- 1 - ! "# $!%!&!! !!&& '#( ) !"#$%$ & '( ( ) $ (( $*%%$ + ( ( ( !"#$%$ & '( +, +$ %* +%+!$) $*'$) ( +# %- +%$" ( R Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ++%$ ( .( ( ( ( $ $% +%+! / . 0( #% 1234561237891:5;<=><56;?41; + 6?;2@@12A?;=?A14272?:;55612B234<=5613?>8:2A ?: < ++%$ 42514 +# %- +%$" @2;;14 >C 561 <5<3 DD?41:5A2?9;3?>8:2AE ?F2C2@832 * 61 =2D5; <= 561 D2;1 231 5625 <: ++ $+ +%$* 25 2><85 %%@ 9 :123 2?;6:2G? 153<A 89@<:$*255625 5?913?413<=561 <5<3CDA1>123?:7< $*(#+D291 ?:6?76;@1142:4?:32;62:4:17A?71:592::13?:2B3<:7;?41 2:4 42;614 5< 561 2@@1AA2:5 81 5< B6?D6 561 2@@1AA2:5 ;8;52?:14 =32D5831 ?:F83?1; 2:4 ?9914?251AC 249?5514 5< 2D6D61<;?52A<A2@83=<35312591:5 - 3 - :F8314DA2?92:5 =?A14 2 DA2?9 @15?5?<: DA2?9?:7 D<9@1:;25?<: <= ; $%%%%%% 61 3?>8:2A 2=513 D<:;?413?:7 1:5?31 1G?41:D1 <: 31D<34 4?;9?;;14 561 DA2?9 @15?5?<: ! 773?1G14 >C 561 ;2?4 2B234 56?; 2@@12A ?; @31=13314?:B6?D6?5?;D<:51:51456255613?>8:2A4?;9?;;14 561 @15?5?<: B?56<85 2@@31D?25?:7 561 92513?2A <: 31D<34 @3<@13AC2:4?5B2;<>;13G1456255613?>8:2A62;133<:1<8;AC ;52514 56131 B2; :< @3<@13 1H@A2:25?<: >C 561 2@@1AA2:5 5< D<:4<:156141A2C<=+42C;?:=?A?:7561D<9@A2?:52:4568; 31I81;51456?;<8355<;152;?41561F84791:5<=5613?>8:2A 2:45<2AA<B5612@@12A # 1;@<:41:5 < $ 3192?:14 1H@2351 >1=<31 561 3?>8:2A2=51331D1?G?:7561:<5?D1 123:14 D<8:;1A =<3 561 :;832:D1 <9@2:C 62; =?A142B3?551:;525191:5>CD<:51:4?:75625561@<A?DCB2;:<5 ?:1H?;51:D12:4561<B:13<=5619<5<3DCDA162;:<5?:5?92514 2><85 561 2DD?41:5 5< 561 <9@2:C 5 ?; =835613 D<:51:414 5625 56131 ?; :< F83?;4?D5?<: 5< 1:51352?: 561 2@@12A 2; 561 2@@1AA2:5?;31;?41:5<= 26232;65322:45612DD?41:55<<J@A2D1 - 4 - 25 26232;6532 2:4 61:D1 ?5 ?; 31I8?314 5< 41:C 2AA <5613 2;@1D5; 5?;=835613;525145625561D<9@A2?:5B2;A<4714>C 561 3?413 <= 561 9<5<3DCDA1 2=513 + 42C; <= 561 2DD?41:5 2:4 561<B:13?;?:D<AA8;?<:B?562@@1AA2:52:4561@<A?D12856<3?5C @A2:514 ?:;8314G16?DA1 5< DA2?9 561 D<9@1:;25?<: B3<:7=8AAC 5 ?; =835613 ;52514 5625 B2; 317?;51314 2; @13 < #--+%$ >85 ?: 561 ?:F83C D135?=?D251 :89>13 ?; ;6<B:2;/$#. 5?;=835613D<:51:4145625?:561D<9@A2?:5 561 4251 <= 2DD?41:5 ?; ;6<B: 2; +* %$ +%$* 2:4 561 3?413 <= 561 9<5<3DCDA1 62; :< G2A?4 43?G?:7 A?D1:D1 25 561 5?91 <= 2DD?41:5 68; D<:;?413?:7 2AA 561;1 2;@1D5; 31I81;514 =<3 4?;9?;;2A<=5612@@12A " 61 2@@1AA2:5 62; 1H29?:14 $ 5< * 2:4 923J144<D891:5;2;H $5<H $ - 61 :;832:D1 D<9@2:C 1H29?:14 $ 2:4 + 2:45614<D891:5B2;1H29?:142;H $ 61<835B?5:1;; B2;1H29?:142;$2:4H $?;561;?7:25831<=$ $% : @138;2A <= 561 =2D5; <= 561 D2;1 561 2@@1AA2:5 915 B?56 2: 2DD?41:5 <: ++ $+ +%$* >85 561 D<9@A2?:5 B2; 7?G1: <: $! %$ +%$ 8:413 H $ 2:4 56131 ?; 2: ?:<34?:251 - 5 - 41A2C<=+42C;2:4:<312;<:;2312;;?7:14=<3561;2?441A2C ?:7?G?:7561D<9@A2?:5 :561D<9@A2?:5?5B2;;525145625?5 B2; 317?;51314 2; @13 < #--+%$ >85 ?: 561 ?:F83C D135?