Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63620 (KAR)
NAGESH DOULATA BHAJANTRI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/201734/2025 · 2025-08-14
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63620 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63620 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #
$ #! # %"&'###
%"&'#&
(#)
! " #
$ %
"
" &$
' %
"
&(
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
! % $*'+
" $,'' #
% ''& '') % % % % - % %#
%
% $$'',
. "
'$$'' % % - # %
' % % '''
% -
% %
%
+ + /
/ %
- 3 -
" ! + / %#
012 34515167 12 89 :72:;;422<:= >33=1;>75 84<6?4 504 >?7>5>@> 5>54 AB17125?>51C4 ?18:7>= 17 >33=1;>5167 6'$$'';>==17D17E:4251675046?A4?6<A12B122>= 6< 504 2>1A >33=1;>5167 A>54A $$'', F04?489 504 AB17125?>51C4 ?18:7>= >==6F4A 504 >33=1;>5167 17 3>?5 504?489 245 >21A4 504 1B3:D74A 47A6?24B475 84>?17D 6,('$&$) A>54A '$$''' 3>224A 89 ?42367A475 6' C1A4 774G:?4H) 6F4C4? 504 ?18:7>=0>2A4;=174A56D?>75504<:?504??4=14<26:D0517 504 >33=1;>5167 14 504 A1?4;5167 56 ?42367A475 6' 56 122:4 3?6B65167 6?A4? 56 504 >33=1;>75 <?6B 504 3625 6< >?A4?5650436256<4>A>?A4?F0475041BB4A1>54 I:716?6<>33=1;>7514?42367A4756F>23?6B654A>2 504 7>B4 6< ?42367A475 6 >334>?2 >5 =6$) 17 774G:?4 89 ;6721A4?17D 504 ?43?42475>5167 A>54A $(''' C1A4 774G:?4& 04 ;0>==47D4 17 5012
- 4 -
34515167 12 56 504 6?A4? 3>224A 89 504 ?18:7>= 67=9 17 ?4234;56<5046?A4?>5!111# ' 048?14<6:5=1746<504<>;52=4>A17D56<1=17D6< 5043?4247534515167>?4>2:7A4?+ 04>33=1;>75F>2>3361754A>2>F>?A4?1750494>? '$':824E:47556012>336175B47504F>236254A56 475?>= ?1267
4==>?9 >7A F6?@4A 504?4 >2 04 0>2 ;6B3=454A 5F6 94>?2 6< 24?C1;4 >7A 012 3?68>5167>?9 34?16A 0>2 8447 A4;=>?4A 2>512<>;56?1=9 7 '$''' 504 24;67A?42367A4753:8=1204A 24716?159 =125 6< F>?A4?2 >2 67 $$'''$ 7 504 2>1A =125 504 7>B4 6< 504 >33=1;>75F>2206F7>5=6$&17?421A:>=3>?475;>A?4 =125>234?774G:?4' 75043?6C12167>=24716?159=125 A>54A
504 24;67A ?42367A475 >2 34? 504 4B6?>7A:B A>54A $',''' ;>==4A 504 24?C1;4 3>?51;:=>?26<F>?A4?2F06>?4F6?@17D17?421A:>=3>?475>= ;>A?4 >7A >=26 9A4?>8>A >?7>5>@> 4D167 ;>A?4 !)$# 6F4C4? 17 504 2>1A =125 504 7>B4 6< 504 >33=1;>75F>2765<6:7A04'7A43>?5B475>= ?6B65167
- 5 -
6BB15544! #F>2;672515:54A5606=A5043?6;44A17D2 67'&'''75042>1A3?6;44A17D25047>B46<504 >33=1;>75 0>2 765 8447 ;6721A4?4A <6? 3?6B65167 67 504 D?6:7A 50>5 > ?436?5 0>2 8447 2:8B1554A 56 504 6C4?7B47567504>==4D>516750>5674:2:? >;0>@0>7> F06 F>2 :217D 504 B681=4 17 504 ?1267 >7A 50>5 504 ?4>267 <6? 06=A17D 504 3?6B65167 6< 504 >33=1;>75 04 7>B46<504>33=1;>75>334>?2>5=6$'$>234?504 3?6;44A17D2A>54A'&'''!774G:?4H,#
:824E:475=9 ?42367A475 6' 3>224A 3?6B65167 6?A4? 67 ''' 56 504 F>?A4?2 17 504 ?421A:>= 3>?475>= ;>A?4 4G;=:A17D 504 7>B4 6< 504 >33=1;>75 17 504 3?6B65167 =125 F04?417 504 7>B4 6< 504 1BB4A1>54 I:716?6< 504 >33=1;>75 14 ?42367A475 6 17 504 >33=1;>5167 >334>?17D >5 =6$) F>2 206F7 >2 4=1D18=4 <6? 3?6B65167 !774G:?4# 04 345151674? 1BB4A1>54=9 ><54? 7651;17D 504 2>1A <>;5 2:8B1554A 012 A45>1=4A ?43?42475>5167 A>54A $(''' >7A ?4E:4254A ?42367A4756'56;6721A4?504;>7A1A>5:?4<6?3?6B65167
- 6 -
>2 34? 504 24716?
