- 1 - ! "#$## %% & '$( ) !" ! # ! $ % & '( ) ( * Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( % ( ( ++(%! & ' ( + ( +, ( ( * ( + ( + (( ( + ( % ) ( - ( ) "# ' * ' * ( + ) ( # - ( ) ') * """ ( + ) - 3 - ( - ) ( $ # ' - ) ( * ./0 122314 /0 56 7.3 241/87/990 1::;/3<3= 56 7.3 >?=:@387 18= =3A;33 =173= 21003= /8 B"# 3C BB87.39/43B97.338/B; (/</4 )?=:3 ?@8151= '.3;3/81973; ;393;;3= 10 D+/;07 22344173(B?;7E*56C./A.7.3+/;0722344173(B?;7C./43 0377/8: 10/=37.3>?=:@387 18==3A;33 =173= # 21003=/8 B"""B87.39/43B97.3;/8A/214(/</4 )?=:3');8*(B?;7?@8151==/0@/003=7.30?/7C/7. AB070 .315B<30?/7/8 B"""/09/43=/8/70 ;32;3038717/<3A.1;1A73;?8=3;;=3;?43((567.3 241/87/990 C.B 1;3 1223441870 .3;3/8 033F/8: 7.3 9B44BC/8: ;34/390% - 4 - * ! (103 B9 7.3 241/87/990 /0 7.17 7.36 1;3 7.3 ;30/=387B9?@8151= BC87.36.1<3AB@@B8;/:.718= /873;307 B<3; 7.3 =/02?73= 217.C16 14B8: C/7. 8?@3;B?0 18= 03<3;14 23;0B80 B9 ?@8151= BC8 .17 7.36 1;3 38:1:3= /8 5?0/8300 18= B7.3; A144/8:0 18= 9B; 7.17 2?;2B03 7.36 .1<3 7B :B B?70/=3 B9 ?@8151= 9B; 7;1802B;717/B8 91A/4/7/30 @1=3 56 7.3 =3938=1870 B 7.3 3107B9 (5?00718=:1=/416B?7/00/7?173= B7.3 C307 B9 ( 5?0 0718= ?@18151= 2B4/A3 0717/B8 /0 0/7?173= (5?00718=/0/83G/0738A39B;@B;37.18 631;01;4/3; (5?00718=C1038A4B03=938A3=C/7. 151;53=C/;31;B?8=/7431</8:10@144C16172B/87 - 5 - 7B# .303C160C3;343979B;7.3?0318=38>B6@387B9 7.3 2?54/A B9 ?@8151= BC8 18= 0?;;B?8=/8: </441:30 C.B.1<35338?0/8:18=38>B6/8:7.301@3101;/:.7B9 C167B3873; (5?00718= .3;31;37CB@1/8:1730 7B 7.3 ( 5?0 0718= B8 /70 8B;7.3;8 5B?8=1;6 91A/8: 4= B" 8 7.3 241A3 B9 51;53= C/;3 938A3 AB@2B?8= C1440 1;3 AB807;?A73= 56 7.3 =3938=1870 18= C./43 AB807;?A7/8: 7.3 AB@2B?8= C144 =3938=1870 .1<3 8B7 =/07?;53=7.301/=C160 .3C160/87B#1;307/44 /8 ?03 .3 =/02?73= C16 /0 A?07B@1;6 ;/:.7 10 C344 10 1 2?54/A C16 41/87/990 18= 2?54/A .1<3 ;/:.7 7B 3873; 7.3 (5?00718=7.;B?:.7.3=/02?73=C16 .3=/02?73= :173 /0 1;;18:3= 7B 91A/4/7173 7.3 2?54/A 7B 2;3<387 7.3 387;18A3B907;1618/@1403938=187053/8:7.3AB;2B;173 