- 1 - ! "#$ %$&!$!$ '! !( ! " " "" # $ %" &''''! % """ ( ) &*+!'! ) " &*+*!' Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , " %% - %%." " / ," " " " " % ' %'%!, ( %, " " , 0 0 12 324/4/5627 /8 92:572 41/8 5;74 822</6= :5>>5?/6= 72>/2:@8A #/ 88;2 B ?7/4 5: C274/57B7/ :57 D;B81/6= 412 /E3;=62F 57F27 5: 427E/6B4/56 5: 324/4/5627 :75E F5/6= 412 B=264 FB42F % ' %'%! ?1/C1 /8 B4 B662G;72 B /88;2F 9H 728356F264 65 % ?/41 B>> C5682D;264/B>9262:/48/6412/64272845:I;84/C2 // 6H5412772>/2:?1/C1412324/4/5627/8264/4>2F45 9257F272F $ % 12 CB82 5: 412 324/4/5627 /8 41B4 12 1B8 9226 412=2645:728356F264& 57357B4/568/6C2'* ') !JJJB6F 72C5=6/K/6=1/88/6C272827L/C2 21B89226375E542F45 412E2E9275: 1B/7EB6 >;9/6412H2B7%''* 1;812 1B8C5E3>242F%%H2B785:=26CH 1B4B4412/684B6C25: - 3 - 85E2 3278568 B C5E3>B/64 ?B8 >5F=2F B=B/684 1/E 728;>4/6= /6 /88;B6C2 5: 815?&CB;82 654/C28 B6F C1B7=2 81224 FB42F %* '% %'%! 56 412 B>>2=B4/568 5: E/8B337537/B4/56 5: 412 BE5;648 3B/F 9H 412 35>/CH 15>F278 12324/4/56271BF=/L26723>H454128B/FC1B7=2 81224F26H/6=412B>>2=B4/568 1272B:427?/415;415>F/6= B6H 26D;/7H 57 375L/F/6= B6H 533574;6/4H ?1B4852L27 /E3;=62F 57F27 FB42F % ' %'%! CBE2 45 92 3B882F 427E/6B4/6= 412 B=26CH 5: 412 324/4/5627 56 84/=EB4/C =75;6F8 26C2412324/4/56 ) 2B762F C5;682> :57 412 324/4/5627 4B</6= 41/8 5;744175;=141272C57F8B6F8;9E/4841B4412/E3;=62F 57F27FB42F% ' %'%!375F;C2FB4662G;72&F528654 ?1/8327B6H41/6=B95;4B6H533574;6/4H1BL/6=9226=/L26 45 412 324/4/5627 5: 26D;/7H 2 B>85 72:278 45 412 815?& CB;82 654/C2 FB42F %* '% %'%! 375F;C2F B4 662G;72& B6F412723>H=/L269H412324/4/5627B8327662G;72& 45 412 8B/F 815?&CB;82 654/C2 B6F 8;9E/48 41B4 2L26 412 723>H =/L26 9H 412 324/4/5627 45 412 815?&CB;82 654/C2 - 4 - 1BL2 654 9226 BFL2742F 45 /6 412 8B/F 57F27 2 :;74127 8;9E/48 412 ?15>2 =75;6F 5: B>>2=B4/56 /8 B95;4 B>>2=2F E/8B337537/B4/56B6FE/8&;4/>/KB4/565:83BC29H97541275: 412 324/4/5627 6BE2>H BL/ 1BLB6 2 8;9E/48 B88;E/6=2L26/:41297541275:412324/4/56271BF/6F22F /6L5>L2F /6 85E2 E/8B337537/B4/56 41B4 CB6654 92 412 =75;6F :57 427E/6B4/56 5: B=26CH 5: 412 324/4/5627 1272:572 12 8;9E/48 56 B>> C5;648 412 57F27 5: 427E/6B4/56 /8 ;68;84B/6B9>2 3B74/C;>B7>H ?/415;4 C56F;C4/6=41226D;/7H 6 72835682 >2B762F C5;682> :57 412 728356F264& 57357B4/56 L212E264>H 8;9E/48 41B4 412 57F27 5: 427E/6B4/56 1B8 372C2F2F ?/41 B 372>/E/6B7H 26D;/7HB6F41272B:427/88;B6C25:815?&CB;82654/C2 2 72:27845662G;72&*375F;C2FB484B42E2645:59I2C4/56 B4 3B=2 5 % B6F 8;9E/48 41B4 B F24B/>2F 26D;/7H ?B8 C56F;C42F 37/57 45 /88;B6C2 5: 815?&CB;82 654/C2 4 /8 56>H 9B82F 56 412 8B/F :/6F/6=8 5: 412 8B/F 26D;/7H 412 815?