- 1 - !"# $% & % % & ' ( " # ! ) * ! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + ' ( " !, # & - "!# + $ $ ./! -& * 0./&1 $ + $ % % - 3 - "% # 2304556473083769:;74<917=06>?<96>6@A3=<-"!# =8 A26 4<9 @B?303A3=< @A @24776<C3<C D?9CE6<A 4<9 4F4>9 94A69 ./! 540069 :; 997 6<3=> 3G37 ?9C6?7:4>C43<=-& >36884@A0=8A26@4064>6A24AA264556774<A30 A26=F<6>=82=?065>=56>A;:64>3<C=-&!-=84C==> G3774C6 26 0439 5>=56>A; F40 4@B?3>69 :; A26 56@347 4<9@B?303A3=< 883@6>8=>0?:E6>C3<C6<<6A=>4>=D6@A @@=>93<C7;A264F4>9F405400694F4>93<C8=>40?E=8 0-//!&163<C4CC>36G69:;A2604E6A26@743E4<A 2400=?C2A8=>>686>6<@6?<96>6@A3=<!/"!#=8A264<9 @B?303A3=< @A 8=> 6<24<@6E6<A =8 @=E56<04A3=< 26 >686>6<@6 @406 240 :66< <?E:6>69 40 =-& 26 686>6<@6 =?>A :; 3A0 D?9CE6<A 94A69 ./! 240 6<24<@69 A26 @=E56<04A3=< 4E=?<A 8>=E 0-//!&1 A= 0! /&1 $2376 6<24<@3<C A26 E4>H6A G47?6 3< >6056@A =8 0?:D6@A 2=?06 5>=56>A; A26 - 4 - 686>6<@6 =?>A 240 969?@A69 I A=F4>90 965>6@34A3=< G47?6 =8 A265>=56>A; =<A26 C>=?<9 A24A=EE3003=<6>J0 >65=>A300?:E3AA693<A26;64>.264@B?303A3=<30=8 A26;64>63<C 4CC>36G69 :; A230 54>A =8 A26 D?9CE6<AA2674<97=06>30:68=>6A230=?>A 64><69@=?<06745564>3<C8=>A264556774<A240 0?:E3AA69 A24A 6G6< A2=?C2 A26 =EE3003=<6> 240 0?:E3AA69 4 >65=>A 3< A26 ;64> . A26 5>=56>A; 240 :66<G47?69403A6K30A03<A26;64>!126>68=>6 A26>6 30 <= B?60A3=< =8 965>6@34A3=< =8 I =< A26 96A6>E3<69 @=E56<04A3=< 6@=<97; 26 240 @=<A6<969 A24A A26 686>6<@6 =?>A 240 <=A 49969 A26 6K56<060 3<@?>>69 A=F4>90 676@A>383@4A3=< F4A6> 4<9 04<3A4>; F2376 4F4>93<C @=E56<04A3=< =< A26 E4>H6A G47?6 =8 A26 4@B?3>692=?06 - 764><69 @=?<067 8=> A26 >605=<96<A =0!4<94<9764><693C2=?>A=G6><E6<A76496> @=<A6<969 A24A 6G6< 400?E3<C 40 56> A26 >65=>A A26 - 5 - G47?4A3=< 240 :66< @=<0396>69 40 3A 6K30A0 3< A26 ;64> !1 A26 74<9 F40 4@B?3>69 3< A26 ;64> ! 26>68=>6 =<6 ;64> 965>6@34A3=< 240 A= :6 969?@A69 26; 8?>A26> @=<A6<969 A24A 6<A3>6 0A>?@A?>6 240 :66< 40060069 4A 0-/..&1 26>68=>6 4993A3=< =8 676@A>383@4A3=<F4A6>0?557;4<904<3A4>;83AA3<C0@4<<=A:6 49969 =<0396>3<C A26 >65=>A 0?:E3AA69 :; A26 =?>A =EE3003=<6> A26 686>6<@6 =?>A 240 >3C2A7; 969?@A69 I 965>6@34A3=< 4<9 4F4>969 @=E56<04A3=< =8 0! /&16<@60=?C2AA=930E300A26455647 64>9764><69@=?<0678=>A2654>A3606>?069 A264556475456>0 A30<=A3<9305?A6A24AA26@743E4<A&74<97=06>30 A26 =F<6> =8 A26 2=?06 5>=56>A; :64>3<C =-&!