- 1 - !"!! ! #$ #%&' #&& ( ! " ! # ! ! ! ! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ! $ % ! ! ! & & ! ! " ! $# ! " ' $" ! # ! - 3 - $! ! ! ! ( ) * + * % ! * !$ " " *, ** ! ( ) *- *"+ * " * )+ " * )%+ %. * , !! "!" !!"!" * % . * ** "! !& $ "! * - 4 - ** * * % / )/ + 012 34515167 12 8194:;< 504345151674=2 >06 ?=4504 1=4@56=268?=?7A??0?B?=1?BB?=4?=B0?741<?C15? )86= 206=5 DEF?= *?@56=<G+ 244B17F HE?2017F 68 504 3=6@44:17F2347:17F17=1C46 "!"86=50468847@42 3E7120?;94E7:4=4@51672 "! !& $ ?7:"!68 5047:1?747?96:4!)86=206=5DG+ " *?@5294?:17F56504@?24?=4?2E7:4= 42367:475 6" :48?@56 @6C39?17?75 >06 12 504 0148I4@E51J4881@4=68504125=1@5475=?96634=?51J4 ?7B1C154:0?296:F4:?@6C39?175?F?17255043=42475 345151674=2 >06 ?=4 25?54: 56 ;4 504 1=4@56=2 68 504 @67@4=74:EF?=*?@56=<512?994F4:50?5504345151674=2 - 5 - 17 5041= @?3?@15< ?2 1=4@56=2 0?J4 @672@16E29< 3?224: ? =4269E5167:?54:! !"!"#504=4;<C12=43=4247517F504 HE?75EC 68 2EF?= 256@B >0194 ?J?1917F ? 96?7 68 2$ @=6=428=6C5042?1:?7B@@6=:17F56504@6C39?17?75 504 8?@56=< E7:4= 504 ?E506=15< 68 504 1C3EF74: =4269E51678?9249<3=6A4@54:50?51536224224:2EF?=256@B 56 504 5E74 68 "$"$ HE175?92 J?9E4: ?5 2&""&$ >04=4?2 17 8?@5 76 2E@0 256@B >?2 ?J?19?;945128E=504=?994F4:50?5504345151674=2>150? :491;4=?5417547556:48=?E:504?7B1789?54:504J?9E468 5042EF?=256@B?7:24@E=4:5042?1:96?767504;?21268 2E@081@51516E2=43=42475?5167?24:6750424?994F?51672 504@6C39?1750?2@E9C17?54:17504=4F125=?516768=1C4 6 "!" ?F?1725 504 345151674=2 86= 504 ?994F4: 68847@42 # 4?=74:4716=6E7249=1?<?BEC?=?519 ?334?=17F 86= 504 345151674=2 J404C4759< @67547:4: 50?5 504?7B0?2?9=4?:<17151?54:=4@6J4=<3=6@44:17F2E7:4= 5043=6J12167268 504 4@E=1512?5167?7:4@6725=E@516768 - 6 - *17?7@1?9 22452 ?7: 786=@4C475 68 4@E=15142 754=425 @5 "!!" )86= 206=5 504 D* @5G+ 4 8E=504= 2E;C1554:50?55041754=7?917234@5167>01@0@E9C17?54:17 504 3=43?=?5167 68 ?7 17234@5167 =436=5 86=C17F 504 J4=< ;?212 86= 504 3=42475 @6C39?175 12 504 2E;A4@5 C?554= 68 3=6@44:17F2 ;486=4 5012 6E=5 17 %6"!"# "!" >04=4175042?1:17234@5167=436=50?2;44725?<4:7504 91F05 68 504 347:47@< 68 =4@6J4=< 3=6@44:17F2 ?7: 504 1754=1C 25?< 634=?517F ?F?1725 504 17234@5167 =436=5 504 94?=74: 4716= 6E7249 @67547:2 50?5 504 17151?5167 68 @=1C17?9 3=624@E5167 67 504 2?C4 245 68 8?