=?D251? 1 H * :89>13?;;6<B:2;/$#.2:4?:561 D<9@A2?:55614251<=2DD?41:5?;;6<B:2;+* %$ +%$* :561 ;@<5@2:D62:292? 1 H +5614251<=2DD?41:5?;;6<B:2; %* %$ +%$2:4?:561D62371;6115? 1 H #!?5B2;;6<B:2; ++ $+ +%$ 835613 * ?: 6?; 1G?41:D1 62; ;52514 5625 >C 9?;52J1 ?: 561 561 4251 <= 2DD?41:5 ?; B3?551: 2; +* %$ +%$*?:;5124<=++ $+ +%$*2:4?5?;B3?551:B3<:7AC>C <G13;?765 :561D2;1;61155<<5614251<=2DD?41:5?;;6<B: 2;++ $+ +%$* 1:D156131231;<92:C4?;D31@2:D?1;?:561 92513?2A 4<D891:5; 317234?:7 561 4251 <= 2DD?41:5 2:4 561 B?5:1;;1; ;?9@AC ;52514 5625 ?5 B2; 2 9?;52J1 <3 <G13;?765 <:;?413?:7 561 2><G1 ;2?4 2;@1D5; 561 ;2?4 1H@A2:25?<: D2::<5>12DD1@514 $$ :@138;2A<=561B?5:1;;1; :89>13B2;:<5 ;6<B:@3<@13AC2:4 *?:6?;D3<;;1H29?:25?<:62;249?5514 56255625 < $#?;:<5=<3561C123+%$* 8356136162; =835613 ;52514 5625 ?: 561 @31;1:D1 <= 124 <:;52>A1 ' ) - 6 - < $$->C:291 62G2:561D<9@A2?:5?;@31@23142:4 $ 2A;< ;52514 5625 61 ?; 561 (8DJA1 < $$- B6< 317?;51314561D2;12;@13 < #--+%$ (85561D<@C<= 561;2?4D<9@A2?:5?;:<5=?A14>1=<31561<835 $+ 835613 561 <5<3 G16?DA1 ' ) 31@<35 <= 561 <==1:4?:7 G16?DA1 ?; :<5 @3<48D14 >1=<31 561 <835 2:4 :< 1H@A2:25?<: ?; 7?G1: =<3 561 ;291 61 3?>8:2A 62; 3?765AC D<:51:4145625?=56141A2C?:=?A?:7561D<9@A2?:5?;1H@A2?:14 @3<@13AC561:<:AC?5?;2DD1@52>A1<:161:D1?5?;:<5=252A5< 561D2;1<=5612@@1AA2:5 :56?;D2;156141A2C?;:<5252AA 1H@A2?:14 2:4 ?:F8314 :<5 =?A14 2:C D135?=?14 D<@?1; <= D<9@A2?:5;@<5@2:D62:292 31@<35?:F83CD135?=?D2512:4 561D62371;6115>1=<31561<835 ;;8D65613?>8:2A62; 3?765AC<>;13G145625561@<;;?>?A?5C<=@A2:5?:7<3?:G<AG?:7561 9<5<3DCDA1 < $*(#+ D2::<5 >1 38A14 <85 2:4 2DD<34?:7AC5613?>8:2A62;3?765AC4?;9?;;14561@15?5?<: $* : 2 D?525?<: 31@<3514 ?: >15B11: ?5B2;61A42;=<AA<B; - 7 - ! " ! - 8 - ! # $%&'( &) & * & + , 1:D1?:G?1B<=5612><G1;2?41H532D514D?525?<:?5?; =<35612@@1AA2:55<@3<G1562561915B?562:2DD?41:52:461 62; 5< 7?G1 561 D<9@A2?:5 ?: 5?91 2:4 >2;?:7 <: 561 ?:G1;5?725?<:561D62371;6115?;5<>1=?A14 DD<34?:7AC?5?; =<3 6?9 5< @3<G1 561 ?:G<AG191:5 <= 561 G16?DA1 2:4 561 1H?;51:D1 <= 561 @<A?DC 2; <: 561 4251 <= 2DD?41:5 : 561 @31;1:5D2;156131?;?:<34?:25141A2C<=+42C;2:4?5?;:<5 - 9 - 1H@A2?:14 >C 561 2@@1AA2:5 @3<@13AC 2:4 56131 231 ;< 92:C 4?;D31@2:D?1; ?: 561 92513?2A 4<D891:5; 2; ;52514 2><G1 6131=<31 ?5 ?; 2DA123 D2;1 <= =2A;1 ?9@A?D25?<: <= 561 G16?DA1 2:4 561 3?>8:2A 62; 3?765AC 2;;1;;14 561 1:5?31 1G?41:D1 <: 31D<342:44?;9?;;145612B234 $ :56131;8A556?;<835=?:4;:<312;<:5<?:513=131 B?56 561 <3413 <= 561 3?>8:2A 2:4 2DD<34?:7AC 56?; 2@@12A ?; >CD<:=?39?:75612B234<=5613?>8:2A *+, '&!! ( % ?;5< $A< $