- 1 - ! " # $% # $% ## &'( ) ! " #$ % $ ! " $$ % & ! " Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $' % ! % ( )*(*&'+ # ! % % ! % )*(*&'+ * ! " $# % ! % ( )*(*&'+ &, ! '# '$'$& #- * +& .(( / '.'.$'$$ 0((!$'$' / - 3 - / % % 1 1 % % 1 234566758349387:;<=27>4?@5>A7BC65><A5883>D 3> E?74=3B> =27 F?:DC7>= 5>: 5G5@: :5=7: '.'.$'$$ 65447: 3> B0((!$'$' ;< =27 B?@= B9 =27 7>3B@ 3H38?:D75>:9B@42B@=I@3;?>58J23>A2B83 $ 27:5=7B95AA3:7>=:75=2B95KC5>G2B34 =272?4;5>:B9A853C5>= B 5>:95=27@B9A853C5>= B4$ 5>: & 3>HB8H7C7>= B9 H723A87 5>: 835;383=< =B 65< =27 ABC67>45=3B> 34 >B= 3> :346?=7 27 B>8< :346?=7 34 G3=2 @7D5@:=BE?5>=?CB9ABC67>45=3B> & 75@: @3 5>F?>5=2 5885<<5427==< 875@>7: AB?>478 56675@3>D 9B@ 5667885>=!>4?@5>A7 BC65>< 5>: - 4 - @377@5>5DB?:558365=38875@>7:AB?>47856675@3>D9B@ @746B>:7>= B4 =B& # @3 5>F?>5=2 5885<<5427==< B> =GB D@B?>:4 A5887:3>E?74=3B>=27F?:DC7>=5>:5G5@:65447:;<=27 @3;?>58 >7 B> =27 AB?>= =25= 54 67@ 85G 853: :BG> ;< =27 B>J;87 67K B?@= 3> =27 A547 B9 H4 4B95@545::3>DB9 9?=?@76@B467A=4=2745C742B?8:25H7;77>$*L3>4=75: B9#'L54254;77>=5M7>;<=27@3;?>5843>A77H7>54 67@ =27 @746B>:7>=4 =27 :7A7547: G54 CB@7 =25> #* <75@45>:5467@=276B4=CB@=7C@76B@=27G54#'<75@4 37 27 G54 5;BH7 &. <75@4 5>: 47AB>: D@B?>: 34 3> @7467A= B9 :7:?A=3B> =BG5@:4 =27 67@4B>58 7K67>474 B9 :7A7547:4=27A853C5>=45@7B>8<=2@773>>?C;7@=27 @3;?>58B?D2==B25H7:7:?A=7: !&@:3>4=75:B9 !#=254 254 ;77> 278: ;< =27 B>J;87 67K B?@= 3> =27 A547 B9 H4 $ > =2747 =GB AB?>=4 27 4?;C3=4 =25==27 566758 ;7 588BG7: $' + 00(' $$''. $.( - 5 - 5>:ABC67>45=3B>D@5>=7:;<=27@3;?>58;7CB:3937:5>: @7:?A7: * 79?=3>D=274?;C3443B>B9=27875@>7:AB?>478 9B@ =27 5667885>=!>4?@5>A7 BC65>< @3 77@5>5DB?:5 58365=38 9B@ A853C5>=4 H727C7>=8< 4?;C3=4 =25= 54 67@ 6B4=CB@=7C@76B@==275D7B9=27:7A7547:G54#'<75@4 5>:3>=7@C4B9:7A343B>3>J4A5474?6@53= 34?6=B#'<75@49?=?@76@B467A=434=B;75::7:5=#'L 5>: 43>A7 @746B>:7>= >B# G2B 34 584B =27 87D58 @76@747>=5=3H7 B9 A853C5>=4 3>A7 27 254 >B= FB3>7: =27 A853C5>=4 G2387 9383>D =27 A853C 67=3=3B> 27 254 =B ;7 AB?>=7:G2387:?A=3>D67@4B>587K67>474B9=27:7A7547: 27 @3;?>58 25H3>D =5M7> >B=7 B9 =27 7>=3@7 95A=4 254 6@B67@8< 5::7: #'L 3>4=75: B9 $*L =BG5@:4 9?=?@7 6@B467A=45>::7:?A=7: !#=23>4=75:B9 !&@:54254;77> A853C7:;<=275667885>=!>4?@5>A7BC65><5>:5G5@:7: 6@B67@ABC67>45=3B>?