=125 !774G:?4 H &# 6 504 2>1A ?43?42475>5167 ?42367A475 6' 0>2 122:4A >7 47A6?24B47525>517D50>5>?436?50>284472:8B1554A56 5046C4?7B4755617151>54A12;13=17>?93?6;44A17D2>D>1725 504 >33=1;>75 67 504 >==4D>5167 25>54A 2:3?>!774G:?4H $)# DD?14C4A 89 504 2>1A 47A6?24B475 504 >33=1;>75 >33?6>;04A 504 ?18:7>= 17 504 3?42475 >33=1;>5167 C1A4 >33=1;>756'$$''<6?504<6==6F17D?4=14<2+
! "##$
" %
"
"
& ' ( ) (*+, -.+(/'0,'1 /( '' (/(( 23,14 (
%)
" 5&' (
6
& -
2 &- #7 & '/1 3,84 /'/. (/(( 9 3,0 " 6)! - 7 -
!:##
;!<
, 04345151674?>33=1;>750>25>@47<1C4D?6:7A2 84<6?45045?18:7>=25>517D0124=1D181=159%1?25=90412<:==9 4=1D18=4<6?3?6B65167<?6B50436256<>?A4?565043625 6<4>A>?A4?>234?50424716?159=125F04?4170127>B4 F>2 206F7 F01;0 0>2 8447 634?>54A 89 504 A43>?5B475 F01=4 122:17D 3?6B65167 4;67A=9 ?42367A475 6' 67 504 8>212 6< 3?6C12167>= 24716?159 =125 A>54A '$''' ;>==4A <6? 504 24?C1;4 3>?51;:=>?2 <?6B 504 4=1D18=4 ;>7A1A>5467$','''75042>1A=1255047>B46<504 >33=1;>75 >334>?2 >5 =6$& 17 504 ?421A:>= 3>?475>= ;>A?48:5F01=4122:17D5043?6B651675650436256<4>A >?A4?6?A4??42367A4756'4G;=:A4A5047>B46<504 >33=1;>75 17 504 >8247;4 6< >79 ;?1B17>= ;>24 6? A12;13=17>?93?6;44A17D347A17D>D>1725504>33=1;>752 2:;05043?6B65167;6:=A7650>C48447F15004=AB4?4=9 67 26B4 A12;13=17>?9 3?6;44A17D2;?1B17>= 3?6;44A17D2
- 8 -
3?63624A >D>1725 504 4B3=6944 17 504 >8247;4 6< >79 ;0>?D4 B4B6;0>?D4 20445 0>2 >=?4>A9 8447 122:4A >D>1725504345151674?04?4>?4762:;03?6;44A17D2>2 67 504 A>54 6< 3?6;44A17D2 6F4C4? 67=9 67 504 D?6:7A 50>5 26B4 3?6362>= 0>2 8447 B>A4 56 504 6C4?7B475<6?17151>517D26B4A12;13=17>?93?6;44A17D212 765 > D?6:7A 56 A4;=174 3?6B65167 56 504 345151674? 01?A=9040>22:8B1554A50>51<504>33=1;>7512765<6:7A <15<6?3?6B651676504?F124?42367A47576'206:=A0>C4 122:4A 206F ;>:24 7651;4 56 504 >33=1;>75 >2 504 3?6;4A:?4 >2 F4== >2 504 3?17;13=42 6< 7>5:?>= I:251;4 ;6754B3=>54 50>5 76 3?6B65167 >C47:4 ;6:=A 84 5>@47 >F>9 F1506:5 ;>:217D >79 7651;4
:5 504 3?6B65167 A4;=174A56504>33=1;>75F1506:524?C17D>797651;45601B >7A F1506:5 206F17D >79 4<<6?52 56 D45 504 4G3=>7>5167 <?6B 504 >33=1;>75 2 2:;0 504 >;5167 6< ?42367A475 6'121==4D>=>?815?>?9:7I:251<14A>7A765B>175>17>8=4 7501236175504345151674??4=14A67504I:ADB4756<1D0 6:?56<6=@>5>17504;>246<
- 9 -
