Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63544 (KAR)
RAMLINGAPPA S/O BHUJANGAPPA BANDAGE v. BHIMARAYA S/O SHIVARACHAPPA KANDGULE
RSA/7162/2010 · 2025-11-20
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63544 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63544 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#"$""
%%
&' (
! "
#
! ! $
!%& $
! ! !%&
$
! ! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!%& $
!! ! !%&
$
! ! !%& $
"#
! !%'& $
"
! !% & (
$
")
! *
% $&
$
! - 3 -
"
$
+
! ! $
))
! ) $
)
! '
! %&
%&
! %&
! - 4 -
%&
! %&
! %'&
! *
% $ $ '), $$' %&, %&%&%&%'&$, $
-+""+"%&%'&' %&&
' ++ '
$
#
--# #+!"++- $ %$& '
"++- #+"++ $ %$& ' '' #
--#
''
$
. - 5 -
$" % . &
/01 233425 01 67 8/4 3520980::1 2;;<04=4> 67 8/4 ?@>;A498 29> >4B<44 >284> #+!"++- 32114> 09 C#
--# C9 8/4 :054 C: 8/4 <09B0325 0=05 @>;4 %<9& 29> ' 529> %:C< 1/C<8 D8/4 <025 C@<8E& >01A01109;8/41@08C:8/43520980::1F/0B/01BC9:0<A4>67 8/4 ?@>;A498 29> >4B<44 >284> +#+"++ 32114> 09 C
"++- C9 8/4 :054 C: 8/4 0=05 @>;4 %<9& 529>%:C<1/C<8D8/4'0<1833455284C@<8E&
" /4 26C=4 1@08 09 C#
--# 01 :054> 67 8/4 3520980::1 B520A09; 8C 64 8/4 B/05><49 C: C94 /@?29;2332 @6?4B8 A2884< C: 8/4 1@08 01 529> 642<09;
7 C+ A421@<09; ) 2B<41 !" ;@9821 108@284> 28 2;>/2<0 $0552;4 G 529> 018 @562<;2 /4 B214 C:
8/4 3520980::1 01 8/28 1@08 3<C34<87 /2> 6449 ;<2984> 09 :2=C@< C: 8/40< :28/4< /@?29;2332 09 8/4 742< -" 09 84<A1C:7>4<262>4929B7 <298B8-+11@B//4 F21093C114110C929>49?C7A498C:8/412A455<4BC<>1
- 6 -
6409;4984<4>09/0192A4F/0B/BC9809@4>@38C8/4742< - /4:28/4<C:8/43520980::132114>2F27098/4742< - + :84</01>4A0143520980::12<4093C114110C929> 49?C7A498C:8/43<C34<87/4>4:49>2981F08/C@8/2=09; 297 BC9B4<9 F08/ 8/4 1@08 3<C34<87 F4<4 0554;2557 0984<:4<09;29>3<4=49809;8/43520980::1:<CA49?C709;8/4 12A449B48/41@08:C<>4B52<280C98/288/43520980::12<4 8/4 CF94<1 09 3C114110C9 29> 49?C7A498 C: 8/4 1@08 3<C34<87 29> :C< BC914G@498025 <4504: C: 34<A29498 09?@9B80C9/4352098F211@614G@498572A49>4>144H09;
>4B52<280C9 8/28 1254 >44> >284> ")+ - 64 >4B52<4> 21 9@55 29> =C0> 29> 9C8 609>09; C9 8/4 3520980::1 29> 2584<9280=457 8C >4B52<4 8/4 3520980::1 8C 64 8/4 CF94<1 C: 8/41@083<C34<8767F27C:2>=4<143C114110C9 ! /4F<0884918284A49801:054>>49709;8/4352098 2=4<A4981 251C >49709; 8/28 8/4 1@08 529> /2> 6449 ;<2984>098/492A4C::28/4<C:8/43520980::109742<-" 29>/0192A4BC9809@4>098/4<4BC<>1C:<0;/88055- 8 01 BC9849>4> 8/28 C<0;092557 8/4 529> F21 CF94> 29>
- 7 -
3C114114> 67 C94 290H<2C 1
C 29@A298<2C /4 /2=09; 3@<B/214>8/412A4@9>4<2<4;0184<4>>44>C:1254>284> ++- /4<42:84<290H<2C1C5>8/41@083<C34<878C >4:49>298 C/0A2<272<43<414984>67/01;@2<>02909 84<A1 C: >44>C: 1254 >284> "+- 4:49>298 C 8/@1 64B2A4 8/4 CF94< C: 8/4 3<C34<87 29> /01 92A4 /2=09;64494984<4>098/4<4=49@4<4BC<>1/41@08529> F2132<8080C94>648F449>4:49>2981134<8/432<8080C9 >4:49>298 CF21255C884>!2B<41"";@9821,>4:49>298 C"F21255C884>!2B<41" ;@9821,>4:49>298 C!F21 255C884>!2B<41" ;@9821,>4:49>298 C)F21255C884>!
