- 1 - ! "#$ %!&!'!! !!'' (# ) * ! "" # # " $! %# & #'"#( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " # !# )* #** * $ ## & *# $! $ ( # **# # ## " $! % # & "#* + $" # # #( #** )&(*"# # * # # #" # * * # # * # " # " # # # '" " # # # ,! $ ## # * # # " # - - . # - 3 - & #/0,1223140,25363553789:/3;410<1=:,1>10=,::/3 ?@7><3=: 1=7 1A157 71:37 21,,3789 :/3" 770:0B=143=0B50C04@7>31=73<835B:B5;;073=: 410<, #508@=14$'" "0?1912@51 D6B5 ,/B5: E#508@=14FG 0= " B ,33H0=> 3=/1=;3<3=: B6 ;B<23=,1:0B= =317151B<3:A0:/1=1;;073=:B=! 1=7 7037 0, A063 1=7 ;/04753= 60437 ;410< 23:0:0B= ;410<0=> ;B<23=,1:0B= B6 ,) $ A0:/ 0=:353,: #/3#508@=14;B=,073537:/33=:053<1:35014,B=53;B571=7 1A15737 , $A0:/0=:353,:1::/351:3B6I235 1==@<65B<:/371:3B623:0:0B=:04453140,1:0B=>>503C37 89:/3,107B5735;410<1=:,60437:/0,122314 3157 15>@<3=:, B6 8B:/ :/3 215:03, 1=7 235@,37:/3<1:35014,1C1041843B=53;B57 #/3 <10= ;B=:3=:0B= B6 :/3 ;410<1=:, 153 :/1: :/30=;B<3B6:/373;31,37A1, , $235<B=:/89 - 4 - 7B0=>>50;@4:@514AB5H8@::/3#508@=14A0:/B@:1=981,0, 1,,3,,37:/3,1<31: ,) $235<B=:/1=7:/@,2519 6B5 3=/1=;3<3=: B6 :/3 ;B<23=,1:0B= A0:/ I 0=:353,: 2351==@<0=,:317B6I1A1573789:/3#508@=14 : 0, ,@8<0::37 89 :/3 4315=37 ;B@=,34 6B5 53,2B=73=: B J =,@51=;3 B<21=9 :/1: :/3 ;B<23=,1:0B=1A1573789:/3#508@=140,?@,:1=725B235 A/0;/7B3,=B:;1446B51=90=:356353=;3 7<0::3749 1: :/3 :0<3 B6 1;;073=: 73;31,37 A1,1>379315,1=7:/@,:/3<@4:02403512240;18430,E)F 1=7=B:EF1,:1H3=89:/3#508@=14:0,,:1:37:/1:/3 A1, 315=0=> , 235 <B=:/ 8@: =B 7B;@<3=: 0, 25B7@;37:B25BC3:/3,1<3=:/318,3=;3B625BB6B6 0=;B<3 1, 235 :/3 >@07340=3, 0,,@37 89 :/3 15=1:1H1 :1:33>1435C0;3,@:/B50:9:/0,B@5:60=7,0:?@,:1=7 531,B=1843:B:1H3:/3=B:0B=140=;B<3B6:/373;31,371: ,! $ 235 <B=:/ 6B5 :/3 1;;073=: B6 :/3 9315 0=,:317B6 ,) $1,:1H3=89:/3#508@=146 57B6 :/0,1<B@=:0,737@;:37:BA157,:/3235,B=143K23=,3,B6 - 5 - :/3 73;31,37 :/3 ;410<1=:, 153 3=:0:437 6B5 57 B6 :/3 0=;B<3 #/@, :/3 4B,, B6 7323=73=;9 ;B<3, :B- ,! $KK)K L , ! $ ) ,23541A41077BA=89:/323KB@5:0=:/3 ;1,3 B6 ;410<1=: B, :B 830=> ;/04753= B6 :/3 73;31,371533=:0:4376B5 , ! $31;/:BA157,4B,,B6 2153=:14;B=,B5:0@<0=:B:14 , $1=714,B1A157 1=1<B@=:B6 , $@=735:/3;B=C3=:0B=14/317, ! ;;B570=>49:/3;410<1=:,1533=:0:4376B5:B:14 ;B<23=,1:0B= B6 , $ 1, 1>10=,: , $ 1A15737 89 :/3 #508@=14 #/353 A044 83 3=/1=;3<3=: B6 ,) $ 3,2B=73=: B $ =,@51=;3 B<21=9 /1, 1453179 732B,0:37 :/3 ;B<23=,1:0B= 1A15737 89 :/3 #508@=14 *B5:/316B53,107531,B=,:/36B44BA0=>- - 6 - &0( #/31223140, &00( #/3 1223441=:, 153 3=:0:437 6B5 ;B<23=,1:0B= B6 ,) $ A0:/ 0=:353,: 1: I 2351==@<65B<:/371:3B623:0:0B=:04453140M1:0B=0= 1770:0B=:BA/1:/1,833=1A1573789:/3#508@=14 &000( 3,2B=73=:BJ=,@51=;3B<21=90, 7053;:37:B732B,0::/3;B<23=,1:0B=1<B@=:A0:/0= 6B@5A33H,65B<:/371:3B6:/0,?@7><3=: &0C( 223441=:, ;410<1=:, 153 235<0::37 :B A0:/751A :/3 3=:053 3=/1=;37 ;B<23=,1:0B= A0:/ 0=:353,:1;;5@37B=0:3N@1449 B@=,34 6B5 53,2B=73=: B 0, 235<0::37 :B 6043 "1H141:A0:/0=:ABA33H, +,- ('!! ) & 0,:B-4B- #-