- 1 - ! " #$ %# & &"## ' ( ! " " # $ % " &'((($ ) " &$ * &+$($ Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , &+$($ " &+)$- ! " $%). %, # ))' ))- /0 12314567489:;<59=36<9>3?46@<@124A3=?B48: 466:942?@<82?3C32:2:<9388:466:748A594?5748 @<8 83=C<9D392= $ % ) 8: 85C4 4E48 42:6 ;<59=36 @<8 83=C<9D392= 49D , 49D 8: 85975148 148E59D4CC4 ;<59=36@<883=C<9D392<?4F34CC3483D:9C38=<9 - 3 - ) ?3 ;4C2:<93D 8:2 32:2:<9 := @:63D =337:9E 2?3 @<66<B:9E836:3@= 4# ==53 4 8:2 <@ 382:<848: 2< G54=? 2?3 :946 363;2:<9 :=2 D423D $-())() C4==3D >H 83=C<9D392<F:D3 993I583& ># ==53 49H B8:2 <8D38 <8 D:83;2:<9= 4= 2?:= <582 D331= @:2 :9 2?3 ;:8;51=249;3= <@ 2?3 ;4=3:92?339D=<@A5=2:;3 ?3=?<82@4;2=483=2423D4=@<66<B= <2:@:;42:<9B4=:==53D<9$J )((J)();466:9E@<849 4CC<:921392 2< 2?3 C<=2 <@ :>848H 5C38F:=<8 :9 2?3 841 49;?4H42? B:2?:9 2?3 56>48E4 :=28:;2 1<9E <2?38= 2?3 C32:2:<93849D83=C<9D392<4CC6:3D@<82?3=4:DC<=259D38 423E<8H& @2382?383;3:C2<@2?34CC6:;42:<9= 2?3452?<8:2H ;<9;3893DC83C483D2?336:E:>6349D:936:E:>636:=2=?39413<@ 2?3C32:2:<938B4=9<2:9;65D3D:92?336:E:>636:=2?39413<@ 2?3@:@2?83=C<9D392B4=:9;65D3D:92?336:E:>636:=239;32?3 C32:2:<938 =5>1:223D 4 D324:63D <>A3;2:<9 2< 2?3 =363;2:<9 6:=2 ;<9239D:9E 2?42 83=C<9D392 < >36<9E= 2< ;?3D563D 8:>3= 4=C38:8;5648D423D)J($)())49D)J$()()).83=C<9D392 - 4 - <D<3=9<2>36<9E2<423E<8H&3=C:232?3=4:D<>A3;2:<9 4@:946=363;2:<96:=2B4=C83C483D=363;2:9E@:@2?83=C<9D3922< 2?3C<=2<@:>848H5C38F:=<89D382?3=3;:8;51=249;3=2?3 C32:2:<938:=>3@<832?:=<582 , <59=36 @<8 2?3 83=C3;2:F3 C482:3= 58E3D =3F3846 ;<92392:<9=348D2?348E51392=49DC385=3D2?3 8:2C4C38= B:2?;483 ?3:==53@466=B:2?:949488<B;<1C4==49D836423= 2< 2?3 =363;2:<9 <@ 2?3 @:@2? 83=C<9D392 2< 2?3 C<=2 <@ :>848H 5C38F:=<8 <59=36 12314 567489: @<8 2?3 C32:2:<938 =5>1:2= 2?422?3@:@2?83=C<9D392>36<9E=2<K464B484L4=C382?34=23 382:@:;423:==53D>H2?34?4=:6D48?348E53D>H=4H:9E2?42 4= C38 2?3 4139D1392 2?3 =4:D 4=23 @466= 59D38 ;?3D563D 8:>3= <59=36 2?383@<83 F3?313926H ;<9239D3D 2?42 D3=C:23 2?3<>A3;2:<9=4@:9466:=2B4=C83C483D HB4H<@83C6H2<2?:=;<92392:<9;<59=368: 85975148 148E59D4CC4@<82?3@:@2?83=C<9D392=5>1:2=2?422?3@:@2? 