2B<41 " ;@9821 29> 8/40< 92A41 /2=4 6449 2BBC<>09;57 4984<4>098C8/4<4=49@4<4BC<>1 ) /28 8/4 :28/4< C: 8/4 3520980::1 /2> :251457 B520A4>/0A145:8C648/4849298C:8/41@08529>520980::1 /2> :054> F<08 348080C9 09 C" #
-- 64:C<4 8/4 0;/ C@<8 F/0B/ F21 >01A0114> C9 )+"--# /4 2/105>2<529>/2>/45>2949G@0<7C98/423350B280C9C:
8/43520980::129>:C@9>8/28'C<A C#/2>9C86449:054>
- 8 -
21 8/4 3520980::1 F4<4 9C8 09 3C114110C9 C: 8/4 1@08 529> /4>4:49>29816409;8/4CF94<1093C114110C9C:8/41@08 529> F/0B/ 01 BC9:0<A4> 67 8/4 43@87 CAA0110C94<
@562<;2/43520980::1/2=09;:2054>092558/40<2884A381 /2=4:054>3<41498:25141@0849B41C@;/8:C<>01A01125C: 8/41@08
/42>>080C925F<0884918284A49801:054>09=04F C:8/42A49>A4988C8/4352098>49709;3520980::1/2=09;
6449 09 3C114110C9 C: 8/4 3<C34<87 29> 34<:4B809; 8/40< 80854 67 2>=4<14 3C114110C9 8 01 8/4 BC9849>4> 8/28 8/4 :28/4<C:8/43520980::1F218/43<C84B84>849298C:8/41@08 529> /4 C<0;0925CF94<C: 8/4 529>41/A@H/ /2> 09080284> <41@A380C9 3<CB44>09;1 09 :054 C
! C: - 144H09;<41@A380C9C:/0114=4<25529>1C942AC9;F/0B/ F21 8/4 1@08 3<C34<87 CBB@304> 67 8/4 :28/4< C: 8/4 3520980::1 /4 :28/4< C: 8/4 3520980::1 /2> :054> 2 BC91498 F<08849 18284A498 C9 + +- 29> 8/4 <06@925 67 C<>4<>284>!++)-#"/2>C<>4<4>:C<<41@A380C9C:8/4 529> 8C 64 /29>4> C=4< 8C 8/4 C<0;0925 CF94< /@1 8/4
- 9 -
84929B70:297/2>644984<A09284>/2841/A@H/ /2>4I4B@84>>44>C:1254>284>++- 09:2=C@<C: 290H<2C/4120>>44>C:1254F212884184>678/4:28/4< C: 8/4 3520980::1 /4<42:84< 290H<2C /2> 1C5> 8/4 1@08 3<C34<87C9"+- 09:2=C@<C:>4:49>298 C18C)
/28 8/4<4 F21 C<25 32<8080C9 2AC9;18 8/4 >4:49>2981 29> 8/40< 92A41 F4<4 4984<4> 098C C9 +#+- /28 09 --! 3520980:: C! /2> :054> 29 23350B280C9 64:C<4 8/4 43@87 CAA0110C94< 144H09; 3<C84B80C9 F/0B/ F21 >4B5094> 21 9C 'C<A C# 23350B280C9/2>6449:054>29>/4F219C8093C114110C9 F<08 348080C9 09 C" #
-- /2> 6449 :054> 67 8/4 3520980::1 B520A09; 8/4A145=41 8C 64 8/4 54;25 <43<41498280=41C:C<0;092584929898/4120>F<08348080C9 8/47/2>B/25549;4>8/4B4<80:0B284C:<41@A380C9;<2984> C9 !++-# F/0B/ F21 >01A0114> C9 )+"--# 49B41C@;/8:C<>01A01125C:1@08
- 10 -
# 214>C98/43542>09;18/4<025C@<8:<2A4> 8/4:C55CF09;011@4129>2>>080C925011@41
! "! #
$! #
%%&' (
! # )
*
&! #
(
+
!",% !"-.)!/!)! 0! '! 11223452667861 9'%%&# ! # # (
(
- 11 -
! # ( 4!"0,&'%& $% '%&'
(
"! #
(
11223452667861 9$%%' ! ! 4! 4!"0,&'%&
(
"! 4! : ( (
'&
520980:: C! /21 6449 4I2A094> /0A145: 21 29> 8/<44 F08941141 /2=4 6449 4I2A094> C9 /01 64/25: 21 1" 8C ) 29> 4I/06084> >CB@A4981 A2<H4> 21 I1 8C 9 64/25: C: >4:49>2981 8FC F08941141 /2=4 6449 4I2A094> 21 1 29> " 29> 4I/06084>"!>CB@A4981A2<H4>21I18C"!
