Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63593 (KAR)
MAHAMAMED RAFIQ @ NAPATHA RAFIQ v. THE STATE THROUGH
CRL.P/201884/2025 · 2025-11-28
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63593 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63593 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$
%#& ##
#
' '()* ' )) +
!"#
$ $% & %!&'(((
) ' $% %!&#*
+ $ $
,%
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!&'&(#
-
!"##
+ $
&'
% *'
! $ !% '''((* ,% %
((--&
"* ( ( ( *"& *#
!$ , , ,$
. !
'(( (*!(&!(& '((* '(( % - 3 - / , / , 0123456131370126899:46;8<6466=30>?:84230>7@ 126 5<7966;30>4 30 7'((* 8<3430> 7:1 7@ <3A6 7'(( 7@ 6B7>3 7B396 181370 341 8B8C:<8>3 @7< 1267@@609645:03428CB6:0;6<6913704((--& "*(((*"&80;691370*#7@0;380608B 7;6 '"( 560;30> C6@7<6 3D3B ,:;>6 80; , ,6D8<8>3CE5B8930><6B3809670126F:;>A601<60;6<6;CE 12664437047:<1307&-(126<6CE89?:31130> 899:46;74"#(17&(80; 26@8914B68;30>1712698468<684@7BB7G4 26 5<64601 561313706<4 30 126 56131370 8B70> G312 7126< 97!899:46; G6<6 4:CF6916; 17 9<3A308B 5<7469:1370 8BB6>30> 1281 7G30> 17 5<37< 803A7431E C61G660 899:46; 7 80; ;696846; 84B3A 70 ((( 81 8C7:1 *( 5A70!&&816B:<$3BB8>6899:46;74"1730 - 4 - @:<126<80967@1263<97AA707CF69180;8<A6;G312;68;BE G685704 8<<3D6;30 1G7 <6HH898<4 @7<A6; 80 :0B8G@:B 8446ACBE 12<681606; 80; =3;08556; 126 ;696846; 80; 97AA3116;;89731E7@126D6239B6134@:<126<8BB6>6;1281 81126304180967@899:46;7417*899:46;7480; * <6963D6; 4:58<3 281926; 8 970453<89E 17 97AA31 126 7@@609680;126<6CE97AA3116;7@@609645:03428CB6:0;6< 6913704 ( 80; (- <68; G312 691370 *- 7@ 7046?:601BE 8BB 899:46; G6<6 928<>6; G312 7@@60964 :0;6<6913704(80;(<68;G312691370*-7@ 41265<64601561313706<4G6<68C4970;30>845B31928<>6 42661 G84 @3B6; 26 <6A83030> 899:46; 08A6BE 899:46; 74" # ( 17 & ( 80; G6<6 1<36; 80; :570 9709B:4370 7@ @:BB!@B6;>6; 1<38B 126 6443704 ,:;>6 6I6<93430> 57G6< :0;6< 691370 & < 89?:3116; 126A 7@ 7@@60964 :0;6< 6913704 * ( (- -& "((*"&80;*#<68;G312691370*- 0126C89=;<757@12689?:3118B<697<;6;CE126 64437047:<1307&-(1265<646015613137034 - 5 - @3B6; 70 126 5<6A346 1281 126 5<309358B 899:46; 28D6 8B<68;EC66089?:3116;7@126D6<E7@@6096480;1281126 5<7469:1370 9846 8>83041 126 561313706<4 8<6 304658<8CB6 @<7A 1281 7@ 126 89?:3116; 97!899:46; 1 34 970160;6; 128112670BE8BB6>813708>83041126561313706<456<1830417 126 8BB6>6; 9<3A308B 970453<89E :0;6< 691370 ( 80; 1281 30 D36G 7@ 126 9816>7<398B @30;30>4 <697<;6; CE 126 6443704 ,:;>6 126 561313706<4 G27 4180; 70 126 48A6 @77130> 84 126 89?:3116; 899:46; 