@52 12 >0699< E7>?==?754:?7:?C6E75256?;E24683=6@422689?>4 0?2 39?@4:=491?7@4 67504 AE:FC475 6850467G;9434I 6E=517 ?7: 504 :4@12167 68 ? 66=:17?54 47@0 68 5012 6E=5 17 ! " " 56 ;E55=422 )"! +&! "&&)"+"& - 7 - 012 @675475167 50?5 3?=?9949 @=1C17?9 3=6@44:17F2 ?=4 1C34=C1221;94 >047 504 :123E54 12 3=1C?=19< @1J19 6= =4FE9?56=<177?5E=4?7:?9=4?:<E7:4=?:AE:1@?5167 94?=74: @6E7249 =1 ?9?991 ?334?=17F86==42367:4756" :48?@56@6C39?17?75>0194 =4154=?517F 504 @6754751672 E=F4: 17 504 25?54C475 68 6;A4@516722E;C1554:50?5504345151674=2;417F1=4@56=2 68 504 EF?= *?@56=< 0?: A61759< 21F74: 504 =4269E5167 :?54: ! !"!"# ?2 4J1:47@4: ?5 774IE=4K ?24: 675012=4269E51675048?@56=<=43=424754:56504?7B50?5 15>?2069:17F2EF?=256@B68"$"$HE175?92J?9E4:?5 2&""&$ ?F?1725 >01@0 504 ?7B 2?7@51674: ? 96?7 68 2$ @=6=42 ;< 5=4?517F 504 256@B ?2 394:F4: 24@E=15< 6>4J4= E367 2E;24HE475 J4=181@?5167 ?2 =4894@54:17774IE=4K15>?2=4J4?94:50?5504?@5E?9 2EF?= 256@B >?2 679< $$ HE175?92 5 12 17 5012 ;?@BF=6E7: 50?5 504 @6C39?175 >?2 96:F4: ?994F17F :491;4=?548?92181@?5167?7:8=?E:E9475C12=43=42475?5167;< 5041=4@56=24?=74:@6E7249504=486=4@67547:4:50?5 - 8 - 504?994F?51672:12@9624?@94?=@6F71L?;9468847@4?7:504 17J4251F?5167 0?J17F ;447 9?>8E99< 245 17 C65167 6EF05 765 56 ;4 1754=84=4: >150 ?5 5012 25?F4 7 2E336=5 68 012 2E;C1221672 04 39?@4: =491?7@4 67 504 AE:FC4752 68 504 67G;94 E3=4C4 6E=5 17 # # $ % # ?7: $ % & # % 56 4C30?21L4 50?5 @=1C17?9 3=624@E5167 @?7765 ;4 251894: C4=49<;4@?E24@1J196==4@6J4=<3=6@44:17F2?=4347:17F 4?=74: 1F0 6E=5 6J4=7C475 94?:4= C5 715? 4::<2E336=517F5042E;C122167268=42367:475 6" 2E;C1554: 50?5 504 @6C39?175 ?7: ?@@6C3?7<17F C?54=1?9 :12@9624 @6F71L?;94 68847@42 >?==?7517F506=6EF017J4251F?5167512@67547:4:50?5504 C?554= 17J69J42 24=16E2 ?994F?51672 68 817?7@1?9 8=?E: ?7: C12=43=42475?5167?7:504=486=4761754=84=47@412@?994: 86=?550123=491C17?=<25?F46817J4251F?5167 #"!$# )"!+#& - 9 - 0?J4 04?=: =1 ?<?BEC?= ?519 94?=74: 4716= 6E7249 ?334?=17F 86= 504 345151674=2 C5 715? 4::< 94?=74: 1F0 6E=5 6J4=7C475 94?:4= 86= =42367:475 6 5?54 ?7: =1 ?9?991 94?=74: @6E7249 ?334?=17F 86= =42367:475 6" :48?@56 @6C39?17?75 $ 7 ? @9624 4I?C17?5167 68 504 C?54=1?939?@4:67=4@6=:50126E=51268504@6721:4=4: J14> 50?5 504 C4=4 347:47@< 68 504 >=15 34515167 @67@4=717F504@0?9947F456J?