- 9 233<4B0280C9 C: 4=0>49B4 8/4 <025 C@<8 291F4<4>011@4 C1)2>>080C925011@4 C1!29>"09 8/4 2::0<A280=4 1C 251C 011@4 C" %8/C@;/ 1/CF9 21
- 12 -
94;280=4&098/42::0<A280=4011@4 C1!#2>>080C925 011@4 C1 29> " 09 8/4 94;280=4 29> BC914G@49857 >01A0114>8/41@08 + 409; 2;;<04=4> 3520980::1 3<4:4<<4> <4;@52< 233425 09 C
"++- C910>4<09; 8/4 ;<C@9>1 8/4 '0<18 33455284 C@<8 :<2A4> 8/4 :C55CF09; 3C0981 :C< BC910>4<280C9, ! )
)((
(
!!#3!6!4!0,0 ! ! )
;
*( 5 ) 36 4!0,0 0!"! "! 9 <4233<4B0280C9 8/4 4=0>49B4 C9 <4BC<> >01A0114> 8/4 233425 409; 2;;<04=4> 8/4 3520980::1 2<4 64:C<48/01C@<8
- 13 -
" /01C@<867C<>4<>284>""+)"++2>A0884> 8/42334258CBC910>4<8/4:C55CF09;1@618298025G@4180C91 C:52F, <- . *
=
(
6 $ >
! #
6 $$ ? : 5 +(
#& -
. *
(
6
$ 6 $$ ? : 5 +(
#&# (
( (
!
42<94> BC@9145 :C< 8/4 2334552981 82H09; 8/01 C@<8 8/<C@;/ 8/4 <4BC<>1 4I84910=457 1@6A081 8/28 4=49 2BBC<>09;8C8/4>4:49>2981:28/4<C:8/43520980::192A457 /@?29;2332F218/484929829>8/484929B73<CB44>09;1 29> 8/4 <41@A380C9 3<CB44>09;1 F4<4 349>09; BC910>4<280C9@38C8/4742<-#"41@6A0818/282>44> C: 1254 B2A4 8C 64 4I4B@84> 09 - C9 64/25: C:
- 14 -
252B/29><241/A@H/09:2=C@<C:290H<2C@5H2<9029> 09 8/4 12A4 742< 290H<2C @5H2<90 09 8@<9 1C5> 8/4 3<C34<87 09 :2=C@< C: >4:49>298 C1 8C ) /C@;/ >4:49>298 C18C)/2=41@614G@498571C5>8/43<C34<87 09 8/4 742< "++ 8C >4:49>298 C1 29> 8/4 1254 8<2912B80C91 8/28 8CCH 352B4 09 8/4 742< - 2<4 /08 67 8/4 3<C=010C91 C: 4B80C9 )) C: 8/4 2<9282H2 29> 4:C<A1 B8 -%:C< 1/C<8 D8/4B8E& 4<4:4<18C 8/4 120>3<C=010C9129>1@6A0818/289C8F08/1829>09;8/4529> 6409; 09 3C114110C9 C: 8/4 8492981 3<0C< 8C 8/4 >284 C:
BCAA49B4A498 C: 8/4 B8 12A4 =4184> 09 8/4 8284
