- 1 - ! "# ## #$ %&'%()* +%)) , ! "# $% & % ' % ! "# % & %&% ( & ! #" $% & % % % ( )*+ ( % % ' % &% , ( ' % #"#"#! * *"#+ & ,( ( , #-"!"" % %% " "#! & , .& % (' ( ' % Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ( /&, % /&, 01 2134345617 81469 301 :5;1 <==>:1? 46 5* *"#+56301@4;15@301;1<761???43456<;4A4; ,>?91 <6? ,( <?947 B 74<; 5>73. 4: 4C2>96469 301 D>?9C163 5@ =56A4=3456 <6? 57?17 5@ :16316=1 ?<31? #"#"#! =56A4=3469 04C @57 301 5@@16=1 2>64:0<8;1 >6?171=3456)+*5@%<6?:16316=46904C35>6?1795 :4C2;14C274:56C163@57<21745?5@561E1<7<6?352<E @461 5@ :#"""" F430 ?1@<>;3 :16316=1 F04=0 F<: =56@47C1?4674C46<;221<;5" "#!56301@4;15@301 ;1<761? 4:374=3 <6? 1::456: ,>?91 <?947 B(47:3 221;;<315>73.A4?1D>?9C163?<31?#-"!"" (<=3: 5@ 301 =<:1 46 8741@ <71 30<3 <0:4;?<7 <?9470<?71=14A1?<=71?48;146@57C<3456719<7?4694;;19<; :<6? C46469 <6? :357469 301 :<C1 46 301 ;<6? 5@ 301 - 3 - 2134345617 81<7469 E5#- 5@ <334G>64 A4;;<91 1 46@57C1?304: @<=3 35 301 D>74:?4=3456<; 25;4=1 <6? F163 35 301:253<;569F43025;4=1<6?53017:3<@@C1C817:7<4? F<:01;?56# ""#<3-)"%#"=>84=C1317:5@ :<6? F<: @5>6? 35 0<A1 8116 :3571? 46 E5#- 5@ <334G>64A4;;<9181;56946935301<==>:1?<6?30171@57143 4: =56316?1? 30<3 01 0<: =5CC4331? 301@3 5@ 301 :<6? 4;;19<;;E 01 <==>:1? <221<71? 81@571 301 74<; 5>73 2;1<?1?6539>4;3E<6?=;<4C1?35813741? 01275:1=>3456 1H<C461? %:# 35 <6? 953 C<7G1? H:%# 35 %#- 46 :>22573 5@ 30147 =563163456 ==>:1? ?1641? <;; 301 46=74C46<3469 C<3174<;: <A<4;<8;1 56 71=57? 05F1A17 01 0<: 653 =05:16 35 ;1<? <6E 1A4?16=1 46 :>22573 5@ 04: ?1@16=1 ) 01 74<; 5>73 <@317 3<G469 4635 =56:4?17<3456 301:1 C<3174<;: 56 71=57? =<C1 35 301 =56=;>:456 30<3 301 275:1=>3456 4: :>==1::@>; 46 275A469 301 9>4;3 5@ 301 <==>:1? 81E56? 71<:56<8;1 ?5>83 <6? <==57?469;E =56A4=31? <6? :16316=1? 04C <: :3<31? <85A1 01 - 4 - <==>:1?0<?=0<;;1691?301:<4?D>?9C16381@571301(47:3 221;;<315>73467;5" "#!F04=0F<:=<C13581 ?4:C4::1? &1469 <99741A1? 8E 301 :<C1 <==>:1? 4: 81@571304:5>73 - 1<7?74EE<6<95>?<%<34;;1<761?=5>6:1; @57 301 71A4:456 2134345617 <6? C3 <734 %<34; ;1<761? 4905>735A176C163%;1<?17@5771:256?163 6 A41F 5@ 301 74A<; =563163456: >791? 8E 301 ;1<761?=5>6:1;@5785303012<7341:3012546330<3F5>;? <74:1@57CE=56:4?17<34564: I013017 301 4C2>961? D>?9C163 2<::1? 8E 301 74<; 5>73 F04=0 F<: =56@47C1? 8E 301 (47:3 221;;<31 5>73 4: ;4<8;1 35 81 46317@171? F430JK E <6:F17 35 301 <85A1 25463 4: B @57301@5;;5F469 - 5 - + 3 4: 301 =563163456 5@ 301 275:1=>3456 30<3 <==>:1? 0<: =5CC4331? 301@3 5@ :<6? <6?301 :<C1 F<: :3571?4;;19<;;E 4604:;<6?81<7469E5#-5@ <334G>64 A4;;<91 01 275:1=>3456 0<: 1H<C461? %:# <6? F05 <71 301 F4361::1: 35 301 :14L>71 C<0<L<7 F017146 #" =>84=C1317:5@:<6?F<::3571?<6?301:<C1F<::14L1? @75C 301 ;<6? 