5B=60.B?4=4BBF1973;7.3AB8<38/38A318=C3491;3B97.3 2?54/A18=7.3/;53773;@387 .3=3938=18701;3/8738=/8: 7B A4B03 7.3 =/02?73= 217.C16 56 38A4B0/8: /7 C/7. AB@2B?8=C144 .3;3H?3070@1=3567.32?54/A1741;:3 - 6 - 6/34=3= 8B ;30?470 41/87/990 A1?03= 7.3 /00?3 B9 1 8B7/A3 =173=#"";3H?307/8:=3938=18708B77BA4B037.3 =/02?73= 217.C16 BC3<3; =3938=1870 7.;317383= 7B A4B03 7.3 =/02?73= 217.C16 9B;A/546 C/7./8 1 C33F :/</8: ;/037BA1?03B91A7/B838A37.30?/7 3938=1870 B8 7.3 B7.3; .18= =/02?7/8: 7.3 A103B97.3241/87/990AB8738=3=7.177.3;3/08BA?07B@1;6 ;/:.7B<3;7.3=/02?73=217.C163;3/8AB8<38/38A37.17 @1653A1?03=7B7.3=3938=18707B;31A.7.35?00718= A188B7 :/<3 7.3@ 7.3 A?07B@1;6 ;/:.7 B<3; 7.3 =/02?73= :173C163938=18701;3387/743=7B@1/871/87.32;B23;76 10 150B4?73 BC83;0 B9 7.3 5?0 0718= 2;3@/030 .3 =/02?73= :173C16 /0 53/8: ?03= 56 7.3 =3938=1870 18= 7.3/;3@24B63305?7/7/08B7@31879B;2?54/A?7/4/7610/7 C10 4397 9B; 7.3 5;/8:/8: @173;/14 ;3H?/;/8: 9B; 7.3 AB807;?A7/B8 B9 7.3 AB@2B?8= C144 .3 0?/7 /0 ./7 56 2;B</0/B80 B9 1;8171F1 ?54/A ;3@/030 A7 38A3 0B?:.79B;=/0@/0014B97.30?/7 - 7 - .3 ;/14(B?;79;1@3=7.39B44BC/8:/00?30% "#$ % & '(")* + ( , ! % - % % ! +/<3C/7830030.1<353383G1@/83=B853.149B9 7.3241/87/99010 7B 18=.1<3 3G./5/73=7C34<3 =BA?@3870 10 23; G0 7B G 83 1@1;1B .?@143 .10 5338 3G1@/83= 10 B8 53.149 B9 7.3 =3938=1870 18= 7.3 (B?;7 (B@@/00/B83; C10 122B/873= 7.;B?:. C.B@ 7.;33 =BA?@3870 10 23; ( 7B ( .1<3 5338@1;F3= - 8 - # 8 122;3A/17/B8 B9 3</=38A3 7.3 ;/14 (B?;7 180C3;3= 7.3 /00?30 B 18= /8 7.3 199/;@17/<3 18= /00?3 B/87.383:17/<318=AB803H?38746=3A;33=7.3 0?/7102;163=9B; 3/8:1::;/3<3=567.301@37.3=3938=1870% 18=AB;2B;17/B82;393;;3=;3:?41;122314(B80/=3;/8:7.3 :;B?8=0 7.3 +/;07 22344173 (B?;7 9;1@3= 7.3 9B44BC/8: 2B/8709B;/70AB80/=3;17/B8% . ) * ! * % & ) % " 8 ;3%122;3A/17/B8 B9 7.3 3</=38A3 7.3 +/;07 22344173(B?;7180C3;3=7.32B/87 B/87.3199/;@17/<3 18= AB803H?38746 144BC3= 7.3 122314 =/0@/00/8: 7.3 0?/7 56 0377/8: 10/=3 7.3 >?=:@387 18= =3A;33 21003= 56 7.3 ;/14(B?;718==/0@/003=7.30?