- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( !"!#$# % & ' # !"!$# ( # ) !"!#$# % & (* $" $+ ($(( #' #,&#' ' #!"#" ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ($#- #!"($#" (+($$$ +. #--$$$ #(. / / 0 # # 1234556472358696886:4;42<3==16>:;?6<=4<: 4@48::4=6:$" $ ($#-54336:2< A #!"($#"BC=16 82<D25476<2A82E27>:;64<: 474B>84;2&9A831A8= F=16 =82B><47G' 366H2<; 6<14<D6?6<= A9 =16 DA?56<34=2A< 4@48:6:BC=16=82B><47 ( 16 4556774<=D742?4<= ?6= @2=1 4DD2:6<= 4<: 3>99686: 2<I>8263 6 4:?2==6: 2< =16 1A352=47 4<: =AAH =864=?6<= 69276:D742?56=2=2A<B69A86=16=82B><47366H2<; DA?56<34=2A< A9 3 (+$$$$$ 47A<; @2=1 2<=6863= 4= =16 84=6 A9 +. 568 4<<>? 98A? =16 :4=6 A9 56=2=2A< =277 86472J4=2A< ;;826E6:BC=16342:>:;?6<=4<:4@48:=16 D742?4<= 58696886: =16 58636<= 455647 2< @12D1 2= 23 DA<=6<:6: =14= =16 4?A><= 4@48:6: BC =16 =82B><47 23 - 3 - 2<4:6K>4=6 4<: 763368 4?A><=3 486 ;84<=6: 1A>;1 =16 AD=A8 ( 143 4336336: =16 :234B272=C 4= ($ (!. 43 568?4<6<= 51C32D47 :234B272=C =A @1A76 BA:C =16 =82B><47 DA<32:682<;#,8:A9($.4336336:=16:234B272=C4=. 16 =82B><47 143 ;84<=6: ?64;68 4?A><=3 =A@48:3 542< 4<: 3>99682<; 4<: 7A33 A9 2<DA?6 = 23 DA<=6<:6: =14= =16 D742?4<= @43 648<2<; 4 3>? A9 3 #$$$$ 568 ?A<=1B>= =16=82B><47143=4H6<1232<DA?64=3 "$$$ 568?A<=1 16869A861686K>63=3=A6<14<D6=16DA?56<34=2A<4?A><= 4@48:6:BC=16=82B><47 , 16 D742?4<= @43 4;6: 4BA>= ! C6483 4<: 16 @43 4 7A88C :82E68 6 473A 9276: :82E2<; 72D6<D6 6L=84D= 4= L # 1A>;1 16 3=4=6: =14= 16 @43 648<2<; 4 3>? A9 3 #$$$$ <A2<DA?658AA9143B66<58A:>D6:B69A86=16 =82B><47 6 ?6= @2=1 4DD2:6<= A< ## $! ($# 3 568 =16 ;>2:672<63 A9 48<4=4H4 =4=6 6;47 68E2D63 >=1A82=C 9A8 =16C648($#1232<DA?6143=AB6=4H6<4=3 #$(!$ 568 ?A<=1 16D742?4<=6L4?2<6:=16AD=A8 ( 3568=16 :23D148;63>??48C=16D742?4<=3>3=42<6:984D=>86A982;1= =2B24 4<: 984D=>86 A9 769= 74=6 =2B247 DA<:C76 < =16 @A><: - 4 - D68=292D4=62=23?6<=2A<6:=14=2<I>82634=7 A (4<:,486 ;826EA>32<<4=>86 L "23=16:23D148;63>??48C 6@43 1A352=472J6: 9A8 #! :4C3 ( 233>6: :234B272=C D68=292D4=6 4<: 3=4=6: =14= =1686 23 M 2<D1 31A8=6<2<; A9 82;1= 76; 3@6772<; 4<: 542< 2< =16 82;1= 4<H76 4<: 76; 4<: ;84:6 @64H<633 2< ?