- 1 - ! " #$%! &# '"( #&# '"( #$(%""$ #"#&&" )%* + ! " # $ % & '(')* + ! ( ,* % & '('+ !* ! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , % % '+!!!! + && ' ! " # ( & , & +$ & & ),# $ & - $& ,!( * & & & % $ , ((! ,!((! * &% & ,!! - (. & & / / - 3 - "( # / $ 012 344536 7895: 5;<1=8 ),# $ => =<=: 501;652 ;< - #05:5183><5: :5>5::59 <= 32 ?<05 ;<@$ 032 A558 >1659 AB <05 ;631C38< ;036658D18D <05 E79DC58< 93<59 , ((! 432259 AB <05 581=: 1F16 79D5 & % 5G3:D118 =,!((! * ( &3;<2 D1F18D :125 <= <05 >1618D => <05 344536 A:15>6B 2<3<59 3:5 <03< =8 ! ((! + 95;53259 323F3:3E G32 :1918D 85G C=<=: ;B;65 03F18D 032212 = ! !!)(, >:=C 5G3:D1 <= 89=63F1663D5 =8 5G3:D1' 030347:347A61;:=3926=G6B389;37<1=726B<3A=7<!' ,!<059:1F5:=>:3;<=:389:=665BA53:18D:5D12<:3<1=8 ='(')*'+ !* 9:=F5 1< 18 :320 389 85D61D58< C3885:2=32<=58938D5:<=07C3861>5G1<001D024559 389 2799586B 3446159 <05 A:53H G1<0=7< =A25:F18D <05 F501;65;=C18D>:=C<05A3;H219558;595;53259032 8= <1C5 <=3F=19 <05 01<<18D => 012 F501;65 389932059 <= - 4 - <05A3;H2195=><05:=665B23:5276<=><053>=:52319 3;;1958< <05 95;53259 272<31859 D:15F=72 18E7:152 389 91593<<0524=< , 05;631C38<>165945<1<1=87895: 5;<1=8 ** => <05 ;<255H18D;=C45823<1=8 <G324653959<03<2052458< 21D81>1;38<3C=78<<=G3:92C591;365I458252;=8F5B38;5 ;03:D52 389 =<05: :563<59 ;=2<2 < G32 >7:<05: 4653959 <03< <05 3;;1958< =;;7::59 975 <= :320 389 85D61D58< 9:1F18D =8 <05 43:< => <05 9:1F5: => :3;<=: 389 :=665B =G859AB:524=8958<= 389(:5245;<1F56B + 4=8 25:F1;5 => 8=<1;5 <05 :524=8958< =2 389 ( 8=< 34453:59 A5>=:5 <05 :1A7836 389 5I'43:<5 524=8958<=2,389+34453:59<0:=7D0<051:;=782562 389>16592543:3<5G:1<<58=AE5;<1=82<=<05;631C45<1<1=8 8 <05 A3212 => <05 4653918D2 => <05 43:<152 <05 631C2:1A7836>:3C59<05122752389<05:53><5::5;=:959 <05 5F1958;52 05 :1A7836 AB 1C47D859 E79DC58< 389 - 5 - 3G3:9 032 912C12259 <05 ;631C 45<1<1=8 518D 3DD:15F59 <054:5258<344536032A558>1659 * 05 653:859 ;=78256 34453:18D >=: <05 ;631C38< 032 ;=8<58959<03<<053;;1958<12=;;7::59975<=85D61D58;5 9:1F5: => <05 :3;<=: CC5913<56B 3><5: <05 3;;1958< ;=C46318< 032 6=9D59 3D3182< <05 9:1F5: => <05 :3;<=: & 032 A558 :5D12<5:59 3><5: <0=:=7D0 18F52<1D3<1=8 4=61;5 032 >1659 3 ;03:D5 2055< 3D3182< <05 9:1F5: => <05 :3;<=: 389 1< 12 362= 8=< 18 91247<5 <03< 95;53259 323F3:3E 9159 975 <= 3;;1958< =;;7::59 