@?5167681754=1C6=:4=;< 50433499?54E506=15<17?7?334?9E7:4=4@5167!)#+ 68504?=7?5?B?6634=?51J46@145142@5&&@?7765 ;< 152498 @672515E54 ? J?91: F=6E7: 56 HE?20 504 @=1C17?9 3=6@44:17F2 17 =1C4 6 "!" 04 ?994F?51672 17 504 @6C39?175?=4234@181@?7:F=?J4177?5E=40442247@468 504 @6C39?175 12 50?5 504 345151674=2 17 5041= @?3?@15< ?2 1=4@56=268504EF?=*?@56=<0?J43?224:?=4269E516756 24@E=4 ? 2E;25?751?9 96?7 8=6C 504 125=1@5 475=?9 6634=?51J4 ?7B 1C154: 7 504 2?1: =4269E5167 504 - 10 - :45?192 68 256@B 17@9E:17F 2EF?= C69?2242 ?7: ;?F?224 >4=4 17:1@?54: ?7: 504 3=6362?9 >?2 86=>?=:4: 56 504 475=?9 ?7B 86= =474>?9 68 504 B4< 96?7 8?@1915< 5 12 ?994F4: 50?5 504 1=4@56=2 =4269J4: 56 394:F4 "$"$ HE175?92 68 2EF?= ?2 256@B 24@E=15< 6>4J4= 504 @6C39?17?75?224=5250?55012:4@9?=?516712@675=?=<56504 256@B 25?54C475 8E=71204: ;< 504 8?@56=< 56 504 34I ?7B >04=417 504 @96217F 256@B >?2 206>7 ?2 $$ HE175?92679<012F9?=17F:123?=15<17256@B81FE=4286=C2 504 86E7:?5167 68 504 ?994F?5167 50?5 504 1=4@56=2 ;< :431@517F1789?54:256@B0?J4175475167?99<C12=43=424754: 504 817?7@1?9 36215167 68 504 8?@56=< >150 ? J14> 56 6;5?1717F?01F04=@=4:158?@1915<8=6C504?7B 04 94?=74: 4716= 6E7249 ?334?=17F 86= 504 345151674=20?225=47E6E29<@67547:4:50?5217@4504?7B 0?2 ?9=4?:< 17151?54: =4@6J4=< 3=6@44:17F2 E7:4= 504 4@E=1512?5167 ?7: 4@6725=E@5167 68 *17?7@1?9 22452 ?7: 786=@4C475 68 4@E=15142 754=425 @5 "!!" 504 21CE95?746E217151?516768@=1C17?93=624@E5167675042?C4 - 11 - 245 68 8?@52 12 E7>?==?754: ?7: @672515E542 ? C12E24 68 3=6@4226>4J4=50126E=51276517@9174:56?@@435504 2?1: @675475167 5 12 76> >499 245594: ;< ? @?547? 68 :4@1216726850467G;9434I6E=5?2 >499?250126E=5 50?54@676C1@68847@42?=4765C4=43=1J?54:123E542;E5 ?=43E;91@>=67F250?525=1B4?5504J4=<86E7:?516768504 817?7@1?9 1754F=15< 68 172515E51672 04=486=4 6E=52 4I4=@1217FAE=12:1@5167E7:4=4@5167"685040?=?51<? ?F?=1BE=?B20??7015?"!"#)86=206=5D"!"#G+ ?=4 =4HE1=4: 56 4I4=@124 F=4?5 @?E5167 ?7: 206E9: =48=?17 8=6C 1754=:1@517F ?7 17J4251F?5167 ?5 504 7?2@475 25?F4 E79422 504 @6C39?175 8?192 56 :12@9624 ?7< @6F71L?;94 68847@4 & 04 AE:FC4752 =4914: E367 ;< 504 94?=74: @6E724986==42367:4756"?=42HE?=49<?3391@?;9456504 3=42475 @?24 04 C?54=1?9 67 =4@6=: 17:1@?542 50?5 504 26@145< 50=6EF0 152 1=4@56=2 >06 ?