- 1 - ! "# $ ## #%% & &'%() & (( * ! " # ! $ %&& ' & (## && (## #&!) & & ! $ %&& &' Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ( *)+%' ( & & ( ( *!! & !! & * ( & ((& *+ * ! ,*+ ( & ( ( & & ,& & - $# %& -' ./ 011/220345 6/738 099:5/; <5 03; * 73 =7>/ < !! <? 3;7 <279/ 4047<3 =/8754/=/; ?<= 4./ <??/39/5 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947<35 * *+ *) 03; ! <? 73 < !! <34./ ?72/ <?4./2/0=3/; ;;2 /557<35 :;8/ 7@0A01:=0 0=/ 5//B738 4< 5/4 057;/ 4./ @:;8>/34 <? 9<3C7947<3 03; <=;/= <? 5/34/39/ ;04/; *!! 9<3C794738 ?<= 4./ <??/39/5 1:375.062/ :3;/=/947<35*+ * 03;! <?03;5/34/39738 4<:3;/=8<57>12/7>1=75<3>/34?<=01/=7<;<? ><34.5 03;4<10A?73/<?5 !!! /09. 73;/?0:244<10A?73/ - 3 - 4< :3;/=8< 57>12/ 7>1=75<3>/34 ?<= ;0A5 ?<= 4./ <??/39/1:375.062/:3;/=/947<3*+=/0;D74./947<3*+ <? 4<:3;/=8<=78<=<:57>1=75<3>/34?<=01/=7<;<?* A/0=503;4<10A?73/<?5* !!! /09. 73;/?0:244<10A ?73/ 4< :3;/=8< 57>12/ 7>1=75<3>/34 ?<= <3/ ><34. ?<= 4./ <??/39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947<3 * =/0; D74. /947<3*+<?03;4<:3;/=8<57>12/7>1=75<3>/34?<= 01/=7<;<?*><34.503;4<10A?73/<?5 !!! /09. 73 ;/?0:244<10A?73/ 4<:3;/=8<57>12/7>1=75<3>/34?<= ;0A5 ?<= 4./ <??/39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947<3 ! =/0; D74./947<3*+<? ./?0945<?4./905/736=7/?0=/4.04 ,4./C7947>D.<D0508/;A/0=5 2<;8/;4./ ?7=54 73?<=>047<3 0807354 099:5/; <5 4< * 022/8738 9<>>7557<3 <? <??/39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947<35 * *+ *) 03;! <? 9<34/3;7384.04<3!*!!! 04 *! 1> 099:5/;<5 4< * ?<=9762A B7;3011/; ./= 03;5./D0540B/3730//16A9=7>73022A7347>7;047384< - 4 - 90:5/ ;/04. 03; D=<38?:22A 9<3?73/; 73 4./ .<:5/ <? 099:5/;< 03;204/=099:5/;<9<>>744/;=01/<3 ./=739/ 4./011/220345./=/736/738099:5/;<503; * D/=/ 0659<3;738 0 51274:1 9.0=8/ 5.//4 90>/ 4< 6/ ?72/; ./>073905/73<! !! D054=7/;0807354 099:5/;<3747022A 099:5/;<D0509E:744/;?<=4./ <??/39/ ./ 404/ .0; 9.022/38/; 4./ 507; 09E:74402 6A 1=/?/==738 =7>7302 11/02 <* !! 6/?<=/ 4.75 <:=4 ./ 7C757<3 /39. <? 4.75 <:=4 C7;/ @:;8>/34 ;04/; !!!* 022<D/; 4./ 011/02 03; 099:5/; < D05 9<3C794/; ?<= 4./ <??/39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947<35 * *+ *) 03; ! <? 3 4./ >/0347>/ 099:5/; <5 03; * D/=/ 011=/./3;/; 03; 4./A D/=/ 4=7/; 6A 4./ =702 <:=4 73 < !! 739/ 4./ 099:5/; .0C/ 12/0;/; 3<4 8:724A 1=<5/9:47<3 /F0>73/; ,5 4< 03; 8<4 >0=B/; F5 4< 7;/347?7/; 73 5:11<=4<?745 9<34/347<3./099:5/;.0C/3<4 2/; 03A /C7;/39/ 73 4./7= ;/?