&CB;82 654/C2 FB42F %% '* %'%! ?B8 /88;2F 2 - 5 - 8;9E/484128B/F26D;/7H723574B4662G;72&*/6F/CB428 3B74/C/3B4/565:9541324/4/5627B6F1/89754127 1272:572 /4 /8 654 5326 :57 412 324/4/5627 45 C56426F 41B4 65 533574;6/4H?B8=/L26 7/6=/6=45412654/C25:41/8 5;74 2=;>B4/56 5 %' 12 8;9E/48 41B4 41272 /8 B6 B332B> 375L/F2F B6F ?/415;4 2G1B;84/6= 41B4 72E2FH 324/4/5627 CB6654 B3375BC1 41/8 5;74 847B/=14 B?BH ;6F27 74/C>2 %%5:412 5684/4;4/565:6F/B 26C2822<8:57F/8E/88B> 5:412B332B> * 2B7F327;82F41272C57F8 335/64E264 8;83268/56 427E/6B4/56 3;6/81E264 5: 412 B=2648 B6F 84B::8 5: 412 728356F264& 57357B4/56/8=5L2762F;6F2741272=;>B4/568375F;C2FB4 662G;72&!4541284B42E2645:59I2C4/56 2=;>B4/56! 375L/F28 2G1B;84/L2 E2C1B6/8E :57 C56F;C4/6= 5: 412 /6D;/7H 4 B>85 EB6FB428 B 72B856B9>2 533574;6/4H 5: 92/6= 12B7F 45 92 =/L26 45 412 B=264&BCC;82F 6 54127 - 6 - ?57F8 37/6C/3>28 5: 6B4;7B> I;84/C2 1BL2 9226 =/L26 2E31B8/82L26/64128B/F72=;>B4/568 . 27;8B> 5: 412 72C57F8 /6 412 >/=14 5: 412 B:5728B/F 72=;>B4/568 /6F/CB42 41B4 B 372>/E/6B7H 26D;/7H 1B8 9226 C56F;C42F 9H 562 /81572 4 F528 654 /6F/CB42 1/884B4;857358/4/56 12C5E324264B;4157/4H45C56F;C4 41226D;/7HB832741272=;>B4/56/8375L/F2F/6C12F;>2& 454128B/F72=;>B4/56 >2B7>H4128B/F372>/E/6B7H26D;/7H 375F;C2F B4 662G;72&* FB42F % '+ %'%' F528 654 E22441272D;/72E2645:41272=;>B4/565:B626D;/7H4592 C56F;C42F9H412C5E324264B;4157/4H + 2C56F>H 412 815?&CB;82 654/C2 FB42F %* '% %'%!1B89226/88;2F3;735742F>H9B82F564128B/F 26D;/7H 723574 24/4/5627 1272/6 1B8 /88;2F B F24B/>2F 723>HB8:5;6FB4662G;72& 45412?7/4324/4/56 1272/8 65 26D;/7H C56F;C42F B8 C5642E3>B42F ;6F27 2=;>B4/56 !5:4122=;>B4/56B4>2B84B:427/88;B6C25:815?&CB;82 654/C2B6F8;9E/88/565:723>H9H412324/4/5627 C7H34/C - 7 - /E3;=62F 57F27 1B8 9226 3B882F B8 327 662G;72& 9H 41226/57/L/8/56B6B=27 54 C>2B7 ?12412712 /8 412 B;4157/K2F57C5E324264B;4157/4H;6F2741272=;>B4/56 J E3;=62F57F275:427E/6B4/56B45:662G;72& F528654C564B/6B6H=75;6F87B/82FB=B/684412324/4/5627 4 F528 654 2L26 /6F/CB42 57 B74/C>2 5: C1B7=28 C568/F27B4/56 5: 412 2G3>B6B4/56 5::272F9H 412324/4/5627 92:572/88;/6=4128B/F57F275:427E/6B4/56 !' 87/=14>H35/642F5;49H412>2B762FC5;682>:57 412 324/4/5627 /E3;=62F 57F27 5: 427E/6B4/56 92/6= 84/=EB4/C B6F /6 412 >/=14 5: 847/C4 7;>2 5: 7/6C/3>2 5: 6B4;7B> I;84/C2 72D;/72F 45 92 C5E3>/2F 2L26 ;6F27 2=;>B4/56 ! 72:2772F 45 B95L2 412 57F27 /E3;=62F /6 412 C568/F272F L/2? 5: 41/8 5;74 CB6654 92 8;84B/62F CC57F/6=>H412:5>>5?/6=A B 12324/4/56/8B>>5?2F 9 1257F27FB42F% ' %'%!/8D;B812F - 8 - C 12 728356F264& 57357B4/56 /8 B4 >/9274H 45 15>F :7281 26D;/7H : 85 /4 81B>> 15>F 8;C1 /6D;/7H 9H 8;33>H/6= B>> 412 EB427/B> 2L/F26C2 ?1/C1 412 728356F264& 57357B4/56 /6426F2F4572>H;356B=B/684412324/4/5627 B6F B:427 B::57F/6= 8;::/C/264 533574;6/4H 45 412 324/4/5627 375C22F :;74127 847/C4>H /6 BCC57FB6C2 ?/41 412 72=;>B4/568 72:2772F 45 B95L2 !)* '$!$( & /845 !>5 %*