=4 504 345151674=2 04=417 0?2 ?J?194: ? 2E;25?751?9 96?7 68 2$ @=6=42 ;< 394:F17F >0?5 12 ?994F4: 56 ;4 ?7 1789?54: 2EF?= 256@B - 12 - %04504= 504 1=4@56=2 ?5 504 51C4 68 3?2217F 504 =4269E5167 0?: 17 8?@5 :491;4=?549< 6J4=25?54: 504 256@B 36215167>15050417547556:48=?E:504?7B?7:24@E=4?7 4I@4221J4 96?7 12 ? C?554= 50?5 8?992 2HE?=49< >15017 504 :6C?17 68 17J4251F?5167 04 67G;94 E3=4C4 6E=5 17 $ & # %0?2@?54F6=1@?99<049:50?5?@52 68 817?7@1?9 :4@435167 34=345=?54: E367 ;?7B17F 172515E51672 ?C6E75 56 68847@42 ?F?1725 504 4@676C1@ 04?950 68 504 7?5167 ?7: >?==?75 24=16E2 17J4251F?5167 E@0 ?@52 @?7765 ;4 5=4?54: ?2 C4=4 @675=?@5E?9 6= @1J19 :123E542 ?2 504< =4894@5 8=?E:E9475 175475 ?7: 4=6:4 504 2?7@515<68817?7@1?9:12@139174 ! 7J14>68504E7:4=9<17F3=17@1394247E7@1?54: ;<50467G;9434I6E=517504?86=42?1::4@1216725012 6E=5 12 68 504 @6721:4=4: 6317167 50?5 504 3=42475 @?24 :642 765 >?==?75 1754=84=47@4 E7:4= 4@5167 " 68 504 "!"#04?994F?51672?F?1725504345151674=2?=468 24=16E2 7?5E=4 17J69J17F 504 ?994F4: 1789?5167 68 256@B 81FE=42 ?7: 394:F17F 68 7674I125475 17J4756=< 56 24@E=4 - 13 - ?7 476=C6E2 96?7 ?C6E7517F 56 2$ @=6=42 04 :12@=43?7@142 ;45>447 504 256@B 81FE=42 =4894@54: 17 504 8?@56=<G2 =4269E5167 ?7: 50624 86E7: 17 504 2E;24HE475 17234@5167 =436=5 ?2 4J1:47@4: ;< 774IE=4K ?=4 2E;25?751?9?7:=4HE1=4506=6EF0J4=181@?5167 5501225?F45046E=5@?77654C;?=BE367? :45?194: ?33=4@1?5167 68 504 :123E54: 8?@52 6= ?:AE:1@?54 E367 504 J4=?@15< 68 504 ?994F?51672 04 C?554= 74@422?=19<>?==?752?@6C3=404721J417J4251F?5167;<504 AE=12:1@5167?93691@456?2@4=5?17>04504=5041=4@56=2;< 3?2217F 504 1C3EF74: =4269E5167 0?: @67231=4: 6= ?@54: 17 @67@4=5 >150 ? 8=?E:E9475 :421F7 56 24@E=4 ? 817?7@1?9 ?:J?75?F4;<C12=43=42475?5167754=84=47@4?5501225?F4 >6E9:?C6E75562518917F?94F151C?5417J4251F?51671756?7 4@676C1@68847@4 " %1506E54I3=42217F?7<631716767504C4=15268 504 @?24 5012 6E=5 :44C2 15 ?33=63=1?54 56 34=C15 504 17J4251F?5167563=6@44:E7017:4=4:04345151674=2;417F - 14 - 1=4@56=2 68 504 EF?= *?@56=< ?=4 ;6E7: 56 4I547: 8E99 @6634=?5167 56 504 7J4251F?517F 881@4= 17 504 @6E=24 68 50417J4251F?5167 # *6= 504 86=4F617F =4?2672 ?7: 6;24=J?51672 5012 6E=5 817:2 76 C4=15 17 504 34515167 @@6=:17F9< 504 @=1C17?93451516725?7:2:12C1224: )' #!!& " 125696#