- 1 - !"# $"%"" " &' &()* &)) +,-.,,/ !""# $ %% #% % !# % %% % & # ##### % '(!) # "# ##% %* % %% ! !# $ % # # Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % %% + % ,(" + ### % "( + % % %% #, #!(")") % % %% %-# & %# % ++ % !")!)* * , )" ")! ) , , +% + % %% % & &+ & ## #"!!")", % %+% . %% #-% % #!(")") % ),#)#")" % % % +% ## #"!!")", % + % % + % #!(")")# % %% + % % / #&% / #&% 0 1234 56131370 126 5613137068 927 34 :88:3;06< :4 :==>46<07#,34466?30;@>:4230;7A126587=66<30;430 7#"!!")", :83430; 7>1 7A 83B6 7#!(")") 7A 6C7;3 7C3=61:1370 341#:C:D>8:;3A781267AA60=645>0342:DC6 >0<686=13704!") !)* * , )" ")! ) , :0< 6=1370 , 7A 0<3:0 60:C 7<6 !() 560<30; D6A7863E3C&><;6:0<&+ &6E:8:;3 DF5C:=30;86C3:0=6 - 3 - 70 126 G><;B601 860<686< DF 126 6443704 7>81 30 ##7#!*")"!12686DF:=@>31130;:==>46<74# !) 17! "):0<"!# "# %26A:=14C6:<30;17126=:46:86:4A7CC794 %26 5864601 5613137068 30 126 56131370 :C70; 9312 71268 =7:==>46< 9:4 4>DG6=16< 17 =83B30:C 58746=>1370 :CC6;30; 12:1 7930; 17 58378 :03B7431F D619660 :==>46< 7#" :0< <6=6:46< %:4C3B 70 !#)!#")") :1 :D7>1 ,) 5#B#70!:16C>83CC:;6 :==>46<74#17!" 30 A>81268:0=67A12638=7BB707DG6=1:0<:8B6<9312<6:<CF 96:5704 :883E6<30 197 86HH:=:84 A78B6< :0 >0C:9A>C :446BDCF 1286:1606< :0< ?3<0:556< 126 <6=6:46< :0< =7BB3116<<:=731F7A126E623=C6#134A>81268:CC6;6<12:1 :11263041:0=67A:==>46<74#!17, :==>46<74#!:0< !, 86=63E6< 4>5:83 2:1=26< : =704538:=F 17 =7BB31 126 7AA60=6 :0<12686DF=7BB3116<7AA60=645>0342:DC6>0<68 6=13704 !") :0< !)* 86:< 9312 6=1370 !,* 7A # 7046@>601CF :CC :==>46< 9686 =2:8;6< 9312 7AA60=64 - 4 - >0<686=13704)":0<")!86:<93126=1370!,*7A# 4 126 5864601 5613137068 9:4 :D4=70<30; : 45C31 =2:8;6 42661 9:4 A3C6<# %26 86B:3030; :==>46< 0:B6CF :==>46< 74# !) 17 ! ") :0< "! 9686 1836< :0< >570 =70=C>4370 7A A>CCAC6<;6< 183:C 126 6443704 &><;6 6I68=3430; 57968 >0<68 6=1370 "! 8### :=@>3116< 126B 7A 7AA60=64 >0<68 6=13704 !, !") !)* * )" ")! ,:0<, 86:<93126=1370!,*# # 0126D:=?<8757A126:=@>311:C86=78<6<DF126 64437047>8130##7#!*")"! 