>3D763 A9 82;1= 4<H76 4<: 82;1= H<66 4<: 4336336:=16:234B272=C=A=16@1A76BA:C4=($ (!. 648<6:DA><3679A8=164556774<=DA<=6<:6:=14= =164556774<=@4347A88C:82E68:>6=A=162<I>82633>3=42<6: 2< =16 4DD2:6<= 16 D4<<A= :82E6 =16 E612D76 58A5687C 4<: =1>3=169><D=2A<47:234B272=C23=AB6=4H6<4=#$$. ! 68 DA<=84 7648<6: DA><367 9A8 =16 <3>84<D6 DA?54<C 86726: >5A< 4 :6D232A< A9 =16 A<GB76 >586?6 A>8= 2< ! " "# #$% & " "'( @16862< 2= 23 167: =14= F - 5 - ! " #$% &' (' ) &*+(, + 16=82B><47 143 =4H6< :234B272=C4= #,8: A9 ($. @12D1 23 . 16 34?6 23 58A568 4<: DA886D= 123 A>8= 92<:3 <A 8643A< =A 2<=689686 2< =16 34?6 A33 A9 9>=>86 648<2<;@A>7:B643><:68/ 3 #$(!$ )#()#).N3 #($!$ - 6 - 16 =82B><47 143 4@48:6: 4 3>? A9 3 (-+ =A@48:3 ?6:2D47 6L56<363 16 34?6 23 DA886D= 123 A>8= 92<:3 <A 8643A< =A 2<=689686 2< =16 34?6 A<32:682<; =16 <4=>86A92<I>82635682A:A91A352=472J4=2A<4<:ADD>54=2A<A9 =16D742?4<==123A>8=92<:32=8643A<4B76=A4@48:43>?A9 3 !$$$ =A@48:3 542< 4<: 3>99682<; 4 3>? A9 3 ,$$$$ =A@48:3 7A33 A9 4?6<2=263 4<: 4 3>? A9 3 ,$$$$ =A@48:3 =84<35A8=4=2A< 6L=84 <A>8231?6<= 4<: 4==6<:4<= D148;63 16 D742?4<= ?2;1= 14E6 <A= 4==6<:6: 4<C @A8H 9A8 4 5682A: A9 9A>8 ?A<=13 :>6 =A =16 2<I>8263 16869A86 16 23 6<=2=76 9A8 4 3>? A9 3 #$$$ &3 #$(!$ ) ' 9A8 7A33 A9 2<DA?6 :>82<; 742: >5 5682A: 16=A=47DA?56<34=2A<@A>7:B6439A77A@3/ ) *+,-./0*1-+231 /412 # 42<4<:3>99682<; 3 !$$$ ( A33A99>=>862<DA?6 3 #($!$ , A33A94?6<2=263 3 ,$$$$ 84<35A8=4=2A< 6L=84 <A>8231?6<= 4<: 4==6<:4<=D148;63 3 ,$$$$ ! 6:2D476L56<363 3 (-+ + A33A92<DA?6:>82<;742: >55682A: 3 #$$$ 2+) - 56 - 7 - " 648<6: DA><367 9A8 =16 <3>84<D6 DA?54<C 3>B?2=3=14==164?A><=4@48:6:BC=16=82B><47143B66< :65A32=6: - DDA8:2<;7C=169A77A@2<;A8:68/ &2' 1645564723477A@6:2<548=* &22' 16 DA?56<34=2A< 4?A><= 4@48:6: BC =16=82B><472<43>?A93 (+($$$ 236<14<D6: =A3 ,+-!$ 47A<;@2=12<=6863=4==1684=6A9 +. 568 4<<>? 98A? =16 :4=6 A9 56=2=2A< =277 =16 :4=6A986472J4=2A<* &222' 16 <3>84<D6 DA?54<C 23 :286D=6: =A :65A32= =16 6<14<D6: DA?56<34=2A< A9 3 #$!$ 47A<;@2=12<=6863=@2=12<45682A:A9 A<6?A<=198A?=16:4=6A9=123A8:68* &2E' < 3>D1 :65A32= =16 D742?4<= 23 568?2==6: =A @2=1:84@ =16 6<=286 4?A><= 47A<; @2=12<=6863=4DD8>6:=1686A< -,6 %$ ' # 23= A /#7 A /!#