- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &'( ) ! " # $% & ' %% ( % )'('* ! % ! +$+ $% *% ,,! " #% +!- ',!!,!' ' & %+ + '(#'& + % %+ % $% '*,!!,!, $ $%+ % % ('!,'( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ++ $% % .%$ $ # .%$& /01234/01567/839:;<:349=2/9 ! 4=9 0>>/0? =9 ;=?/2 050=893 34/ @6257/83 082 0A012203/2'*,!!,!,>099/2<B34//8=:1=C=?$625/ 082 $%+ 082 % % 6102 =8 % :(' :; !,'( 4/;0D39:;34/D09/01/3403:8! ',!,'34/ 21=C/1:;34/C/4=D?/</01=85/5 :%!!(( 21:C/ =3=810940828/5?=5/837088/10822094/2=33:08:34/1 C/4=D?/ </01=85 /5 :%') (*, 26/ 3: A4=D4 34/D?0=708396930=8/251=/C:69082;10D361/=8@61=/9 ) 4/ =8@61/2 D?0=7083 05/2 ! B/019 ;=?/2 0 D?0=7 >/3=3=:8 </;:1/ 34/ 1=<680? D?0=7=85 D:7>/8903=:8 :; 9,,,,, 4/ 1=<680? D:89=2/1=85 34/ /83=1/ - 3 - /C=2/8D/ :8 1/D:12 51083/2 D:7>/8903=:8 :; 9(!!,, A=34 =83/1/93 03 E >0 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; >/3=3=:83=??1/0?=903=:80822=1/D3/2<:341/9>:82/83 :9' 082!3:2/>:9=334/907/ 551=/C/2<B34/90=2@6257/830820A01234/ =8@61/2 D?0=7083 409 >1/;/11/2 34=9 0>>/0? =8 A4=D4 =3 =9 D:83/82/2 3403 34/ 0>>/??083 409 96930=8/2 ;:??:A=85 =8@61=/909>/1FG=8@61BD/13=;=D03/ '& /02=8@61BA=34#3&9=2/ !& +0D/%6?3=>?/9A=349A/??=85 & #3&34=549A/??=85 )& #3&?/5 / 3::H 31/037/83 ;1:7 ! ',!,' 3: ,'!!,' 4/1/=994:13/8=85:;?/5<BD70827:7/83:;1=543 H8// =9 1/931=D3/2 !:D3:1 099/99/2 34/ 2=90<=?=3B 03 ,E 3: 34/ A4:?/ <:2B <63 34/ 1=<680? /11/2 =8 30H=85 34/ 2=90<=?=3B 03 !E :8?B 4:654 4/ A09 /018=85 9' ,,, >/1 7:834 082 ;=?/2 0 >0B 9?=> 34/ 1=<680? - 4 - /11/2=830H=854=9=8D:7/039',,,,>/17:834082 34691/I6/93/2;:1/8408D/7/83:;34/D:7>/8903=:8 /018/2D:689/?;:11/9>:82/83 :!896108D/ :7>08B D:83/82/2 3403 34/ 1=<680? 409 D:89=2/1/2 '12:;,E2=90<=?=3B09!E9:0?9:34/=8D:7/:;34/ 0>>/??083 A09 30H/8 03 9',,,, >/1 7:834 1=543?B D:89=2/1=85 4=9 :DD6>03=:8 082 3469 =3 8//29 8: =83/1;/1/8D/ ( F =9 34/ 2=90<=?=3B D/13=;=D03/ 4/ 2:D3:1 =9 /F07=8/209!3A099655/93/23:4=734034/=98:3 34/ >/19:8 A4: 31/03/2 34/ >03=/83 <63 4/ :>=8/2 3403 34/1/=994:13/8=85:;1=543?/5<BD7082A/0H8/99:; 1=5434=>1=54334=540821=543?/53A09:<9/1C/2<B34/ 1=<680? 3403 F =9 8:3 96>>:13/2 <B 102=:?:5=D0? 1/>:133A090?9::<9/1C/2340334/<09=9;:1099/99=85 34/2=90<=?=3BA098:3D?/01?B7/83=:8/2<B34/:D3:14/ 0>>/??083 9303/2 3403 4/ =9 680<?/ 3: A0?H 082 93082 ;:1 ?:85 >/1=:2 4/ 1=<680? :<9/1C/2 3403 8: /C=2/8D/ =9 - 5 - >?0D/2 1/5012=85 ?:99 :; 7/7:1B 082 0DD:12=85?B 099/99/234/A4:?/<:2B2=90<=?=3B03!E /018/2 D:689/? ;:1 34/ 0>>/??083 9303/2 3403 0;3/134/0>>/??0837/3A=34080DD=2/834/A091/7:C/2 ;1:734/@:</A09A:1H=85090/8=:1/D48=D=08082 /018=85 9' ,,, >/1 7:834 082 4/ D088:3 5/3 4=9 >1/C=:69@:< 0824/ 70B 8:3 5/308B ;6361/:>>:1368=3B 63=3A09:<9/1C/2<B34/1=<680?34034/4098:3;=?