?436?54A 17 !$((# $&( %6:?50=9 504 345151674? 0>2 ;67547A4A 50>5 504 24;67A ?42367A4750>2765122:4A>797651;456504>33=1;>7576? ;>==4A <6? 012 4G3=>7>5167 <6? F15006=A17D767 ;6721A4?>5167 6< 012 3?6B65167 <?6B 504 3?6B65167 =125 A>54A ''' F01;0 12 ;=4>?=9 17 C16=>5167 6< 504 3?17;13=42 6< 7>5:?>= I:251;4 >7A 568:55?422 012 >?D:B475 040>2?4=14A67504I:ADB4756< ?436?54A 17 !!" # $%& F04?417 504 ;66?A17>54 847;0 6< 5012;6:?50>204=A50>5= =
< >7A =>25=9 504 >33=1;>75 0>2 2:8B1554A > A45>1=4A ?43?42475>5167 56 ?42367A4756&25>517D50>5504I:716?F>23?6B654AC1A4 6?A4? A>54A ''' ?4E:42517D 56 ;6721A4?
012 3?6B65167 >5=4>25 <?6B 504 A>54 3?6B65167 D1C47 56 504 I:716?6F4C4??42367A4756'0>2765;6721A4?4A504 ;>24 6< 504 345151674? 67=9 67 504 D?6:7A 50>5 26B4
- 10 -
3?6362>=0>284472475565046C4?7B475>7AA4;=174A56 >;;435 504 ?43?42475>5167 >7A 122:4A 504 47A6?24B475 1B3:D74A17504>33=1;>5167
04A>542>?476517A123:5404 B44517D F>2 04=A 67 '&''' >7A =125 F>2 3?43>?4A 67 ''' >7A >AB1554A=9 504 >?51;=42 6< ;0>?D42 >=67D F1507651;4F>2122:4A67',$$'''>7A2:824E:475=9> ?43=9 F>2 D1C47 56 504 2>1A >?51;=42 6< ;0>?D42 89 504 345151674? 67 $$$'' 2 34? 504 6C4?7B475 6?A4? 84>?17D6 ''(A>54A$,)$((3>?>D?>30 6&12>33=1;>8=456504;>246<504345151674?>33=1;>75 & 4<:517D5042:8B12216726<504>33=1;>7584<6?4 504 ?18:7>= 504 =4>?74A <1=4A 504 25>54B475 6< 68I4;5167 ;67547A17D 50>5 504 A43>?5B475 F04?417 504 >33=1;>75 A12;0>?D17D 012 A:5142 12 > C4?9 2472151C4 A43>?5B475 6< 504 5>54 6C4?7B475 >7A 0>2 504 ?423672181=159 56 B>7>D4 , 3?12672 6< C>?16:2 ;>54D6?142 17 504 5>54 0424 , 3?12672 0>C4 >86:5 $&& 3?12674?2F0617;=:A4A?4>A4AD>7D254?254??6?1252B><1>
- 11 -
634?>56?2>7A;?1B17>=26<>==6504?;>54D6?14204?4>?4 >?6:7A$3?12676<<1;4?2>7A25><<6<C>?16:2?>7@2F06 B>7>D450424,3?126721750425>54512504A:596<>== 5046<<1;4?2>7AD:>?A17D25><<6<5043?1267256F>5;0>7A 24>?;0 504 3?12674?2 >7A 5041? 84=67D17D2 17 504 8>??>;@2;4==217F01;05049>?4;67<174A049206:=A84 C4?9C1D1=>75F01=4A12;0>?D17D504A:51427504;>2467 0>7A 15 12 7651;4A 50>5 > 34?267 89 7>B4 :2:? >;0>@0>7>:217D012B681=417504I>1=<6?4G56?516750>5 12 504 >==4D>5167 >D>1725 504 345151674? >7A >?51;=42 6< ;0>?D42F4?4122:4A<6?5042>1AA4?4=1;51676<A:592 34? 504 3?6C121672 6< >?7>5>@> ?12672 >7A 504 6??4;5167>= 4?C1;42 >7:>= ''$ :7A4? >?>D?>30 6'( 6< 0>354? -" >7A 2:8 3>?>2 !1# >7A !11# >5 504 51B4 6< =6;@ :3 504 D:>?A17D 34?26774= 20>== 24>?;0 504 8>??>;@2>7A3?12674?.284=67D17D506?6:D0=9>7A;67<1?B 50>5763?6018154A>?51;=42>?43?42475>7AF04504?504?4 >?4>79B681=42=6;>54AF15017504I>1=75012;6774;5167 504?4>?424C4?>=;1?;:=>?2>7A6<<1;1>=B4B6?>7A:BF4?4