>:7@=27275:I8B44B9:767>:7>A<J 7 254 9?@=27@ 4?;C3==7: =25= =27 @3;?>58 254 >B= 6@B67@8< 5G5@:7: ABC67>45=3B> ?>:7@ =27 275: ) 938358 - 6 - AB>4B@=3?C3>H37GB985G 853::BG>;<=27B>J;8767K B?@= 3> =27 A547 B9 H4 ! & 5>: 477M4 =B 5G5@: 566@B6@35=7 ABC67>45=3B> 5>: 4B?D2= =B :34C344 =27 566758 0 5H3>D 275@: =27 875@>7: AB?>478 9B@ =27 65@=37467@?47:7>=3@75667586567@4=27B>8<6B3>==25= GB?8:5@3479B@AB>43:7@5=3B>34% + ?@5>4G7@=B=275;BH76B3>=9B@AB>43:7@5=3B> 3465@=8<3>5993@C5=3H79B@=279B88BG3>D% ( :C3==7:8<7H7>5AAB@:3>D=B=276B4=CB@=7C @76B@==27:7A7547:G54#'<75@4B8:467@:7A343B>3> A5474?6@5G23A2254;77>@797@@7:;< 2 $' ($+($ - 7 - =27 @3;?>58 3> 65@5D@562 B $ 5= 65D7 $& B9 =27 F?:DC7>= 278: =25= =27 B>J;87 67K B?@= 254 A875@8< B;47@H7:=25==27:7A7547:3>=27453:A547G54&.<75@4 37;78BG#'<75@45AAB@:3>D8<#'L254;77>=5M7>> =27A547B>25>:5467@=276B4=CB@=7C@76B@==275D7 B9=27:7A7547:G54#'<75@4>=25=H37GB9=27C5==7@ =27 @3;?>58 254 7@@7: 3> 5::3>D =27 9?=?@7 6@B467A=4 5= #'L3>4=75:B9$*L . 27>7K=6B3>=B>G23A2=27875@>7:AB?>4789B@ =27 5667885>=!>4?@5>A7 BC65>< A5>H5447: 34 B> :7:?A=3B> =BG5@:4 67@4B>58 7K67>474 4 67@ =27 A853C 67=3=3B> B>8< G397 5>: =GB A238:@7> 25H7 9387: =27 A853C 67=3=3B> G27@754 =27 B=27@ 4B> 254 >B= FB3>7: =27 25>:4 G3=2 =27 A853C5>=4 234 A875@8< 42BG4 =25= 27 34 >B= :767>:5>= B> =27 :7A7547: > H37G B9 =25= =27 @3;?>58 B?D2= =B 25H7 =5M7> =27 :7:?A=3B> =BG5@:4 67@4B>58 7K67>474B9=27:7A7547:5= !&@:3>4=75:B9 !#=254254 ;77> 278: ;< =27 B>J;87 67K B?@= 3> J4 A5474?6@5 - 8 - ' BG7H7@=27@3;?>5825495387:=BAB>43:7@=27 85G 853: :BG> ;< =27 B>J;87 67K B?@= 3> J45>:J4A54744?6@5G27@73>75A2B9=27 87D58@76@747>=5=3H745@77>=3=87:9B@938358AB>4B@=3?C7H7> =2B?D2 =27 @746B>:7>= >B# 254 >B= FB3>7: =27 A853C5>= B4 =B&G23879383>D=27A853C67=3=3B>?=27;73>D=27 87D58 @76@747>=5=3H74 B9 :7A7547: 34 7>=3=87: 9B@ 938358 AB>4B@=3?C 3> =7@C4 B9 =27 85G 853: :BG> ;< =27 B>J;87 67K B?@= 4=5=7: 4?6@5 4 =27@7 5@7 9B?@ 87D58 @76@747>=5=3H74 75A2 5@7 7>=3=87: 9B@ 4#''''!N ?>:7@ =27 275: 938358 AB>4B@=3?C AAB@:3>D8< =234 B?@= 5>4G7@7: =27 6B3>= 9B@ AB>43:7@5=3B> 65@=8< 3> 5993@C5=3H7 5>: B> @7N:7=7@C3>5=3B> =27 ABC67>45=3B> =BG5@:4 8B44 B9:767>:7>A<GB?8:ABC74549B88BG4% 4 &$*'!NO$*LK $K *K$!&P .(+*''!N 27 @3;?>58 254 ABCC3==7: 7@@B@ 3> 5G5@:3>D ABC67>45=3B>?