- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &'( ) ! " # $ %&# '( )** # +, ) * & "#($ - * .. ( ! " #&)/ # ' )) % $ & & '" $ & # * $& #' ) && Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ % & % ))) * # ' ) & * % 0 ) % )0 $ % ) & %# 1 $ "1 $ 23456723489:2;6<=>672?234;25@=9;<2?>=4A=67 672B346C2< ) 7C< 3BB23? C< >C?25 383C;<6 672 =4524 53625 ))) * 383C;<6 672 3D345 => 672 4CA9;3? B3<<25 C; # =' ) AE 672 55C6C=;3? C<64C@6 3;5 2<<C=;<95823;5 3C@794 ' 72>3@6<=>672@3<23426736=; ) 36 3A=96'3:6723BB2??3;63?=;8DC677C<<=;AE;3:2 - 3 - 34C 4C<7;3 D3< B4=@225C;8 =; # @==6E F2<6 A234C;8 ='( =;3C@794CG3;8243:3C;4=35366736 '( )** @3:2 DC67 7C87 <B225 3;5 C; 3 43<7 3;5 ;28?C82;6:3;;243;553<725383C;<6672H27C@?2926= 672 C:B3@6 => 3@@C52;6 672 3BB2??3;6 <9<63C;25 84C2H=9< 3;5 :9?6CB?2 C;G94C2< 3;5 D3< <7C>625 6= 3<7=53 =<C63? E5243A35 72 @?3C: B26C6C=; D3< >C?25 AE 672 C;G9425 @?3C:3;6@?3C:C;8@=:B2;<36C=;=><) DC67 C;6242<6 72 4CA9;3? 3>624 @=;<C524C;8 2;6C42 :3624C3? =; 42@=45 843;625 <* 3?=;8 DC67 C;6242<6 36 672 4362 => 0 B24 3;;9: >4=: 672 5362 => B26C6C=;6C??52B=<C6 884C2H25 AE 672 <3C5 =4524 67C< 3BB23? C< B42>24425D7242C;C6C<@=;62;525673667225C@3?=345 3<<2<<256725C<3AC?C6E36 06=672D7=?2A=5EA96672 4CA9;3? 24425 C; 63IC;8 672 <3:2 36 0 < B24 672 ;@=:2 3J 42694;< 72 D3< 234;C;8 < B24 3;;9: A96 672 4CA9;3? 73< 63I2; 7C< C;@=:2 3< - 4 - <( B24:=;673;56723:=9;6<843;6259;524672 =6724 7235< ?CI2 ?=<< => 3:2;C6C2< ?=<< => C;@=:2 594C;8 ?3C59BB24C=53;5B3C;3;5<9>>24C;8342:238243;5:=42 =H24 7C< @=;64CA96=4E ;28?C82;@2 C< >CJ25 3< )0 DC67=96 3;E A3<C< 7242>=42 42K92<625 6= :=5C>C@36C=; => 672 =4524 ( 72 3BB2??3;6 D3< 3 8=?5<:C67 3;5 234;C;8 < B243;;9: 72 4CA9;3?73<=A<24H25672 >3@667366723@@C52;66==IB?3@2=;6722J642:24C876<C52 =>6724=35D7C@7<7=D<672DC567=>6724=353<(>226 723@@C52;6D3<6==IB?3@23635C<63;@2=> )>226>4=: 672?2>62582=>6724=35A96C;672@4=<<2J3:C;36C=;C6C< 35:C662567366723@@C52;66==IB?3@2C;672:C55?2=>672 4=35;B249<3?C6C<=A<24H2567363<B24J)672 3@@C52;66==IB?3@2;=6C;672:C55?2=>6724=353<% @3:2 6= 672 4C876 => 672 4=35 3;5 672 =>>2;5C;8 H27C@?2 53<725 672 3BB2??3;6L< H27C@?2 >4=: A27C;5 96 DC67=96 @=;<C524C;8672<23<B2@6<672 4CA9;3?72?5673667242C<3 - 5 - @=;64CA96=4E;28?C82;@2=>)0=;6723BB2??3;6 @?3C:3;6 D7C@742K9C42<42@=;<C52436C=; = A96642<< 7C< 3489:2;6 672 @=9;<2? >=4 672 3BB2??3;6 @?3C:3;642?C259B=;672@C636C=;42B=4625C;CHC? BB23? =') * )) A26D22; 34C<C;8 =96 => = ' ) *D7C@7D3<72?53<>=??=D< 5:C6625?E 672 @73482<7226 D3< >C?25 383C;<6 672 54CH24=> @2#27C@?2A234C;8;9:A246C<>=4 672;<943;@2=:B3;E6=5C<B4=H2672;28?C82;@2A96C6 >3C?256=5=<= 2>96C;8672<9A:C<<C=;<=>672?234;25@=9;<2? >=4 672 3BB2??3;6 ?234;25 @=9;<2? >=4 672 42<B=;52;6< - 6 - 348925 6736 672 3BB2??3;6 7C:<2?> @3:2 6= 672 2J642:2 4C876<C52=>6724=353;5@=;64CA9625>=46723@@C52;6A96 =; 42@=;<C52436C=; 672 @=;64CA96=4E ;28?C82;@2 => )0 >CJ259B=;6723BB2??3;6C<244=;2=9<3;5C642K9C4256=A2 <263<C52 * 72 3BB2??3;6 7C:<2?> D3< 2J3:C;25 3< % 3;572>C?25J'M=BE=>%=9;5246C>C@362J<(3;5 C<@734829::34C2<3?