- 12 -
122:4A 56 2563 504 :24 6< 3?6018154A >?51;=42 1721A4 504 3?126717;4504>33=1;>750>2765A12;0>?D4A012A:5917 ;67267>7;4F150504A1?4;516726<504;1?;:=>?2>7A>2F4== >2 504 4?C1;4 >7:>= ''$ 25>54A 047;4 504 A43>?5B475>= 47E:1?9 F>2 3?63624A 4 0>2 <:?504? 2:8B1554A 50>5 504 6C4?7B475 4B3=69442 F1== 84 ;6721A4?4A<6?3?6B6516717>;;6?A>7;4F150504>?7>5>@> 6C4?7B4754?C>752!4716?159#:=42$()675048>212 6< 24716?159 =67D F150 50>5 504 3?6B65167 <?6B 674 ;>A?4 56 504 3625 6< 74G5 01D04?
=4C4= ;>A?4 F1== 84 6824?C4A 89 504 ;?154?1> >2 2513:=>54A 17 504 6C4?7B475 1?;:=>?A>54A$')'0424?C1;43>?51;:=>?26<504 4B3=69442 F4?4 ;>==4A F01=4 B44517D <?6B 504 172515:5167 F04?4 5049 F4?4 3?42475=9 F6?@17D >5 50>5 36175 6< 51B4 7 504 ;>24 67 0>7A 217;4 504?4 F>2 > 3?6362>=<6?17151>517D>;5167>D>172501B<6?01274D=1D47;4 17 @44317D 504 ;=624 494 67 504 B6C4B4752 6< 504 3?12674?2 7 50424 ;1?;:B25>7;42 504 A43>?5B475 0>2 5>@47 24?16:2 7654 6< 15 >2 504 A43>?5B475 12 > C4?9
- 13 -
2472151C4 A43>?5B475 >7A 504 >==4D>51672 B>A4 >D>1725 01B >?4 24?16:2 17 7>5:?4 6721A4?17D 504 ;>24 504 47A6?24B475 0>2 8447 122:4A >2 04 12 765 47515=4A <6? 3?6B65167 7 504 3?42475 ;>24 504?4 F>2 =>324 67 504 3>?56<:34?17547A4756<504 ?1267F0684=67D256?6:3 J.;>A?4>7A5046C4?7B47512504A12;13=17>?9>:506?159 56 <?>B4 504 ;0>?D42 >D>1725 504 A4=17E:475 6<<1;4? 2 2:;0504?4;6BB47A>51672F4?4B>A4565046C4?7B475 56 17151>54 504 2>B4 C1A4 6<<1;4 =4554? A>54A $)''' 17;4504?4F>2>3?6362>=50447A6?24B475122:4A1217 >;;6?A>7;4 F150 =>F >7A 50>5 12 504 ?4>267 <6? 504 A43>?5B475 56 247A 504 3>?51;:=>?2 >7A 3?6362>= <6? 17151>517D 43>?5B475>= 7E:1?9 >7A 17 504 4C475 504 ;0>?D42 765 3?6C4A >7A 504 >33=1;>75 12 4G674?>54A 012 3?6B65167>234;5F6:=A84;6721A4?4A>22:;0504>;5167 ;6754B3=>54A >5 3?42475 12 17 >;;6?A>7;4 F150 =>F >7A A642765;>==<6?>791754?<4?47;4>7A>;;6?A17D=926:D05 56A12B122504>33=1;>5167
- 14 -
) 04 ?18:7>= ><54? 04>?17D 8650 504 21A42 04=A 50>5 504 I:ADB4752 ?4<4??4A 89 504 >33=1;>752 >?4 765 >33=1;>8=456504;>24670>7A >?51;:=>?=9>5 >?>D?>30 62$$>7A$'504?18:7>=0>2D1C47152?4>2672<6?765 ;6721A4?17D0123?>94?<6?>A1?4;516756;6721A4?504;>24 6< 504 >33=1;>75 <6? 3?6B65167 04 3>?>D?>30 62$$ >7A$'>?44G5?>;54A89:2<6?5044>29?4<4?47;4F01;0 ?4>A2>2<6==6F2 ''! 6 5 : % (0!/>!(/((! ?= '1!/8(/((