A5<G558 <05 :3;<=:389C=<=:;B;65:1A7836032G:=8D6B3227C5<03< :195: => <05 C=<=:;B;65 G32 F5:B ;6=256B G1<0=7< C318<31818D <05 912<38;5 012 >18918D 12 3::1F5 G1<0=7< 38BC3<5:1365F1958;558;5052=7D0<>=:366=G18D<05 344536 ) 653:859;=7825634453:18D>=::524=8958< =2,389+03227AC1<<59<03<<0595;53259C=<=:;B;65 G32 4:=;55918D <05 23C5 91:5;<1=8 G5:5 :3;<=: G32 - 6 - 4:=;55918D 5 G32 4:=;55918D A3;H2195 => <05 :3;<=: G1<0=7< C318<31818D 38B 912<38;5 218;5 :3;<=: <B:5 G32 A7:2<9:1F5:G323446159<05A:53H0595;53259;3C5 >:=C A3;H2195 389 932059 <= <05 0189 4=:<1=8 => <05 :3;<=:05:5>=:5<05:5128=85D61D58;5=8<0543:<=> <05 9:1F5: => <05 :3;<=: 58;5 :1A7836 032 :1D0<6B 912C12259<05;631C45<1<1=8 53:9 <05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 43:<152 389 45:7259<05E79DC58<3893G3:9=><05:1A7836 - 05 ;325 => <05 ;631C38< <03< =8 ! ((! + 95;53259 323F3:3E G32 :1918D C=<=:;B;65 032212 = !!)(,>:=C5G3:D1<=89=63F1663D5 =8 5G3:D1'030347:3 47A61; :=39 < 3A=7< !,! <05 9:1F5: => <05 :3;<=: 389 :=665B A53:18D 5D=' (')*'+ !* G32 9:1F18D <05 :3;<=: 18 01D0 24559 389 2799586B 3446159 <05 A:53H G1<0=7< =A25:F18D <05 F501;65 ;=C18D >:=C <05 A3;H 2195 5;53259 323F3:3E G324:=;55918D=8<0523C591:5;<1=8<=<05A3;H2195=> - 7 - <05:3;<=:03201<<0501894=:<1=8=><05:3;<=:38905 27;;7CA59<=<0518E7:152 ! 05:1A7836G1<0=7<38B27>>1;158<C3<5:136032;=C5 <= <05 ;=8;6721=8 <03< <05 95;53259 G32 :1918D <05 C=<=:;B;65 G1<0=7< C318<31818D 38B 912<38;5 >:=C <05 :3;<=:012>18918D=><05:1A7836128=<A325974=838B C3<5:136 5F1958;5 389 362= 8=< ;=82195:59 <03< & =C46318< 03:D52055< :54=:< 389 <05:5 12 8= >18918D <03< G05<05: <05:5 G32 38B ;=8<:1A7<=:B 85D61D58;5 05 :1A7836 032 5::59 18 912C12218D <05 45<1<1=805:1A7836362=8=<32252259<05;=C45823<1=8 58;5 G5 3:5=> <05 =4181=8 <03< <05 C3<<5::5J71:52 <= A5:5C38959A3;H>=:>:520;=82195:3<1=8 ;;=:918D6BG5432259<05>=66=G18D=:95: 3$ 0534453612 - 8 - A$ 05;=CC=8E79DC58<93<59, ((! 432259AB <05 581=: 1F16 79D5 & % 5G3:D1 18 =,!((! *1205:5AB25<32195 ;$ 05 C3<<5: 12 :5C1<<59 A3;H <= <05 :1A7836 <= :5;=82195:3>:520183;;=:938;5G1<063G3><5:D1F18D 38 =44=:<781<B <= A=<0 <05 43:<152 <= 3997;5 5F1958;53894:=97;5<0585;5223:B9=;7C58<2 9$ < 12 C395 ;653: <03< =7:< 032 8=< 5I4:52259 38B =4181=8=8<05C5:1<2=><05;325 5$ 66<05;=8<58<1=82=><0543:<1523:5H54<=458 #.- )&#* ( #.- )$(%""$* ( 12<= 6=*, KKK