C=4<9A498 /4<4:C<4 25049280C9 8/C@;/ A2>4 B299C8 64 1@182094> 21 252B/29><2 41/A@H/ /0A145: >0> 9C8 /2=4 1@6101809; 80854 09 08 /4<4:C<4 8/4 1@614G@498 B520A1 A2>4 67 8/4 32<8041 2<4 C: 9C BC914G@49B41 49B4 /4 1@6A081 8/28 >4:49>298 C1 8C ) 29> 1@614G@498 >4:49>298 C1 8C F/C B520A 8C /2=4 2BG@0<4> 8/4 80854 @9>4< 8/4 120> 8<2912B80C9 >@<09; 8/4 349>49B7 C: 8/4 3<CB44>09;1 B299C8 B520A 297 80854 4
- 15 -
1@6A0818/288/4:28/4<C:8/43520980::1/@?29;233229> 8/4<42:84<3520980::16409;093C114110C929>49?C7A498C: 8/43<C34<872<4<4G@0<4>8C64>4B52<4>21CF94<1C:8/4 3<C34<87 29> 8/4 1254 >44>1 /2=4 8C 64 >4B52<4> 21 9@55 29>=C0> ) 9 <413C914 542<94> BC@9145 :C< 8/4 <413C9>4981
>4:49>29811@6A0818/28/@?29;233232114> 2F27098/4742<- +@<09;/0150:480A48/4<41@A380C9 3<CB44>09;1/2>82H49352B4B@5A092809;09<41@A380C9C:
529> 09 :2=C@< C: 252B/29><2 41/A@H/ /@?29;2332 8/4 :28/4< C: 8/4 3520980::1 /21 94=4< B/25549;4> 120> <41@A380C9C<>4<>@<09;/0150:480A4/4F<08348080C98/28 /21 6449 :054> 67 8/4 3520980::1 6409; 8/4 B/05><49 C:
/@?29;2332 /21 251C 6449 >01A0114> 21 34< I! 4 1@6A081 8/01 C@<8 /21 :C@9> 8/28 8/4 <41@A380C9 C<>4< 9C8 /2=09; B/25549;4> 8/4 12A4 /2> 2882094> :0925087 /4<4:C<4 8/4 3520980::1 /2> 9C
% 8C :054 8/4 348080C9
- 16 -
4:@<8/4<1@6A0818/288/4>44>1C:1254/2=4 64494I4B@84>2>A0884>57098/4742<- F/4<48/41@08 /21 6449 :054> 09 8/4 742< - # 04 2:84< 52314 C: !- 742<1/41@08018/4<4:C<462<<4>6750A08280C9/288/4 290H<2C8/43@<B/214<C:8/43<C34<87098/4742<- 251C/219C86449A2>432<878C8/41@0849B4144H1:C< >01A01125C:8/4233425
42<>34<@14>8/4<4BC<>1 # /4<4 01 9C >013@84 C: 8/4 :2B8 8/28 8/4 <41@A380C93<CB44>09;1F4<409080284>@9>4<4B80C9)C: 8/471C<44929B7B8-"67252B/29><241/A@H/ 09 <41@A380C9 3<CB44>09;1 C
!
