218#$32A1E4F191G381522=722=17::1;723459 E452735182=161357619@A9275237::?761>12323454D2=1G16? 97F1 7::1;723459 F781 A? 2=1 91E458 619>458152 35 =16 176:316 E4F>:7352 87218 &&$ <=3E= =79 7:6178? A115 1H267E218 =161357A4G1 HE1>2 D46 E162735 G7;@1 7991623459 E4@E=18 35 9:3;=2:? 7:21618 :75;@7;1 2=1 9@A9275E1 4D 2=1 7::1;723459 61F7359 @5E=75;18 1G162=1:199 35 46816 24 79E162735 2=1 572@61 4D 7EE@97234597582=11H21524D2=1364G16:7><32=2=1176:316 E4F>:73522=394@62E45938169327>>64>63721241H267E235 - 9 - 1523612?2=191E458E4F>:735287218#$35<=3E= 4DD15E19 >@539=7A:1 @5816 1E23459 $ $() $() & 758 &()(F) 4D 2=1 !=76723?7 ?7?7 75=327 =7G17;735A11535G4B187:45;<32=2=14DD15E197::1;18 @5816 2=1 >64G393459 4D 2=1 E=18@:18 79219 758 2=1 E=18@:1863A19(,61G1523454D264E32319)E2 :=]1 !"#D$%&5( =])>Z)=>=Z % 011 %.3 4%.3 ") ^__]`?a>==5%*0-F%:AFb ' * 011 %.3 K% ."CDF J 0#(%K<8c K%b'16%.3F K% * %7 %.3 5% " ' MH" .(% J @@ 1 UF % 8 K %" % 0"&(% F K% b +, 5( 8#d ^`> < K% MC 0"&( ' E @ " F 0#(% E /, K IF J I I eC ". L @@ 69 & 1 C" %'AC- CJ -' . 0"6-5(%.35( J '"CF% .5( K!:O(# 89%F%@@ /,0"J I% MC %/, f% / 5(% 5+,1+,<J 0#( MC0" - 10 - M%%T @@ 'AC- 5(%%" ' %, K 0C-F( ' Pe ".F K @@ <6E ""C F 89 . 0< E F K b 5g% 8,E6E -F(% "3"3 'Q%E"F"3"3J )J6E)J"F < @ 4 % b 0"% 0A(% ' F C'0"&bJ 89b 0"% 0A(% K% b "6 F J "6 8< .(%) '@ ?=)>_)=>=Z % 8#d 8#d ^`> 011 %.3 K% 8 J % @@ K% 4%.3@@"C% .0"% .J '@-AC- K6-%.3-KK @@89(% % ??=%."+<%() M 0Th C K: I&( K%@ "6 %b5% %("F"7%&: M& "8 :%%+,C#b -"CDF)\ 5 7 E761D@: E4F>76723G1 617835; 4D A42= 2=1 E4F>:73529 87218 &&$ 758 #$ 2=39 4@62 D3589 E45938167A:1 F1632 35 2=1 E452152345 4D 2=1 >12323451692=722=1:72216E4F>:735239542=35;A@278361E2 E4@5216A:792242=1E4F>:7352:48;18A?2=1D3692>123234516 3563F1 4 $=191C@15E14D1G15292=123F35; - 11 - 4D 2=1 E4F>:7352 758 2=1 572@61 4D 7::1;723459 @5F3927B7A:? 3583E721 2=72 2=1 91E458 619>458152 =79 @5D462@5721:? 61946218 24 F39@91 4D >4:3E1 F7E=3516? A? :48;35; F@:23>:1 %9 1G38152:? <32= 2=1 352152345 4D 1H16235; >6199@61 758 3523F3872345 @>45 2=1 D3692 >123234516 =39 4@62 39 7:94 @57A:1 24 4G16:44B 2=1 D7E2 2=72 >@69@752 24 2=1 176:316 E4F>:7352 :48;18 A? 2=1 91E458619>45815245&&$<=3E=619@:2183563F1 4# $ 2=1 5G1923;7235; DD3E16 =79 7:6178? 9@AF32218 7 E=76;1 9=112 3;53D3E752:? <=3:1 8435; 94 2=1 5G1923;7235; DD3E16 =79 864>>18 2=1 E=76;1 @5816 1E2345&()(F)4D2=1!=76723?7 ?7?775=327D 2=39 >64E18@67: 81G1:4>F152 39 7EB54<:18;18 79 75 @5839>@218 D7E2@7: E36E@F9275E1 2=1 61;392672345 4D 7 91E458 E4F>:7352 7;735 7::1;35; 61>17218 67>1 @5816 2=1 G16? 97F1 >64G39345 E75542 A1 9@9273518 35 :7< =15 381523E7: 7::1;723459 <161 1H7F3518 176:316 758 D4@58 359@DD3E3152 1G15 24 E45235@1 >6491E@2345 @5816 1E2345 - 12 - &()(F) 4D 2=1 ! 7 9@A91C@152 % 45 2=1 97F1 D4@5872345 39 E:176:? 3F>16F3993A:1 758 7F4@529 24 7 91E45835G1923;7234535242=197F17::1;723459 !1 2=72 79 32 F7? 75 757:?939 4D A42= E4F>:73529 >7623E@:76:? 2=1 D3692 E4F>:7352 87218 &&$ <=3E= =79 7:6178? A115 1H267E218 =161357A4G1 61G17:9 @5F3927B7A:? 