>:7@=27AB>H7>=3B>58275:427@79B@754 67@ =27 :7A343B> B9 =27 B>J;87 67K B?@= 3> 5>: J4 A5474 =27A853C5>=4 - 9 - 37=27G3975>:A238:@7>B9=27:7A7547:5@77>=3=87:=B 4#''''!N 75A2 ?>:7@ =27 275: I*++ ,-+./0123 5>:I8++0*04*,-+./0123 $ ?@=27@3>H37GB9=27F?:DC7>=B9=27B>J;87 67KB?@=3>=27A547B9 " # !" $ % &#=27@742588;75>7>25>A7C7>=B9 'L B> =27 AB>H7>=3B>58 275:4 9B@ 7H7@< =2@77 <75@4 5M3>D 3>=B AB>43:7@5=3B> =27 45C7 =27 ABC67>45=3B> 5G5@:7: =BG5@:4 I8B44 B9 AB>4B@=3?CJ ;73>D 4 0''''!N =27 74A585=3B> 5= $'L GB@M4 B?= =B 4&$'''!N AAB@:3>D8< =27 A853C5>=4 5@7 7>=3=87: 9B@ 5 4?CB9 4 .$'''!N 4 0''''O$'L=BG5@:45*++ ,-+./0123 3>A8?:3>D I*++ +61+4* 5>: 0*04* -+./0123 & ?@=27@5ABC67>45=3B>B9 4 *'''!N75A234 5G5@:7: ?>:7@ =27 275: 5*++ 7+/4/73 5>: 51-7.4* #$'$$$+0+ - 10 - 7867-+7+3 @7467A=3H78< 58B>D G3=2 $'L 74A585=3B> 27@79B@7 4&0'''!N 4 *''' K $ O $'L =BG5@:4 5*++7+/4/734>:51-7.4*7867-+7+3 # 2?4 3> 588 =27 A853C5>=4 5@7 7>=3=87: 9B@ @75447447:ABC67>45=3B>549B88BG4% B44767>:7>A< % 4 .(+*''!N B44B9B>4B@=3?C % 4 .$'''!N B44 B9 4=5=7 - ?>7@58 K67>474 % 4 &0'''!N % + ""9 * 27 =B=58 ABC67>45=3B> @7N:7=7@C3>7: ;< =234 B?@= GB@M4 B?= =B 4$$ **''!N 54 5D53>4= 4$*+#$*'!N5G5@:7:;<=27@3;?>58 0 B@ =27 9B@7DB3>D @754B>4 =234 B?@= 6@BA77:4 =B6544=279B88BG3>D% 3 27566758344**:7;0-64./, - 11 - 33 27F?:DC7>=5>:5G5@:65447:;<=27@3;?>583> 5G5@: :5=7: '.'.$'$$ 3> B0((!$'$' 65447: ;< =27 7>3B@ 3H38 ?:D7 5>: 23>A2B83 34 CB:3937: ;< @7:?A3>D =27 ABC67>45=3B> 9@BC 4$*+#$*'!N =B 4$$ **''!N, 333 27 A853C5>=4 5@7 7>=3=87: 9B@ ABC67>45=3B> B9 + ""9 58B>D G3=2 3>=7@74= 5= 0L 67@ 5>>?C 9@BC =27 :5=7 B9 9383>D B9 =27 67=3=3B> =388 @7583Q5=3B>, 3H 27 5CB?>= 3> :76B43= ;7 =@5>4C3==7: =B =27 AB>A7@>7:@3;?>589B@:34;?@47C7>=9B@=2G3=2, H 27 5667885>=!>4?@5>A7 BC65>< 42588 :76B43= ;585>A75CB?>=58B>DG3=23>=7@74=5==27@5=7B9 0L 67@ 5>>?C 9@BC =27 :5=7 B9 67=3=3B> =388 @7583Q5=3B> G3=23> 43K G77M4 9@BC =27 :5=7 B9 @7A736= B9 5 AB6< B9 =234 B@:7@ ;79B@7 =27 AB>A7@>7:@3;?>58, - 12 - H3 34;?@47C7>= 54 G788 54 566B@=3B>C7>= B9 =27 ABC67>45=3B> 5CB?>= 42588 ;7 54 67@ =27 3C6?D>7:B@:7@B9=27@3;?>58, H33 BB@:7@54=BAB4= > H37G B9 :346B458 B9 C53> 566758 67>:3>D 3>=7@8BA?=B@< 56683A5=3B> 39 5>< :B74 >B= 4?@H3H7 9B@ AB>43:7@5=3B>5>:5AAB@:3>D8<:34C3447: ;9 &# ( % ;9 &( % !34= B% 8 B%$( %