12658646015613137034 A3C6< 70 126 586B346 12:1 126 5830=35:C :==>46< 2:E6 :C86:<FD660:=@>3116<7A126E68F7AA60=64 :0<12:1126 58746=>1370=:46:;:304112656131370683430465:8:DC6A87B 12:17A126:=@>3116<=7:==>46<#134=70160<6<12:1126 70CF :CC6;:1370 :;:3041 126 5613137068 5681:304 17 126 :CC6;6< =83B30:C =704538:=F >0<68 6=1370 !") :0< 12:1 30 E369 7A 126 =:16;783=:C A30<30;4 86=78<6< DF 126 6443704 &><;6 126 5613137068 927 41:0<4 70 126 4:B6 A77130; :4 126 :=@>3116< :==>46< :86 60131C6< 17 43B3C:8 - 5 - 86C36ADF6I68=3467A12630268601G>834<3=13707A12347>81 >0<686=1370,("8### ,# 712 C6:806< =7>046C A78 126 5613137068 :<75130;3<6013=:C:8;>B6014 2:E6<8:90126:116013707A 1234 7>81 17 126 86C6E:01 A30<30;4 7A 126 6443704 &><;6 923C6 :=@>31130; 126 =7:==>46<# :813=>C:8 6B52:434 34 5C:=6< 70 5:8:;8:524 , 17 , 7A 126 G><;B601 17 <6B70418:16 12:1 126 58746=>1370 A:3C6< 17 641:DC342 126 =2:307A=38=>B41:013:C6E3<60=606=644:8F17D830;27B6 126 ;>3C1 7A 126 :==>46<# 1 34 4>DB3116< 12:1 126 :CC6;:13704 :0< 7E681 :=14 :1183D>16< 17 126 5613137068 C3B316<17126:CC6;:13707A=704538:=F:8630<34130;>342:DC6 A87B12746C6E6CC6<:;:3041126:=@>3116<:==>46< :0<126 6E3<60=6 :<<>=6< 30 126 =:46 34 30465:8:DC6 :0< 30<3E343DC6# %2686A786 70 126 5830=35C6 7A 5:831F 126 561313706834:C4760131C6<17126D606A317A:=@>311:C#134 A>81268:8;>6<12:1 6E603A12658746=>137034568B3116<17 587=66< 126C3?6C3277<7A=70E3=1370346I186B6CF86B716 :0<4>DG6=130;126561313706817:587C70;6<=83B30:C183:C - 6 - 97>C< :B7>01 17 :D>46 7A 126 587=644 7A C:9# 1 34 :C47 D87>;21 17 126 0713=6 7A 1234 7>81 12:1 126 G><;B601 7A :=@>311:C 30 ##7#!*")"! 2:4071D660 =2:CC60;6< DF 126 1:16 :0< 2:4 :11:306< A30:C31F :0< =7046@>601CF =70130>:1370 7A 587=66<30;4 :;:3041 126 5613137068 34 >09:88:016<# # 68 =7018: 126 C6:806< 923C6 071 <345>130; 126 G><;B601 7A :=@>311:C 30 ##7#!*")"! =70160<4 12:1 126 5613137068 9:4 :D4=70<30; 864>C130; 30 126 A3C30; 7A : 45C31 =2:8;6 42661 :0< 12:1 26 B>41 A:=6 183:C30<6560<601CF#134:8;>6<12:1 30E3697A126;8:E6 0:1>867A:CC6;:13704 30=C><30; 1267AA60=6>0<686=1370 )" 86:< 9312 6=1370 !") 126 587=66<30;4 =:0071 D6@>:426<>0<686=1370,("8###B686CFD6=:>46126 =7:==>46<2:E6D660:=@>3116<# # :E30;26:8<C6:806<=7>046CA781265613137068 :0<126C6:806<A781261:16 12347>81=7043<68431 06=644:8F D6A786 587=66<30; A>81268 17 6I:B306 126 - 7 - =8>=3:C A30<30;4 86=78<6< DF 126 6443704 &><;6 923C6 :=@>31130; 126 =7:==>46<# :8:;8:524 "( 17 , 7A 126 G><;B601 :86 12686A786 86C6E:01 :0< :86 86@>386< 17 D6 6I18:=16<A78587568=7043<68:1370# !!!! " !!!! # "$% & "'%&(&!