2=72 2=1 61:723459=3> A12<115 2=1 D3692 >123234516 758 2=1 91E458 619>458152 <79 E459159@7: 35 572@61 5E1 2=1 5G1923;7235; DD3E16 =79 45 2=1 92615;2= 4D 7G73:7A:1 F721637: E459E34@9:? 864>>18 1E2345 &()(F) 4D 2=1 ! 7 >619@F>2345 51E199763:? 763919 2=72 2=161 <161 54 F721637:9 24 81F459267217A915E14DE45915246249@;;192E4FF399345 4D 61>17218 67>1 =1 61E468 D@62=16 839E:4919 2=72 2=1 91E458 619>458152 7>>1769 24 =7G1 7E218 @5816 7 F39E45E1>2345461F423457:617E2345763935;4@24D2=1D3692 >123234516J961D@97:24F766?=16819>3212=136E459159@7: 3523F7E? =39 1F423457: 2@6F43: =79 1G38152:? 26759:7218 3524 2=1 :48;35; 4D 61>17218 %9 2 39 7:94 811>:? - 13 - 61;61227A:1 2=72 352=1 91E458 E4F>:73529=1 =79 E=4915 243F>:3E7212=1D3692>123234516J97;18>761529758?4@5;16 A642=16<=4=7G15451H@9<=72941G16<32=2=1839>@21 758 <=4 761 7:6178? A135; 867;;18 3524 E63F357: >64E11835;9<32=4@275?D4@58723457:F721637: =1 D3692 >123234516 39 7:6178? D7E35; 2637: 35 >1E37:791 4$ $452=1D3:14D2=188323457: 39263E27581993459"@8;1!3876932235;72!797G7B7:?75 =1 7::1;723459 35 2=1 91E458 E4F>:7352 761 1H D7E31 G7;@1 4F53A@9 35 572@61 758 :7EB 75? 9>1E3D3E4G162 7E2 72263A@218 24 2=1 >1232345169 =1 E4F>:7352 39 E:176:? G3583E23G1F423G7218758D3:1845:?797E4@52167E234524 2=1 E4F>:7352 :48;18 A? 2=1 D3692 >123234516 <=3E= =79 E@:F3572183563F1 4 $45235@723454DD@62=16 35G1923;72345359@E=E36E@F9275E19<4@:87F4@52249=116 7A@91 4D 2=1 >64E199 4D :7< =39 4@62 7:94 54219 2=1 35E617935; 26158 61>17218:? =3;=:3;=218 A? 2=1 45JA:1 >1H 4@62 79 <1:: 79 2=39 4@62 <=16135 >762319 35 E459159@7: 61:723459=3>9 @>45 839E468 46 A617B84<5 - 14 - 7221F>224E45G1629@E=839>@2193524E63F357:7EE@9723459 A? 7::1;35; 67>1 @5816 2=1 ;76A 4D 7 D7:91 >64F391 4D F76637;1239<1::9122:182=727E459159@7:61:723459=3> 1G15 3D 7EE4F>75318 A? 7 >4993A3:32? 46 1H>1E272345 4D F76637;184195427@24F723E7::?26759:7213524754DD15E1 4D 67>1 @5:199 E:176 1G3815E1 4D :7EB 4D E459152 46 D67@8@:152358@E1F1523981F459267218 %@62=16F461 2=1 19915237: 35;61831529 4D 1E2345 &()(F) 4D 2=1 !=76723?7 ?7?7 75=327 <=3E=61C@361961>172187E294D91H@7:35216E4@691<32=4@2 E459152 761 E459>3E@4@9:? 7A9152 35 2=1 >619152 E791 5 :3;=2 4D 2=1 7A4G1 6179459 E45235@72345 4D 2=1 3F>@;518 >64E11835;9 <4@:8 @584@A218:? 7F4@52 24 7A@91 4D >64E199 758 <4@:8 81D172 2=1 1589 4D I@923E1 =39 4@62 2=161D461 D3589 32 51E19976? 24 1H16E391 329 35=16152 I@63983E234524C@79=2=1>64E11835;9 & %46 2=1 D461;435; 6179459 2=39 4@62 >64E1189 24>7992=1D4::4<35; - 15 - (3) =163F357:,12323459275897::4<18 (33) =1 %3692 5D46F72345 1>462 35 63F1 4 $ 4D ! 7;76 ,4:3E1 272345 7:7A@67;3 32? D46 4DD15E19 >@539=7A:1 @5816 1E23459$$()$()&758&()(F) 4D 2=1 !=76723?7 ?7?7 75=327 758 @5816 1E23459 ()(G7) ()(9) 758 ()(<) 4D 2=1 E=18@:18 79219 758 E=18@:18 63A19 (,61G152345 4D 264E32319) F158F152 E2 $ 54< >15835; A1D461 2=1 88323457: 39263E27581993459"@8;17:7A@67;33594D76 79 7EE@918 49 24 & 761 E45E16518 927589 C@79=18 ,* '##) & ,