/7B97.3241/87/990 - 9 - 3/8:1::;/3<3=567.301@37.3241/87/9901;3 539B;37./0(B?;7 ;/ 1A./8 1.1>18 431;83= AB?8034 12231;/8:9B;7.31223441870;3/73;17/8:7.3:;B?8=0?;:3= /8 7.3 122314 @3@B 0?5@/773= 7.17 7.3 +/;07 22344173 (B?;73;;3=/8.B4=/8:7.177.30?/7/0./7562;B</0/B80B9 1;8171F1?54/A;B@/030A7C/7.B?7<3;/96/8:7.391A70 18= A/;A?@0718A30 B9 7.3 A103 .3 +/;07 22344173 (B?;7 B?:.7 8B7 7B .1<3 ;3<3;03= 7.3 9/8=/8: 18= AB8A4?0/B8 1;;/<3=567.3 ;/14(B?;7 .177.3241/87/99010C344107.3 :383;142?54/AB9 7.3 BC8.1<35338?0/8:7.30?/7C16 9B; /8:;300 18= 3:;300 0/8A3 7/@3 /@@3@B;/14 .3 3G/0738A3 B9 7.3 0?/7 C16 .10 5338 1=@/773= 56 7.3 ;302B8=3870 .17 7.3 1<1/415/4/76 B9 7.3 1473;8173 C16 B?:.78B77B.1<353387.3;310B89B;7.3+/;0722344173 (B?;77B144BC7.312231418=7B=/0@/007.30?/7C/7.B?7 122;3A/17/8:7.391A77.177.3=/02?73=0?/7C16.105338 /8 ?03 0/8A3 7/@3 /@@3@B;/14 .17 C.38 7.3 241/87/990 .1<3307154/0.3=7.3/;A?07B@1;6;/:.7B93103@3878B8% - 10 - AB80/=3;17/B8B97.3@173;/143</=38A3241A3=B8;3AB;=56 7.3 241/87/990 C/7.B?7 ;393;38A3 7B 7.3 2;B</0/B80 B9 3A7/B80!18=B97.3103@387A7.10:/<38;/037B 0?507187/14H?307/B8B941CC1;;187/8:/873;93;38A3177.3 .18=0B97./0(B?;7 / 431;83=AB?80349B;7.3;302B8=3870 <3.3@38746 0?5@/70 7.17 7.3 <3;6 0?/7 9/43= 56 7.3 241/87/990 /0 @/0AB8A3/<3= .17 8B A?07B@1;6 ;/:.70 .1<3 5338 307154/0.3= 56 7.3 241/87/990 10 ;3H?/;3= ?8=3; 41C .3;/:.7B9C1653/8:A41/@3=;?807.;B?:.7.35?00718= B9 ;302B8=387 % AB;2B;17/B8 7 /0 8B7 0193 7B 23;@/7 7.3 241/87/990 7B .1<3 /8:;300 18= 3:;300 7.;B?:. 7.3 5?0 0718= 21;7 9;B@ 241/87/990 8B7 53/8: 387/743= ?8=3; 41C 9B; ;3AB:8/7/B8 B9 0?A. ;/:.7 /7 CB?4= 140B 38=18:3; 7.3 019376 B9 4/93 18= 2;B23;76 B9 7.3 241/87/990 18= B7.3; 23;0B80 7B C.B@ 7.3 241/87/990 A41/@ 7B ;32;30387 .17 7.3;3 1;3 @1/8 :1730 B8 7.3 8B;7.3;8 0/=3 B9 7.3 ( 5?0 0718= C./A. /0 ?03= 56 7.3 2?54/A 7B 3873; 7.3 5?0 0718=C./A..1053381=@/773=567.3241/87/990EC/7830030 - 11 - 3;3/8AB8<38/38A3A188B7537.3:;B?8=9B;7.3241/87/990 7B 033F A?07B@1;6 ;/:.7 7B 3873; 7.3 5?0 0718= 38A3 033F09B;=/0@/0014B97.3122314 31;=3;?03=7.3;3AB;=0 +;B@ 7.3 1<3;@3870 /8 7.3 241/87 18= 7.3 2;163; 0B?:.7 7.3;3/8 /7 /0 A431; 7.17 7.3 241/87/990 1;3 033F/8: =3A41;17/B8 B9 7.3/; A?07B@1;6 ;/:.7 B9 C16 B<3; 7.30?