& # ) * # "% ) # ++, - &. # . ( & . / *0 * 1 0 ) "$ 0 2 & "% - 8 - * **0 # +.'' * 3 & # # * # 0 !+ # .(2 - +. & / 4 & ) 5 " & 0 +.% ! # 1 & $% ) +.5 6! 6 & & &.! ) - 4 ) # / - 9 - & " 0 +.&% ! # 1 # 6 & . . # # # * -6 6 '& " * "& ) ' + # . 3 6 .44# 3 / # &# !!! +.'% ++'( 3 ) 6('0 ) & 6(' # - 10 - $.7 +$%, - !!!! # * " 8 ) 1 " 0 % . & # 0 # # ) + # . ' # "$ , # ( 0 0 # 9 # # . # # - 11 - # 0 " # " # !! # , # # ! 9 . 4 :96 " 1 7 / " "'& " ( " ) "' % # " 9 # . .% " - 12 - * & # "$ !& & & & '& ! & %6# 9 & # # # # & # 0 & # # ;& # # # # '6# 9 0 # ++ 8+ & !$0 6# 9 !6# 9 9 ) & - &< 0< # # - 13 - -#& # * 5 # ' 0 # # 5 # # ) # & ## # # ) * $ 0 & # *& 0 ## 5 # ;< # + / "$%!'&! - 14 - / = & 0 " " # # 0 : =:86A>C 86:<30; 7A 126 <61:3C6< 7D468E:13704 B:<6 DF 126 C6:806< 6443704 &><;6 923=2 A78B6< 126 D:434 A78 :=@>311:C 7A 126 =7:==>46< 31 D6=7B64:D>0<:01CF=C6:812:1126:CC6;:13704:;:3041126 5864601 5613137068 41:0<4 70 126 4:B6 A77130; :4 12746 C6E6CC6<:;:3041126:=@>3116<:==>46<#%2646:CC6;:13704 :86927CCF3016897E609312126D87:<6858746=>137012678F 923=2 2:4 :C86:<F D660 <34D6C36E6< 30 314 6013861F DF 126 64437047>81# (# %26 6I18:=16< A30<30;4 A87B 5:8:;8:524 "( 17 ,7A12664437047>81G><;B601<34=C74646E68:C=8>=3:C <6A3=360=364923=2<386=1CF3B5:=11264>41:30:D3C31F7A126 58746=>1370 :;:3041 126 5864601 5613137068# %26 6443704 &><;62:4=:16;783=:CCF0716<12:11265830=35:C931064464 0:B6CF #"" 17 #" 927 :CC6;6<CF C:41 4:9 126 <6=6:46<30126=7B5:0F7A:==>46<74#17!":16C>8 - 15 - 2:E6 1>806< =7B5C616CF 27413C6# +>81268 126 6443704 &><;6 923C6 :0:CF430; 126 =87446I:B30:1370 7A #!, 126 =7B5C:30:01 2:4 23;2C3;216< 12:1 1234 9310644 456=3A3=:CCF <6036< 126 =786 :CC6;:1370 12:1 126 <6=6:46< 9:4?3<0:556<:11263041:0=67A:==>46<74#!17,#%26 6443704 &><;6 2:4 :C47 :<E6816< 17 126 E7C>01:8F 41:16B60147A:==>46<74# !) !! !" !, ! "):0< "! :0< 2:4 =70=C><6< 12:1 126 58746=>1370 2:4 A:3C6< 17 641:DC342 126 6446013:C 30;86<36014 7A 6=1370 " 7A 126 0<3:0 E3<60=6 =1 :0< 12:1 126 :CC6;6< 86=7E68364 :86 071 587E6< 30 :==78<:0=6 9312 C:9# 0 :<<31370 126 6443704 7>81 2:4 3<6013A36< B:1683:C =7018:<3=13704 7B3443704 :0< 46837>4 C:5464 30 126 30E6413;:1370 >C13B:16CF27C<30;12:1126=2:307A=38=>B41:013:C6E3<60=6 86C36<>570DF12658746=>1370<764071A78B:=7B5C616 :0<>0D87?60C30?5730130;17126;>3C17A126:==>46<# 0 1234 7E68:CC :44644B601 126 =7:==>46< 0:B6CF :==>46< 74# !) 