81;569469 35 301 <==>:1? &>3 8530 301:1 F4361::1:0<A13>761?05:34;1 ! %) 4: 301 46@57C<63 F05 4: 301 <0:4;?<7 5@ <334G>64 A4;;<91 3 F<: 01 F05 71=14A1? 301 =71?48;1 46@57C<3456719<7?469301@35@:<6?<6?:357469301:<C1 46301;<6?81;56946935301<==>:1? 04:F4361::0<:@>;;E :>225731?301=<:15@301275:1=>3456<6?:3<31?30<301 0<? 9561 35 301 :253 <;569 F430 301 '4;;<91 ==5>63<63 <6? 25;4=1 <6? :14L1? 301 :<6? 4;;19<;;E :3571? >6?17 301 :14L>71 C<0<L<7 <: 217 H%# 04: F4361:: F<: =75:: 1H<C461? 8E 301 ;1<761? =5>6:1; @57 301 <==>:1? 8>3 - 6 - 6530469 0<: 8116 1;4=431? @75C 04C 35 ?4:81;41A1 04: A17:456 * %-4:65615301730<6301'4;;<91==5>63<63 F05 <==5C2<641? %) 35 301 :253 1 0<: <;:5 @>;;E =5775857<31?3011A4?16=15@%)% 4:301F05 2<73;E =56?>=31? 46A1:349<3456 <6? :>225731? 301 =<:1 5@ 301 275:1=>3456 % 4: 301 6A1:349<3469 @@4=17 F05 =56?>=31?@>7301746A1:349<3456<6?@4;1?301=0<791:0113 #" %:) <6? - 81469 301 5@@4=4<; F4361::1: 0<A1 @>;;E:>225731?301=<:15@301275:1=>3456?5653@46? <6E 71<:56 35 ?4:81;41A1 30147 A17:456: ==>:1? 1H=123 ?16E469301=563163456:3<G168E301275:1=>34560<:653 3<G16 <6E ?1@16=1 5 4;;F4;; 57 C534A1 4: :>991:31? <9<46:3 %) 6?17 :>=0 =47=>C:3<6=1: 275:1=>3456 4: :>==1::@>; 46 275A469 301 9>4;3 5@ 301 <==>:1? 81E56? 71<:56<8;1?5>83<6?<==>:1?4:;4<8;13581=56A4=31? ## 3304::3<91;1<761?=5>6:1;@573012134345617 =56316?1?30<330121343456174:65F<91?+E1<7:<6?4: - 7 - :>@@17469 @75C 2<7<;E:4: 0171@571 01 27<E: @57 :05F469 ;16416=E4604:@<A5>70<A195613075>903014C2>961? D>?9C163 5@ =56A4=3456 <6? 57?17 5@ :16316=1 2<::1? 8E 301 74<;5>73 01 74<;5>730<:=56A4=31?301<==>:1? <6?:16316=1?04C35>6?17954C274:56C163@57<21745? 5@ 561 E1<7 <6? 35 2<E @461 5@ :#"""" F430 ?1@<>;3 :16316=1 5@ :4H C5630: : 217 :1=3456 )+* 5@% F04=0 ?1<;:F4302>64:0C163@573015@@16=15@301@3:3<31:30<3 F051A17 =5CC43: 301 5@@16=1 5@ 301@3 :0<;; 81 2>64:01? F430 4C274:56C163 5@ 143017 ?1:=7423456 @57 < 317C F04=0 C<E1H316?3530711E1<7:57F430@46157F4308530 # 6A41F5@301<85A1<C5@301524645630<3 46:31<?5@4C25:469:>8:3<634A1:16316=1@4614C25:1?8E 301 74<; 5>73 =5>;? 81 160<6=1? F04=0 F5>;? C113 301 16?:5@D>:34=1 #) ==57?469;E<6:F17301<85A125463 <6?275=11?352<::301@5;;5F469 - 8 - 4 74C46<; 1A4:456 %1343456 4: 44 01 D>?9C163 5@ =56A4=3456 ?<31? #"#"#! 2<::1? 46 5* *"#+ 8E 301??43456<;4A4;,>?91<6?,(<?947 F04=0 F<: =56@47C1? 8E 301 4:374=3 <6? 1::456: ,>?91 <?947 46 74C46<; 221<; 5" "#!4:01718E=56@47C1? 444 7?175@:16316=12<::1?8E301 74<;5>73 4:C5?4@41?<:>6?17 < %134345617<==>:1? 4: :16316=1? 35 2<E @461 5@ : """" @<4;469 F04=0 01 :0<;; >6?1795 :4C2;1 4C274:56C163 @57 < 21745? 5@ 561 E1<7 194:37E 4: ?471=31? 35 :16? 8<=G 301 74<; 5>73 71=57?:<;569F430<=52E5@304:57?17@5746@57C<3456<6? 611?@>;<=3456 -* %##) ' 4:35#;5# %