Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63576 (KAR)
SHARANAMMA v. DHULAMMA AND ORS
RFA/200093/2024 · 2025-07-25
K S Hemalekha, Mohammad Nawaz
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63576 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63576 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "####$%
"## !! &!'!( $
! "
#$ %
&
'( )%
*+,+
$
'( )%
*+,+
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
$-
) *+,+
. $$
'( )%
*+,+
+
/
$-
. *+,+
#
. & $+
&&
*+,+
-
-0
*+,+
,
/)
#0
/
- 3 -
*+,+
/
#
#0
/
*+,+
!. / %1
/ +1 $#%-
+-+
,
//"
// #
/
. #$
. # )
# //
/ /. )
/ / . -+
/
. :. 2. &
2. - 4 -
)# ! 2. "
345 677869 45 7:8;8::8< 6=64>5? ?38 @:<8: <6?8< #$76558<AB?38<<4?4@>698>4@:4C49.D<=8 696AD:6=4!38:84>6;?8::8;8::8<?@'?:469@D:?(;@:53@:?" 4> @# E38:8AB ?38 ?:469 @D:? 699@E8< @, ;498< D><8: 8F?4@> + @; ?38 @<8 @; 4C49 :@F8<D:8 , !'( ;@: 53@:?" AB <8;8><6>? @+ 6>< F@>58GD8>?9B :8H8F?8< ?38 7964>? @> ?38 =:@D>< ?36? ?38 6778996>? 7964>?4;; 38:84> <8>48< 38: 54=>6?D:8 @>?386I696?36>6J6<D:4>=38:F:@5508K6J4>6?4@>
778996>? 7964>?4;; ;498< 6 5D4? ;@: 76:?4?4@> 6>< 5876:6?8 7@558554@> 4> :8578F? @; D:C8B @# J865D:4>= - 6F:85 =D>?65 54?D6?8< 6? L6<7D: 69DI 6>< 45?:4F? 696AD:6=4 !'5D4? 7:@78:?B( ;@: 53@:?" 588I4>= +?3 536:8 6>< ;@: <8F96:6?4@> ?36? ?38 5698 <88<5 8K8FD?8<AB:857@><8>?@+?@,65>D996><C@4<6><>@? A4><4>=@>?38536:8@;?387964>?4;;
- 5 -
$ D:4>= ?38 :8F@:<4>= @; 8C4<8>F8 E38> E65 F:@5508K6J4>8< 538 <8>48< 38: 54=>6?D:8 @> ?38 6I696?36>6J6 /@99@E4>= ?345 :857@><8>? @+ <8;8><6>? @+ ;498< 6> 67794F6?4@> D><8: 8F?4@> +@;588I4>=677:@7:46?8@:<8:5@>?38=:@D><?36? ?38 6778996>? 365 <45@E>8< 38: 54=>6?D:8 @> ?38 6I696?36>6J6 38 @AH8F?4@>5 E8:8 ;498< AB ?38 6778996>? 7964>?4;;?@@,
38 ?:469 @D:? 389< ?36? F6?8=@:4F699B <8>48< 38: 54=>6?D:8 @> ?38 6I696?36>6J6 38>F8 ?38 6<C@F6?8F@D9<>@?36C8:87:858>?8<4>?385D4?6>< F@>58GD8>?9B ?38 5D4? E65 >@? J64>?64>6A98 <D8 ?@ ?38 6A58>F8@;6C694<6I696?36>6J68K8FD?8<AB38 ?:469 @D:? ;D:?38: @A58:C8< ?36? 54>F8 <4:8F?9B 6>< D>8GD4C@F699B <8>48< 36C4>= 54=>8< ?38 6I696?36>6J6 ?38:8 E65 >@ 5F@78 @; 4>C@I4>= 8F?4@> -$ @; ?38 ><46> C4<8>F8F?,-!'F?(;@:53@:?"6><AB?38@:<8:?38 ?:469@D:?699@E8<@,6><:8H8F?8<?387964>?@>?38
- 6 -
=:@D><?36??38:845>@C694<6I696?36>6J68K8FD?8<AB
+ 86:< ?38 986:>8< F@D>589 67786:4>= ;@: ?38 6778996>? 6>< ?38 986:>8< F@D>589 67786:4>= ;@: ?38 :857@><8>?56><78:D58<?38J6?8:469@>:8F@:< # 38J64>F@>?8>?4@>@;?38:857@><8>?545?36? ?38 7:858>? 677869 45 >@? J64>?64>6A98 54>F8 699@E4>= @;
@, 6>< >@ :8=D96: 677869 9485 ?38 6778996>? 7964>?4;;
@D=3? ?@ 36C8 5@D=3? :8J8<B 4; 6>B D><8: :8C454@> HD:45<4F?4@> - > ?38 564< F@>?8K? 986:>8< F@D>589 67786:4>= ;@:?386778996>? 7964>?4;;5DAJ4?5?36??38564<F@>?8>?4@> 45 98=699B J45F@>F84C8< 6>< D>?8>6A98 65 8F?4@> !" @;
?38 6 :8H8F?4@> @; 7964>? 6J@D>?5 ?@ 6 <8F:88 <8F:88 45 6778696A98 D><8: 8F?4@> # @; ? 45 F@>?8><8< ?36? E36? 45 677869 6=64>5?