17 ! ") :0< "! 9686 :=@>3116< 7A :CC - 16 - =2:8;64 >0<68 6=13704 !, !") !)* * )" ")! ,:0<, 86:<93126=1370!,*7A# *# %26 C6:806< =7>046C A78 126 5613137068 2:4 5C:=6< 86C3:0=6 70 126 G><;B601 7A 126 70.DC6 >586B6 7>8130 :4 96CC:4126G><;B6017A126778<30:1660=230 ! "!" #$ %!!"!!&'%'(#%265830=35C64C:3<<790 1268630 5:813=>C:8CF 12:1 92686 126 6E3<60=6 :;:3041 =7 :==>46< 34 30465:8:DC6 :0< 30<3E343DC6 :0< 126 B:30 :==>46< 2:E6 D660 :=@>3116< 70 B68314 =70130>:1370 7A 587=66<30;4 :;:3041 126 :D4=70<30; :==>46< 97>C<D6 :0 :D>46 7A 587=644 4@>:86CF :55CF 17 126 5864601 =:46# 686 126 58746=>1370 =:46 86414 47C6CF 70 =38=>B41:013:C 6E3<60=6#%26B741=8>=3:C=38=>B41:0=6 0:B6CF126JC:41 4660K 12678F 2:4 =7CC:546< 30 E369 7A ?6F 931064464 1>8030; 27413C6# 0=6 126 4>D418:1>B 7A 126 58746=>1370 =:462:4D660=7B5C616CF<34C7<;6<DF126A30<30;430## 7#!*")"! 12347>81347A126=7043<686<E36912:1126 - 17 - 5864601 5613137068 927 A:=6 :CC6;:13704 7A 3<6013=:C :0< 30465:8:DC6 0:1>86 =:0071 D6 =7B56CC6< 17 >0<68;7 : A>CCAC6<;6< 183:C# ==78<30;CF 126 56131370 <6468E6 17 D6 :CC796< :0< 126 587=66<30;4 560<30; :;:3041 :==>46< 74#, 34C3:DC617D6@>:426<# !)#4:C86:<F<34=>446< 6E603A12646443704=:464 9686 17 D6 30<6560<601CF 58746=>16< 126 C3?6C3277< 7A =70E3=13707A1265613137068346I186B6CF86B716#0A:=1 30 C3;21 7A 126 =:16;783=:C A30<30;4 86=78<6< DF 126 6443704 7>81 30 ##7#!*")"! 126 57443D3C31F 7A =70E3=1370 34 E381>:CCF 0706I341601# >DG6=130; 126 5613137068 17 : 587C70;6< =83B30:C 183:C 30 4>=2 =38=>B41:0=64 97>C< :B7>01 17 568B31130; :0 :D>46 7A 126 G><3=3:C 587=644 923=2 1234 7>81 =:0071 =7>0160:0=6# %2686A786 =70130>:13707A126587=66<30;434927CCF>09:88:016<:0< C3:DC617D6@>:426<# !!# 0 E369 7A 126 A786;730; <34=>44370 1234 7>81 587=66<4175:44126A7CC7930; - 18 - 3%2656131370342686DF!#)# 33 %26 587=66<30;4 560<30; 30 7#"!!")",:83430;7>17A83B67#!(")")7A 6C7;3 7C3=6 1:1370 341# :C:D>8:;3 A78 126 7AA60=645>0342:DC6>0<686=13704!") !)* * , )" ")! ) ,:0<6=1370, 7A 0<3:0 60:C 7<6 !() 560<30; D6A786 3E3C &><;6 :0< &+ &6E:8:;3 3047A:8 :4 126 561313706834=70=6806< :862686DF@>:426<# 0* &"") % & 3417#"C7#! %