8<6 60131B6; 17 43A3B8<<6B36@CE6I6<93467@1263026<601F:<34;3913707@1234 7:<1:0;6<691370*'< * 712 B68<06; 97:046B @7< 126 561313706<4 8;75130>3;601398B8<>:A601428D6;<8G01268116013707@ 1234 7:<1 17 126 <6B6D801 @30;30>4 7@ 126 6443704 ,:;>6 G23B6 89?:31130> 126 97!899:46; 8<139:B8< 6A528434 34 5B896; 70 58<8><8524 * 17 *" 7@ 126 F:;>A601 17 ;6A7041<816 1281 126 5<7469:1370 @83B6; 17 6418CB342 126 928307@93<9:A4180138B6D3;60960696448<E17C<30>27A6 126 >:3B1 7@ 126 899:46; 1 34 4:CA3116; 1281 126 - 6 - 8BB6>813704 80; 7D6<1 8914 811<3C:16; 17 126 561313706<4 B3A316;171268BB6>813707@970453<89E8<630;34130>:3428CB6 @<7A12746B6D6BB6;8>8304112689?:3116;899:46;80;126 6D3;6096 8;;:96; 30 126 9846 34 304658<8CB6 80; 30;3D343CB6 26<6@7<6 70 126 5<30935B6 7@ 58<31E 126 561313706<48<68B4760131B6;17126C606@317@89?:3118B1 34@:<126<8<>:6;12816D603@1265<7469:13703456<A3116; 17 5<7966; 126 B3=6B3277; 7@ 970D391370 34 6I1<6A6BE <6A716 80; 4:CF69130> 126 561313706<4 17 8 5<7B70>6; 9<3A308B1<38BG7:B;8A7:01178C:467@1265<796447@B8G 1 34 8B47 C<7:>21 17 126 071396 7@ 1234 7:<1 1281 126 F:;>A601 7@ 89?:3118B 30 7&-( 284 071 C660 928BB60>6; CE 126 1816 80; 284 8118306; @308B31E 80; 97046?:601BE 970130:81370 7@ 5<7966;30>4 8>83041 126 561313706<434:0G8<<8016; & 6< 9701<8 126 B68<06; G23B6 071 ;345:130> 126 F:;>A601 7@ 89?:3118B 30 7&-( 970160;41281126561313706<4G6<68C4970;30><64:B130>30 126@3B30>7@845B31928<>64266180;1281126EA:41@896 - 7 - 1<38B30;6560;601BE1348<>:6;128130D36G7@126><8D6 081:<67@8BB6>813704 309B:;30> 1267@@6096:0;6<691370 ( <68; G312
691370 ( 126 5<7966;30>4 980071 C6?:8426;:0;6<691370*'<A6<6BEC698:46126 97!899:46;28D6C66089?:3116; " 8D30>268<;B68<06;97:046B@7<126561313706<4 80;126B68<06;@7<126181612347:<197043;6<431 0696448<E C6@7<6 5<7966;30> @:<126< 17 6I8A306 126 9<:938B @30;30>4 <697<;6; CE 126 6443704 ,:;>6 G23B6 89?:31130> 126 97!899:46; 8<8><8524 ' 17 *" 7@ 126 F:;>A601 8<6 126<6@7<6 <6B6D801 80; 8<6 <6?:3<6; 17 C6 6I1<8916;@7<5<756<97043;6<81370 !!!! "
!!!! #
"$% &
"'%&(&!&
# )
*
#
"%
)
# ++,
- 8 -
-
&. #
. ( &
. /
*0 *
1
0
)
"$ 0
2 &
"%
* **0
# +.'' *
3 &
# # *
# 0
!+
#
.(2
-
+. &
/
4 & )
5
"
&
- 9 -
0
+.% ! #
1
&
$% )
+.5
6! 6
&
&
&.! )
-
4 )
#
/
&
"
0
+.&% ! #
1
#
6
&
. . #
# #
*
-6
6 '&
" *
- 10 -
"& )
' +
#
. 3
6
.44#
3
/
# &# !!! +.'% ++'( 3
)
6('0
)
&
6('
#
$.7
+$%,
-
!!!! # *
"
8
)
1
"
0
% . &
#
0
#
- 11 -
# )
+
#
. '
#
"$ , #
( 0
0
#
9 # #
. # #
#
0
"
#
"
# !! # , #
#
! 9
. 4
:96
"
- 12 -
1
7 /
"
"'&
" (
"
)
"' %
#
"
9 #
. .%
"
*
& #
"$ !& & & & '& !