AB ?38 6778996>? 7964>?4;; 45 ?38 :8H8F?4@> @; ?38 7964>? 6>< >@? - 7 -
6=64>5??384>?8:9@FD?@:B67794F6?4@>38:8;@:84? 45F@>?8><8<?36??387:858>?67786945J64>?64>6A98 ,
> J8:4?5 986:>8< F@D>589 67786:4>= ;@: ?38 6778996>? 5DAJ4?5 ?36? ?38 :8H8F?4@> @; ?38 7964>? @> ?38 =:@D>< @; <8>469 @; 54=>6?D:8 @> ?38 6I696?36>6J6 45 D>5D5?64>6A98 ? 45 F@>?8><8< ?36? ?38 6778996>? <8>48< 38: 54=>6?D:8 <D:4>= F:@5508K6J4>6?4@> <D8 ?@ F@>;D54@> 6>< ?36? 5DF3 <8>469 8C8> 4; 6FF87?8< 6? ;6F8 C69D8 :896?85?@67:@F8<D:69<8;8F??36?45FD:6A984>>6?D:8? 45F@>?8><8<?36??38?:469@D:?4>5?86<@;<45J4554>=?38 5D4? @D=3? ?@ 36C8 <4:8F?8< ?38 6778996>? ?@ ;498 6 ;:853 6I696?36>6J6@:5@D=3?F96:4;4F6?4@>?3:@D=3677:@7:46?8 98=697:@F8554>F9D<4>=4>C@I4>=8F?4@>-$@;?38F?? 45 6:=D8< ?36? :8H8F?4@> @; 7964>? 365 :85D9?8< 4> J45F6::46=8@;HD5?4F86><<8>469@;677:8F46?4@>@>J8:4?5
? 45 ?38 F@>?8>?4@> @; ?38 986:>8< F@D>589 ;@:
?38 :857@><8>?5 ?36? @>F8 ?38 6778996>? 7964>?4;; <8>48< 38: 54=>6?D:8 @> ?38 6I696?36>6J6 ?38 F@D>589 F8658<
- 8 -
?@ 3@9< 6D?3@:4?B ?@ :87:858>? 38: 6>< ?38 7964>? ;498< ?3:@D=35DF3:87:858>?6?4@>A8F@J854>C694<
6C4>= 386:< ?38 986:>8< F@D>589 67786:4>= ;:@J A@?3 ?38 76:?485 ?38 7@4>? ?36? 6:4585 ;@: F@>54<8:6?4@>45
! " #
$
% &
'
&
()
8;@:8 6>5E8:4>= ?38 7@4>?5 ;@: F@>54<8:6?4@> ;:6J8<E8E@D9<6>5E8::8=6:<4>=?38J64>?64>6A494?B@; ?38677869
8;8><6>? @+ ;498< @, D><8: 8F?4@> +@;588I4>=>8F8556:B@:<8:5?@A876558<@>?38 =:@D><?36??387964>?4;;3656998=8<9B<8>48<38:54=>6?D:8 @> ?38 6I696?36>6J6 3@D=3 ?38 67794F6?4@> 45 ;:6J8< D><8:8F?4@>+@;?38?:D87D:7@:?6><5DA5?6>F8
- 9 -
@; ?38 67794F6?4@> E65 ?@ 588I :8H8F?4@> @; ?38 7964>? 38:8;@:8<8574?8A84>=5?B98<D><8:8F?4@>+@;
?38 67794F6?4@> 8;;8F?4C89B 5@D=3? ?@ :8H8F? ?38 7964>? @> J8:4?5 AB ?:86?4>= ?38 7964>?4;;(5 <8>469 65 ;6?69 ?@ ?38 J64>?64>6A494?B @; ?38 5D4? ? 45 E899 58??98< 96E ?36? >@J8>F96?D:8 45 >@? <8?8:J4>6?4C8 E36? J6??8:5 45 ?38 5DA5?6>F8@;?387:6B8:6><4?598=69F@>58GD8>F8B?38 4J7D=>8< @:<8: 7964>? 45 ':8H8F?8<( 38 :8H8F?4@> @; ?38 7964>? 45 6 <8F:88 E4?34> ?38 J86>4>= @; 8F?4@> !" @; 6><45?3D56778696A98D><8:8F?4@>#@; >F8 ?38 7964>? 45 :8H8F?8< ?38> @AC4@D59B >@?34>= 45 78><4>= A8;@:8?38?:469@D:??38@:<8::8H8F?4>=?387964>?A84>= ?38<8F:88AB?38?:469@D:??38@>9B:8J8<B4;7964>?4;;
45 6==:48C8< 45 AB ;494>= 6> 677869 6>< >@? AB ;494>= :8C454@>78?4?4@>65F@>?8><8<AB?38:857@><8>?5 $ @EF@J4>=?@J8:4?5?38=:@D><@>E34F3?38 7964>? E65 :8H8F?8< 45 ?36? ?38 7964>?4;; <8>48< 38:
54=>6?D:8 @> ?38 6I696?36>6J6 38 :8H8F?4@> @; ?38 7964>?45=@C8:>8<AB :<8:-D98@;E34F3699@E5
- 10 -
?38@D:??@:8H8F??387964>?6?4>4?4695?6=8454;4?<@85>@?