83=C<9D392?4D=5>1:223D2?34=23382:@:;4232?42B4=:==53D - 5 - >H 2?34?4=:6D48 @M46C58 4657 464>584E: :=28:;2 <59=36 @582?38=5>1:2=2?424131<?4=>339@:63D@589:=?:9E2?32853 ;<CH <@ 2?3 6423=2 4=23 382:@:;423 :==53D >H 2?3 4?4=:6D48 49D2?3=41314H>324739<983;<8D 5>1:==:<9:=9<23D31<:=C64;3D<983;<8D <59=368:85C44E4842:6=5>1:2=2?422?3363;2:<9 <11:22334;23D5C<92?34=23382:@:;4232?42B4==5>1:223D >H 2?3 <1C32392 52?<8:2H 49D ?39;3 ;<59=36 A5=2:@:3D 2?3 4;2:<9<@2?3363;2:<9<11:2233 E<<D D346 <@ 48E51392 := ;49F4==3D 4><52 2?3 ;<9=2:252:<9464139D139249D4:8;5648 <2:@:;42:<9:==53D>H 2?3<F3891392<23D2?3=5>1:==:<9B:2?521<=2;483 H 49 4139D1392 2?3 K464B484L 4=23 ?4= >339 :9;65D3D :9 2?3 6:=2 <@ ;?3D563D 8:>3= :9 2?3 2423 <@ 489424742:==:E9:@:;4922<9<232?424:8;5648B4=:==53D<9 )J($)()) D:83;2:9E 466 2?3 3C52H <11:==:<938= 49D 4?4=:6D48= <@ 2?3 :=28:;2= 2< :==53 2?3 4=23 382:@:;423 2< C38=<9>36<9E:9E2<K464B484L4=C382?34M3223<2:@:;42:<9 D423D)(()()( - 6 - 2 4CC348= 2?42 2?3 C32:2:<938 ?4D ;3824:9 <>A3;2:<9= 4><522?34=23382:@:;423<@2?3@:@2?83=C<9D39249D=?3?4D @:63D <>A3;2:<9= >3@<83 2?3 363;2:<9 <11:2233 4><52 2?3 =413 ?3 363;2:<9 <11:2233 :==53D 49 39D<8=31392 <9 (-())() =242:9E 2?42 2?3 363;2:<9 <11:2233 ?4= 4;23D 5C<92?3;4=23382:@:;423:==53D>H2?34?4=:6D48 ?3C32:2:<938;499<2?4F349H7:9D<@E8:3F49;34E4:9=2 2?3@:@2?83=C<9D39249D2?3363;2:<9<11:2233?3834=<9 := 4CC48392 = 46834DH 9<23D 4><F3 >H F:8253 <@ 2?3 <F3891392:8;56482?3<F3891392<@48942474?4D:==53D 93;3==48HE393846:9=285;2:<9=2<4662?33C52H<11:==:<938= 49D2?34?4=:6D48=2<:==532?34=23382:@:;4232<2?3C38=<9 >36<9E:9E 2< K464B484L 4= C38 2?3 4M3223 <2:@:;42:<9 D423D )(()()( ?3 4=23 382:@:;423 2?42 B4= :==53D >H 2?3 4?4=:6D48 B4= =5>1:223D >H 2?3 @:@2? 83=C<9D392 49D 2?3 363;2:<9<11:22334;23D5C<92?3=4:D4=23382:@:;4232:= C:F<246 2< 9<23 2?42 2?3 363;2:<9 <11:2233 ?4= 24739 :92< ;<9=:D3842:<9 2?3 138:2 <@ 2?3 @:@2? 83=C<9D392 @ 42 466 2?3 C32:2:<938?4=49HE8:3F49;34><522?34=23382:@:;423<@2?3 @:@2? 83=C<9D392 2?3 8313DH B<56D >3 2< 4CC8<4;? 2?3 - 7 - ;<1C32392 <851 :9 4;;<8D49;3 B:2? 2?3 64B 39;3 2?3 ;<92392:<9<@2?3C32:2:<9382?422?3@:@2?83=C<9D392;<56D9<2 ?4F3>339=363;23D59D38423E<8H&;499<2>3=5=24:93D?3 C32:2:<938 ?4= 9<2 14D3 <52 E8<59D= 2< @:9D @4562 B:2? 2?3 =363;2:<9 C8<;3== ?3 8:2 32:2:<9 := D3F<:D <@ 138:2= 49D := 6:4>632<>3D:=1:==3D ' 3=5624926H2?3 8:232:2:<9:= 3;45=3 <@ D:=1:==46 <@ 2?3 8:2 32:2:<9 C39D:9E :92386<;52<8H4CC6:;42:<9=:@49H49D:9238:1<8D38<8D:83;2:<9= :@49H=249DD:=;?48E3D )* '&"##( & :=2<$6<'