&
%6#
9 &
#
#
#
#
&
#
0 &
#
#
;&
# #
#
# '6#
9
- 13 -
0
#
++ 8+
&
!$0 6#
9
!6#
9
9
)
& - &<
0<
# #
-#&
#
*
5
#
' 0
#
# 5
#
# )
#
&
##
#
- 14 -
#
)
*
$ 0 &
#
*& 0
##
5
#
;<
#
+
/
"$%!'&!
/
=
& 0
"
" #
# 0 8 98<6@:B <68;30> 7@ 126 ;6183B6;
7C46<D813704 A8;6 CE 126 B68<06; 6443704 ,:;>6 G2392 @7<A6; 126 C8434 @7< 89?:3118B 7@ 126 97!899:46; 31 C697A648C:0;801BE9B68<12811268BB6>8137048>83041126 5<64601 561313706<4 4180; 70 126 48A6 @77130> 84 12746 B6D6BB6;8>8304112689?:3116;899:46;047@8<84899:46;
74" 80; - 30 <3A308B 6131370 7(&"'(& 8<6 97096<06;12670BE8BB6>8137056<18304171263<8BB6>6;<7B6
- 15 -
30 2819230> 8 9<3A308B 970453<89E 3=6G346 30 <3A308B 6131370 7(("&(& 8<3430> 7:1 7@ 7("(* 126 8BB6>813704 8>83041 899:46; 74 80; <6B816 17 80 8BB6>6; 803A7431E 28<C7:<6; CE 899:46; 7 G27 G84 <643;30> 30 126 0316; <8C A3<8164 17G8<;4 %# 84 G6BB841268BB6>6;8917@60>8>30>899:46;7480;* 17=3;08580;A:<;6<126;696846;26468BB6>8137048<6 G27BBE 3016<G7D60 G312 126 C<78;6< 5<7469:1370 1267<E G2392 284 8B<68;E C660 ;34C6B36D6; 30 314 6013<61E CE 126 64437047:<1 ' 26 6I1<8916; @30;30>4 @<7A 58<8><8524 ' 17 *"7@12664437047:<1F:;>A601;349B74646D6<8B9<:938B ;6@393609364G2392;3<691BE3A58911264:418308C3B31E7@126 5<7469:1370 8>83041 126 5<64601 561313706<4 26 6443704 ,:;>62849816>7<398BBE0716;12811265<309358BG31064464 08A6BE % 17 %& G27 8BB6>6;BE B841 48G 126 ;696846;3012697A580E7@899:46;74"17816B:< 28D6 1:<06; 97A5B616BE 27413B6 :<126< 126 6443704 ,:;>6 G23B6 808BE430> 126 9<744!6I8A3081370 7@ %*
- 16 -
126 97A5B830801 284 23>2B3>216; 1281 1234 G310644 45693@398BBE ;6036; 126 97<6 8BB6>81370 1281 126 ;696846; G84=3;08556;81126304180967@899:46;7417*26 6443704 ,:;>6 284 8B47 8;D6<16; 17 126 D7B:018<E 41816A60147@899:46;74"(*&(80;
80; 284 9709B:;6; 1281 126 5<7469:1370 284 @83B6; 17 6418CB342 126 64460138B 30><6;36014 7@ 691370 # 7@ 126 0;380 D3;6096 91 80; 1281 126 8BB6>6; <697D6<364 8<6 071 5<7D6; 30 8997<;8096 G312 B8G 0 8;;31370 126 6443704 7:<1 284 3;6013@36; A816<38B 9701<8;3913704 7A3443704 80; 46<37:4 B85464 30 126 30D6413>81370 :B13A816BE27B;30>1281126928307@93<9:A4180138B6D3;6096 <6B36;:570CE1265<7469:1370;764071@7<A897A5B616 80;:0C<7=60B30=5730130>17126>:3B17@126899:46;0 1234 7D6<8BB 844644A601 126 97!899:46; 08A6BE 899:46;
74" # ( 17 & ( 80; G6<6 89?:3116; 7@ 8BB 928<>64 :0;6< 6913704 * ( (- -& " ( (*"&80;*#<68;G312691370*-7@
- 17 -
- 26 B68<06; 97:046B @7< 126 561313706<4 284 5B896; <6B38096 70 126 F:;>A601 7@ 126 70.CB6 :5<6A6 7:<130
84 G6BB84126F:;>A6017@1267!7<;30816609230
! "!" #$ %!!"!!&'%'(265<30935B64B83;;7G0 126<630 58<139:B8<BE 1281 G26<6 126 6D3;6096 8>83041 97!