:@ % A ! ?= 0 # = ) ?= ! ?=! '(! ?= =#
- 15 -
5 : %
5 : % = = 0 ?= '* /1!'..- !# %
# % #'# '( # # ')*+ , -# # # ')*+ ./00/1"+22/!0
= ?=! : ? (*!''!(/(( )3
) 6 ! =
=
5 : % =
# % #'# '( # 3 '+ , #
+ 42,
# &$56 !/$ .
+.21 #/0$$6 !//17 #'# '( # # ')*+ ,
-# # #')*+./00/1"+22/!0 ?=!<
- 16 -
;;6?A17D=9 504 ?18:7>= >==6F4A 5012 >33=1;>5167 17 3>?5 E:>204A 504 1B3:D74A 47A6?24B475 06F4C4? A4;=174A56D?>75504?4=14<6<B>7A>B:2>234?5046?A4? 17!111#51250126?A4?3>224A89504?18:7>=A4;=1717D56 122:4A1?4;5167565046C4?7B475<6?;6721A4?>51676<504 ;>246<504>33=1;>75345151674?<6?3?6B6516712;>==4A17 50123?4247534515167
4>?A?1>?:501=4>?74A;6:724=>334>?17D <6?504345151674?>7AB5>9>=4>?74A1D06:?5 6C4?7B475 =4>A4?34?:24A4751?4345151673>34?2 ( 2;6:=A842447<?6B504?4;6?A2504A>546< B44517D F>2 '&''' >7A504 >?51;=42 6< ;0>?D42 F>2 122:4A 67 ',$$''' >=67D F150 7651;4 2 67 504 A>546<504 B44517D>7A3?43>?>51676<24716?159=125 76A12;13=17>?93?6;44A17D2;?1B17>=3?6;44A17D2>?441504? 17151>54A6?347A17D6?<17>=1K4A17?4234;56<504>33=1;>75 04=4>?74A;6:724=>334>?17D<6?504>33=1;>75?4=14A67 504I:ADB4756<50466?A17>54
47;06<50126:?517
- 17 -
6''(,'', !# A>54A $&$'' 7 >7 1A4751;>= 215:>5167 5012 ;6:?5 ?4=917D 67 504 I:ADB475 6< 50467/8=434G6:?517504;>246< 71676<7A1>>7A 6504?2 "2 " >7>@1?>B >7A 6504?2 >7A 26 >=26 504 I:ADB475 6< 504 66?A17>54
47;0 ?4<4??4A 17 504 2>1A I:ADB47517 6$(,)''F04?417504I:ADB4756< 50467.8=434G6:?517">7>@1?>B24F>2>=26 ?4=14A >7A :304=A 504 ;675475167 ?>124A 89 504 >33=1;>75 504?41750>5>267504A>546<;67C4717D6<504 >7A>2 67 504 A>54 6< 3?6B65167 504?4 F4?4 76 3?6;44A17D2 347A17D >2 >D>1725 504 4B3=6944 04 6824?C>51672 6< 504 66?A17>54 847;0 17 504 I:ADB475 25>54A ?4;6?A4A 17 3>?>D?>30 62$$ >7A $' 504 2>B4 >?4 4G5?>;54A89:2<6?4>29?4<4?47;4 ''! , %
=
5:%!:&!'.*/1+(/(-! :=
- 18 -
,> = 3 B C> 6,) % : &! '/(8.8+(/(- 2#,D4
B C0! # ?=
'*!/1!'..-
=
% ) 5:% @! "
5:%@ (/!'( (/('
% # %
) /'!/(!(/((! $
=
(/!'(!(/(' % % # ! 6 3%D!9!;A D #A 24
- 19 -
= 7 = C .! =
=" E
" 5:% (0/>(/((!" ? = 5:%
6
)
) (*!''!(/((! = 5:%
! '/!"=
! " = =5:% 6
! ! ''! D# & '-8-+(/(-
- 20 -
) 6 3,8
!C '(! , D!9!;A
= 5 : %
! A,
6D!!:!&!'/8.0/+(/(*! = 6 ! !:&!'/8.0/+(/(*!: &!'.*/1+(/(-!<
$ 6504E:4?96<504;6:?5504=4>?74A 12 :7>8=4 56 36175 6:5 >795017D >2 56 F04504? >79 3?6;44A17D2 347A17D >2 67 504 A>54 6< B44517D >2 F4== >2 504 A>54 6< 3?6B65167 =125 14 '&''' >7A ''' ?4234;51C4=9 04 67=9 2:8B122167 B>A4 89 504 =4>?74A 12 50>5 504?4 F>2 > 3?6362>= 17 504 B6750 67 $)''' <6?
