Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63696 (KAR)
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD v. SHIVAPPPA AND ANR
MFA/203982/2024 · 2025-08-14
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63696 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63696 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#! $%!!&!& !!''
(&) *
! "#$#%&$
&
'
'
(
#))$'
"#$#%&$
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(
! &
( ( *%(
(
(
(
' +&
+,
&+&-
%
+,
&+&-
*&+, (
( ''( (
( '
( (
'
. '
%
/01233425/216447805496:;/471<=27>4?@327:
>/25547A07A ;/4 B<27;<@ ?8 >?@34712;0?7 2C2=949 07 D<9A@47;2792C2=992;49+&
+,
&+&-32114907? *&+,6:;/4 470?=0E05'<9A4279'(2794@64= ?8/25F0
& 42=9 542=749 >?<7145 8?= ;/4 23345527; 279 542=749>?<71458?==413?7947;? % 42=749 >?<7145 8?= ;/4 23345527; C?<59 >?7;479;/2;=413?7947;? "520@27;C219?07A>??504 279 /4 /21 1<1;20749 ?75: ?74 8=2>;<=4 279 ;/2; ?8 548;
- 3 -
;0602279>?71094=07A;/412@490126050;:;2F472;&+G01 ?7/0A/4=1094
48<=;/4=1<6@0;1;/2;107>4>520@27;/21 1<1;20749 ?75: ?74 8=2>;<=4 /4 01 7?; 47;0;549 8?= 8<;<=4 3=?134>;<1
4 1<6@0;1 ;/2; >?@34712;0?7 2C2=949 6:
;/4=06<7258?=?;/4=/42910
4
32072791<884=07A5?11?8 2@470;041 5?11 ?8 07>?@4 9<=07A 5209 <3 34=0?9 8<;<=4 @490>254H3471412798??92797?<=01/@47;2=4?7/0A/4= 1094
4 1<6@0;1 ;/2; ;/4 >520@27; C21 29@0;;49 07 ;/4 /?130;258?=234=0?9?8;/=4492:1
0;/;/414/43=2:1 ;? 255?C ;/4 233425 279 =49<>4 ;/4 B<27;<@ ?8 >?@34712;0?72C2=9496:;/4;=06<725
- 42=749 >?<7145 8?= =413?7947; ? C?<59 >?7;479 ;/2; 07 255 9?><@47;1 ;/4 2A4 ?8 ;/4 >520@27; 01 @47;0?74921##:42=1
/4=06<725/214==4907;2F07A 2A4?8;/4>520@27;21+:42=1
48<=;/4=1<6@0;1;/2;
=06<725 /21 =0A/;5: 2C2=949 >?@34712;0?7 07 255 /4291 2793=2:18?=901@01125?8;/4233425
# 2E07A /42=9 542=749 >?<71451 ;/01 ?<=; /21 34=<149;/40@3<A749D<9A@47;279;=025?<=;=4>?=91
- 4 -
/4 >520@27; /0@1458 /21 80549 80=1; 078?=@2;0?7 279 ;/4 >?3: ?8 12@4 01 2; H
C/4=407 /01 2A4 01 @47;0?74921##:42=1
H
-018<=;/4=1;2;4@47;?8;/4 >520@27;
"80=1; 078?=@27; C/4=407 251? /01 2A4 01 @47;0?749 21 ## :42=1
7 H
, "901>/2=A4 1<@@2=:
011<49 6: =2:2E0 ?130;25 ;/4 2A4 ?8 ;/4 >520@27; 01 @47;0?749 21 ## :42=1
7 H
" 5??9 27F =?11 2;>/07A 41; =43?=; 011<49 6: 092= 71;0;<;4 ?8 490>25 >047>4 279 42>/07A ?130;25 092= ;/4 2A4 ?8 ;/4 >520@27; 01 @47;0?749 21 ## :42=1
55 ;/414 9?><@47;1 0790>2;4;/2;2A4?8;/4>520@27;01##:42=1
/4=06<725 /21 4==49 =45:07A ?75: ?7 ;/4 C?<79 >4=;080>2;4 "H
* C/4=407 2A4 ?8 ;/4 >520@27; 01 @47;0?749 21 + :42=1 ?71094=07A 26?E4 2134>;1 ;/4 =06<725 /21 4==49 07 ;2F07A2A4?8;/4>520@27;21+:42=1
/4=06<725?<A/;
;? /2E4 ;2F47 2A4 ?8 ;/4 >520@27; 21 ## :42=1
/4 @<5;03504=23350>26548?=;/412092A401
* /49?>;?=C/?/21011<490126050;:4=;080>2;4
"H
+ /21 6447 4H2@0749 21
&
1 34= 90126050;:
- 5 -
>4=;080>2;4279/014E0947>4;/490126050;:?8;/4>520@27;
01 2; %,G
/4 =06<725 /21 ;2F47 90126050;: 2; &+G ?71094=07A 8=2>;<=4 ?8 =0A/; ;0602 ;/4 90126050;: ;2F47 6:
;/4 =06<725 01 ?7 /0A/4= 1094 279 ;/4 =06<725 ?<A/; ;?