- =8 4C==> G3774C6 A 30 470= <=A 3< 9305?A6 A24A A26 0439 2=?06 240 :66< 4@B?3>69:;A26 >605=<96<A&4?A2=>3A; 8=> A26 5?>5=06 =8 0?:1E6>C3<C 3< 6<<6A=>4 >=D6@A F2376 300?3<C 5>673E3<4>; <=A383@4A3=< ?<96> 6@A3=< - "!# - 6 - =8 A26 4<9 @B?303A3=< @A =< /!!! 26 4<9 @B?303A3=< 883@6> 240 540069 4< 4F4>9 A= A26 6KA6<A =8 0-//!&163<C4CC>36G69:;A2604E6A26@743E4<A 0=?C2A>686>6<@6?<96>6@A3=<!/"!#4<9@B?303A3=<@A 26 >686>6<@6 56A3A3=< 240 :66< <?E:6>69 40 =-& 26 686>6<@6 =?>A 240 >3C2A7; 6<24<@69 A26E4>H6AG47?6=8A264@B?3>692=?06$23766<24<@3<C A26@=E56<04A3=<A26686>6<@6=?>A6>>693<969?@A3<C I A=F4>90 965>6@34A3=< 8=> . ;64>0 < 84@A 3< A26 =EE3003=<6>J0>65=>AA26G47?6=8A265>=56>A;240:66< 40060069 40 3A F40 6K3A69 3< A26 ;64> !1 26 5>673E3<4>; <=A383@4A3=< 240 :66< 300?69 8=> 4@B?3>3<C A26 0439 2=?06 30 3< A26 ;64> ! 26>68=>6 965>6@34A3=< 02=?79:68=>=<6;64><A26=EE3003=<6>J0>65=>AA26 A=A47G47?6=80A>?@A?>6=8A262=?06240:66<400600694A 0-/..&1 <4993A3=<LIA=F4>90676@A>383@4A3=< F23@2 @=E60 A= 0 !&1 4<9 .I 8=> F4A6> 0?557; 4<9 04<3A4>; 83AA3<C0 F=?79 @=E6 A= 0!/ /&1 4<9 F23764F4>93<CA26@=E56<04A3=<A264993A3=<47G47?6=8 - 7 - A26 676@A>383@4A3=< 4<9 F4A6> 0?557; 4<9 04<3A4>; 83AA3<C0 240 <=A :66< @=<0396>69 :; A26 686>6<@6 =?>A 26>68=>6 A26 =>96> 540069 :; A26 686>6<@6 =?>A >6B?3>69A=:6E=938369056>A26=EE3003=<6>J0>65=>A A26A=A47G47?6=8A262=?065>=56>A;240:66<4006006940 0./&1 ?A=8F23@240?E=80!/&1240A= :6 969?@A69 8=> 4993A3=<47 8=> ?<8=>6066< 26< A26 A=A47 G47?6 =8 A26 2=?06 5>=56>A; @=E60 A= 0. ..&1 ?A=8F23@2=<6;64>965>6@34A3=<240A= :6 969?@A69 4A A26 >4A6 =8 I 36 0!//&1 8A6> 969?@A3<C 965>6@34A3=< =8 =<6 ;64> A26 G47?6 =8 A26 5>=56>A; @=E60 A= 0 /--&1 "0. ..&1 E3<?0 0!//&1# 26>68=>6 A26 6<24<@69 E4>H6A G47?6 =8 A264@B?3>692=?065>=56>A;@=E60A=0!.-&1 . @@=>93<C7;F65>=@669A268=77=F3<C% "3# 2645564730 - 8 - "33# 26 A=A47 E4>H6A G47?6=8 A26 0?:D6@A 4@B?3>69 2=?06 30 83K69 4A 0 /--&1 40 4C43<0A 0! /&1 4F4>969 :; A26 686>6<@6 =?>A F3A2477@=<06B?6<A347:6<683A03<@7?93<C@=0A "333# 264556774<A&@743E4<A02477<=A:66<A3A7698=> 3<A6>60A =< A26 6<24<@69 @=E56<04A3=< 36 8>=E !!A2694A6=8930E30047=84556478=><=<1 5>=06@?A3=<A377A2694A6=8>60A=>4A3=<=845564736 =<. !" #$ % !" #&'(&% 30A=%!7=% %