899:46; 34 304658<8CB6 80; 30;3D343CB6 80; 126 A830 899:46; 28D6 C660 89?:3116; 70 A6<314 970130:81370 7@ 5<7966;30>4 8>83041 126 8C4970;30> 899:46; G7:B;C6 80 8C:46 7@ 5<79644 4?:8<6BE 855BE 17 126 5<64601 9846 6<6 126 5<7469:1370 9846 <6414 47B6BE 70 93<9:A4180138B 6D3;609626A7419<:938B93<9:A41809608A6BE126JB841 4660K 1267<E 284 97BB8546; 30 D36G 7@ =6E G31064464 1:<030> 27413B6 096 126 4:C41<81:A 7@ 126 5<7469:1370 9846284C66097A5B616BE;34B7;>6;CE126@30;30>430 7&-(12347:<1347@12697043;6<6;D36G1281126 5<64601 561313706<4 G27 @896 8BB6>813704 7@ 3;601398B 80;
304658<8CB6 081:<6 980071 C6 97A56BB6; 17 :0;6<>7 8
- 18 -
@:BB!@B6;>6; 1<38B 997<;30>BE 126 56131370 ;646<D6 17 C6 8BB7G6; 80; 126 5<7966;30>4 560;30> 8>83041 899:46; 74" 80; - 899:46; 74 80; 80; 899:46; 7& 8<6B38CB617C6?:8426; (48B<68;E;349:446;6D603@1264644370498464 G6<6 17 C6 30;6560;601BE 5<7469:16; 126 B3=6B3277; 7@ 970D3913707@126561313706<4346I1<6A6BE<6A7160@891 30B3>217@1269816>7<398B@30;30>4<697<;6;CE1266443704 7:<1 30 7&-( 126 57443C3B31E 7@ 970D391370 34 D3<1:8BBE 070!6I341601 :CF69130> 126 561313706<4 17 8 5<7B70>6; 9<3A308B 1<38B 30 4:92 93<9:A4180964 G7:B;
8A7:01 17 56<A31130> 80 8C:46 7@ 126 F:;3938B 5<79644 G2392 1234 7:<1 980071 97:01608096 26<6@7<6 970130:813707@1265<7966;30>434G27BBE:0G8<<8016;80; B38CB617C6?:8426;
0 D36G 7@ 126 @7<6>730> ;349:44370 1234 7:<1 5<7966;4175844126@7BB7G30>
- 19 -
326561313703426<6CE!#) 33 26 5<7966;30>4 560;30> 30
7'((*8<3430>7:17@<3A67'((7@ 6B7>3 7B396 181370 341 8B8C:<8>3 @7< 126 7@@609645:03428CB6:0;6<6913704((- -&"*(((*"&80;691370*#7@ 0;380 608B 7;6 '"( 560;30> C6@7<6 3D3B ,:;>6 80; , ,6D8<8>3 3047@8< 84 126 561313706<48<697096<06;8<626<6CE?:8426;
,* ' ##) &
, 3417B7'