/2E4;2F472;%G
$ 07>4 ;/4 >520@27; /21 1<1;20749 ?75: ?74 8=2>;<=4 279 /4 01 7?; 47;0;549 8?= 8<;<=4 3=?134>;<1 21 >?71094=49 6: =06<725
/4 >520@27; /216447 29@0;;49 ;?;/4?130;258?=;/=4492:1
?71094=07A;/412@4279 251? >?71094=07A 8=2>;<=4 ?7=0A/; ;0602;/4>?@34712;0?7 2C2=949 8?=3207279 1<884=07A5?11 ?82@470;0415?11?8 07>?@4 9<=07A 5209 <3 34=0?9 279 8??9 279 7?<=01/@47;
2=4?7/0A/4=1094
/4>520@27;/2164470714=;490@3527;
279 0; =4B<0=41 ;? 64 =4@?E49
/4=48?=4 /4 =4B<0=41 8<;<=4@490>254H347141?8 1
&#+++)
, /4>520@27;0147;0;549;?5?11?88<;<=407>?@4 ?8 1
*#$,+) +&#+) H & H H %G 3207 279 1<884=07A 1
#++++)5?11?807>?@49<=07A5209<334=0?9
1
+&#+) H +% @?7;/1 I%+*#+) @490>25 4H347141
- 6 -
1
#++++) 8<;<=4 @490>25 4H347141 1
&#+++) 8??9 7?<=01/@47;279;=2E45>/2=A41 1
%++++)
+
7E04C?8;/426?E4;/4>520@27;0147;0;549;? >?@34712;0?721<794=! !+ ,-./ 0123 42 ()
?11?8(<;<=407>?@4 *#$,+) & 2072791<884=07A #++++) % ?11?8@470;041 #++++) - 209<334=0?9 %+*#+) # 490>25H347141 %#+++)
(<;<=4@490>25H347141 &#+++) * (??9279?<=01/@47; %++++) 3-+
5
/4 >520@27; 01 47;0;549 ;? ;?;25 >?@34712;0?7 ?8
1
%,-+) =<3441 /=44 2F/1 074;: 0H /?<1279 0H<79=49(?=;:?75:212A2071; 1
,%%$#)=<3441 074 2F/1 /0=;: /=44 /?<1279 0A/; <79=49 0H;: (0E4?75:212C2=9496:;/4=06<725
7E04C?8;/426?E4;/48?55?C07A
0 /423342501
- 7 -
00 /4>?@34712;0?72C2=9496:;/4=06<725071<@ ?8 1
,%%$#)=<34410742F/1/0=;:/=44 /?<1279 0A/; <79=49 0H;: (0E4 ?75: 01 =49<>49 ;? 1
%,-+) =<3441 /=44 2F/1 074;: 0H/?<1279 0H<79=49(?=;:?75: 000 C2=9 ?8 07;4=41; 279 ?=94= ?8 943?10; =4@20749 <725;4=49 0E /423345527;"71<=27>4?@327:0134=@0;;49;? C0;/9=2C ;/4 2@?<7; 07 943?10; 943?10;49 07 4H>411?8>?@34712;0?72C2=949 E /4 2@?<7; 07 943?10; @294 6: ;/4 23345527; 648?=4 ;/01 ?<=; 01 ?=94=49 ;? 64 ;=271@0;;49 ;? ;/4=06<725
!.5 (!&!&) %
01;? 5? %