- 1 - !"# ## $ % & ! " # $ ! % & ! ' " (' ) ! ** ) *+ ! !! & ! ', ! ! # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ !! * ) )')) % !** $% * * ! ))) ! *! ')) ! ! * ! *" ! * ! ! ! - ! " $! - !% ./01.2.345622783493427:;/86:53443/<=32.>/<47<2/; ?/2.@6823742.746573426A7<0@;/8.7683<1 ) .34 6@@769 34 ;397: 6163<42 2.7 B0:157<2 6<: 6=68: :627: ))) @6447: ?C 2.7 ::323/<69 6<: ::323/<697<3/83D390:17 3:683</'/;)) .73<B087:>96356<2;397:6>96356@@93>623/<>96353<1 >/5@7<4623/< /; 4) =32. 3<278742 .7 83?0<69 >/<43:783<1 2.7 7<2387 7D3:7<>7 /< 87>/8: 186<27: 2.7 >/5@7<4623/< /; 4)('' =32. 3<278742 62 2.7 8627 /; , @78>7<2@786<<05;8/52.7:627/;@72323/<2399876934623/< - 3 - '11837D7:?C2.7463:/8:782.346@@76934@87;7887: ?C2.76@@7996<2>96356<23<=.3>.3234563<9C>/<27<:7:2.62 2.7 @72323/<78>96356<2 404263<7: >804. 3<B08C 2/ .34 831.2 .6<: 4 40>. .34 831.2 =8342 =64 65@02627: .7 :/>2/8 6447447: 2.7 :346?3932C 64 E 2/ 2.7 =./97 ?/:C ?02 2.7 83?0<69 .64 26A7< /<9C )E :346?3932C .7 >96356<2 =64 768<3<14)@785/<2.?022.783?0<69.6426A7<.34 3<>/57 64 4 @78 5/<2. !7 =64 6:53227: 64 6< 3<@6237<2;/8 :6C47617865/0<24=787186<27:0<:782.7 /2.78 .76:4 .787;/87 87F07427: ;/8 7<.6<>757<2 3< >/5@7<4623/< !768:2.7681057<24/;?/2.43:74 .7@72323/<78>96356<2.64 42627:2.62.7=64617: ' C7684 62 2.7 2357 /; 6>>3:7<2 :/3<1 6183>0920869 =/8A 6<: 96?/08 =/8A 6<: =64 768<3<1 4) @78 5/<2. !/=7D78.7.64</2;397:6<C:/>057<242/@8/D7.343<>/57 .7@72323/<78>96356<2572=32.6<6>>3:7<2/<)),4 @782.7103:793<74/;&68<626A62627716978D3>7402./832C 4) 34 2/ ?7 26A7< 64 .34 </23/<69 3<>/57 6<: 64 .7 - 4 - =64 617:C7684 64 @78 G.3?32 :34>.6817 405568C 2.7 50923@9378 34 2/ ?7 26A7< 64 :53227:9C 2.7 @72323/<78 >96356<240;;787:>804.3<B08C2/.34831.2=83426<:328740927: 3<9/44/;D64>096832C6<:9/44/;47<4623/<!7=64./4@32693H7: ;/8 :6C4432342.7>647/;65@02623/<2.7:/>2/86447447: 2.7:346?3932C64E .7 9768<7: >/0<479 ;/8 2.7 6@@7996<2>96356<2 .64 >/<27<:7: 2.62 2.7 @72323/<78>96356<2 =64 =/8A3<1 64 6< 6183>0920869 96?/08 6<: .7 >6<</2 :34>.6817 .34 :02374 :07 2/ 65@02623/< 6<: 2.787;/87 32 34 2/ ?7 26A7< 64 ;0<>23/<69 :346?3932C 768<7:>/0<479;/8874@/<:7<240?53227:2.622.7 83?0<69 .64 26A7< )E 2/=68:4 ;0<>23/<69 :346?3932C 6<: 2.787;/8732<77:4</3<278;787<>7:53227:9C6432346>647 /; 65@02623/< 2/ 831.2 =8342 2.34 /082 ;3<:4 32 8764/<6?97 2/ 26A72.7:346?3932C6447447:?C2.7:/>2/837E2/2.7=./97 ?/:C .7 >96356<2 34 694/ 7<23297: ;/8 'E 2/=68:4 ;02087 @8/4@7>24 / 2.7 9/44 /; ;02087 3<>/57 >/574 2/ 4), $) I 'E G ) G G E% .7 83?0<69 .64 69876:C 186<27: 4 ' 2/=68:4 57:3>69 7G@7<474 6<: 32 <77:4 </ 3<278;787<>7 .34 /082 ;3<:4 32 - 5 - 8764/<6?972/186<26<65/0<2/; 42/=68:4@63< 6<: 40;;783<1 4 ;/8 9/44 /; 657<32374 6<: 4' ;/8 286<4@/82623/< 7G286 </0834.57<2 6<: 6227<:6<2 >.68174 .7 @72323/<78>96356<2 531.2 </2 .6D7 6227<:7: 6<C /2.78 =/8A 62 97642 ;/8 6 @783/: /; ;/08 5/<2.4 :07 2/ 2.7 3<B08374 404263<7: 3< 2.7 6>>3:7<2 .787;/87 .7 34 7<23297:;/83<>/57/;4$)G'%;/82.79/44/; 3<>/57 :083<1 963: 0@ @783/: .04 3< 699 2.7 >96356<2 34 7<23297:;/82.7>/5@7<4623/</;4)' =32.3<27874262 E @78 6<<05 64 6163<42 4)('' 6=68:7: ?C 2.7 83?0<69 (.76=68:/;>/5@7<4623/<@6447:?C2.783?0<6934 5/:3;37:640<:78 !76:4 5/0<23<4 /44/;;020873<>/57 ), )7:3>697G@7<47 ' 63<6<:0;;783<1 '/44/;657<32374 227<:6<2>.681747G286 </0834.57<26<::372;//: ' /44/;768<3<1:083<12.7963:0@ @783/: /269 ' () - 6 - ,<2.78740922.7;/99/=3<1/8:7834@6447: $3% @@76934699/=7:3<@682 $33% .7 6@@7996<2>96356<2 34 7<23297: ;/8 2.7 2/269 >/5@7<4623/</;4)' =32.3<27874262@78>7<2@78 6<<05;8/52.7:627/;@72323/<23992.7:627/;87693H623/< $333% .7 874@/<:7<23<4086<>7 >/5@6<C .64 69876:C :7@/4327: 2.7 6=68:7: 65/0<2 ?7;/87 2.7 83?0<69 6<: 2.787;/872.7C687:387>27:2/:7@/4322.77<.6<>7:65/0<2/; 4() =32. 3<278742 62 E @78 6<<05 =32.3< /<7 5/<2.;8/52.7:627/;>/@C/;2.34/8:78 $3D% < 40>. :7@/432 2.7 >96356<2 34 @7853227: 2/ =32.:86=2.77<238765/0<269/<1=32.2.73<2787426>>807:/< 32 *+) $#% " 342/9/