J88?F8:?64>98=69:8GD4:8J8>?5658>C456=8<D><8: :<8:
- D98 !6 ?@ <" @; 38 =:@D><5 ;@: :8H8F?4@> 4>F9D<85 6 38:845>@F6D58@;6F?4@>4>?387964>?MD98 !6"N A 385D4?45D><8:C69D8<MD98!A"N F 964>?45>@?5D;;4F48>?9B5?6J78<MD98!F"N < 964>?45A6::8<AB96EMD98!<"N
38 @:<8: 699@E4>= @, 6>< :8H8F?4>= ?38 7964>?4598=699BD>5D5?64>6A986><<@85>@?;4?4>6>B@;?38 :8GD4:8J8>?658>C456=8<D><8: :<8:-D98!6?@<" @; 38 ?:469 @D:? 7:@F88<5 @> 6 J4567794F6?4@> @;
7:@F8<D:69 96E 6>< <45:8=6:<5 ?38 FD:6A98 >6?D:8 @; <8;8F?4>C6I696?36>6J6 + 38 78K @D:? 4> ?38 F658 @;
1 (2006) 1 SCC 75
- 11 -
"*
! %
# 365 389<?36?O
! &&
&
+
&
,
%
&
' -! +
+ , &&
&
+
&- &&
& -
% ! ) 6>< ;D:?38: 389< ?36? O -! ! . ! -
+ - & -
-! ! & -
& , -! -! & &&+
&
) # @> F@J7946>F8 8C8> 655DJ8< ?@ A8 ?38:8 F@D9<A8@>9B67:@F8<D:69:8GD4:8J8>?6><?345<8;8F?@: 4?454::8=D96:4?B6:8FD:6A986><53@D9<>@?A8699@E8<?@ <8;86?5DA5?6>?469:4=3?5@:?@F6D584>HD5?4F8@:8@C8:4> ?345 F658 ?38 7964>?4;; <8>48< 38: 54=>6?D:8 <D:4>= ?38
- 12 -
F@D:58@;38:F:@5508K6J4>6?4@>?45>@?8C8>?38F658@;
?38 :857@><8>?5 ?36? ?38 7964>?4;; 365 >@? 36><8< @C8: 6I696?36>6J6?@38:F@D>5896><4;6?699?36?F@D9<A86 =:48C6>F84?E@D9<36C8A88>J6<8AB?387964>?4;;38:589; 6>< >@? AB ?38 :857@><8>?5 :DF4699B @>F8 6 6I696?36>6J645@>:8F@:<<D9B54=>8<6><6F?8<D7@> ?38AD:<8>?@7:@C8?36?4?454>C694<@:D>6D?3@:4L8<9485 @> ?38 76:?B F36998>=4>= 4? 38 :857@><8>?5 >8C8:
<457D?8< ?38 6I696?36>6J6 38:8;@:8 ?38 @D:? 8::8< 4>7:85DJ4>=4>C694<4?BA658<@>9B@>65?:6B<8>469 - 38?:469@D:?E65>@?HD5?4;48<4>:8H8F?4>=?38 7964>?E4?3@D?=4C4>=6F36>F8?@:8F?4;BFF@:<4>=9B?38 7@4>? ;:6J8< ;@: F@>54<8:6?4@> 45 6>5E8:8< 6>< E8 7655 ?38;@99@E4>=
4 3867786945
- 13 -
44 38 4J7D=>8< @:<8: <6?8< #$ 76558< 4> @# AB <<4?4@>69 8>4@: 4C49 .D<=8
696AD:6=445 444 38 J6??8: 45 :8J4??8< A6FI ?@ ?38 ?:469 @D:? ;@:;:853F@>54<8:6?4@>4>6FF@:<6>F8E4?396E 4C 38 5D4? 45 :85?@:8< ?@ ;498 ?38 7:@F88<4>=5 ?@ A8F@>?4>D8<6??385?6=8E38:84?E655?@778< 6:?485 ?@ 67786: A8;@:8 ?38 ?:469 @D:? @> ,+ C 345 @D:? 365 >@? 8K7:8558< 6>B @74>4@> @> ?38J8:4?5@:<8J8:4?5@;?38F658 C4 99?38F@>?8>?4@>5@;?3876:?4856:8I87?@78>
*' &###$%(
*' &#(
45?@9@#