Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63585 (KAR)

VITTAL CHALAWADI v. THE CHIEF ENGINEER

WP/202192/2025 · 2025-11-26

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$% &%'!%!% (!!) !"# $ % & # ' ' (!) " (!) * ' (!) $ %& Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ""! + "", ' ' ' ' - ' " ""# "*)""" & ' ' & ' ' # - " ( ""# )#"" # ' '' ). ' / % /& 01 2134345617 48 91:571 3048 5;73 811<46= :5>>5?46= 71>41:@8A B%C& 88;1 C ?743 46 301 6C3;71 5: DC6ECD;8 E471F346= 301 718256E1638 35 F5684E17 301 56>461 C22>4FC3456:4>1E9G3012134345617C8217661H;71 534:4FC3456 5" ""# EC31E "*)""" 488;1E 9G 301 C317 185;7F1 12C73D163 - 3 - %9&88;1C?743463016C3;715:DC6ECD;8E471F346= 301 718256E1638 35 F5684E17 301 56>461 C22>4FC3456 :4>1E9G3012134345617C6EF5D2>13130171F7;43D163 275F188C81C7>GC8258849>1 %F&88;1C?743463016C3;715:DC6ECD;8E471F346= 301718256E1638354681733016CD15:3012134345617 4630181>1F3456>483#C3661H;712;9>4FC345646 5" ( ""# EC31E )#"" 488;1E 9G 301 718256E163 5# F041: 16=4611746=5::4F1 C317185;7F1 12C73D163C801 48D17435745;8FC6E4EC31C6E81F;71E ). %E& 88;1 C ?743 57 57E17 E471F3456 C8 E11D1E :43 ;6E17301:CF38C6EF47F;D83C6F185:301FC8146301 463171835:I;834F1C6E1J;43GK " C815:30121343456174830C3467182568135301 6534:4FC3456 EC31E "*)""" 488;1E 9G 301 C317 185;7F1 12C73D163 :57 301 2;72581 5: :4>>46= ;2 5: 301 9CF<>5= 25838 ;6E17 301 F01E;>1 C831 FC31=57G 35 301 2583 5: 1F56E 4L48456 88483C63 5: 75;2 M@ FCE71 21343456170CE8;9D4331E56>461C22>4FC3456;981J;163>G 2134345617?C8FC>>1E;256:57E5F;D163L174:4FC34560C3 010CE8;9D4331EC>>30171J;471EE5F;D1638C8C6E?016 FC>>1E ;256 9G 301 71F7;4346= C;305743G 0C3 301 718256E163(C;305743G 0CE 488;1E C 275L48456C> >483 56 - 4 - ",!""016CD15:2134345617?C8653805?6146= C==741L1E9G3018CD130121343456174891:57130485;73 * 1C761E F5;681> :57 301 2134345617 C221C746= 3075;=0 L4E15 F56:1716F1 8;9D438 30C3 301 2134345617 0CL46=81F;71E ).46301CFCE1D4F48D571D17435745;8 30C6 DC6G 5: 301 FC6E4EC318 ?0581 6CD1 :4=;71E 46 301 275L48456C> >483 1 254638 5;3 35 F173C46 6CD18 :5;6E C3 >58 * ,, C6E :75D # 35 ##) ?0171 301 FC6E4EC318?050CE81F;71E217F163C=1:C791>5?30C35: 301 2134345617 46 30147 CFCE1D4F8 0CL1 9116 >4831E 01 718256E163(71F7;43D163 C;305743G 0C8 653 C884=61E C6G 71C8568 ?0C3851L17 143017 35 CFF123 57 35 71I1F3 301 FC6E4EC3;71 5: 301 2134345617 16F1 01 811<8 :57 301 C>>5?46=5:30121343456 6 71825681 >1C761E C221C746= :57 301 718256E1638E7C?46=C331634565:30485;73352C=15!! 5: 301 ?743 21343456 C3 661H;71( C 275L48456C> >483 8;9D438 30C3 301 FC6E4EC318 ?0581 6CD18 ?171 >1:3 5;3 - 5 - ?17171J;471E35:4>13014759I1F34568C6E30121343456170C8 653:4>1EC6G59I1F3456:570486CD10CL46=9116>1:35;3 1:17746= 35 3018C4E E5F;D1638 :75D2C=158!! 35 * >1C761E 8;9D438 30C3 FC6E4EC318 0CE :4>1E 30147 59I1F34568 C6E ?05 0CE 1L16 81F;71E 913317 30C6 301 2134345617017146C6E821F4:4F71C85680CL19116C884=61E :57656(F5684E17C34565:30147C22>4FC34569G301C;305743G 1 8;9D438 30C3 2134345617 5;=03 35 0CL1 :4>1E 048 59I1F34568 35 301 275L48456C> >483 30C3 653 0CL46= 9116 E561 9G 301 2134345617 FC6653 F7G C6G :5;> 91:571 3048 5;73463048213434561:;7301771:17835C275L48456C>>483 6534:4FC3456 EC31E ###"" ?04F0 48 488;1E E;746= 301 216E16FG 5: 3048 ?743 21343456 ?04F0 48 C 71L481E 275L48456C>81>1F3456>483:57301C:5718C4E25838F56848346= 5: # " FC6E4EC318 0171:571 01 8;9D438 30C3 301 2134345617 48 653 16343>1E 35 301 71>41: C8 85;=03 :57 5?1L1701:C47>G8;9D43830C3846F1301:46C>>4830C8653 9116C665;6F1E4:3012134345617DC<18C712718163C3456 3018CD1?4>>91F5684E171E46CFF57EC6F1?430>C? - 6 - 018;9D488456483C<165671F57E ! 01 :CF38 6C77C31E C95L1 C6E 301 71F57E8 71:1771E 35 C95L1 46E4FC31 30C3 C:317 2;9>4FC3456 5: 301 275L48456C>>48359I1F34568?171:4>1E9GFC6E4EC318?0581 6CD18 0CE 9116 >1:3 5;3 C6E 301 8CD1 0CL1 9116 F5684E171E 9G 301 71F7;4346= C;305743G 9G =4L46= E13C4>1E 71C85646= ED4331E>G 2134345617 0C8 653 :4>1E C6G 59I1F3456 01 81F56E 275L48456C> >483 0C8 9116 2;9>4801E 56###""C:317F5684E17C34565:59I1F3456846F1301 :46C> 81>1F3456 >483 48 653 G13 C665;6F1E C6E C>85 30171 48 65 F56E43456 2718F74946= 57 275L4E46= C6G F;3(5:: EC31 :57 8;9D488456 5: 301 59I1F34568 46 301 >4=03 5: 8;9D488456 DCE1 9G >1C761E 3 48 5216 :57 301 2134345617 4: CEL481E 35 8;9D43 048 712718163C345659I1F3456 35 301 71F7;4346= C;305743G(718256E163 5" : 8;F0 C6 C22>4FC345659I1F3456 48 :4>1E 718256E163 5" 80C>> F5684E17 301 8CD1 46 CFF57EC6F1 ?430 >C? C6E 2C88 C2275274C31 57E178 C6E F5DD;64FC31 301 8CD1 35 301 2134345617 - 7 - 430C95L159817LC345683012134345648E482581E5: !*+ (%!%) ' 4835#>5#