- /4 120> <41@A380C9 3<CB44>09;1 18284> 8C /2=4 B@5A09284> 09 321109;C:8/4C<>4<678/429><06@925C9!++-# >0<4B809; /29>09; C=4< 8/4 3C114110C9 C: 8/4 529> 8C 252B/29><2 41/A@H/ 332<49857 :28/4< C: 3520980::
/@?29;2332/2>;0=49BC91498C9+ +- /4<4/21 64499CB/25549;48C8/4120>C<>4<C:<41@A380C98055>284 =49 21 82H49 9C84 C: 67 8/4 CC<>09284 49B/ C: 8/4
- 17 -
C@<8 09 081 C<>4< >284> )+"--# 32114> 09 C" #
-- 3<C>@B4> 28 I! 8/4 <41@A380C9 C<>4<32114>/219C86449B/25549;4>/01C@<8/21251C 82H499C84C:8/4:2B88/288/C@;/8/4348080C94<18/4<409 %3520980::1 /4<409& /2> B/25549;4> 8/4 B4<80:0B284 C:
<41@A380C9 8/47 /2> 9C8 B/25549;4> 8/4 C<>4< C: <41@A380C9/01C@<8/21251C82H49C84C:8/4:2B88/28 348080C94<18/4<409%3520980::1/4<409&/2>9C83<C>@B4>297 A284<025 8C 1/CF <4;2<>09; 8/40< :28/4< /2=09; :054> 297 23350B280C909'C<A C#8/21251C82H499C84C:8/4:2B8 8/284=490:1@B/23350B280C9F21:054>8/412A4F219C8 A20982092654 2:84< <41@A380C9 C<>4< BBC<>09;57 >01A0114>8/4F<08348080C9
8 01 1@6A0884> 8/28 21 2;20918 8/4 2:C<4120> C<>4<C:8/01C@<82F<08233425F21:054>29>8/412A4 251C<41@584>09081>01A011259C8/4<FC<>18/4C<>4<C:
<41@A380C9 /21 2882094> :0925087 /4 1@618298025 G@4180C9 C:52F098/01A2884<01<2014>67<4:4<<09;8C4B80C9))C:
8/4 2<9282H2 29> 4:C<A1 B8 %:C< 1/C<8 D8/4 B8E&
- 18 -
4B80C9 )) C: 8/4 B8 /21 6449 0914<84> 4::4B80=4 :<CA ++!-#) 3<C=0>09; :C< =41809; C: 529>1 09 8/4 8284
C=4<9A49829>=2<0C@1BC914G@49B41F/0B/FC@5>:C55CF 09B5@>09;255<0;/818085429>0984<418=41809;098/4CF94<1 C: 1@B/ 529>1 29> C8/4< 34<1C91 0984<4184> 09 1@B/529>1 1/255 B4214 29> 64 =4184> 261C5@8457 09 8/4 8284
C=4<9A498:<44:<CA25549B@A6<29B41 - /4 0A34>0A498 0: 297 :C< 25049280C9 C: 8/4 529> BC@5> C957 64 8<2B42654 :<CA 8/4 >284 F/49 8/4 3<C=010C9 A2>4 4::4B80=4 F/0B/ 01 ++)-#) /4 1254 >44>1 09 8/01 B214 2>A0884>57 /2> 6449 4I4B@84> 09 8/4 742<- >@<09;F/0B/34<0C>8/4<4F219C3<C/06080C9 <>4< C: 41@A380C9 F21 32114> C9 !++)-#" /@1 4=49 0: 8/4<4 F4<4 8C 64 297 1@B/ 3<C/06080C9 8/4 1@614G@498<41@A380C9C:8/4529>09:2=C@<C:8/4C<0;0925 CF94</21BC9:0<A4>/0180854C=4<8/43<C34<87/412A4 09 297 B214 FC@5> 9C8 ;0=4 297 14A6529B4 C: <0;/8 80854 0984<41809:2=C@<C:8/43520980::1520980::1B299C8B520A8C
- 19 -
64>4B52<4>218/4CF94<C:8/43<C34<87C98/462101C: 8/013@<3C<84>29CA257
"+ 1 <0;/857 3C0984> C@8 67 8/4 542<94> BC@9145 :C<8/4>4:49>29818/41@0809G@4180C9/216449:054>2:84< !- 742<1 C: 4I4B@80C9 C: 8/4 1254 >44> 67 C<0;0925 CF94< 252B/29><241/A@H/09:2=C@<C:290H<2C29>F08/C@8 A2H09; /0A 21 2 32<87 8C 8/4 1@08 290H<2C 09 8@<9 /2> 1C5>8/43<C34<8709:2=C@<C:>4:49>298 C18C)098/4 742< - F/C 09 8@<9 1C5> 8/4 3<C34<87 09 :2=C@< C:
>4:49>298 C1 8C 09 8/4 742< "++ /4 42<504< 1254 >44>1/2=49C86449B/25549;4>C9571254>44>C:"++01 1C@;/8 8C 64 B29B4554> @618298025 G@4180C91 52F <2014> 2<4291F4<4>2BBC<>09;57
" 'C< 8/4 2:C<4120> <421C91 29> 29257101 8/4 233425:205129>2BBC<>09;57
)* &""' $
018 C5 C 83H