/39/ ./ =702 <:=4 0?4/= - 5 - 40B738734<9<357;/=047<34.//347=/>04/=70250C072062/<3 =/9<=; 90>/ 4< 4./ 9<392:57<3 4.04 4./ 1=<5/9:47<3 75 5:99/55?:2731=<C7384./8:724<?4./099:5/;?<=4./06<C/ 507; <??/39/5 03; 099<=;7382A 1055/; 4./ 7>1:83/; @:;8>/34 <? 9<3C7947<3 03; <=;/= <? 5/34/39/ /738 088=7/C/; 6A 4./ 50>/ 099:5/; <5 03; * 0=/ 6/?<=/ 4.75<:=4 * &/0=; =7 .7C0303; 044035./447 2/0=3/; 9<:35/2 011/0=738 ?<= 4./ 011/220345 03; =70>0;0= .0.06:;;73 2/0=3/; & ?<= =/51<3;/34404/ /=:5/;4./>04/=7025 7392:;7384./=702<:=4=/9<=;5 + 3 C7/D <? 4./ =7C02 9<34/347<35 :=8/; 6A 4./ 2/0=3/; 9<:35/2 ?<= 4./ 011/220345 4./ 1<734 4.04 D<:2; 0=75/?<=>A9<357;/=047<375 - 6 - A035D/= 4< 4./ 06<C/1<734 75G H ?<=4./?<22<D738 , 75 4./ C7947> ./ 2<;8/; 4./ ?7=54 73?<=>047<3051/=F0807354099:5/;<54<*4 754./51/97?799<34/347<3<?4./1=<5/9:47<34.04 099:5/; <5 4< * 4<8/4./= B7;3011/; 4./ >73<= 87=2 08/; * A/0=503;099:5/;<503;* .0;B3<D3?:22AD/224.04 5./ 75 27B/2A 4< 6/ ?<=9/; 4< .0C/ 7227974 734/=9<:=5/ D74. 099:5/; < 03; 4./=/6A 9<>>744/; 4./ <??/39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947<3 * <? 4 75 3<4 4./ 9<34/347<3 <? 4./ 1=<5/9:47<3 4.04 4./5/ 099:5/; .0C/ 9<>>744/; 4./ <??/39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947<3 *) <? ./ 9.0=8/ 0807354 4./5/ 099:5/; 75 <32A ?<= 4./ <??/39/51:375.062/:3;/=/947<35* *+03;! <? ) 10=4?=<>,4./C7947> 7475<32A,*4./ ><4./= <? 4./ C7947> D.< .05 5:11<=4/; 4./ 905/ <? 1=<5/9:47<322<4./=D743/55/5.0C/4:=3/;.<5472/475 - 7 - 1/=473/344<3<4/4.04 ;:=7389=<55/F0>73047<3<?, 2/0=3/; 9<:35/2 ?<= 4./ 011/220345 51/97?79022A 5:88/545 4.04 099:5/; < D05 73 4./ @//1 03; 4./ C7947> D05 B7;3011/; 6A 099:5/; <5 03; * 4 75 4./ ?0402 5:88/547<34<,;:=7389=<55/F0>73047<34D05025< 5:88/54/; 4.04 5./ D05 40B/3 4< 4./ .<:5/ <? 099:5/; <03;D059<3?73/;4./=/73 ,*5:11<=455:9.9<34/347<350A7384.04 4./ C7947> D05 =/59:/; ?=<> 4./ .<:5/ <? 099:5/; < <=/<C/= 099:5/; < 75 025< 9<3C794/; 6A 4./ 7C757<3 /39.<?4.75<:=4?<=4./5/<??/39/502<38D74./947<3 *) <?C/34.<:8.,5 +4< *03;+.0C/ 4:=3/; .<5472/ 4./ /C7;/39/ <? ,5 03; * ?:22A 5:11<=4/; 4./ 905/ <? 4./ 1=<5/9:47<3 D74. =/80=; 4< 9<>>7557<3<?4./<??/39/51:375.062/:3;/=/947<3* 03; *+ <? 6A 4./5/ 011/220345 ;< 3<4 ?73; 03A =/05<3 4< ;756/27/C/ 4./7= C/=57<3 3;/= 4./5/ 97=9:>54039/5 0><?4./<1737<34.044./011/2203450=/ - 8 - 27062/ ?<= 9<3C7947<3 ?<= 4./ 06<C/ 507; <??/39/5 739/ 4./=/ 0=/ 59034A /C7;/39/ ?<= .0C738 9<>>744/; 4./ <??/39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947<3 ! <? 