/7C16@1;F3=/8;3=AB4B?;7B3873;7.35?00718= B97.3=3938=18707.;B?:.7.30?/7C16177.32B/878 B7.3; CB;=0 7.3 241/87/990 1;3 033F/8: 1AA300 7B 7.3 5?0 0718=7.;B?:.7.30?/7C16 .B?:.7.30?/7/09;1@3=7B A41/@3103@3871;6;/:.7010?8=3;07BB=567.3 ;/14(B?;7 /8 91A7 /7 /0 9B; 7.3 2?;2B03 B9 :1/8/8: 1AA300 7B 7.3 5?0 0718= (41/@ 9B; A?07B@1;6 3103@387 /0 5103= B8 1 4BA14A?07B@7.17144BC018/8=373;@/81543A4100B923B243 7B ?03 418= B9 18B7.3; 23;0B8 9B; 023A/9/A 2?;2B03 7 /0 .34=561:;B?2B;AB@@?8/76/8;3417/B87B7.3/;4BA14/76 - 12 - 41/87/990.1<391/43=7B307154/0.7.36534B8:7B0?A.:;B?2 B;AB@@?8/76B97.34BA14/7638>B6/8:7.3;/:.7:;1873=56 14BA14A?07B@7B.1<31=@/773=7.177.361;3 8B77.3;30/=387B9831;561;31 .36.1<31=@/773=7.17 7.3;3 1;3 7CB @1/8 :1730 387;18A3 2;B</=3= B8 7.3 8B;7.3;8 0/=3 B9 7.3 5?0 0718= C./A. /0 ?03= 56 :383;14 2?54/A9B;/8:;30018=3:;300 ! .3;3 /0 8B =/02?73 B9 7.3 91A7 7.17 2;B23;76 C.3;37.35?00718=/00/7?173=534B8:07B7.3;302B8=387 % AB;2B;17/B8 7 /0 7.3 2;3;B:17/<3 B9 7.3 ;302B8=387 % AB;2B;17/B8 7B 2;303;<3 18= 2;B73A7 /70 2;B23;76 18= 2;B</=3 1AA300 7B 7.3 2?54/A /8 7.3 ;3:?4173= @1883; =@/773=46 ;302B8=387 % AB;2B;17/B8 .10 2;B</=3= @1/8 :1730 B8 7.3 8B;7.3;8 0/=3 B9 7.3 5?0 0718= 9B; :383;14 2?54/A 7B .1<3 /8:;300 18= 3:;300 41/87/990 B; 186B83 7.;B?:. B; ?8=3; 7.3@ A188B7 A41/@ 186 2;3;B:17/<3 7B 3873; 7.3 5?0 0718= 7.;B?:. 1 21;7/A?41; :173 17 7.3/; AB8<38/38A3B;B27/B8 - 13 - # .3 ;/14 (B?;7 .10 @/0;31= 7.3 2;B</0/B80 B9 41C18=7.391A718=A/;A?@0718A30B97.3A103C./A.7.3 +/;0722344173(B?;7/87.3AB80/=3;3=</3CB97./0(B?;7 .10037/7;/:.7 B0?507187/14H?307/B8B941CCB?4=1;/03 9B; AB80/=3;17/B8 /8A3 7.3 122314 41AF0 @3;/7 AAB;=/8:467.39B44BC/8:, * .3122314/0=/0@/003= * .3 >?=:@387 18= =3A;33 21003= 56 7.3 +/;0722344173(B?;7/0AB89/;@3= *' &##( $ )) /07 B4 B (