- 1 - !" #!$ %$!&!$$ $ '( ')*+ '!!** , ! " # $ % &!$ '%(" ) * + Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , ! '%(%" ! % ! '%' - ! '%(%#" ) * ,. ,+ , #( ,+ ! / ("" "("%"" ! , "" , ! , , ,' + , 0 , , , ,, ! 1 - 3 - * 1 + 23435656&7389:367;<==>93?&95&%<83933@67; 5&A><92523=86B67<C48&=33?67;967656<53?<;<6795523B67 86B3 &("" &D !&B37 &C6=3 5<56&7 <6=2>8 437?67;67&""&7523D6C3&D523C3<873? ??C6E6C>?;3F,'<6=2>8*238367<D53883D3883? 5& <9 G86<C &>850+ 83;695383? D&8 523 &DD37=3 4>7692<:C3 >7?38 3=56&79 #$(' %"# %" 8H #$ &D <7? 3=56&79<7?#&D&H8I8&26:656&7=5*D&892&85 =5+ 3<8? 86 >?<892<7 C3<873? =&>793C D&8 523 435656&7389 <7? 86 <B<?<8 2<2<:>??67 C3<873? 6;2&>85&E387B375C3<?38D&85238394&7?375&J 5<53 86 <8>7 <56C C3<873? =&>793C D&8 8394&7?375 &38>93?523B<5386<C9&783=&8? 7 E63H &D 523 86E<C =&753756&79 >8;3? :I 523 C3<873?=&>793CD&8:&525234<856395234&67552<5H&>C? <8693D&8BI=&796?38<56&769 - 4 - !"#$% # I<79H385&523<:&E34&67569& 0D&8523D&CC&H67; !! % 394&7?375&<9=&B4C<67<75D6C3?<486E<53 =&B4C<67567&(#"":3D&8352386<C&>85<;<6795 <==>93? &9 5& % <CC3;67; =&BB6996&7 &D &DD37=39 4>7692<:C3 >7?38 3=56&79 #$(' %"# %" 8H #$ &D <7?3=56&79<7?#&D=5569523=&753756&7 &D 523 =&B4C<67<75 52<5 923 B<8863? <==>93? & &7 "#"% <7? 967=3 5237 923 95<853? 8396?67; 67 523 B<586B&76<C 2&>93 ==>93? & 69 523 D<5238 <==>93? &69523B&5238<==>93?&9#<7?%<835239695389&D <==>93? & 5 523 56B3 &D B<886<;3 % 5&C<9 &D ;&C? &87<B3759 " 5&C<9 &D 96CE38 <856=C39 <7? 2&>932&C? - 5 - <856=C39H&8529%""""'H383;6E3723=&B4C<67<75 H<9H&8@67;<934>5I<7<;3867 ,<7@<5<6=2>8 <7? <D538 523 B<886<;3 923 ;&5 58<79D3883? 5& 6K<I<4>8 <7?95<I3?67523B<586B&76<C2&>93 5 69 =&7537?3? 52<5 ?>867; 238 95<I 67 523 B<586B&76<C 2&>93 923 H<9 583<53? H652 =8>3C5I <9 523 <==>93?>93?5&<:>9323867D6C52IC<7;><;3:I9>943=567; 238 D6?3C65I <7? 923 H<9 2>B6C6<53? <7? =86B67<CCI 6756B6?<53?>867;&E3B:38"923H<9<44&6753? 67 A>65<9 <7@ <5 >:C6 8<7=2 <7? 52383D&83 923 2<9 926D53? 238 8396?37=3 5& >:C6 <7? 95<853? 8396?67; 52383 <C&7; H652 <==>93? & 3 6796953? 238 5& 4<I 9 C<@29H26=29232<?83=36E3?D8&B ,<7@23H<9 D&8=3?5&58<79D38523<B&>75:I<==>93?&&793E38<C &==<96&79 56995<53?52<5&7""$<==>93?&<5 523 67956;<56&7 :I 523 &5238 <==>93? B<?3 <CC3;<56&7 <;<6795 238 :I 9>943=567; 238 =2<8<=538 <7? 5863? 5& - 6 - 958<7;>C<5323873=@H652<76753756&75&=<>93238?3<52 35283H<CC238=C&529&>567523B6?76;25==>93?&9 <7?2<E39>44&853?<==>93?&752367=6?375238 42&73 <C9& ;&5 ?