Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63682 (KAR)

ASHOK S/O KRISHNAPPA CHAVAN v. C.S. PATIL AND ANR

MFA/201166/2023 · 2025-10-30

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %& ' !"! # $ % ! !"! &' !"! # $ '( "" ! )% '' *"$!% ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) +!"" ' "! ' ) , # -./0- 1-2 344235 67 567128 9.: 38;6776.< =61- 1-2 >.<72<1 .9 523:<28 >./<725 9.: 1-2 43:1627 61 67 13?2< /4 9.:96<358674.735 -67 344235 67 96528 3036<71 1-2 @/80;2<1 3<8 3=3:883128+!""437728AB1-288616.<352<6.: 6C65 /802 3<8 .;;6776.<2: 9.: ;45.B227 .;42<7316.< 6@3B34/:36< . .9"! * -2A:62993>17.91-2>3723:21-311-2>536;3<1 =373:20/53:2;45.B22/<82::274.<82<1 .!=-.=37 5377.<1:3>1.:<*""!3742:1-286:2>16.<.9 :274.<82<1 .! =-652 -2 =37 2<03028 6< 96556<0 1-2 ;6D28 >2;2<1 6< 1-2 A/>?21 9.: /45.386<0 1-2 73;2 - 3 - 1.=3:87617753A>.<>:212=.:?3<8713<86<0A25.=1-27368 A/>?21=-65261=37A26<0569128/4=3:87619255.<-67:60-1 5209..18/21.=-6>--27/7136<289:3>1/:26<@/:6271.-67 :60-1 520 3<8 9..1 -2:29.:2 -2 96528 3 >536; 421616.< A29.:2 1-2 .;;6776.<2: >536;6<0 >.;42<7316.< .9 7!"""""" =61-6<12:27131!E43 -2 .;;6776.<2: >.<7682:6<0 1-2 2<16:2 2C682<>2.<:2>.:80:3<128>.;42<7316.<.97"! =61-6<12:27131!E433912:2D46:B.9*"83B79:.;1-2 3>>682<1629:.;""!1655:23567316.< 00:62C28AB1-27368@/80;2<13<83=3:81-2 6<@/:28 >536;3<1 -37 4:292::28 1-67 344235 6< =-6>- 61 67 >.<12<8281-31-2=3702116<07353:B.97!"""" 42: ;.<1-( :274.<82<1 .! 868 <.1 >-..72 1. >.<1271 1-2 ;3112:( 1-2 .;;6776.<2: 2::28 6< 13?6<0 -67 6<>.;2 37 7*F 42: ;.<1-( 1-./0- -2 7/7136<28 0:62C./7 6<@/:6271-28673A6561B =3713?2<.<5B31E3<8;286>35 2D42<727=2:2<.10:3<1284:.42:5B-2:29.:2:2G/27128 9.:2<-3<>2;2<1.9>.;42<7316.< - 4 - 23:81-23:0/;2<17.9A.1-76827 F -29.55.=6<07/A713<1635G/2716.<7.953==./58 3:6729.:>.<7682:316.<6<1-67344235 6% )-21-2:1-2.;;6776.<2:=37@/71696286< 3772776<0 1-2 6<>.;2 .9 1-2 3442553<1 31 7*F 42:;.<1-H 66% )-21-2:1-2.;;6776.<2:=61-./113?6<0 6<1. >.<7682:316.< 1-2 2992>1 .9 1-2 8673A6561B/4.<1-223:<6<0>343>61B.91-2 3442553<1 =37 @/7169628 6< 3772776<0 1-2 42:;3<2<18673A6561B.9EH 666% )-21-2:1-2.;;6776.<2:=37@/71696286< -.586<01-311-2<8:274.<82<167563A521. 43B >.;42<7316.< 1.=3:87 ;286>35 2D42<727H -2 4.56>B =37 13?2< 9.: !" 2;45.B227 62 F 42:;3<2<1 2;45.B227 3<8 * >.<1:3>1 2;45.B227 3<8 1-2:29.:2 1-2:2 ;3B A2 1.135 7353:B =37 7-.=< 37 - 5 - 7*F" -2 .;;6776.<2: >.<7682:6<0 1-2 7368 23:<6<0 -37 13?2< 1-2 6<>.;2 .9 1-2 3442553<1 31 7*F 42: ;.<1- 3<8 9.: 1-2 4/:4.72 .9 >35>/5316.< -37 13?2< "E .9 1-2 7368 3;./<1 37 7+ 42: ;.<1-=-6>-67@/713<84:.42:67302=37* B23:73<8 1-2:252C3<193>1.:67!+ -23442553<1-377/7136<28 9:3>1/:2 .9 :60-1 9..1 9:3>1/:2 .9 <8 3<8 *:8 ;21313:735 3<8 >/A.68 -2 3442553<1 2D3;6<28 1-2 8.>1.: 37 ) 3<8 -2 37727728 1-2 8673A6561B 37 E /<82: D!* /1 1-2:6A/<35-3713?2<.<5BE.<7682:6<01-2<31/:2.9 6<@/:627 3<8 .>>/4316.< 1-67 ./:1 96<87 61 :237.<3A52 1. 13?2 1-2 8673A6561B 37 E -/7 1-2 1.135 3;./<1 =./58 A2 7+ D!+ DEI7 + -2 .;;6776.<2: -37 0:3<128 7"*! 1.=3:87 ;286>35 2D42<727 3<8 -37 86:2>128 :274.<82<1 .!1.43B1-273683;./<1=-6>-67@/713<84:.42:3<8 <2287<.6<12:92:2<>2 - 6 - !" -/7 1-2 3442553<1 67 2<161528 9.: 1.135 >.;42<7316.< .9 7 " 35.<0 =61- 6<12:271 31 !E 43 !! -2 7/A713<1635 G/2716.<7 .9 53= 3:2 3<7=2:28 3>>.:86<05B ! <1-2:27/511-29.55.=6<0.:82:67437728 $6% 4423567355.=286<43:1 $66% -2 3442553<1 >536;3<1 67 2<161528 9.: 1-2 1.135 >.;42<7316.< .9 7 " =61- 6<12:271 31 !E 42: 3<</; 9:.; 1-2 8312 .9 3>>682<1 1655 1-2 8312 .9 :23567316.< $666% /1 .9 1-2 7368 3;./<1 :274.<82<1 .! 67 563A52 1. 43B 7"*! 3<8 :274.<82<1 .<7/:3<>2 .;43<B 67 563A52 1. 43B 7 35.<0 =61- 6<12:271 37.:82:283A.C2 - 7 - $6C% 274.<82<1 .7!3<83:286:2>1281.824.761 1-2 39.:27368 >.;42<7316.< 3;./<1 =61-6< .<2 ;.<1- 9:.;1-28312.91-67@/80;2<1 $C% < 7/>- 824.761 1-2 3442553<1 67 42:;61128 1. =61-8:3= 1-2 2<16:2 3;./<1 35.<0 =61- 6<12:271 3>>:/28 .<61 ()* %$ & # 671 .!5 .