=;8DC67435C=?=8C@3?42B=46< 3;53?<=>C?25J)C<3AC?C6E246C>C@362C<<925AE672 25C@3?=345249<3?=>672C<3AC?C6E246C>C@362<7=D< 673672<9<63C;25>=??=DC;8C;G94C2< C$ ?225C;8>4=:4C876234;=625 CC$ 3@243625 D=9;5 =H24 ?2>6 C;52J >C;824 DC67 2JB=<942=><=>66C<<923;5@9662;5=; CCC$ 3C; 3;5 62;524;2<< =H24 4C876 D4C<6 >43@6942 A=67A=;2<=>4C876>=4234: CH$ 3C; 3;5 62;524;2<< ;=625 =H24 ?=D24 A3@I 428C=; H$ A43<C=;=H24>=427235'J)@: < B24 J( M C<@73482 9::34E C<<925 AE 672 3<7=53=<BC63?72D3<35:C6625=; ) 3;5 - 7 - 5C<@734825 =; (*) ; 672 5C<3AC?C6E @246C>C@362 C<<925 AE 672 25C@3? =345 C6 D3< <63625 6736 72 D3< 6423625 AE & >=4 >43@6942 435C9< => 4C876 <C52 3;5 ?2>6 73;5<=>66C<<92B4=@259423;5@=;<24H36CH264236:2;6=> ) >43@6942@24HC@3? ' >43@6942 3;54C876<@3B9?34 >43@6942 3;5 C6 D3< 3?<= =A<24H25 6736 67242 D3< 3 :3?9;C625>43@6942=>4C876<@3B9?3C;H=?HC;8?36243?A=4524 3;5 :3?9;C625 >43@6942 => 5C<63? 2;5 4C876 435C9< DC67 C;643346C@9?34 2J62;<C=; 3;5 >C;3??E 3<<2<<25 672 5C<3AC?C6E 3< 0 72 4CA9;3? 73HC;8 @=;<C52425 '45 => 672 5C<3AC?C6E<6362563I2;672<3:23< 096672 @=9;<2? >=4 672 3BB2??3;6 73< >3C4?E @=;62;525 6736 72 <9<63C;25>=94>43@6942<3;5<63625673672<9<63C;25@49<7 C;G94E => ?2>6 73;5 >43@6942< => H2462A43 3;5 <2H243? >43@6942< C;@?95C;8 7C< <BC;2 67242>=42 67C< =946 >C;5< G9<63;5423<=;3A?26=63I26725C<3AC?C6E3<'0 ) 2 D3< 3825 E234< D=4IC;8 3< =?5<:C67 3;53<B24672 2694;<7C<C;@=:2D3<3?4235E63I2; - 8 - 3<< ) B24:=;673;5C6;225<;=C;624>242;@23;5 672 :25C@3? 2JB2;<2< 843;625 AE 672 4CA9;3? C2 <( ;225<;=C;624>242;@2@@=45C;8?E7C<?=<< =>>96942C;@=:2D=9?5@=:2<6=<( ( " )J )J 'J'0$ ' ;524 672 7235< =<< => :2;C6C2< 3;5 3C; 3;59>>24C;867C<=946>C;5<423<=;3A?26=2;73;@2672 @=:B2;<36C=; 6= < 3;5 < 72 3:=9;6 3?4235E 843;625 9;524 672 7235 &==5 =94C<7:2;6 3;5 662;53;6 73482< ;225< ;= C;624>242;@2 ;5246727235M=<<=>C;@=:2594C;8?3C59B B24C=5 67C< =946 72?5 6736 72 :C876 ;=6 73H2 5=;2 3;E D=4I 36?23<6 >=4 3 B24C=5 => >=94 :=;67< 67242>=42 B4=@225<6=843;63;3:=9;6=>< " )J$ ; 3?? 672 6=63? @=:B2;<36C=; D=9?5 @=:2< 6= < '( DC67 C;6242<6 36 (0 B24 3;;9: >4=: 672 5362=>B26C6C=;6C??6725362=>423?CN36C=; - 9 - ( 72 3D345 => @=:B2;<36C=; B3<<25 AE 672 4CA9;3?C<:=5C>C253<9;524 *+,- ./0120- =<<=>>96942C;@=:2 ( ( )3C;3;5<9>>24C;8 '=<<=>3:2;C6C2< 25C@3?2JB2;<2< ( &==5 ;=94C<7:2;6 3;5 3662;53;6@73482< (=<<=>234;C;8594C;8672?3C5 9BB24C=5>=4(:=;67< 1+3 4 @@=45C;8?E 672 3BB2??3;6 C< 2;6C6?25 >=4 3 6=63? @=:B2;<36C=; => -4 383C;<6 672 3D345 843;625 AE 672 4CA9;3? C2 2;6C6?25 >=4 3; 2;73;@25 @=:B2;<36C=;=>-554 ;67242<9?6672>=??=DC;8=4524C<B3<<25 C$ 723BB23?C< CC$ 72 @?3C:3;6 C< 2;6C6?25 >=4 672 6=63? @=:B2;<36C=;=>< '( DC67C;6242<6 36 (0 B24 3;;9: >4=: 672 5362 => B26C6C=; 6C??6725362=>423?CN36C=; - 10 - CCC$ 72 3:=9;6 843;625 AE 672 4CA9;3? C2 <* C< 3?4235E 52B=<C625 67242>=42 42<B=;52;6 =) C< 5C42@625 6= 52B=<C6 672 2;73;@25 @=:B2;<36C=; => <' DC67C;6242<6366724362=>(0>4=:6725362 =>67C<=4524 CH$ ; <9@7 52B=<C6 672 3BB2??3;6 C< B24:C6625 6= DC67543D 672 3:=9;6 3?=;8 DC67 C;6242<6 3@@4925=;C6 -,4 &%!! ( $ C<6= ?=