0807354 4./ 011/220345 4./A0=//34742/;?<=0309E:74402 44.755408/ 2/0=3/;9<:3972?<=4./011/220345 1=0A5 4< 5.<D 2/37/39A 73 ?0C<:= <? 4./ 011/220345 73 5/34/39738 4./> 5739/ 4./ ;04/ <? <??/39/ D05 !*!!! 03;06<:4A/0=5.0C/02=/0;A2015/;:4 4./ ?094 =/>0735 4.04 4./5/ 011/220345 =/>073/; 0659<3;738 03; 51274 :1 9.0=8/ 5.//4 90>/ 4< 6/ ?72/; 0807354 4./> D.79. 9<34=76:4/; 4< 4./ ;/20A 73 4=702 &<D/C/= 9<357;/=738 4./ ?094 4.04 4./5/ 011/220345 .0C/ 3<4 9<>>744/; 4./ <??/39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947<3 *) <? 0><?4./<1737<34.042/37/39A9036/5.<D373 4./7=?0C<:= ! .0C/8<3/4.=<:8.4./7>1:83/;@:;8>/34<? 9<3C7947<303;<=;/=<?5/34/39/1055/;6A4./=702<:=4 D.79..0540B/3734<9<357;/=047<34./>04/=7025<3=/9<=; - 9 - 03; 9<3C794/; 4./ 011/220345 ?<= 4./ <??/39/5 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947<35 * 03; *+ <? 6:4 9<>>744/; 03 /==<= 73 9<3C794738 4./> /C/3 ?<= 4./ <??/39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/=/947<3! <?./=/?<=/ 0><?4./<1737<3 4.04 4./ 7>1:83/; @:;8>/34 <? 9<3C7947<3 03; <=;/= <? 5/34/39/ 90225 ?<= 734/=?/=/39/ 99<=;7382A 035D/= 4./ 06<C/1<73410=42A734./0??7=>047C/03;1=<9//;4<1055 4./?<22<D738 %7' ./011/0275 I %77' ./ @:;8>/34 <? 9<3C7947<3 03; <=;/= <? 5/34/39/ ;04/; *!! 1055/; 73 < !!<34./?72/<?4./2/0=3/; ;;747<302/557<35:;8/ 7@0A01:=075 ><;7?7/;I %777' ./011/2203450=/<?4./<??/39/ 1:375.062/:3;/= I - 10 - %7C' ./ ?73/ 0><:34 ;/1<574/; %7? 03A' 75 <=;/=/;4<6/=/?:3;/;4<4./011/220345<3 ;:/7;/347?79047<3 %C' ./ @:;8>/34 <? 9<3C7947<3 =/?/==/; 4< 06<C/ 9<3C794738 4./ 011/220345 ?<= 4./ <??/39/5 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947<3 * 03; *+ <? 75 9<3?7=>/; 6:4 4./ <=;/= <3 5/34/39/ ;04/; *!! 75 ><;7?7/; 05:3;/= %0' ./ 011/220345 5.022 :3;/=8< 57>12/7>1=75<3>/34?<=01/=7<; <? 4D< ><34.5 03; 10A ?73/ <? 5* !!! /09. 3 ;/?0:24 4< 10A ?73/ 4./A 5.022 :3;/=8< 57>12/ 7>1=75<3>/34 ?<= <3/ ><34.?<=4./<??/39/1:375.062/ :3;/= %6' ./ 011/220345 5.022 :3;/=8< 57>12/7>1=75<3>/34?<=01/=7<; <? <3/ ><34. 03; 10A ?73/ <? 5 !!! /09. 3 ;/?0:24 4< - 11 - 10A ?73/ 4./A 5.022 :3;/=8< 57>12/ 7>1=75<3>/34 ?<= ?7?4//3 ;0A5 ?<= 4./ <??/39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= %C7' ./011/2203450=//34742/;?<=5/4<?? %C77' ./ 5:6540347C/ 5/34/39/5 5.022 =:3 9<39:==/342A ??79/ 75 ;7=/94/; 4< 5/3; 609B 4./ =702 <:=4 =/9<=;502<38D74.09<1A<?4.75@:;8>/34?<=73?<=>047<3 03;?<=3/9/550=A0947<3 +) &##( $ ,# 754<2< #