- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &' ( ) !" # $ # % " # & # & " #'$ # " Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ($') (*$* +% % & ! , " #,& # (&%"(-,$- " . (*$*&+- / &/ %( &/ " + +%+%* , -& )$$ ! +% %%+ - +$ %%+ - ! # # 0 ! - 3 - $ # 0 ! 1234 561 237891:5; <= >123:14 ?<8:;1> =<3 561 2@@1>>2:5 123:14 ?<8:;1> =<3 31;@<:41:5 <; 2:4 & 62A1:<5=B>14A2C2>2562:4561D62A1:<5583:148@E1=<31 561<835 % 6B; 2@@12> B; =B>14 272B:;5 561 F84791:5 2:4 2G234 42514 +% %%+ - @2;;14 ED 561 44B5B<:2> 1:B<3BAB>!84712:4 19E13 2>2E8327BB: <-'<=%+ * & 61 =2?5; <= 561 ?2;1 231 5625 <: $ %+ & G6B>156141?12;146BA2>11>22><:7GB56<:1B;6G2:256 G2; @3<?114B:7 <: 9<5<3?D?>1 E123B:7 317B;5325B<: <(&%"(-,$-2;2@B>>B<:3B413=3<9:G23AB>>2715< 624B@83AB>>2715613B413<=5619<5<3?D?>13<41B5B:6B76 ;@114 2:4 32;6 2:4 :17>B71:5 92::13 481 5< G6B?6 561 41?12;14 =1>> 4<G: 2:4 ;8;52B:14 73B1A<8; B:F83B1; 2:4 ;8??89E145<561;291G6B>1;6B=5B:75<5616<;@B52> - 4 - , 6131=<31 561 ?6B>431: 2:4 9<5613(B:(>2G <= 561 41?12;14 =B>14 2 ?>2B9 @15B5B<: E1=<31 561 3BE8:2> ?>2B9B:7 ?<9@1:;25B<: <= ; %+++++"( 61 3BE8:2> ?<:;B413B:7 561 1:5B31 1AB41:?1 <: 31?<34 732:514 ?<9@1:;25B<: <= ;--+ ++"( GB56 B:5131;5 25 'H @2 =3<9 561 4251 <= @15B5B<: 5B>> 312>B;25B<: 2:4 4B31?514 31;@<:41:5 <%(:;832:?1<9@2:D5<41@<;B5561;291 * 773B1A14ED561;2B4F84791:52:42G234561 B:;832:?1 ?<9@2:D 62; @31=13314 56B; 2@@12> 4B;@85B:7 561 >B2EB>B5D <: 561 73<8:4 5625 56131 G2; :< 43BAB:7 >B?1:?1 ' 123:14 ?<8:;1> =<3 561 2@@1>>2:5 92B:>D ?<:51:414 562556131 B;AB<>25B<: <= 561 @<>B?D ?<:4B5B<:; 2:461:?1561B:;832:?1?<9@2:DB;:<5>B2E>15<@2D561 ?<9@1:;25B<: - ;@1356178B41>B:1;<=561<:IE>1@1J<835 B: 4B?589 <= - 5 - 56B; <835 =B:4; B5 312;<:2E>1 5< 4B31?5 561 2@@1>>2:5(:;832:?1 <9@2:D 5< =B3;5 41@<;B5 561 ?<9@1:;25B<: 2G23414 ED 561 3BE8:2> 2:4 561: 31?<A13 561 ;291 =3<9 561 <G:13 <= 561 A16B?>1 6131=<315612@@12>41;13A1;5<E12>><G14B:@235 $ :56131;8>5561=<>><GB:7<3413B;@2;;14# B @@12>B;2>><G14(B:(@235 BB 612@@1>>2:5(B:;832:?1?<9@2:DB;4B31?5145< @2D561?<9@1:;25B<:<=;--+ ++"(2><:7GB56B:5131;5 25 561 3251 <= 'H @2 =3<9 561 4251 <= @15B5B<: 5B>> @2D91:5 2; 2G23414 ED 561 3BE8:2> <G1A13 561 2@@1>>2:5B;25>BE135D5<31?<A13561;291=3<931;@<:41:5 <,(<G:13<=561A16B?>1ED481@3<?1;;<=>2G BBB 61 2@@1>>2:5(B:;832:?1 ?<9@2:D ;62>> 41@<;B5 561?<9@1:;25B<:GB56B:<:19<:56=3<95614251<=56B; <3413 1 (2018) 3 SCC 208 - 6 - BA :;8?641@<;B5561?>2B92:5;231@139B55145< GB56432G5611:5B3129<8:52><:7GB56B:5131;52??3814<: B52;@135612@@<35B<:91:59241ED5613BE8:2> A 6129<8:5B:41@<;B5E1=<3156B;<835;62>>E1 532:;9B55145<5613BE8:2>=<34B;E83;191:5 *+, &%!! ( $ B;5 <# > <#-'