/2 08B1/I6=1/22:D67/833:94:A34034/A091/7:C/2;1:7 9/1C=D/ 082 8:3 A:1H=85 08BA4/1/ 0;3/1 34/ 0DD=2/83 4:654 34/ 0>>/??083 409 ;=?/2 34/ >0B 9?=> 4/ 409 8:3 /F07=8/2 34/ /7>?:B/1 3: >1:C/ 4=9 =8D:7/ 4/1/;:1/ 34/ 1=<680? 409 30H/8 4=9 =8D:7/ 03 9',,,, >/1 7:834D:89=2/1=854=9:DD6>03=:808234=9:613;=8298: 1/09:83:=83/1;/1/A=3434/907/ * 9>/1FGA:682D/13=;=D03/34/0>>/??083 96930=8/2 4/02 =8@61B A=34 1=543 9=2/ ;0D/ 76?3=>?/ 9A=349A/??=851=54334=549A/??=850821=543?/5 082 =8@61B :9' 082 ) 01/ 51=/C:69 =8 80361/ / - 6 - 96930=8/2;10D361/:;7082=<?/;10D361/:;3=<=0082;=<6?0 0820?9:;10D361/:;JB5:703=D<:8/082:1<=3 ', /018/2 D:689/? ;:1 34/ 0>>/??083 70=8?B D:83/82/2340334/0>>/??08396930=8/2;:61;10D361/9082 ?:93 4=9 /7>?:B7/83 082 34/ 2=90<=?=3B 099/99/2 <B 34/ 1=<680?=98:3>1:>/1/A094:9>=30?=9/2;:10>/1=:2:; 20B9 4/1/;:1/ 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: D:89=2/134/2=90<=?=3B03),E=893/02:;!ED:89=2/1/2 <B 34/1=<680? 9 4/ A09 05/2 B/019 34/ 76?3=>?=/1 0>>?=D0<?/ =9 ' /8D/ 34/ 3:30? ?:99 :; ;6361/ /018=859 D:7/93:9',,,,F'!F'F),EK9(!,,,, '' 4/1/ =9 8: 2=9>63/ 1/5012=85 34/ 07:683 0A012/2 682/1 34/ 4/02 L7/2=D0? /F>/89/9M 03 9!',,,,/8D/=38//298:=83/1;/1/8D/ '! :89=2/1=85 34/ 80361/ :; =8@61=/9 082 34/ >/1=:2 :; 4:9>=30?=903=:8 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 51083 08 07:683 :; 9(,,, ;:1 >0=8 082 96;;/1=85 - 7 - 9!,,,;:1?:99:;07/8=3=/90829,,,,3:A0129 31089>:1303=:8/F3108:61=947/83082033/82083D4015/9 ' 4/ 1=<680? 409 0A012/2 08 07:683 :; 9'!,, ;:1 ?:99 :; =8D:7/ 261=85 31/037/83 >/1=:2 A4=D48//298:=83/1;/1/8D/ ') 4/1/;:1/ 34/ 0>>/??083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 34/ 7:2=;=/2D:7>/8903=:8682/12=;;/1/834/02909</?:A 0=808296;;/1=85 9(,,, %/2=D0?/F>/89/9 9!',,,, 1089>:1303=:8 /F310 8:61=947/83 082033/82083D4015/9 9,,,, :99 :; =8D:7/ 261=85 31/037/83 >/1=:2 9'!,, :99:;;6361//018=859 9(!,,,, :99:;07/8=3=/9 9!,,, :30? /990A012/2<B1=<680? 8408D/7/83 9',(!,, 9(!!,, *+ 469 34/ 0>>/??083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 /8408D/2 D:7>/8903=:8 :; 9,,,, A=34 =83/1/93 03 E >/1 0886708234/1/;:1/34/0>>/0?2/9/1C/93:</0??:A/2=8 >013 ' 834/1/96?334/;:??:A=85:12/1=9>099/2 - 8 - #=& >>/0?=90??:A/2=8>013 #==& 4/ 0>>/??083D?0=7083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 34/ /8408D/2 D:7>/8903=:8 :; 9,,,, A=34 =83/1/93 03 E >/1 08867 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; >/3=3=:8 3=?? 34/ 203/ :; 1/0?=903=:8 #===& /9>:82/83 :!896108D/ :7>08B =9 2=1/D3/2 3: 2/>:9=3 34/ 0;:1/90=2 D:7>/8903=:8 07:683 A=34=8:8/7:834;1:734/203/:;34=9@6257/83 #=C& 8 96D4 2/>:9=3 34/ 0>>/??083 =9 >/17=33/2 3: A=34210A 34/ /83=1/ 07:683 0?:85 A=34 =83/1/93 0DD16/2 :8=3 #C& /018/2 D:689/? ;:1 1/9>:82/83 :! =9 >/17=33/23:;=?/C0H0?034A=34=83A:A//H9 *,- &%!! ( $ =93 :'? :()