06=A17D A43>?5B475>= 47E:1?9 >D>1725504345151674?512;=4>?<?6B504I:ADB4756<504
- 21 -
66?A17>546<50126:?5?4<4??4A25>54A2:3?>50>5504?4 F>2 76 3?6;44A17D2 347A17D %6? > 3?6;44A17D 56 ;6BB47;4 15 ;6BB47;42 <?6B 504 A>54 6< 122:>7;4 6< >?51;=42 6< ;0>?D42 >=67D F150 504 206F ;>:24 7651;4 AB1554A=917504;>24670>7A504206F;>:247651;4>2 F4== >2 504 >?51;=42 6< ;0>?D42 122:4A 67 ',$$''' 7 50424 ;1?;:B25>7;42 506:D0 504 ?18:7>= 0>2 ?1D05=9 245 >21A4 504 1B3:D74A 47A6?24B475 06F4C4? <>1=4A 56 ;6721A4? 504 ;>24 6< 504 >33=1;>75 <6? 122:>7;4 6< > A1?4;5167:7A4?B>7A>B:2<6?;6721A4?>51676<504;>246< 504>33=1;>75<6?3?6B65167>7AA4;=174A56D?>75504?4=14< 67=9 67 504 D?6:7A 50>5 504 ;>24 6< 504 >33=1;>75 206:=A 84 5?4>54A >2 0>C17D 8447 3=>;4A 17 > 24>=4A ;6C4? 3?6;4A:?4 A:?17D 04=A 67 '&''' >7A 504 >33?63?1>54 >;5167 >2 34? 504 ?42:=5 6< A43>?5B475>= 47E:1?9206:=A845>@4717>;;6?A>7;4F150504=>F><54? A43>?5B475>=3?6;44A17D2>?4<17>=1K4A89504?42367A475 >:506?151427504>8247;46<>793?6;44A17D12347A17D >26750451B46< 50126?A4?6<504?18:7>=12 ;=4>? - 22 -
C16=>51676<5046?A4?3>224A895041C12167
47;06<5012 6:?5>C17D;6721A4?4A504;>24670>7A>7A504A>542 6<4C4752A>54AF4<17A50>55045?18:7>=124??4A17 765 D?>7517D 504 A1?4;5167B>7A>B:2 56 504 ?42367A4752 <6? ;6721A4?>5167 6< 504 ;>24 6< 504 345151674? F01;0 0>2 844726:D0517504>33=1;>5167 $$ ;;6?A17D=9F43?6;44A563>22504<6==6F17D+
1# 043451516712 11# 04 A1?4;5167 6< 504 ?18:7>= >5 !111# 12 04?489 E:>204A 111# F?15 17 504 7>5:?4 6< B>7A>B:2 12 122:4A A1?4;517D ?42367A475 62$ >7A ' 56 122:4 3?6B651676?A4?56504>33=1;>75<?6B5043625 6<>?A4?5650436256<4>A>?A4?F047504 1BB4A1>54 I:716? 6< 504 >33=1;>75 14 ?42367A475 6 17 504 >33=1;>5167 F>2 3?6B654A 89 ;6721A4?17D 504 ?43?42475>5167
- 23 -
A>54A $(''' C1A4 774G:?4 H & 56 504 >33=1;>5167 1C# 04 345151674? 12 A1?4;54A 56 2:8B15 > <?420 ?43?42475>5167 >=67D F150 774G:?4& 17 504 >33=1;>516756?42367A47562$>7A'F15017> 34?16A6<5F6F44@2<?6B504A>546<?4;41356< ;6396<50126?A4? C# 42367A47562$>7A'20>==;6721A4?5042>1A ?43?42475>5167 17 54?B2 6< 504 I:ADB475 ?4<4??4A1750126?A4?>7A>=265046824?C>51672 B>A41750126?A4?>7A3>22>33?63?1>546?A4?2 F15017<6:?F44@2504?4><54? #*+ (##) '
#*+ (& ) '
1256+$=6+ +