- 1 - !" # $% # $% !%"! ## &"' ( ! "## $ # % # & ' # # # ( Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #' ! "# ( ') ' * ''+ (( $ ( ( &"$ ( , ' ''+ ''' ( ( ( # # , ( '- # #( # ( % ( ( , .# .# % " .# $ /01 233425 67849 4:;0<7 &"$ <= <;<9 4/0:541 :; * "/494072=;49 94=49948 ;< 21 >;/4 :;?$ /21 @447 =0548@A;/4:520B27;:/25547C07C;/4D68CB47;2782E298 82;48 ' ''+ 321148 @A 907:0325 470<9 0F05 68C4 278 4B@49 - 0D2A23692 07 < ''' - 3 - E/494@A ;/4 34;0;0<7 =0548 @A ;/4 :520B27;23345527; E21 801B01148 ' (2:;1 C0F07C 9014 ;< ;/4 =0507C <= ;/4 233425 @904=5A 1;2;48 294;/2;<7 ' ''2;2@<6; /<691 ;/4 23345527; E21 39<:44807C <7 B<;<9:A:54 @42907C 94C01;92;0<7< -+-'*2;52C6967:/2769(29B <28 52C69 256G 2B2G/2780 ; ;/2; ;0B4 /4 B4; E0;/272::0847;161;2074807D69041278E21/<130;250H48 /4:520B27;=0548234;0;0<7678494:;0<7"$<= ;/4 :; 144G07C :<B34712;0<7 =9<B ;/4 9413<7847;1 ;<E298107D69041161;20748@A/0B + 3<7 149F0:4 <= 7<;0:4 ;/4 9413<7847; <1 278 ' 23342948;/9<6C/;/40994134:;0F4:<67145278=0548E90;;47 1;2;4B47; 847A07C ;/4 2F49B47;1 B284 07 ;/4 :520B 34;0;0<7 7 ;/4 @2101 <= ;/4 3542807C1 <= ;/4 329;041 ;/4 520B190@6725=92B48;/4011641278;/4942=;4994:<9848 ;/4 4F0847:4 /4 90@6725 @A 0B36C748 D68CB47; 278 - 4 - 2E298 /21 801B01148 ;/4 :520B 34;0;0<7 #407C 2CC904F48 ;/4394147;233425/21@447=0548 90 #236C<68208823325429748:<6714523342907C =<9;/4:520B27;/21920148;/4=<55<E07C:<7;47;0<71 2$ (091;5A 4F47 ;/<6C/ ;/4 :520B 34;0;0<7 E21 =0548 678494:;0<7"$<=;/4:;;/42::0847;<::69948<7 ' '' /4 2B478B47; <= ;/4 <;<9 4/0:541 :; :2B407;<=<9:4<7 * '* /494=<94;/4233425/21 ;< @4 ;942;48 67849 14:;0<7 + <= ;/4 :; ,0;/<6; :<71084907C ;/01 2134:; ;/4 90@6725 49948 07 801B01107C ;/4:520B34;0;0<7 @$ 4:<785A213494:;0<7+<=;/4:;;/4:520B27; 01 7<; 94I60948 ;< 35428 <9 41;2@501/ ;/2; ;/4 842;/ <9 07D69AE21864;<27AE9<7C=652:;74C54:;<984=265;<= ;/4 <E749 <= ;/4 F4/0:54 ;/4 F4/0:54 :<7:49748 <9 27A <;/49 3491<7 ,0;/<6; :<71084907C ;/414 39<F010<71 ;/4 90@67254994807801B01107C;/4:520B34;0;0<7 - 5 - & 7 ;/4 <;/49 /278 B; 944;0 2;05 45G6780 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 23342907C =<9 ;/4 716927:4 <B327A :<7;47848 ;/2; ;/4 2::0847; <::69948 864 ;< ;/4 74C50C47:4 <= ;/4 :520B27; /0B145= 278 /4 /28 =0548 ;/4 34;0;0<7 67849 4:;0<7 "$ <= ;/4 :; 7849 4:;0<7 "$<=;/4:;0=23491<716==49107D69A864;<2145=- =255 ;/4 716927:4 <B327A 01 7<; 502@54 ;< 32A :<B34712;0<7 ; 01 ;/494=<94 16@B0;;48 ;/2; ;/4 90@6725 /2190C/;5A801B01148;/4:520B34;0;0<7 4298 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 329;041 278 3496148;/4D68CB47;2782E298<=;/490@6725 * /4 :214 <= ;/4 :520B27; 01 ;/2; <7 ' '' 2; 2@<6; /<691E/054/4E2139<:44807C<7B<;<9:A:54 @42907C 94C01;92;0<7 < -+-'* <7 52C69 67:/2769 (29B <28 52C69 2B2G/2780 ;256G /4 5<1; :<7;9<5 =455 8<E7 278 16==4948 07D69041 /4 2::0847; <::69948 <7 ' '' E/49421 ;/4 2B478B47; ;< ;/4 <;<94/0:541:;'*:2B407;<=<9:4<7 * '* /494=<94;/434;0;0<701B207;2072@54678494:;0<7+ - 6 - <= ;/4 :; F47 ;/<6C/ ;/4 34;0;0<7 E21 =0548 67849 4:;0<7"$<=;/4:;0;0194I60948;<@4:<71084948 678494:;0<7+ 4:;0<7+9428121=<55<E1 J #)*+,-. /+0,-1).2- 2- /)1, 3,).4 5 65,7281 485. ,./ 9 "$ <;E0;/1;27807C27A;/07C:<7;2074807;/01:;<9 07 27A <;/49 52E =<9 ;/4 ;0B4 @407C 07 =<9:4 <9 071;96B47; /2F07C ;/4 =<9:4 <= 52E ;/4 <E749 <= ;/4 B<;<9 F4/0:54 <9 ;/4 26;/<90148 0716949 1/255 @4 502@54 ;< 32A 07 ;/4 :214 <= 842;/ <9 C904F<61 /69;864;<27A2::0847;290107C<6;<=;/4614<= B<;<9 F4/0:54 2 :<B34712;0<7 <= 2 16B <= =0F4 52G/96344107:214<=842;/<9<=;E<2782/25= 52G/ 963441 07 :214 <= C904F<61 /69; ;< ;/4 54C25 /4091<9;/4F0:;0B21;/4:214B2A@4 "'$ 7 27A :520B =<9 :<B34712;0<7 67849 16@- 14:;0<7 "$ ;/4 :520B27; 1/255 7<;@4 94I60948 ;< 35428<941;2@501/;/2;;/4842;/<9C904F<61/69; 0794134:;<=E/0:/;/4:520B/21@447B284E21 864 ;< 27A E9<7C=65 2:; <9 74C54:; <9 84=265; <= ;/4 <E749 <= ;/4 F4/0:54 <9 <= ;/4 F4/0:54 :<7:49748<9<=27A<;/493491<7 "$ ,/494 07 94134:; <= 842;/ <9 C904F<61 /69; 864;<272::0847;290107C<6;<=;/4614<=B<;<9 F4/0:54 :<B34712;0<7 /21 @447 3208 67849 27A <;/4952E=<9;/4;0B4@407C07=<9:416:/2B<67; - 7 - <=:<B34712;0<71/255@49486:48=9<B;/42B<67; <=:<B34712;0<732A2@5467849;/0114:;0<7 K (9<B;/42@<F439<F010<70;01:5429;/2;0727A:214 <=842;/<9C904F<61/69;864;<272::0847;290107C<6;<= ;/4 614 <= 2 B<;<9 F4/0:54 07 :2141 <= C904F<61 /69; :<B34712;0<7 <= 1 '- /21 ;< @4 3208 ;< ;/4 F0:;0B @A ;/4 <E749 <9 ;/4 26;/<90148 0716949 /4 :520B27;017<;94I60948;<35428<941;2@501/;/4842;/<9 C904F<61 /69; 07 94134:; <= ;/4 :520B E21 864 ;< 27A E9<7C=65 2:; <9 74C54:; <9 84=265; <= ;/4 <E749 <= ;/4 F4/0:54<9<=;/4F4/0:54:<7:49748<9<=27A<;/493491<7 ;017<;0780136;4;/2;;/4:520B27;16==494807D69041 864 ;< 27 2::0847; 290107C <6; <= ;/4 614 <= ;/4 B<;<9:A:54 278 ;/2; ;/4 1208 F4/0:54 E21 0716948 E0;/ 9413<7847; < '-716927:4 <B327A /494=<94 ;/4 :520B27; 01 47;0;548 ;< 2 :<B34712;0<7 <= 1 '- 678494:;0<7+<=;/4:; ' 7;/494165;;/4=<55<E07C<984901321148 - 8 - 2$ /423342501 @$ /4D68CB47;<=;/4 520B190@67250114;21084 :$ 413<7847; < ' 01 502@54 ;< 32A ;/4 :<B34712;0<7 <= 1 '- E0;/ 07;4941; LM 3 2 =9<B ;/4 82;4 <= =0507C <= ;/4 :520B 34;0;0<7;055;/432AB47;<=:<B34712;0<7E0;/07 23490<8<=10NE44G1=9<B;/482;4<=94:403;<= :<3A<=;/01D68CB47; 8$ 0@49;A 01 94149F48 ;< ;/4 :520B27; ;< E0;/892E ;/42B<67;;<@4843<10;48@A;/49413<7847;1 4$ /4 90@6725 01 8094:;48 ;< 9454214 ;/4 47;094 :<B34712;0<72B<67;07=2F<69<=;/4:520B27; 2=;498640847;0=0:2;0<7278F490=0:2;0<7 3: &# ' % 3: &!%"!' % 01;< 5< &