<B<;3? ;<67 &7 ""$ <==>93? &2<?:3<537238B38=6C399CI269D<=5H<967D&8B3? :I8394&7?375&5&2384<83759<7?923=<B3:<=@5& <6=2>8&7""$2383<D538923;&558<79D3883?5& <6=2>8<7?D6C3?486E<53=&B4C<675&7""" ( 23C3<873?<;6958<532<983D3883?523B<5538 D&867E3956;<56&7>4&7H26=286B3&(""&D<6=2>8 !&B37 &C6=3 5<56&7 =<B3 5& :3 83;695383? D538 67E3956;<56&7 D67<C 834&85 =<B3 5& :3 D6C3? D&8 523 <:&E3 9<6? &DD37=39 23 435656&7389 :367; <==>93? &9 5& % <83 :3D&83 5269 &>85 933@67; 5& A><92 523 =86B67<C 48&=33?67;967656<53?<;<6795523B $ 23 B<5386<C9 &7 83=&8? ?69=C&93 52<5 8394&7?375&H<9938E67;<934>5I<7<;3867 , <7@ <6=2>8 <7? <D538 238 B<886<;3 923 938E3? 67 6K<I<4>8:I95<I67;67B<586B&76<C2&>9356CC3453B:38 - 7 - " <538 923 ;&5 <44&6753? 67 A>65<9 <7@ >:C6 8<7=2 394&7?375 & 943=6D6=<CCI 95<53? 52<5 967=3 " 923 <7? <==>93? & H383 8396?67; 67 >:C6 934<8<53CI ==&8?67; 5& 8394&7?375 & 523 67=6?375 52<52<?&==>883?&7""$2<9;<E38693D&8926D567; 238 8396?37=3 5& <6=2>8 <538 923 D6C3? 486E<53 =&B4C<675 &7 """ :>5 9&B3 2&H <CC3;<56&79 <83 B<?3 <;<6795 <==>93? &9 <7? <9 H3CC 95<567; 52<5 523I H383 365238 <:>967; &8 583<567; 238 H652 =8>3C5I &8 <:35567;<==>93?&:I9>44&8567;26B7CI:<C?<7? ;3738<C<CC3;<56&79<83B<?3<;<6795<==>93?&9<7? <7?7&5267;2<9:33795<53?<;<6795<==>93?&9#<7?% " 5 69 95<53? 52<5 <==>93? &9# <7? % <83 523 B<8863? 9695389 &D <==>93? & ==>93? &# 69 523 8396?375 &D >B:<6 <7? <==>93? &% 69 523 8396?375 &D <?<; <@67; 675& =&796?38<56&7 <CC 52393 D<=59 <7? =68=>B95<7=39 <B &D 523 &4676&7 52<5 8394&7?375& 2<9 D6C3? 486E<53 =&B4C<675 :3C<53?CI &7 """ B<@67; :<C? <7? ;3738<C <CC3;<56&79 <;<6795 523 D<B6CI - 8 - B3B:389 &D 238 2>9:<7? 3D67653CI 65 69 <7 <:>93 &D 48&=399 &D C<H :I 8&467; 67 <==>93? &9 5& % 67 523 =86B67<C48&=33?67;92383D&83523=86B67<C48&=33?67;9 67656<53?<;<6795523435656&738&95&%<==>93?&95& % 69 C6<:C3 5& :3 A><923? 67=3 52383 <83 943=6D6= <CC3;<56&79 <;<6795 435656&738&<==>93? & <B&D 523&4676&752<523697&537565C3?D&89>=2:373D65 7E63H&D523<:&E3<79H38523<:&E34&675 <7? 48&=33? 5& 4<99 523 D&CC&H67; 6 23435656&769 66 23 435656&7 D6C3? :I 435656&738 &<==>93?&69?69B6993? 666 23 435656&7 D6C3? :I 435656&738 &9 5& %<==>93?&95&%69<CC&H3? - 9 - 6E 23 =86B67<C 48&=33?67;9 67656<53? <;<6795 435656&738&95&%<==>93?&95&%67 86B3 &("" &D !&B37 &C6=3 5<56&7 <6=2>8 437?67; 67 &"" &7 523 D6C3 &D 523 C3<873? ??C 6E6C >?;3 F ,' <6=2>8 *238367<D538 83D3883? 5& <9 G86<C &>850+ 83;695383? D&8 523 &DD37=3 4>7692<:C3>7?383=56&79#$('%"#%" 83<?H6523=56&7#$&D<7?3=56&79 <7?#&D&H8I8&26:656&7=5692383:I A><923? !-+ '$$* & 695&C&