- 1 - !"# $ % & && '"( ) !" # $$ !% & ' $ ( % ) $ !* Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + $ ) $ ,% , ) $ + ) -$ -. !*!%, $) * %)-/%/% ) !*!%! ! ) ,! * !!, ) -$ !*!,% + & ' %,0 $ 0 .!)/%++! ( ) %/,'%( $ - 3 - +++++ $ *+)+% $ 1 1 2 $ % % 345 677869 45 :498; <= >38 ?5@A6?B8 CD76?= 6E64?5>>38F@;ED8?>6?;6G6A;;6>8;+++++76558; <= >38 ;;4>4C?69 8?4CA 4H49 $@;E8 6?; 696<@A6E4I:CA53CA>"A4<@?69#J4? C*+)+% + ?8 4;A6D6776 D8> G4>3 6? 6BB4;8?> C? +% 6?; ;48; 45 G4:8 6?; B349;A8? :498; B964D 78>4>4C? B964D4?E BCD78?56>4C? C: 5%/!) 38 A4<@?69 BC?54;8A8; >38 8?>4A8 D6>8A4695 C? A8BCA; 6?; 6G6A;8; 5%%,) G4>3 4?>8A85> 6> >38 A6>8 C: K 78A 6??@D :ACD >38 ;6>8 C: 78>4>4C? >499 A869456>4C? EEA48H8;<=>38564;CA;8A?5@A6?B8 CD76?=:498;>345 677869 - 4 - , 86A; 6AE@D8?>5 C: <C>3 >38 76A>485 6?; 78A@58;>38D6>8A46956H6496<98C?A8BCA; 38D64?BC?>8?>4C?C:>386778996?>)?5@A6?B8 CD76?=45>36>>38A4<@?69C@E3>>C36H8;8;@B>8;!K C: >38 4?BCD8 C: >38 ;8B8658; >CG6A;5 345 78A5C?69 8L78?58554?B8B964D6?>C5+6?;,6A8>38D6FCA5C?5C: >38 ;8B8658; 6?; >38= 6A8?C>;878?;8?> C?>38 4?BCD8 C: >38 ;8B8658; 38?B8 >38 A4<@?69 8AA8; 4? ;8;@B>4?E %),>45695CBC?>8?;8;>36>656;D4>>8;<=%)G4:8C: >38;8B8658;4?38A;87C54>4C?>38;8B8658;G656E8;* =86A56>>38>4D8C:6BB4;8?><@>>38A4<@?698AAC?8C@59= 389; >38 6E8 C: >38 ;8B8658; 65 =86A5 6?; 677948; D@9>47948AC:"#4?5>86;C:"!#>45:@A>38ABC?>8?;8;>36> >38 A4<@?69 8AA8; 4? 6;;4?E %K :@>@A8 7AC578B>5 38A8:CA8 38 A8M@85>8; >C 699CG >38 677869 6?; A8;@B8 >38BCD78?56>4C?6DC@?>A865C?6<9= ! > 45 5@<D4>>8; <= >38 986A?8; BC@?589 :CA A857C?;8?> C5% >C ,)B964D6?>5 >36> >38 BCD78?56>4C? - 5 - 6G6A;8;<=>38A4<@?6945F@5>6?;7AC78A6?;4>?88;5?C 4?>8A:8A8?B8 38 3@5<6?; C: B964D6?> C% D8> G4>3 >38 6BB4;8?> C? +% ? L/N C5> CA>8D 87CA> 345 6E8 G65 53CG? 65 =86A5 H8? % 4? 38A ;87C54>4C? 5>6>8; >38 6E8 C: >38 ;8B8658; G65 =86A5 6?;>3C@E35386;D4>>8;>38<4A>3=86AC:>38;8B8658;65 %!% 538 365 ?C> :498; 6?= 6E8 7ACC: 38A8:CA8 BC?54;8A4?E>388H4;8?B8C:%6?;C5> CA>8D87CA> >38 A4<@?69 365 BC?54;8A8; >38 6E8 C: ;8B8658; 65 =86A56?;677948;>38D@9>47948AC:"#345 C@A>:4?;5?C A865C?>C4?>8A:8A8G4>3>38564;CA;8A / @A>38A4? >386<58?B8 C: 7ACC: C:4?BCD8 >38 A4<@?69BC?54;8A8;>38?C>4C?694?BCD8C:>38;8B8658;6> 5%,/!)6578A>38E@4;894?85455@8;<=>386A?6>6O6 >6>8 8E698AH4B85@>3CA4>=:CA>386BB4;8?>C:>38=86A +% 6;;8; %K >CG6A;5 :@>@A8 7AC578B>5 6?; A4E3>9= ;8;@B>8;%),A;C:>C>694?BCD8>CG6A;578A5C?698L78?585 C:>38;8B8658;6?;6G6A;8;5%,)>CG6A;59C55 - 6 - C: ;878?;8?B= >C >38 B964D6?>5 G34B3 ?88;5 ?C 4?>8A:8A8?B8 <= >345 C@A> 38 A4<@?69 C<58AH8; >36> B964D6?> C% N G4:8 C: >38 ;8B8658; 45 8?>4>98; :CA 5) >CG6A;5 9C55 C: 57C@569 BC?5CA>4@D 6?; B964D6?> C5+ 6?; , 6A8 8?>4>98; :CA 5) 86B3 >CG6A;59C55C:76A8?>69BC?5CA>4@D4?>C>695%+) 38 A4<@?69 365 A4E3>9= 6G6A;8; 6? 6DC@?> C: 5,) @?;8A >38 BC?H8?>4C?69 386;5 65 78A >38 B4>6>4C? 4? >38 B658 C: 6?; 4> 695C ?88;5 ?C 4?>8A:8A8?B8<=>345 C@A> * ? H48G C: >38 6<CH8 >38 677869 45 ;8HC4; C: D8A4>5 6?; 946<98 >C <8 ;45D4558; BBCA;4?E9= >38 :C99CG4?E1 '4( 3867786945;45D4558; '44( 778996?> N ?5@A6?B8 CD76?= 45 ;4A8B>8; >C ;87C54> >38 BCD78?56>4C? 6DC@?> - 7 - 69C?EG4>34?>8A85> G4>34? :C@A G88O5:ACD >38 ;6>8C:>345F@;ED8?> '444( ?5@B3;87C54>B964D6?>C5+6?; ,)B349;A8? C: >38 ;8B8658; 6A8 78AD4>>8; >C G4>3;A6G 5%!) 86B3 69C?E G4>3 4?>8A85>6BBA@8;C?4>6?;B964D6?>C%)G4:8C: >38 ;8B8658; 45 78AD4>>8; >C G4>3;A6G >38 A8D64?4?E 6DC@?> 69C?E G4>3 4?>8A85> 6BBA@8; C?4> '4H( >6>@>CA= ;87C54> C: +!K 45 >C <8 >A6?5D4>>8;>C>38A4<@?69 C@?589 :CA A857C?;8?> C 45 ;4A8B>8; >C :498 6O696>G4>34?>GCG88O5 *+, '& ( % 45>C1%9C1! 1$